What do you think?
Rate this book
The Midwinter Dragon #2
Among Sea Wolves: 1150 The Whale Road
1150: The Whale Road. An epic medieval adventure, set in the Viking world of 12th century Orkney. To change their doom, Skarfr and Hlif must pay the price.
Warrior-poet Skarfr embarks on a death-defying pilgrimage with his ruler, Jarl Rognvald, from the wind-whipped shores of Orkney to the Holy Land. He is one of the few men trusted by the Jarl, whether facing sea-monsters or murder. Fifteen ships sail on the ‘whale road’ in the pilgrims’ fleet.
The only woman among the ‘sea wolves’, Hlif is respected as much for her practical skills as for her mystical gifts. Yet beneath her indomitable façade lies a secret – she is handfasted to Skarfr, their love forbidden by the Jarl’s decree.
As tensions rise, Skarfr is torn between fealty to his Jarl and devotion to Hlif. One oath must be broken but which one? How can he steer a course between loyalty and love without losing his honour?
Book 2 in The Midwinter Dragon series, from an award-winning writer, Among Sea Wolves is perfect for fans of Madeline Miller's mythic storytelling, Bernard Cornwell's gritty realism, and Matthew Harffy's visceral medieval sagas.
Warrior-poet Skarfr embarks on a death-defying pilgrimage with his ruler, Jarl Rognvald, from the wind-whipped shores of Orkney to the Holy Land. He is one of the few men trusted by the Jarl, whether facing sea-monsters or murder. Fifteen ships sail on the ‘whale road’ in the pilgrims’ fleet.
The only woman among the ‘sea wolves’, Hlif is respected as much for her practical skills as for her mystical gifts. Yet beneath her indomitable façade lies a secret – she is handfasted to Skarfr, their love forbidden by the Jarl’s decree.
As tensions rise, Skarfr is torn between fealty to his Jarl and devotion to Hlif. One oath must be broken but which one? How can he steer a course between loyalty and love without losing his honour?
Book 2 in The Midwinter Dragon series, from an award-winning writer, Among Sea Wolves is perfect for fans of Madeline Miller's mythic storytelling, Bernard Cornwell's gritty realism, and Matthew Harffy's visceral medieval sagas.
- GenresHistorical Fiction
344 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 9, 2024
20 people are currently reading
63 people want to read
About the author
Jean Gill
45 books239 followersJean Gill is a Welsh writer and photographer living in the south of France with two scruffy dogs, a beehive named 'Endeavour', a Nikon D750 and a man. For many years, she taught English in Wales and was the first woman to be a secondary headteacher in Carmarthenshire. She is mother or stepmother to five children so life was hectic.
Publications are varied, including prize-winning poetry and novels, military history, translated books on dog training, and a cookery book on goat cheese. With Scottish parents, an English birthplace and French residence, she can usually support the winning team on most sporting occasions.
Sign up for Jean's newsletter at www.jeangill.com for updates and a free book. If you review one of Jean's books you can add a dog to Jean's Readers Dogs Hall of Fame on her website. Contact Jean at jean.gill@wanadoo.fr with comments or questions. She loves to hear from readers.
Publications are varied, including prize-winning poetry and novels, military history, translated books on dog training, and a cookery book on goat cheese. With Scottish parents, an English birthplace and French residence, she can usually support the winning team on most sporting occasions.
Sign up for Jean's newsletter at www.jeangill.com for updates and a free book. If you review one of Jean's books you can add a dog to Jean's Readers Dogs Hall of Fame on her website. Contact Jean at jean.gill@wanadoo.fr with comments or questions. She loves to hear from readers.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews
February 4, 2024
Jean Gill’s novel, ‘Among the Sea Wolves’ the second in ‘The Midwinter Dragon’ series continues the story of Skarfr, Jarl Rognvald’s skald, and Hlif, the Jarl’s ward, as they sail with the Viking fleet from Orkneyjar towards Jerusalem on this medieval pilgrimage to the Holy Land.
In addition to battling storms, sea monsters, murder as well as treachery within the fleet, Skarfr must face his personal battle between his fealty to Jarl Rognvald and his forbidden love for Hlif, the lone woman on board, who is the fleet’s provisioner, endowed with mystical gifts. Along the long and dangerous sea voyage, the Vikings stop at several ports where they discover cultures more advanced than their own. Meanwhile, back in Orkneyjar, Fergus and Brigid, two thralls who were part of Skarfr’s household, fall victim to the revenge of Thorbjon, the cruel ex-husband of Inge, Brigid’s friend.
As the narrator of a previous series by Jean Gill, I knew I was going to enjoy much more than reading a thrilling Viking adventure. Jean Gill has penned a compelling narrative, which will keep readers enthralled. Her dedication to portraying her characters within the actual historical background of the time not only brings readers into the lives, dangers, intrigues and heartbreak of her characters, but also provides a memorable portrait of actual Viking life for both men and women, as they struggle to survive on land and at sea.
Readers will appreciate the depth and breadth of her research and her captivating prose as she seamlessly weaves intricate details of Viking life both at home in Orkneyjar and onboard with the Viking voyagers into this intriguing medieval saga. I look forward to reading the next book in this excellent series.
I was given an advance review copy and am providing this review voluntarily.
In addition to battling storms, sea monsters, murder as well as treachery within the fleet, Skarfr must face his personal battle between his fealty to Jarl Rognvald and his forbidden love for Hlif, the lone woman on board, who is the fleet’s provisioner, endowed with mystical gifts. Along the long and dangerous sea voyage, the Vikings stop at several ports where they discover cultures more advanced than their own. Meanwhile, back in Orkneyjar, Fergus and Brigid, two thralls who were part of Skarfr’s household, fall victim to the revenge of Thorbjon, the cruel ex-husband of Inge, Brigid’s friend.
As the narrator of a previous series by Jean Gill, I knew I was going to enjoy much more than reading a thrilling Viking adventure. Jean Gill has penned a compelling narrative, which will keep readers enthralled. Her dedication to portraying her characters within the actual historical background of the time not only brings readers into the lives, dangers, intrigues and heartbreak of her characters, but also provides a memorable portrait of actual Viking life for both men and women, as they struggle to survive on land and at sea.
Readers will appreciate the depth and breadth of her research and her captivating prose as she seamlessly weaves intricate details of Viking life both at home in Orkneyjar and onboard with the Viking voyagers into this intriguing medieval saga. I look forward to reading the next book in this excellent series.
I was given an advance review copy and am providing this review voluntarily.
February 16, 2024
An epic medieval adventure, set in the Viking world of 12th century. When we follow the warrior poet Skarfr embarks on a death-defying pilgrimage to Holy Land and the seer Hilf respected as much for her practical skills as for her mystical gifts. Both hide a secret, their headfast even to their love is forbidden by the Jarl’s decree. Hilf thinks that their pilgrimage can lift her curse, but in tensions rises Skarft must decide which oath should he break.
