If you're familiar with my reviews, you know by now I'm an avid reader, and a pretty big fan of faithful Biblical fiction. Thus yes, I have read my share of Esther retellings, some stronger than others. Until Protector though, I had never read a speculative fantasy retelling of Esther before and didn't know what to expect. Actually, I bought Protector long before reading it. It just kind of ended up sitting on my TBR pile. Once I got started though, I ended up saying, "What took me so long?"
I do want to offer a slight disclaimer, in that Protector is a young adult novel and I'm somewhat "outside" the target audience. Yet, I write and love YA, so I hope you'll indulge me. Plus, this particular book is superb. Part of the reason is of course, the characters. Novalisse/Astra caught my attention right away with a voice that sounds like an authentic young adult, but holds the signature maturity of a young woman who's lived as an orphan for years and is also a brilliant survivor in a gritty, harsh world. I remember feeling like she did when I was younger. In fact, I still have moments when like Astra, I say, "I want to make a difference. I'm sick of the sidelines; I want to do something real!" And then I end up saying, "No, I didn't mean like *that!*"
Besides that, Astra is a cool, fascinating character, precisely because she and I are different. She's a soldier and an athlete, and a gifted one at that. I indulged in a rueful laugh when Astra first began competing, as in, "Yeah, I'm totally out." Yet I followed her out of admiration and complete respect. I also loved her subtle nods toward friendship, even though she knew helping other girls win would mean she would lose and likely die. This, coupled with moments of understandable cowardice, lent depth and gravitas to her character. Plus, brownie points for Astra's talent in chemistry and ink and some of her ending surprise moves on the final obstacle course. I remember thinking, "Wow! I'd want to try something like that!"
The plot of Protector had me reading at a breakneck pace and on the edge of my seat more than once. One moment in particular, with Hej, had me sitting up and exclaiming out loud, "Okay, WHAT did I just read?" Then I read it again--and said the same thing again! Hej is one shocking character, as are Zadien, Dex, Hatch, and so many others. In fact, one of the best things about Protector's plot is, you think you know who these characters are based on the Esther underpinnings. You think you know who Esther is, who Haman is, who Xerxes is, and what they're going to do at all times.
But while the character archetypes exist, no one does what they're "supposed to do" on an expected timeline. Protector hosts several twists that kept me guessing, and I didn't mind in the least. These twists gave some new gravitas to the story without straying from the basic truths of the Scriptural background. For instance, Astra is understandably angry that she's often left in the dark while everybody else seemingly gets to push her around. That's not in Scripture, but knowing what we do of Esther's character and how she got to Xerxes' palace, yes, she absolutely could've experienced similar emotions. Later, Astra and Zadien end up burned because of how an initial chemistry-filled romance plays out. Again, the Bible doesn't tell us anything like that, but given their culture and the expectations placed on royals--again, it works.
What also worked for me was Megan Shaulis' excellent world-building. First of all, her world-building is surprisingly deft and detailed for a relatively short book. Second, I embraced and devoured every detail, from the contestants' enhancements to the intrigues of a tech-enhanced royal court in the middle of desert Susa, to the hidden, yet nefarious plot against young women in particular. I was somewhat shocked and disappointed at Megan's cliffhanger ending, but that cliffhanger just left me salivating for more of Astra's world, its people, and her story as the follower of Alpha who would save her country's women and people.
Ah, yes, last but not least, Alpha and the subtle yet beautiful spiritual threads. I really can't thank Megan enough for the route she took with them. That is--and I have written this before--the Christian fiction market has a lot of books in which Christianity is completely banned or hidden, and teenagers are tasked with either "saving" it or bringing it back (see Left Behind: The Kids, the Mark series, When Angels Cry, and so on. Nothing wrong with those books, it's just, they've been seen, a lot).
With Astra's world, Alpha is in fact God, and He is in fact the Judeo-Christian God as far as readers can tell. But here, He speaks to Astra as a real, constant Person in her life, while still sounding as the real God might sound, based on the Old and New Testaments. Moreover, Astra doesn't read as the "savior" who will keep Alpha from being "banned." Rather, in her world, it's more, "Alpha exists and following Him is a risk. But here is why the risk is worth it, and why it will keep being worth it." That's a new take I can definitely get behind and want to see more of in Megan's next installment.
I personally can't wait for that installment. Since I have no choice, I recommend Protector, as well as similar books like it, such as The Nightmare Virus or the Cry of the Raven trilogy. I hope to meet Megan and readers back here sooner rather than later to discover where Astra's version of the Esther story goes next.