Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Emily Carlisle was never the main character of her own story. Known only as the Witch of the Stacks, she helped any hero or heroine who asked. Potions, spells, and the occasional magical artifact were passed on. She never kept the power for herself, and never wanted to be anything more than a support character. That is, until the Rot began to spread throughout her library. No one knows where it came from or what triggered it. They only know it consumes everything in its path, and it has set its sights on her books.

Suddenly, Emily is thrust into the role of heroine, with only her faithful betta fish, Orpheus, and reluctant Heroine Ozioma Monroe, by her side. She must use all of the tricks at her disposal to reach the heart of her magical library and stop the Rot from taking away the only home she has ever known.

218 pages, Kindle Edition

Published May 18, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Avery Carter

13 books35 followers
Avery Carter is an English teacher and walking art museum, covered in tattoos, ocean blue hair tied out of their face, and square, purple glasses. They proudly proclaim that they are the "coolest person you know" to their students, and spend each day trying to live up to that title. They are a nonbinary queer author living in South Korea with their wife and two dogs. They spend their days writing new stories, and teaching their students to love words as much as they do.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
25 (39%)
4 stars
21 (33%)
3 stars
13 (20%)
2 stars
4 (6%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews
Profile Image for Carmen.
256 reviews2 followers
May 1, 2024
Spellbound was such a fun and cozy read! The entire book is set in a magical library, and the world building was very easy to follow. The characters are so well written, including the betta fish, Orpheus, and the Griffon, Nike, who have very big personalities. Another exciting aspect is that there is art throughout the book! As Emily enters deeper into the library, each new level gets an illustrated page, which I thought was such a nice touch. I especially loved that, while it’s cozy, serious topics are touched on: imposters syndrome, loss, toxic education systems, and more. Last but not least, the romance was so cute! It is rivals to lovers, and it had me giggling and swinging my feet with joy.
Profile Image for Nathaniel.
Author 35 books321 followers
October 12, 2024
This is such a cute magical library story. I really enjoyed the simplicity of it. It’s short and easy to read, but there’s a lot beneath the surface. It’s worth the read.
Profile Image for Beatrice.
362 reviews29 followers
May 8, 2024
This review was originally published on Reedsy Discovery.

Emily Carlisle is a Witch of the Stack, tasked with taking care of the most powerful magical library in existence and assisting heroes and heroines on their quests with the help of Orpheus, her betta fish Companion. Her daily life goes by peacefully between a magic potion and a spell, until a mysterious Rot starts destroying her library - and everything she holds dear. Having reluctantly enlisted powerful heroine Ozioma Monroe to help her fight the Rot, Emily is suddenly forced to stop assisting and start leading her own adventure, or it might be the last thing any of them do.

Spellbound is a deeply charming and engaging novel brimming with magic and presenting a cast of endearing characters. It is impossible not to root for Emily as she fights hard to save her home, and it is easy to connect with her as her past is slowly revealed. Emily's relationships with her fish, Orpheus, and with heroine Ozioma are also great, with the banter providing several light-hearted moments while maintaining the dialogue feeling natural. The deep bond between the witch, the heroine, and their companions was also deeply touching, and it is clear that great care and tenderness went into drafting it.

As most of the action takes place within the magical library, the worldbuilding is pretty clear and easy to follow. At times, though, references were made to other locations that seemed set partly in a fantasy world and partly in the real world, which became slightly confusing and left the status of the world outside the library unclear. The magic system was explained very well and used consistently throughout, and it was a delight to travel with Emily within the Stacks and discover what the next level held in store. The Stacks themselves are described vividly, and it is almost possible to see them while reading!

The novel is well-paced, even though the ending felt slightly rushed and could have probably used a bit more breathing space to bring everything to a close comfortably. There was at times some confusion around the protagonists' ages, as in a couple of sections it is mentioned they are seventeen but the way they talk about their life experiences and how they interact made them come across as much older than that. It is not a big issue in itself but sometimes felt rather jarring.

This is mostly a cosy read with some elements of adventure and danger, and as such would perfectly suit a young adult audience as well as some older adults looking for a light, fun and heartwarming read.

I received a free copy of this book via Reedsy Discovery. This did not affect my opinion of the book in any way.

