A free digital copy of this book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
It’s tough to describe what Nick the Saint is. There are fantastical elements set in New York during the Industrialization, but the fantasy aspects are too few to regard it as an actual fantasy book. However, it isn’t realistic fiction because most of the events that happened in this book are no way a part of history. As you can see, it is rather difficult to review this book. A struggle, in fact. Which is why I apologize in advance for the incoherence and inarticulateness of this review.
Nick the Saint is the story of a man named Nick who was wrongly imprisoned by Fergus Crank, a powerful man in New York who had everybody under his thumb. With the help of Benny, a crazy inventor, and a priest, Nick runs around town to sabotage all of Fergus’ businesses, freeing the children forced to work under the power-hungry man in the process. Obviously, this is not the story of St. Nicholas, the man we all presume to be the actual historical figure behind Santa Claus.
Prison does things to a man; it forces him to stifle the joy, to bury it so no one can use it against him, but after a while, it gets pushed so deep the man fears he’ll never find it again.
Nick the Saint was compelling enough, but being told in third person with varying perspectives, it lacked the certain depth and moving narration that would have stirred up something more than a shallow enjoyment in me. Yes, I did enjoy the book, but was I touched? Did it stir something in me? No. I pitied the working children but that pity was more for the fact that child labor continues to happen until now, instead of the sympathy provoked by excellent writing. In short, the plot was engaging but the characters lacked distinctiveness, personality and charisma. I did not connect with any person in this book, nor was I on the same wavelength as they were.
For me, a book is truly great is when the gap between the reader and the characters of the story is bridged. Nick the Saint failed to do that. There was always a huge chasm that separated me from Nick, Molly, Benny or any other character featured in this story.
“Didn’t matter. People needed to know – and I’m not just talking about slaves, but all people – they need to know there were still those willing to stand and fight, to defend the ones who can’t defend themselves.”
The fantastical feature of Nick the Saint left me baffled and confused. As it is set in the Industrialization, there were a lot of gadgets presented, including a dancing doll, a bulletproof vest, magnetic hands and a flying sleigh. This was rather jarring to the overall atmosphere of the book. We had the grittiness of the city and the depressing quality of life and the sudden bouts of these technological advances were nonsensical and absurd. At the start of the book, Benny mentions that he was sent to prison after building a flying car for the president which didn’t work. This was just a total ‘huh’ moment for me and these were the parts of Nick the Saint, that made it a little ridiculous.
In A Nutshell:
Overall, Nick the Saint was a semi-disappointment. It was an engaging read but I felt that the gravity of its subject had to have at least stirred up some sort of emotion in me as I was reading it. The dryness and flatness of the characters coupled with the senseless fantastical elements didn’t make it better. As the sneak peek at the end of this book revealed, there is a sequel, but I don’t think I’ll be reading that anymore.