The jorney of Inge, that escapes of the cruelty of Thorbjon, to find kind and attentive partner is emotional and inspiring. We see who much she want to trust Finn, but her past still hunts her and she is afraid to get hurt and get her husband turn away.
This book provides a memorable portrait of actual Viking life for both men and women, as they struggle to survive on land and at sea.
The jorney of Inge, that escapes of the cruelty of Thorbjon, to find kind and attentive partner is emotional and inspiring. We see who much she want to trust Finn, but her past still hunts her and she is afraid to get hurt and get her husband turn away.
This book provides a memorable portrait of actual Viking life for both men and women, as they struggle to survive on land and at sea.
December 14, 2023
Embarking on Jean Gill's "Among the Sea Wolves" is like setting sail on a Viking ship, where every wave and wind has a story to tell. This novel fascinated me with its intricate depiction of ancient navigation techniques, from the subtle art of reading waves and clouds to the unique role of a one-eyed cat aboard the vessel, reminiscent of Odin's wisdom.
Hlif, one of our protagonists, brings to life the daily nuances of seafaring life, from the practicality of lip care to the deeper understanding of the sea's moods. Her one-eyed cat, a delightful addition, not only adds charm but also symbolizes a connection to the divine, mirroring the Norse myth of Freyja's chariot.
The narrative weaves a captivating tale of secret love between Hlif and Skarfr, against the backdrop of a world where the sea's names hold mystical meanings. Jean Gill's vivid descriptions transported me right onto the deck, with the salt air and sea spray almost tangible.
As the story unfolds, we're introduced to Inge, a cunning woman from Orkney, who skillfully uses her wit and charm for familial power. Her journey from a constrained marriage to finding a kind and attentive partner is both empowering and reflective of the era's complexities.
Skarfr's realization that "travel broadens the mind" encapsulates the essence of the book. His journey brings a profound understanding of different beliefs, balancing Christianity and his pagan roots.
The awe-inspiring journey, with its pillage and plunder, is contrasted with Skarfr's admiration for Hlif's resilience and adept management of life at sea. The ending, leaving readers yearning for more, promises that Jean Gill will continue to enchant us with her vivid storytelling in future works. "Among the Sea Wolves" is not just a novel; it's a voyage through the mystic and rugged life of the Vikings.
Hlif, one of our protagonists, brings to life the daily nuances of seafaring life, from the practicality of lip care to the deeper understanding of the sea's moods. Her one-eyed cat, a delightful addition, not only adds charm but also symbolizes a connection to the divine, mirroring the Norse myth of Freyja's chariot.
The narrative weaves a captivating tale of secret love between Hlif and Skarfr, against the backdrop of a world where the sea's names hold mystical meanings. Jean Gill's vivid descriptions transported me right onto the deck, with the salt air and sea spray almost tangible.
As the story unfolds, we're introduced to Inge, a cunning woman from Orkney, who skillfully uses her wit and charm for familial power. Her journey from a constrained marriage to finding a kind and attentive partner is both empowering and reflective of the era's complexities.
Skarfr's realization that "travel broadens the mind" encapsulates the essence of the book. His journey brings a profound understanding of different beliefs, balancing Christianity and his pagan roots.
The awe-inspiring journey, with its pillage and plunder, is contrasted with Skarfr's admiration for Hlif's resilience and adept management of life at sea. The ending, leaving readers yearning for more, promises that Jean Gill will continue to enchant us with her vivid storytelling in future works. "Among the Sea Wolves" is not just a novel; it's a voyage through the mystic and rugged life of the Vikings.
December 21, 2023
I’m a long-term reader and fan of Jean Gill’s writing, and I’ve never read anything of hers which wasn’t fascinating, absorbing and thoroughly enjoyable. It was no surprise, therefore, to find all these qualities in this, her latest novel.
As ever, the depth of research shows itself in the fine detail - as, for example, how it a Viking longship was manned and organised and navigated. Moreover, what it was like to actually live on one during a long voyage. You also see it in the complex interplay of personalities and politics. It takes some skill to weave fictional events and characters into the background of known history but this is done so successfully that you can’t see the join! What you do see is a very rich, very vivid background against which the story is developed.
The story itself is fully character driven - mostly of course by the main characters, the warrior-poet Skarfr and the love of his life, Hlif, mystic and housekeeper (who shows how vital administrative skills were then, as now, and on a longboat as much as ashore). But there are a host of secondary characters who make their contribution, and the balancing of all these factors makes for an intriguing plot that was never predictable and always enthralling!
As a bonus, readers of Gill’s ‘Troubadours’ Quartet will enjoy meeting some old acquaintances in passing, and anyone who likes maps (either for themselves or for the extra information they add to the story) will appreciate the beautiful charts of the Orkney’s and of Skarfr’s voyage.
An excellent sequel to ‘The Ring Breaker’ - I’m already looking forward to the next volume!
As ever, the depth of research shows itself in the fine detail - as, for example, how it a Viking longship was manned and organised and navigated. Moreover, what it was like to actually live on one during a long voyage. You also see it in the complex interplay of personalities and politics. It takes some skill to weave fictional events and characters into the background of known history but this is done so successfully that you can’t see the join! What you do see is a very rich, very vivid background against which the story is developed.
The story itself is fully character driven - mostly of course by the main characters, the warrior-poet Skarfr and the love of his life, Hlif, mystic and housekeeper (who shows how vital administrative skills were then, as now, and on a longboat as much as ashore). But there are a host of secondary characters who make their contribution, and the balancing of all these factors makes for an intriguing plot that was never predictable and always enthralling!
As a bonus, readers of Gill’s ‘Troubadours’ Quartet will enjoy meeting some old acquaintances in passing, and anyone who likes maps (either for themselves or for the extra information they add to the story) will appreciate the beautiful charts of the Orkney’s and of Skarfr’s voyage.
An excellent sequel to ‘The Ring Breaker’ - I’m already looking forward to the next volume!
January 16, 2024
Viking voyages, political scheming, love affairs, runes, and sea battles - what more could you want from a story? The second book in the tale of star-crossed lovers Skarfr (bard and warrior) and Hlif (cursed witch and Jarl’s steward) follows them as they take on the long sea journey from Orkney to Jerusalem with their newly Christian leader.
The clash of old and new faiths forms the background to plenty more conflict between rival Viking lords, the apparently uncouth pilgrims and the gallant French and Spanish courts they visit along the way, and between many characters who hold grudges from past misdeeds.
The story this time follows the servants of Skarfr too - the enslaved Fergus and Brigid from Ireland who are waiting for their freedom to be formalised when one of Skarfr’s enemies takes revenge by burning their home and kidnapping Brigid, sending Fergus, who loves her, on a quest of his own.