For more reviews, visit Book for Thought.
Profile Image for Aly.
15 reviews2 followers
November 10, 2024
A cozy adventure for those who dream of getting lost in a magical library! Emily is relatable and adaptive even in the hardest of times. I look forward to more adventures!
393 reviews10 followers
October 25, 2024
sweet take

This is a sweet story of a young witch, caretaker of the stacks, confronting a great adventure. Of course she has companions alongside her.
Profile Image for Britt.
539 reviews89 followers
May 14, 2024
An amazing magical library?
Yes please!

This was quite a fun adventure. I really enjoyed how magical the library was and the adventures one could have among the stacks.

The relationship was very sweet and I did love how they came together.
Profile Image for Patrick Lynden.
52 reviews
November 14, 2026
Spellbound is brimming with potential and has all the makings of an excellent YA fantasy and I have been so excited to read it but it just felt undercooked.

This story is about a young witch who is "employed" as a caretaker for a magical library that holds vast knowledge of the world and all the stories that ever have been or ever will be. She discovers that a horrific infection, known as the rot, is spreading, and she and her companions must travel to the center of the universe stored within the library to save it.

The idea behind the library itself has lots of potential, as I mentioned, because it has different areas (known as levels one to five), each with a different identity. Each presents its own set of obstacles for Emily and her friends to overcome and has clear aesthetics to help differentiate each from the other. (For example, level one is a typical magical library complete with books, level two is rock-laden and has a large river, three is a seemingly never-ending forest, etc.) The only issue with this is that the ideas are all there but nothing is ever really revealed about the library in any great depth. The reasons for the levels being the way they are are never explored, never explained, and we are kind of just left to accept that this is "just the way it is." That's fine, as I don't expect an overly complex info dump, but something to explain why a magical library only has one of its five levels containing books, and why the rest are forests, rocks and rivers, starlight-imbued space pockets, and so forth, would really help strengthen the story.

One of the other issues I had was the actual origin of the rot and how it works. The origin for it, and the reasons for it coming into existence, feel incredibly weak which is such a shame as it is a fascinating concept on paper. The being responsible (I want to try and avoid spoilers) barely holds any sway in the grand scheme of things and the rot itself seems to change its method of infection depending on the need of the story rather than feeling like it's own thing. I think some clear rules around what exactly it was and what it could or could not do would have glued things together a little more.

I also found that the characters seemed to solve almost every problem almost immediately and with relative ease. The ground is trying to eat one of them up? There's a spell for that that will take me just three sentences to explain, perform and execute. There's a riverbed that we need to walk along with angry stone golems threatening to throw rocks at us from above. Don't worry, the characters have a six different potions in their bags that solve all of those problems. It felt like each obstacle wasn't much of a challenge because Emily either knew a spell (that sometimes felt like it had been conjured up on the spot rather than it be something a person in her profession would know) or she would have a range of items in a tiny pack that she brought with her (but admitted was a rush job so it's a little confusing how she seems to have everything she needs.)

I was really on board with both Emily and Ozioma very early on into the story. Emily was sassy despite being bookish and not having any interest in being a hero (which was a breath of fresh air for me and selling point of the book) and Ozioma was no nonsense, glory hunting and brazen. The two had a history of disliking each other at the hero academy that Emily was eventually kicked out of and waste no time in sniping at each other. So imagine my disappointment when the two VERY QUICKLY fell in love with one another. I noticed that it was around page 93 where the two share small moment over a campfire story and its by page 116 that Emily is confessing to herself that she is harboring feelings for Ozioma. It's not much longer until there is kissing, crying over each other, calling each other love and basically bypassing any tension between the two. I felt a little cheated out of a slow burn (as slow burn as a 206 page book good be) and, as someone who really doesn't like insta-love tropes, I was a bit gutted that the two initial characters that I liked fell into this because it really took me out of whatever immersion I still had in the book.

I really liked the concept, enjoyed the first act thoroughly and think that with a bit more time to cook and a bit more TLC given to the overall plot and character development, this would be excellent for a younger crowd but I think it missed the mark a little for me, which is a big shame.

