Found this very easy and engaging to read. Was a page turner. The author Elisabeth Earnshaw’s (Liz) politics around the impact of financial stress and capitalism on stress was not great. Despite this, she provides good tips that I think would apply to many people. Liz explains stress and how it operates very well. However, she doesn’t describe general stress management tips, just more how it operates and affects people. It was great Liz discussed the mental load and it’s impacts on clients. Liz’s examples of her work with couples and her own interweaving of her life and reflections was so interesting, though I did find some of the stories quite intense because of my own relationship to them (especially cancer related ones).
I liked Liz incorporating all these therapy concepts in the book, with clear examples of what they entail. I enjoyed all her insights and lessons as a couples therapist. It feels like a lot of the book is a clear presentation of other therapy research and concepts - like Emily Nagoski’s “Come as You Are” and Esther Perel’s ideas on the importance of ritual and routine. Liz talking about her techniques in therapy to self regulate herself, and not project on the client was interesting. As I’m studying to be a clinical psychologist it was all really interesting and helpful.
I feel like some sections could have been signposted or more nuanced around financial issues and capitalism as a cause of stress.
- Liz mentions she’s privileged to be able to afford child care. And she mentions not everyone can afford to outsource help like cleaners or childcare, and instead need to rely on community. But she doesn’t properly address poverty or capitalism. The book seems very targeted to the middle class.
- The book doesn’t seem very intersectional in terms of discussing the role of capitalism, sexism, racism, ableism etc. on stress. Liz has a section where she gets a lot of hate comments on her Instagram, one saying “why haven’t you posted about the protests in Philly and what you believe? You’re complicit in harm!”. She then mentions she has been passionate about social justice her entire life, and social justice matters to her but the administrative tasks of daily life leave her no time to research social justice stuff and lean into what matters to her. However surely being up to date on left wing issues is important in therapy? And there are ways to contribute that are lower energy than researching & writing your own political posts - such as reposting other people’s left wing content, attending protests, having deep discussions with friends on issues etc.
- Liz gives an example of her and her husband struggling with money yet they can afford to buy a small apartment to rent out and have childcare. More care could have been used with the wording “not much money” if you can afford to buy an apartment. Also I believe landlords shouldn’t exist, as it takes property off the market and exploits and profits off a basic need.
- This quote from Liz “Many of us are stuck with an endless list of unsolvable, out-of-our-control problems—viruses, chronic illnesses, crime, financial crises, poor political leadership, lack of community connection, long hours at work, too much screen time, and civil unrest—so we pour extra stress into our cup by choice in order to have something to control” feels apolitical. She mentions “poor political leadership” rather than capitalists, and “civil unrest” normally refers to protests for good causes.
- This quote from Liz “Choosing to add stress and refusing to remove it is one of the biggest quagmires of our time” is wrong. Firstly, it’s mainly only for middle class people that having too much on your plate is a choice. It’s a luxury to be able to take something off your plate & have it not negatively affect the quality of your life e.g. if you are financially struggling, working two or more jobs may be your only option for adequate income.
- Liz mentions how hard Covid was for everyone. And how it was hard for her as a non-stop woman who filled her days with things. She discusses the ramifications of this. However, she does not mention her financial privilege during the situation!