I’ve been reading a fair few historic fiction books recently and increasingly am concluding that the good ones wear their deep research lightly, not swamping readers with details but allowing the tale to lead the way. Jean has this gift. You root for the characters and learn en route, but the pages turn easily and you can expect to read late to finish this one. Now I’m waiting for the next book eagerly!
Note - I received a free review copy of this book, and my own book “Words the Vikings Gave Us” was used in the research.
The clash of old and new faiths forms the background to plenty more conflict between rival Viking lords, the apparently uncouth pilgrims and the gallant French and Spanish courts they visit along the way, and between many characters who hold grudges from past misdeeds.
The story this time follows the servants of Skarfr too - the enslaved Fergus and Brigid from Ireland who are waiting for their freedom to be formalised when one of Skarfr’s enemies takes revenge by burning their home and kidnapping Brigid, sending Fergus, who loves her, on a quest of his own.
I’ve been reading a fair few historic fiction books recently and increasingly am concluding that the good ones wear their deep research lightly, not swamping readers with details but allowing the tale to lead the way. Jean has this gift. You root for the characters and learn en route, but the pages turn easily and you can expect to read late to finish this one. Now I’m waiting for the next book eagerly!
Note - I received a free review copy of this book, and my own book “Words the Vikings Gave Us” was used in the research.
February 4, 2024
The second in the Midwinter Dragon series set in the time of the Vikings. It’s 1150 in Orkneyjar and skald Scarfr sets off on a pilgrimage on a seafaring journey to the Holy Land, alongside Jarl Rognvald and his crew. Skarfr is secretly handfasted to the only woman on board, Hlif, the Jarl’s ward. Scarfr is torn between the Jarl and his lady love. Who will he choose and which oath will he break?
It was great to visit Scarfr and Hlif again and see how they were getting on! I loved my time on the Sun Chaser with them. This is a well written and exciting story. The research which has gone into it is amazing. I like the quotes from Norse poetry at the beginning of Scarfr’s chapters, a nice little addition. The characters are well drawn and the plot is skilfully penned. A vivid and atmospheric read with some stunning imagery, I look forward to joining Scarfr and Hlif on their next adventure.
It was great to visit Scarfr and Hlif again and see how they were getting on! I loved my time on the Sun Chaser with them. This is a well written and exciting story. The research which has gone into it is amazing. I like the quotes from Norse poetry at the beginning of Scarfr’s chapters, a nice little addition. The characters are well drawn and the plot is skilfully penned. A vivid and atmospheric read with some stunning imagery, I look forward to joining Scarfr and Hlif on their next adventure.
December 27, 2023
This novel fits solidly in the Viking saga genre, with all of the required elements: storms, swords, religious turmoil. Loyalty questions, tragedy, siblings, sex, blood….. yep; check the boxes.
With all that said, it is ALSO a good solid story with all the required elements…..so if you like Vikings, this is a very fun and well crafted tale. A great ADDITION, and what sets this book a bit apart is the focus on the poetic and saga driven side of the Northmen and the cultural depth of the tale-tellers and oral traditions.
The insertion of the Nordic culture into the Mediterranean world is very thoughtfully and well done, from a place of mutual discovery and evaluation, not stubborn dogmatism.
I enjoyed this book, and appreciated the research that went into the crafting of the characters, the plot, and the settings.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
With all that said, it is ALSO a good solid story with all the required elements…..so if you like Vikings, this is a very fun and well crafted tale. A great ADDITION, and what sets this book a bit apart is the focus on the poetic and saga driven side of the Northmen and the cultural depth of the tale-tellers and oral traditions.
The insertion of the Nordic culture into the Mediterranean world is very thoughtfully and well done, from a place of mutual discovery and evaluation, not stubborn dogmatism.
I enjoyed this book, and appreciated the research that went into the crafting of the characters, the plot, and the settings.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
February 12, 2024
Can't wait for the next book!
Jean does immaculate historical research and really brings the Viking world alive. I always find some bits to look up to find out more. For example, I had not heard of Havelok the Dane, so had to look that up. Jean relishes language and poetry, and I enjoyed the three part descriptions which Skarfr used to define things.
I can hardly wait to read more about Skarfr and Hilf, Fergus and Brigit and Inge and Finn.
Jean does immaculate historical research and really brings the Viking world alive. I always find some bits to look up to find out more. For example, I had not heard of Havelok the Dane, so had to look that up. Jean relishes language and poetry, and I enjoyed the three part descriptions which Skarfr used to define things.
I can hardly wait to read more about Skarfr and Hilf, Fergus and Brigit and Inge and Finn.
February 11, 2024
A very entertaining story of the continuing Viking saga of Skarfr and Hlif. They sail off with nine ships on a Crusade to Jerusalem, and have amazing adventures along the way, including meeting Saracens in Spain. Treachery, betrayal, love, honor, loyalty--all are themes that make this a fantastic Viking epic saga.
Highly recommended!
Highly recommended!
Read
February 11, 2024The main character skafr is the driving story with the love of his life but as always the authors research helps to solidify the fictional story and draws you into this world a five star read .. anyone who appreciates this genre should delve into the realms of dhis authors books I’ve sung and danced about them
February 11, 2024
Again such wonderful characters. A real skill in writing in such a way that the reader feels totally immersed. Such a fascinating historical era.
February 22, 2025
I so love the Midwinter Dragon series. Jean Gill spins such an engaging adventure through the eyes of the Orkney Vikings of the mid-twelfth century, drawn from the events recounted in The Orkneyinga Saga. This second book of this series takes you from Orkney to Sicily as a group of warriors loyal to Jarl Rognvald accompanies him on pilgrimage to Jerusalem. I very much enjoyed the journey. I am very much looking forward to the next book in the series!
February 11, 2024
Among Sea Wolves," the second installment in Jean Gill's Midwinter Dragon series, sweeps readers into a mesmerizing tale set amidst the tumultuous Viking era. Gill masterfully crafts a narrative rich with historical detail, vivid characters, and captivating plotlines, and I was soon thoroughly immersed in the world of Skarfr, Hlif, and their companions.
At the heart of the story is Skarfr, the warrior-poet, and Hlif, the enigmatic mystic, whose forbidden love is tested as they embark on a perilous pilgrimage to the Holy Land alongside Jarl Rognvald and his crew. Gill expertly navigates the complexities of their relationship, weaving together themes of loyalty, love, and sacrifice against the backdrop of Viking culture and traditions.
The journey itself is fraught with danger, from treacherous sea monsters to internal power struggles among the crew. Gill's meticulous research shines through in the vivid descriptions of life aboard Viking longships, and transported me to the harsh yet exhilarating world of 12th-century seafaring.