I ADORE Orpheus though. I wish he was my friend.
Profile Image for Rikka Kang.
186 reviews2 followers
December 7, 2024
Who wouldn't want to be the keeper of the library? Emily is the keeper of the stacks and tasked with protecting the library and its information, while also aiding the heroes as they need it. When the library gets infected with the rot, Emily needs a hero to help her save the knowledge inside. What she doesn't expect is that the hero she gets is Ozioma.

This story is a friends/enemies to lovers, but you can't really call them enemies when the animosity is one sided. Emily, having been expelled from Hero Academy, does not feel like she has the magic or the strength to battle the rot and find the heart of the library, but together, they may be able to accomplish this goal.

This book features magical powers, battles, magical creatures, and a blossoming relationship. It was a quick and fun read for those who enjoy fantasy.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
91 reviews6 followers
December 23, 2025
A delightful, cozy, and wonderfully charming YA fantasy. Avery Carter introduces us to Emily Carlisle, the lovable "Witch of the Stacks," whose quiet life of assisting heroes is upended when a mysterious Rot threatens her magical library. Forced to lead her own quest with a reluctant heroine and her betta fish companion, Emily's journey is brimming with magic, endearing characters, and touching bonds. The magical library setting is vividly realized, and the story balances light-hearted banter with genuine heart and stakes. A perfect, heartwarming read for anyone who loves books about books, magical libraries, and underdog heroines.

Profile Image for A.M. Hamill.
Author 1 book10 followers
June 7, 2024
I really enjoyed this! It's a charming, clever cozy fantasy story set in a well-developed and vivid world. I thought the idea of the stacks was so cool. Each level brought new adventures and stunning imagery. The wider world structure around the Hero Academy, the List etc. was so cool and the book gave a really interesting meta commentary on hero stories and what they mean. I also adored the animal companions. I got very emotional about THAT moment. Would recommend :)
Profile Image for S.J. Pratt.
Author 1 book56 followers
May 4, 2025
You had me at library and magic! What a great read. I thoroughly enjoyed this. It's an easy read in the best way - you can really dive into the story without getting bogged down in fancy words. I love a good sidekick and there are TWO in this story, and the romance is very sweet. My favourite part is all the magic, exploring all the levels of this epic library and learning more about the way magic works in Carter's world.
Profile Image for E.C. Garrett.
Author 15 books193 followers
May 16, 2024
Oh my GOD. I can't believe how quickly this hooked me in. I want my own magical library and betta fish companion. Carter spun a truly spellbinding world that is heart-warming, funny, emotional, and beautiful from beginning to end. One of my favorite reads this year. I can't wait for book two!
Profile Image for Keely Marrs.
103 reviews
April 18, 2025
This story lacked lustre for me. I so wanted to love it, I love the representation of same sex love, but the character development and world building just didn’t do it.
Profile Image for Heather.
128 reviews2 followers
January 1, 2025
I read Spellbound originally as I had the eARC for the sequel, Honorbound, but I found I really enjoyed this cozy fantasy read!

Emily as the Caretaker of the Stacks (magical library) is such a real and relatable character. What brought her to being the Caretaker was thoughtfully shared, giving a lovely insight into what makes her tick. I especially loved Orpehus, her betta fish companion!

Ozioma, a Hero from the Hero Academy, shows up at the library for assistance. Except.. Ozomia is the reason Emily was expelled from the Academy!

A true enemies to lovers story, the adventure of Emily and Ozioma venturing through all of the Levels of the library to the centre, in order to save the Stacks from the encroaching rot is wonderfully and descriptively written.
Profile Image for TheBookMum13.
248 reviews
October 20, 2024
Stuff your kindle day for Fantasy over the weekend.

I love to sit and have a cuppa and shift through all the books available. Cuddled on the sofa with my little she pointed out a few book covers she liked, Spellbound was her favourite one cause she loves fish 😂

So decided to dive into this one today as she's asked me about 20times since Friday if I read the fish yet 😂

This is a YA cozy read! We follow the caretaker of the magic library who has to enlist the help of a reluctant heroine when her library is under attack from some dark magic and rot. With some banter and hatred all mixed in together and some friendly animal companions. Will they be able to save the Library!
Displaying 1 - 16 of 16 reviews