Dr Weinstein chronicles how he spent eight years fighting to help obtain justice for his father, who, along with eight other Canadians, was suing the CIA for negligence in its sponsorship of Dr Ewen Cameron's mind control experiments. That programme included lengthy periods of multiple electroshocks, hallucinogenic drugs such as LSD, prolonged sensory deprivation, forced sleep, induced insulin comas, and psychic driving - an attempt to alter behaviour by forcing patients to listen to taped messages over and over again. In his book, Dr Weinstein describes his feelings of horror and helplessness while watching his father's health and personality be destroyed as he underwent Cameron's experimental protocol. "Psychiatry and the Victims of Mind Control" is Harvey Weinstein's personal account of the events at the Allan Memorial Institute. A chronicle of a medical scandal of horrific proportions, this book is also a story of government misconduct, deceit, and cover-ups. Dr Weinstein further raises questions about the vulnerability of contemporary medicine to the abuse of patients in the context of repeated episodes of ethical transgressions during this century.
Harvey was twelve when his father walked into a Montreal hospital and came out someone else. This memoir by psychiatrist and human rights advocate Dr. Harvey M. Weinstein (not the movie producer) recalls how he lost his childhood after his father was subjected to wretched mind-control experiments. I found it after reading the book he co-authored with his wife Rhona, The Empty Envelope, which felt close to home. This one, thankfully, didn't. I'm grateful I can't relate to what Harvey went through, because even imagining his pain stings like hell. In the 1950s, Lou Weinstein, a gregarious, successful businessman, was left barely able to function after he went into Dr. Ewen Cameron's care at Montreal's Allan Memorial Institute—a notorious outpost of MKULTRA, funded by the CIA and the Canadian government. Harvey lost his childhood, and his mother had to become a caretaker. The joy turned to anger, the business went, and then the house… Harvey writes these devastating events in the early chapters so poignantly that they made me cry buckets of tears. You can feel his pain and anger in your gut. And somehow, that pain drew him into psychiatry, the very profession that broke his father. Then he took the Canadian government and the CIA to court. Dude’s made of titanium. The book then turns to the experiments, their victims, and the fight in court. Harvey lays out the facts about Ewen Cameron’s treatments, like shock treatment, long periods of induced sleep, and hours of “psychic driving,” weighed against the medical ethics and legal precedents of the 1950s and 60s. I was left with zero ambiguity that what happened was heinous, and that’s putting it mildly. Both the CIA and the Canadian government stayed defensive despite being caught with their pants down, and offered, at best, a puny acknowledgment of the lives destroyed. Through all of it, Harvey's prose is genuinely beautiful, especially in his personal reflections. Some lines belong in literary history: "Each source of information was gathered into a square of brightly colored cloth: blues of depression, reds of passion, white of honor, and black of decay." "Canadian patriotism has always been a far more subtle theme than the flag-waving fireworks of the United States." And about Canada: "Was it merely a satellite of its giant neighbor?" Chapters 8, 13 and 14 show Harvey's intellectual prowess. The double whammy hit me really hard: a man who still bears the pain of his childhood, and a man struggling to come to terms with his profession. He tackles the questions that shaped these events head-on, and the answers aren't straightforward by a long shot. For me, the most thrilling part of the book is Harvey taking apart the Cooper Report, the biased and frankly absurd report the Canadian government hid behind to absolve itself. He wields a proverbial scalpel, even as a psychiatrist, to dismantle it with surgical precision. Even though it's one side of the story, he makes compelling points, backed by evidence and precedent. He reviews earlier cases showing that methods like Cameron's, and his approach to consent, were already considered unethical well before Cameron’s time. Yet the Cooper Report calls them acceptable for their era. I vote that Chapter 14 be renamed "The Harvey Report." Some themes repeat, but largely with good reason. They etch the book's core message (and I DO NOT mean through "driving"): ethics in psychiatry, ethics in general, and the refusal of Canada and the U.S. to take responsibility, whether by biased reports or, in the CIA's case, legal brute force. Chapters 9 and 15 are heavy-duty, full of names and excerpts that are hard to follow and kill the pacing. They provide the relevant background but don't move the story. They could easily have been appendices, since later chapters summarize them more concisely. Readers can skim through them. None of that takes away from how fiercely Harvey fought for his father, or how his early anger turned into the understanding that drove the fight. It touched me very deeply how this man juggled so much in the circus of his extraordinary life and yet kept going. The final chapter reads like a legal thriller. I couldn't wait to find out how it all ended, and the aftermath is captured poignantly. The book is not an easy read, and it's no fun, but it's a beautiful reminder that people like Harvey exist among us, unafraid to seek justice and fight for what is right. He continued to fight after the lawsuit, urging academic psychiatry to stay vigilant about ethics. Those lessons reach well beyond medicine. A twelve-year-old lost his father as he knew him. What followed forged him into titanium.
There are several books about the disastrous effects of Dr. Ewen Cameron's CIA-sponsored mind-control experiments in Montreal in the 50s and 60s, but this one is unique, as far as I know, inasmuch as it's written from the point of view of a family member of one of the victims. Weinstein, himself a practicing psychiatrist in San Francisco, has written a book that holds the reader's attention from start to finish, whether he's discussing his family history, attempting to understand how Cameron became such a monster, delving into the origins of the brainwashing techniques Cameron used on Weinstein's dad and others, or chronicling the story of the legal case some of the surviving victims made against the US government (eventually winning a settlement of a small sum of money for each plaintiff--disappointing, but as Weinstein notes, it was the best they could do). No self-pity here, just a great, tragic story, well told.