However, "Among Sea Wolves" is more than just a thrilling adventure. Gill deftly explores the intricacies of human emotions and relationships, delving into the inner conflicts faced by her characters as they grapple with duty, desire, and the inexorable pull of fate. From Skarfr's struggle to reconcile his loyalty to the Jarl with his love for Hlif, to Hlif's quest for redemption and acceptance, each character is imbued with depth and nuance, making them feel wholly real and relatable.
The narrative is propelled forward by Gill's masterful prose, which effortlessly blends poetic lyricism with gritty realism. The pacing is taut and suspenseful, and kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end.
Overall, "Among Sea Wolves" is a triumph of historical fiction, seamlessly blending fact with fiction to create a compelling and immersive story that will captivate readers from start to finish. Jean Gill has proven herself to be a master storyteller, and I can’t wait to read the next instalment in the Midwinter Dragon series.
At the heart of the story is Skarfr, the warrior-poet, and Hlif, the enigmatic mystic, whose forbidden love is tested as they embark on a perilous pilgrimage to the Holy Land alongside Jarl Rognvald and his crew. Gill expertly navigates the complexities of their relationship, weaving together themes of loyalty, love, and sacrifice against the backdrop of Viking culture and traditions.
The journey itself is fraught with danger, from treacherous sea monsters to internal power struggles among the crew. Gill's meticulous research shines through in the vivid descriptions of life aboard Viking longships, and transported me to the harsh yet exhilarating world of 12th-century seafaring.
However, "Among Sea Wolves" is more than just a thrilling adventure. Gill deftly explores the intricacies of human emotions and relationships, delving into the inner conflicts faced by her characters as they grapple with duty, desire, and the inexorable pull of fate. From Skarfr's struggle to reconcile his loyalty to the Jarl with his love for Hlif, to Hlif's quest for redemption and acceptance, each character is imbued with depth and nuance, making them feel wholly real and relatable.
The narrative is propelled forward by Gill's masterful prose, which effortlessly blends poetic lyricism with gritty realism. The pacing is taut and suspenseful, and kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end.
Overall, "Among Sea Wolves" is a triumph of historical fiction, seamlessly blending fact with fiction to create a compelling and immersive story that will captivate readers from start to finish. Jean Gill has proven herself to be a master storyteller, and I can’t wait to read the next instalment in the Midwinter Dragon series.
May 30, 2025
This book was entered in The Wishing Shelf Book Awards. This is what our readers thought:
Title: Among Sea Wolves: 1150 The Whale Road
Author: Jean Gill
Star Rating: 5 Stars
Number of Readers: 15
Stats
Editing: 10/10
Writing Style: 9/10
Content: 9/10
Cover: 5/5
Of the 15 readers:
15 would read another book by this author.
15 thought the cover was good or excellent.
15 felt it was easy to follow.
15 would recommend this book to another reader to try.
Of all the readers, 6 felt the author’s strongest skill was ‘plotting a story’.
Of all the readers, 4 felt the author’s strongest skill was ‘developing the characters’.
Of all the readers, 5 felt the author’s strongest skill was ‘writing style’.
15 felt the pacing was good or excellent.
15 thought the author understood the readership and what they wanted.
Readers’ Comments
“This historical novel has everything going for it – love, loyalty, betrayal, adventure, fast-pacing, and a wonderful setting. So grab a copy of this book and enjoy life on a Viking ship.” Male reader, aged 66
“Historical novels when set so far into the past can be difficult to write. But this author seems in her element, I felt I was back there with Hlif – who was the best character, by the way. The pacing is spot on, the adventure is unpredictable, and the characters are larger than life.” Female reader, aged 65
“A compelling ‘Viking’ saga that kept me rooted to the sofa for way too long. I intend to go back and check out the first book; I just hope it’s as good. Being born in the Viking city of York, this was perfect for me.” Female reader, aged 69
“Accessible writing, poetry, exotic, often harsh settings, What a gem this is! I was fully immersed in this watery world for the first page. I was particularly impressed by Jean Gill’s knowledge of the time and place. Very impressive.” Female reader, aged 49
To Sum It Up:
‘An adventure-filled, historical novel with a memorable cast of larger than life characters. A BRONZE MEDAL WINNER and highly recommended!’ Wishing Shelf Book Awards
Title: Among Sea Wolves: 1150 The Whale Road
Author: Jean Gill
Star Rating: 5 Stars
Number of Readers: 15
Stats
Editing: 10/10
Writing Style: 9/10
Content: 9/10
Cover: 5/5
Of the 15 readers:
15 would read another book by this author.
15 thought the cover was good or excellent.
15 felt it was easy to follow.
15 would recommend this book to another reader to try.
Of all the readers, 6 felt the author’s strongest skill was ‘plotting a story’.
Of all the readers, 4 felt the author’s strongest skill was ‘developing the characters’.
Of all the readers, 5 felt the author’s strongest skill was ‘writing style’.
15 felt the pacing was good or excellent.
15 thought the author understood the readership and what they wanted.
Readers’ Comments
“This historical novel has everything going for it – love, loyalty, betrayal, adventure, fast-pacing, and a wonderful setting. So grab a copy of this book and enjoy life on a Viking ship.” Male reader, aged 66
“Historical novels when set so far into the past can be difficult to write. But this author seems in her element, I felt I was back there with Hlif – who was the best character, by the way. The pacing is spot on, the adventure is unpredictable, and the characters are larger than life.” Female reader, aged 65
“A compelling ‘Viking’ saga that kept me rooted to the sofa for way too long. I intend to go back and check out the first book; I just hope it’s as good. Being born in the Viking city of York, this was perfect for me.” Female reader, aged 69
“Accessible writing, poetry, exotic, often harsh settings, What a gem this is! I was fully immersed in this watery world for the first page. I was particularly impressed by Jean Gill’s knowledge of the time and place. Very impressive.” Female reader, aged 49
To Sum It Up:
‘An adventure-filled, historical novel with a memorable cast of larger than life characters. A BRONZE MEDAL WINNER and highly recommended!’ Wishing Shelf Book Awards
December 13, 2023
I must confess, I adore this series, from the gorgeous covers to the very last page. and so, was thrilled when the second book ‘Among Sea Wolves’ arrived.
Scarfr and Hlif’s story continues as they set sail on the adventure of a lifetime. With Jean Gill’s skilful pen you can be assured they will face all kinds of peril – and we will be right there with them. The challenges faced by the main characters tease the reader from the crest of one wave to the pit of another's dilemma, chapter by chapter. It heightens the suspense and made me want to read on... just one more chapter... and then another, and another. Late into the night!
I loved the quotes from The Wanderer’s Hávamál' at the beginning of each of Scarfr's chapters. In my head I heard LOTR’s Lady Galadriel, both wise and calculating (a riddle or a warning). The quotes provide that pause, to reflect and guess at what they might mean as the next chapter unfolds. They definitely add to the scaldic feel of the whole novel. My favourite being… 'When you recognize evil, call it evil, and give your enemies no peace.'
The balance between the savagery of battle and male head-butting and the sensitivity of Scarfr and Hlif's relationship, is dealt with by a gentle, skilled hand, and it works so well, because without the extremes, the sacrifices wouldn't feel so real.
The prose is beautiful, painting a wonderful picture so easy to visualise. One example that I particularly liked was from Inge… 'She could feel the smile she wore, as new as her clothes, a little stiff but growing more comfortable each day'.
In conclusion… Marvelous, historically accurate ,skilled storytelling, with vivid imagery, and truly wonderful characters. This would step so easily onto the screen. With the popularity of Bernard Cornwell's 'The Last Kingdom' and his 'The Winter King' hitting our screens this month, I foresee a huge market for the Midwinter Dragon Saga.
I would wholly recommend - I can't wait for book 3!
Scarfr and Hlif’s story continues as they set sail on the adventure of a lifetime. With Jean Gill’s skilful pen you can be assured they will face all kinds of peril – and we will be right there with them. The challenges faced by the main characters tease the reader from the crest of one wave to the pit of another's dilemma, chapter by chapter. It heightens the suspense and made me want to read on... just one more chapter... and then another, and another. Late into the night!
I loved the quotes from The Wanderer’s Hávamál' at the beginning of each of Scarfr's chapters. In my head I heard LOTR’s Lady Galadriel, both wise and calculating (a riddle or a warning). The quotes provide that pause, to reflect and guess at what they might mean as the next chapter unfolds. They definitely add to the scaldic feel of the whole novel. My favourite being… 'When you recognize evil, call it evil, and give your enemies no peace.'
The balance between the savagery of battle and male head-butting and the sensitivity of Scarfr and Hlif's relationship, is dealt with by a gentle, skilled hand, and it works so well, because without the extremes, the sacrifices wouldn't feel so real.
The prose is beautiful, painting a wonderful picture so easy to visualise. One example that I particularly liked was from Inge… 'She could feel the smile she wore, as new as her clothes, a little stiff but growing more comfortable each day'.
In conclusion… Marvelous, historically accurate ,skilled storytelling, with vivid imagery, and truly wonderful characters. This would step so easily onto the screen. With the popularity of Bernard Cornwell's 'The Last Kingdom' and his 'The Winter King' hitting our screens this month, I foresee a huge market for the Midwinter Dragon Saga.
I would wholly recommend - I can't wait for book 3!
December 29, 2023
Book two of Jean Gill’s Midwinter Dragon Saga finds Skarfr and Hlif embarking on a pilgrimage to the holy city of Jorsalaheim (Jerusalem), at the head of the fleet of Jarl Rognvald’s Viking longships. Adventure-hungry, Skarfr is the Jarl’s appointed skald, though he is ambitious to be the subject of his own sagas. Hilf, the only woman on board, is serving as provisioner for the voyage – no small task. Outwardly, she is ‘everyone’s housekeeper and no one’s woman.’ But Hlif is on a personal pilgrimage. When at last she reaches Jorsalaheim, she will appeal to the White Christ for his blessing, and the pair will be wed. Until then, she insists that they must keep their forbidden love a secret. Then Skarfr can bring Hlif home as his bride to his homestead on Orkneyjar.
But though the Vikings have accepted the Christian god, to some he is but one of many. Others remain firmly loyal to the old gods. Their aim is political gain and plunder. It is a voyage that will bring murder, terrible storms and sea monsters, clashes both in battles and cultures and mystical encounters, but perhaps the greatest risk of all is treachery from within the ranks.
Jean Gill keeps the stakes and tension high as she skilfully balances life onboard and the home-land they have left behind. With the jarl away, and not knowing when – or if – he will return, tensions run high on Orkneyjar, as contenders engage in a power-play of their own, vying to fill Jarl Rognvald’s shoes. Meanwhile, cruel Thorbjorn exacts a terrible revenge for the part that Skarfr played in helping his ex-wife, the Lady Inge, escape his household.
A must for those already well-versed in Viking lore, but readers of Jean Gill’s The Troubadours series will enjoy cameo roles from Estela and Dragonetz as the pilgrims visit the port of Narbonne – a reminder that her other characters’ stories are playing out in parallel.
But though the Vikings have accepted the Christian god, to some he is but one of many. Others remain firmly loyal to the old gods. Their aim is political gain and plunder. It is a voyage that will bring murder, terrible storms and sea monsters, clashes both in battles and cultures and mystical encounters, but perhaps the greatest risk of all is treachery from within the ranks.
Jean Gill keeps the stakes and tension high as she skilfully balances life onboard and the home-land they have left behind. With the jarl away, and not knowing when – or if – he will return, tensions run high on Orkneyjar, as contenders engage in a power-play of their own, vying to fill Jarl Rognvald’s shoes. Meanwhile, cruel Thorbjorn exacts a terrible revenge for the part that Skarfr played in helping his ex-wife, the Lady Inge, escape his household.
A must for those already well-versed in Viking lore, but readers of Jean Gill’s The Troubadours series will enjoy cameo roles from Estela and Dragonetz as the pilgrims visit the port of Narbonne – a reminder that her other characters’ stories are playing out in parallel.
December 14, 2023
This captivating historical medieval saga takes us on a sea-faring journey from Orkney to Jerusalem, on one of the first pilgrimages to the Holy Land, whilst unfolding the heart breaking story of Skarfr and Hlif who travel as part of the retinue of Jarl Rognvald. She is the only woman aboard the Viking ships and travels as his ward, whilst he is his trusted skald. During their long voyage they stop at many ports including those of Barcelona, Venice and Palermo where the barbarian Northman meet the diverse people living together, trading and sharing their knowledge in the arts, literature and science. They look like savages compared to the Saracens, Jews and Catholic people who are so much more advanced then them. On the other hand back home a couple of thralls who were part of Skarfr's household, Fergus and Brigid are separated and have their lives ruined through an act of vengeance on the part of Thorbjon, the vindictive and abusive ex-husband of Inge, Brigid's friend. Their story is also one of great suffering, however through all the ordeals inflicted by the barbarian men, the woman in the story are the real courageous heroines who band together behind their cruel master's backs. I really enjoyed reading once again about some of the characters from a previous series, I loved taking a peek once again into the very cultured and romantic court of Venice and really appreciated how well researched the books by Ms. Gill always are, they are historically perfect whilst being imbued also with the myth of the old gods which the Northmen believed in. A story of courage, betrayal, abuse and love which I hope to read further about in book 3!
January 15, 2024
Jean Gill’s Among Sea Wolves, part 2 of the Midwinter Dragon saga, continues the story of Skarfr and Hlif as they embark on Rognvald’s pilgrimage to Jerusalem. The romance of the voyage gives way to the practicalities of a long and dangerous sea journey and the pressures of life aboard ships that are not equipped for creature comforts. We are given a fascinating insight into the logistics of such a journey, down to the sourcing of provisions along the way as well as the dangers faced both at sea and on land.
Meanwhile, back in Orkneyjar, Fergus and Brigid’s idyllic lives are shattered when Throbjorn visits a terrible revenge on them in answer to Skafr’s deliverance of his wife, Inge, out of his jurisdiction. Separated and each fearing the other to be lost forever, they have to bide their time apart and ensure they don’t further excite the wrath of Thorbjorn.
Inge, free of Thorbjorn’s oppression, is settled in Ness and preparing for her betrothal to Finn, a loyal and worthy partner. But the brooding menace of the slighted Thorbjorn casts a shadow on their happiness.
These are the threads of the saga that are worlds apart, but set to converge - no spoilers!
Historically accurate, Gill once again weaves fiction into fact to create an utterly convincing narrative of love, loss and loyalty set against the real-life dramas of 12th century viking history and lore.
We are tossed upon stormy seas and stormier relationships with Skarf and Hlif. Swashbuckling bravery is tempered with pathos as they are faced with tragedy as well as triumph.
Action-packed, this is more than a worthy sequel to “The Ring Breaker”. Jean Gill’s best yet!
Meanwhile, back in Orkneyjar, Fergus and Brigid’s idyllic lives are shattered when Throbjorn visits a terrible revenge on them in answer to Skafr’s deliverance of his wife, Inge, out of his jurisdiction. Separated and each fearing the other to be lost forever, they have to bide their time apart and ensure they don’t further excite the wrath of Thorbjorn.
Inge, free of Thorbjorn’s oppression, is settled in Ness and preparing for her betrothal to Finn, a loyal and worthy partner. But the brooding menace of the slighted Thorbjorn casts a shadow on their happiness.
These are the threads of the saga that are worlds apart, but set to converge - no spoilers!
Historically accurate, Gill once again weaves fiction into fact to create an utterly convincing narrative of love, loss and loyalty set against the real-life dramas of 12th century viking history and lore.
We are tossed upon stormy seas and stormier relationships with Skarf and Hlif. Swashbuckling bravery is tempered with pathos as they are faced with tragedy as well as triumph.
Action-packed, this is more than a worthy sequel to “The Ring Breaker”. Jean Gill’s best yet!
February 5, 2024
Among Sea Wolves carries on the story of Skarfr and Hlif, the young Viking couple having to keep their forbidden relationship a secret as they travel with Jarl Rognvald of Orkney on pilgrimage to Jerusalem. At the same time we follow what's happening to the leaders of Orkney left behind to battle for power, and those of their servants, Fergus and Brigid, who we met in the first book.
I really enjoyed the first book of the series and this follows on beautifully. If you have any interest in Viking history, these books are a really immersive experience. The author's research has obviously been meticulous as she doesn't just tell the story of the characters, but manages to place it all in the mindset of the time and people. Some of the Vikings, such as Rognvald, are converting to Christianity, others maintain the older beliefs, and it's interesting to see how these influence and contradict each other. Similarly in this book the pilgrimage takes us on the voyage to places like Narbonne and Sicily, vastly different to Orkney and a real shock to the Vikings to see such vast differences in culture, architecture and behvaiour. The characters are all well drawn and their behaviour makes sense, especially as we are given so much context of their belief system. Skarfr, the main character, is a skald, a poet and teller of sagas, and this series is really the saga of his own life that he yearns for throughout.
The book ends in a whole new situation and I can't wait to see where we go next!
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an advance copy in return for an honest review.
I really enjoyed the first book of the series and this follows on beautifully. If you have any interest in Viking history, these books are a really immersive experience. The author's research has obviously been meticulous as she doesn't just tell the story of the characters, but manages to place it all in the mindset of the time and people. Some of the Vikings, such as Rognvald, are converting to Christianity, others maintain the older beliefs, and it's interesting to see how these influence and contradict each other. Similarly in this book the pilgrimage takes us on the voyage to places like Narbonne and Sicily, vastly different to Orkney and a real shock to the Vikings to see such vast differences in culture, architecture and behvaiour. The characters are all well drawn and their behaviour makes sense, especially as we are given so much context of their belief system. Skarfr, the main character, is a skald, a poet and teller of sagas, and this series is really the saga of his own life that he yearns for throughout.
The book ends in a whole new situation and I can't wait to see where we go next!
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an advance copy in return for an honest review.
February 13, 2024
I enjoyed The Ring Breaker, the previous book in this series, despite the rather passive hero, Skarfr. In this book, Skarfr has deveoped the skills of a warrior and skald and is respected by all. He embarks on a sea journey to Jerusalem with his lord and mentor, Jarl Rognvald. However, what should be an exciting journey bogs down in descriptions of sailing, navigation, and petty arguments between Rognvald and his cousin Eindredi over how best to get to Jerusalem. Skarfr mysteriously learns 4 languages along the way. We don't get a feeling of the places they travel to along the way, as all the sailors care about is eating and sleeping. There's no sight seeing or sense of wonder. Even a shark hunt, which should have been exciting, is sedate, the outcome inevitable. Meanwhile, back in Orkney, the usual suspects are doing the usual plotting, with little sense of urgency. You would think that with Rognvald away so long, they could really have their way, but again they seem more interested in who they will sleep with. And my favourite character, Hlif, gets little to do or say in this book, even though she accompanies Rognvald on the voyage as ship's quartermaster. Her cat gets more to do!
Jean Gill's steady prose, while fluid, does not create emotion or excitement. Perhaps if she let herself go a bit in the writing, and let her characters behave less predictably, the book would have more appeal. It's well written and researched, but it's a slog, especially in the middle of the book, which becomes to use a nautical phrase, becalmed.
Jean Gill's steady prose, while fluid, does not create emotion or excitement. Perhaps if she let herself go a bit in the writing, and let her characters behave less predictably, the book would have more appeal. It's well written and researched, but it's a slog, especially in the middle of the book, which becomes to use a nautical phrase, becalmed.
May 13, 2024
Jean Gill’s return to the generation spanning Midwinter Dragon saga manages to feel more historically authentic than the first book, but only in exchange for less compelling character arcs.
Hilf and Skarfr remain the main draw of the story, and the step up to them dealing with more adult challenges such as parental responsibility and societal expectations is refreshing. I thought that every time Jean Gill checked in with these two, the story beats really resonated, and gave the book the momentum that it sorely needed.
The problems in Among Sea Wolves largely pools from the dilution of a very large cast, with many different characters appearing as perspective chapters. Due to the short amount of time we spend with them they lack the emotional depth and curiosity of Skarfr and Hilf, and feel more like an outlet for plot progression than worthwhile characters in their own right.
The book is further troubled by a fanservice crossover to Jean Gill’s other series (The Troubadours) which felt a bit unwelcome as someone who hasn’t read that series. It’s not necessarily egregious, but it was ultimately unnecessary and pads out an already slow section of the story.
Jean Gill’s mastery of the English language still supplies reasons to read Among Sea Wolves, and to be certain, this is by no means a bad book. I’m only soured because my feelings towards the first were so resoundingly positive that anything less comes across as a step down. For fans, this is worth picking up.
Hilf and Skarfr remain the main draw of the story, and the step up to them dealing with more adult challenges such as parental responsibility and societal expectations is refreshing. I thought that every time Jean Gill checked in with these two, the story beats really resonated, and gave the book the momentum that it sorely needed.
The problems in Among Sea Wolves largely pools from the dilution of a very large cast, with many different characters appearing as perspective chapters. Due to the short amount of time we spend with them they lack the emotional depth and curiosity of Skarfr and Hilf, and feel more like an outlet for plot progression than worthwhile characters in their own right.
The book is further troubled by a fanservice crossover to Jean Gill’s other series (The Troubadours) which felt a bit unwelcome as someone who hasn’t read that series. It’s not necessarily egregious, but it was ultimately unnecessary and pads out an already slow section of the story.
Jean Gill’s mastery of the English language still supplies reasons to read Among Sea Wolves, and to be certain, this is by no means a bad book. I’m only soured because my feelings towards the first were so resoundingly positive that anything less comes across as a step down. For fans, this is worth picking up.
January 22, 2024
This saga is a glorious tale for lovers of Norse history and lore. I was absolutely captivated from page one due to the exemplary attention to detail, the writing style and the immersive narrative
You will feel as if you are embarking on a voyage, learning about navigation methods and life on board a longboat, right down to the smallest details, including skincare. The level of research is astounding and the attention to detail is a joy to behold. These small details add an enriching layer to an already fully immersive saga
The interplay between Hlif and Skarfr is both inspiring and breathtaking, let alone Fergus' quest to be reunited with his lost love. The various relationships and politics are as tumultuous as the seas they traverse and so elegantly woven as to be easy to follow
A key element in this tale, is that it is told in the same style as Norse communities would share their sagas through prose and song and as such, having a warrior poet as an MMC and the well-chosen quotes in the epigraphs were an elegant and fitting detail, a really nice touch
Among Sea Wolves is a fantastic read for fans of Bernard Cornwell, Norse Lore, Viking Saga's and Voyages you can really get your teeth into. Fantastic!
I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily
You will feel as if you are embarking on a voyage, learning about navigation methods and life on board a longboat, right down to the smallest details, including skincare. The level of research is astounding and the attention to detail is a joy to behold. These small details add an enriching layer to an already fully immersive saga
The interplay between Hlif and Skarfr is both inspiring and breathtaking, let alone Fergus' quest to be reunited with his lost love. The various relationships and politics are as tumultuous as the seas they traverse and so elegantly woven as to be easy to follow
A key element in this tale, is that it is told in the same style as Norse communities would share their sagas through prose and song and as such, having a warrior poet as an MMC and the well-chosen quotes in the epigraphs were an elegant and fitting detail, a really nice touch
Among Sea Wolves is a fantastic read for fans of Bernard Cornwell, Norse Lore, Viking Saga's and Voyages you can really get your teeth into. Fantastic!
I received an advance review copy for free and I am leaving this review voluntarily
February 9, 2024
I don’t often read series… But when I do, they’re by Jean Gill. The writing is phenomenal, but make no mistake: this is an adventure story. The author’s historical research and literary flair are always in the service of the adventure, which is historical fiction at its best.
This book continues the saga of Skarfr and Hlif and many of the wonderfully memorable characters from The Ring Breaker. They’re placed in exotic new locales with risky new challenges in an absorbing dual narrative in the Orkney Islands and at sea—the Mediterranean Sea! If you’re looking for seafaring, here it is.
One reason I don’t tend to read series is that the cliffhanger endings of the books that aren’t the last often seem abrupt, an afterthought, a letdown, or otherwise not in line with the rest of the book. Not giving anything away, the ending of Among Sea Wolves does leave a lot of loose ends, but with a clear path for the future that feels more hopeful and well prepared than being truly left hanging. I don’t know how many other readers are like me, but I wanted to highlight how well the ending is done for anyone who is.
This book continues the saga of Skarfr and Hlif and many of the wonderfully memorable characters from The Ring Breaker. They’re placed in exotic new locales with risky new challenges in an absorbing dual narrative in the Orkney Islands and at sea—the Mediterranean Sea! If you’re looking for seafaring, here it is.
One reason I don’t tend to read series is that the cliffhanger endings of the books that aren’t the last often seem abrupt, an afterthought, a letdown, or otherwise not in line with the rest of the book. Not giving anything away, the ending of Among Sea Wolves does leave a lot of loose ends, but with a clear path for the future that feels more hopeful and well prepared than being truly left hanging. I don’t know how many other readers are like me, but I wanted to highlight how well the ending is done for anyone who is.
February 11, 2024
Among sea wolves by Jean Gill.
The midwinter dragon book 2.
Warrior-poet Skarfr embarks on a death-defying pilgrimage with his ruler, Jarl Rognvald, from the wind-whipped shores of Orkney to the Holy Land. He is one of the few men trusted by the Jarl, whether facing sea-monsters or murder. Fifteen ships sail on the ‘whale road’ in the pilgrims’ fleet. The only woman among the ‘sea wolves’, Hlif is respected as much for her practical skills as for her mystical gifts. Yet beneath her indomitable façade lies a secret – she is handfasted to Skarfr, their love forbidden by the Jarl’s decree. As tensions rise, Skarfr is torn between fealty to his Jarl and devotion to Hlif. One oath must be broken but which one? How can he steer a course between loyalty and love without losing his honour?
I really did enjoy this book. I love the cover. Different. I did like how Gill changed their names and places to modern equivalent. The writing is unique. I liked the family tree aswell. I did like the story as it carried on from book 1. I liked the little pictures at the start of each chapter. I did like Skarfr and Hlif. I do hope there is more to come as I feel there is. 4*.
The midwinter dragon book 2.
Warrior-poet Skarfr embarks on a death-defying pilgrimage with his ruler, Jarl Rognvald, from the wind-whipped shores of Orkney to the Holy Land. He is one of the few men trusted by the Jarl, whether facing sea-monsters or murder. Fifteen ships sail on the ‘whale road’ in the pilgrims’ fleet. The only woman among the ‘sea wolves’, Hlif is respected as much for her practical skills as for her mystical gifts. Yet beneath her indomitable façade lies a secret – she is handfasted to Skarfr, their love forbidden by the Jarl’s decree. As tensions rise, Skarfr is torn between fealty to his Jarl and devotion to Hlif. One oath must be broken but which one? How can he steer a course between loyalty and love without losing his honour?
I really did enjoy this book. I love the cover. Different. I did like how Gill changed their names and places to modern equivalent. The writing is unique. I liked the family tree aswell. I did like the story as it carried on from book 1. I liked the little pictures at the start of each chapter. I did like Skarfr and Hlif. I do hope there is more to come as I feel there is. 4*.
December 8, 2023
Thanks to the publisher for the Advanced Review Copy. In this second instalment of Jean Gill’s “The Midwinter Dragon’ series the author takes us on an amazing sea adventure that reeks of suspenseful and enthralling tales told in a Viking hall. As they set sail with other Norse men on a perilous sea pilgrimage both Hlif and Skarfr have their own challenges to navigate. Hlif is coming into her own as a woman filled with mystical gifts and an iron will to manage it, but as the lone woman on the voyage guided by strict rules governing her position, there is constant danger from others who want to eliminate her influence. Skarfr finds the growing pains of Viking manhood a tug between his duty, honour and fealty while trying to maintain his love and devotion to Hlif. It’s a mix that makes for thrilling reading but also filled with all the details, large and small, that make it a real Viking adventure. The story is meticulously researched, yet far from overburdened by it, it gives an in depth view of Viking life artfully inserted into a lively and compelling narrative.
December 6, 2023
I have read an Advanced Review Copy of 'Among Sea Wolves', the second book in Jean Gill's excellent new Viking epoch series. This story takes the protagonists Skarfr and Hlif on a sea voyage pilgrimage heading for the Holy Land. Gill's impeccable research recreates life at sea in a longship so well I felt I was there. The story of how Skarfr and Hlif try to hide their love, and the means by which they can spend time together makes compelling reading. As does what happens to the two thralls we meet in the Book 1, Fergus and Brigid. Gill shows how everybody's life was in jeopardy (especially women) in this epoch. High-ranking women and domestic thralls, their life-styles and prospects may be very different but they are equally constrained. This is top quality literary historical fiction; a cracking story with action and adventure based on real events, plus a touch of magic. Highly recommended.
May 5, 2024
I chose to read this book due to a general interest in Scotland, Vikings, and Norse mythology. When I saw that it was the second in the series, I went back and picked up the first to get the full experience of what these books had to offer (I'm nothing if not thorough). The first book was an interesting look at the day-to-day life of people living in an Orkney village circa 1140. Although I didn't love every scene (the more realistic village scenes were much better than the fantasy cave scene, IMO), I thought the book was interesting and was curious to see what happened next.
This book, unfortunately, just didn't hold up for me. Perhaps it was a mistake to read the books back-to-back as it made for a really long adventure with these characters, but I just didn't like the second book as well as the first. It was difficult to follow along in the adventure as the place names were all unrecognizable to me (yes, there was a translation page, but it disrupted the reading to reference it repeatedly). The sea setting was less compelling to me overall and I was longing for them to just reach any destination so that we could move the story along a little bit. I liked the balance between following the action with Skarfr and Hlif and checking back to Inge and Thorbjorn back in Orkney, but just got tired of reading the book well before I finished the story.
It's apparent that the author is well-read and researched everything thoroughly before writing this series. The author's note was comprehensive and the story was clearly realistic (the fantasy aspects in this one were more to my liking than in book 1, actually). I think that the books would be improved with more streamlined titles-- the series name "The Midwinter Dragon" was fine, I guess. "Among Sea Wolves" is nice, but the subtitle of "1150: The Whale Road" was a bit much-- same for book 1's "The Ring Breaker" compared to its subtitle "1139 Orkneyjahr." It's just a little bit too much to have 5 titles/subtitles to refer to 2 books. I feel like the subtitles could have just been thrown into the author's note. And I guess that was my issue with the whole book. It was just a little wordy and structured without having enough compelling scenes and situations.
Am I glad I read this? Yes. Am I relieved that it's over and I can read something else now? Also Yes. I'm giving this 3 stars, although 2.5 would be more honest.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing a free copy of this book in return for my review.
This book, unfortunately, just didn't hold up for me. Perhaps it was a mistake to read the books back-to-back as it made for a really long adventure with these characters, but I just didn't like the second book as well as the first. It was difficult to follow along in the adventure as the place names were all unrecognizable to me (yes, there was a translation page, but it disrupted the reading to reference it repeatedly). The sea setting was less compelling to me overall and I was longing for them to just reach any destination so that we could move the story along a little bit. I liked the balance between following the action with Skarfr and Hlif and checking back to Inge and Thorbjorn back in Orkney, but just got tired of reading the book well before I finished the story.
It's apparent that the author is well-read and researched everything thoroughly before writing this series. The author's note was comprehensive and the story was clearly realistic (the fantasy aspects in this one were more to my liking than in book 1, actually). I think that the books would be improved with more streamlined titles-- the series name "The Midwinter Dragon" was fine, I guess. "Among Sea Wolves" is nice, but the subtitle of "1150: The Whale Road" was a bit much-- same for book 1's "The Ring Breaker" compared to its subtitle "1139 Orkneyjahr." It's just a little bit too much to have 5 titles/subtitles to refer to 2 books. I feel like the subtitles could have just been thrown into the author's note. And I guess that was my issue with the whole book. It was just a little wordy and structured without having enough compelling scenes and situations.
Am I glad I read this? Yes. Am I relieved that it's over and I can read something else now? Also Yes. I'm giving this 3 stars, although 2.5 would be more honest.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing a free copy of this book in return for my review.
February 8, 2024
Our main characters are away from Orkney and on a voyage, or pilgrimage, to Jerusalem, in a party that even from the start is divided and fractious. With Skarfr having to hide his true relationship with Hlif, things are tense anyway. This is another tremendous episode in this saga of Viking adventure and romance, where you can see the terrific quantity of research that has gone into it and then forget it and enjoy living the book with all its excitement, not just with Skarfr and his ever-growing list of skills, nor with the wonderful and mystical Hlif, but with the people he has left behind in the north and all their hideous politicking. A great set-up for the next in the series.
February 1, 2024
FYI, I received this as an ARC. I really would give this book 3 1/2 but 4 was more fair than 3. The reason is the frequent shifting between stories and characters. It was too frequent and left little time for any real character development. More time could have been used in furthering the story as well. As is, it is setting up the next book for some dynamic story and I am definitely eager to find out what happens to everyone. Hopefully, as stories converge, more plot development can be had and we can really see these wonderful characters blossom.
March 6, 2024
I enjoyed book two more than book.one, I've had time to settle in and get invested with the characters now. And there are a few more threads this time plus more voyaging and history. The uniqueness of the orkneymen's culture stands out against what we traditionally think of as the standard for the age. Another historically rich story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews