What do you think?
Rate this book
Song of Seare #2
Beneath the Forsaken City
Conor and Aine have barely escaped Seare with their lives. Conor knows he must return to find the harp that could end the Red Druid’s reign of terror, but in the midst of their escape, he and Aine are torn apart once more. Surrounded by despair and thrown into as much danger as they left behind, Conor and Aine must cling to the whispers of Comdiu’s plans for them and the homeland that depends on their survival. But at what cost? Will they learn to depend on Comdiu completely? Or will they give up hope?
432 pages, Paperback
First published January 16, 2015
13 people are currently reading
466 people want to read
About the author
C.E. Laureano
4 books67 followersC.E. Laureano’s love of fantasy began with a trip through a magical wardrobe, and she has never looked back. She’s happiest when her day involves martial arts, swords, and a well-choreographed fight scene, though when pressed, she’ll admit to a love of theater and travel as well. Appropriately, she’s wife to a martial arts master and mom to two boys who spend most of their time jumping off things and finding objects to turn into lightsabers. They live in Denver, Colorado with a menagerie of small pets.
C.E. also writes contemporary romance under the name Carla Laureano.
C.E. also writes contemporary romance under the name Carla Laureano.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews
September 16, 2024
4.5⭐️ "This is what happens when My people turn their back on Me. If I removed My influence from the land, people would be wishing for this as a paradise."
A storm on the horizon a musician, a seer and warrior. The brotherhood is scattered and it appears the rule of the Red Druid has closed ranked. Will they give up all hope or follow Comdiu (allegory for the Lord) forward into an unknown future. From the very beginning this story took off and did not let me go. I am so invested in these characters and their relationship dynamics. Especially, the complex romantic relationship for the characters was so great read. I really enjoyed the romantic subplot too! Seeing how obedience and disobedience to Comdiu impacts their lives and those they are responsible for was so palpable and relatable on page. The faith in this book is explored in more depth and was quite inspiring for me to read. AND THE ENDING!! was so shocking, I didn't see it coming at all! I love when my expectations are subverted! I will be reading the final book soon!
A storm on the horizon a musician, a seer and warrior. The brotherhood is scattered and it appears the rule of the Red Druid has closed ranked. Will they give up all hope or follow Comdiu (allegory for the Lord) forward into an unknown future. From the very beginning this story took off and did not let me go. I am so invested in these characters and their relationship dynamics. Especially, the complex romantic relationship for the characters was so great read. I really enjoyed the romantic subplot too! Seeing how obedience and disobedience to Comdiu impacts their lives and those they are responsible for was so palpable and relatable on page. The faith in this book is explored in more depth and was quite inspiring for me to read. AND THE ENDING!! was so shocking, I didn't see it coming at all! I love when my expectations are subverted! I will be reading the final book soon!
February 21, 2024
4⭐️ (both first time & reread)
On a ship, just days after their wedding, Conor & Ane are both taken away by the waves….they survive, but not together. They individually find themselves in predicaments beyond their control and try to serve Comdeiu the best they can.
I liked that this whole book has the newly wed, Conor and Ane not in the same geographical location.
I do find the magic in this story fairly confusing…🤷🏼♀️
Spoilers….
It was a bit odd that Ane kept wondering if she might be pregnant months after she’d even seen Conor…with no indication of her missing a period or not?!? I was a bit thrown off by that
On a ship, just days after their wedding, Conor & Ane are both taken away by the waves….they survive, but not together. They individually find themselves in predicaments beyond their control and try to serve Comdeiu the best they can.
I liked that this whole book has the newly wed, Conor and Ane not in the same geographical location.
I do find the magic in this story fairly confusing…🤷🏼♀️
Spoilers….
It was a bit odd that Ane kept wondering if she might be pregnant months after she’d even seen Conor…with no indication of her missing a period or not?!? I was a bit thrown off by that
June 8, 2021
"Leadership is a privilege and a responsibility, not a right. Those who are trusted with much are expected to do much."
Wow. And I had thought I loved the first book in the series. I love this one more! This second book has more excitement, adventure, suspense, action, magic, betrayal, and stark, raw human emotions, along with deeper faith and a more evident hand of the One who calls these incredible characters to Himself. This is a series that has to be read in order because the author creates a marvelous world in her first book that is the basis of all that happens in this one. If you enjoy Christian fantasy, you will absolutely love this book and series. If you've never read Christian fantasy, then you should totally try out this series; it will captivate you completely.
I loved that Eoghan, Liam, and Riordan have bigger roles and voices in this book. Oh, man - Eoghan is such a lovable character with his unusual gift of communicating directly with Comdiu (God) , his steadfast loyalty and faithfulness, and his maturity. Conor and Aine share separated for most of the book but their gifts grow and expand. The testing of their love and devotion, not knowing if the other is dead or alive, is painful and Conor's insecurity is so real and heart-breaking. The first book concentrated mostly on Conor's warrior training and status but this book created a more deeply layered Conor with his scholarly knowledge, intelligence, and musical gifts that bring out God's power. Aine becomes more perceptive and her increasing gifts are almost astounding. There are plenty of surprising twists and turns in the plot and the group of secondary characters, though quite a few in number, is excellent. As their war against the evil forces rages on, the prophecy regarding 'sword and song' bringing peace for a time and the coming of the High King is still a mystery. I can't wait for the third book!
I received the book from the author and Enclave Publishing and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are solely my own.
Wow. And I had thought I loved the first book in the series. I love this one more! This second book has more excitement, adventure, suspense, action, magic, betrayal, and stark, raw human emotions, along with deeper faith and a more evident hand of the One who calls these incredible characters to Himself. This is a series that has to be read in order because the author creates a marvelous world in her first book that is the basis of all that happens in this one. If you enjoy Christian fantasy, you will absolutely love this book and series. If you've never read Christian fantasy, then you should totally try out this series; it will captivate you completely.
I loved that Eoghan, Liam, and Riordan have bigger roles and voices in this book. Oh, man - Eoghan is such a lovable character with his unusual gift of communicating directly with Comdiu (God) , his steadfast loyalty and faithfulness, and his maturity. Conor and Aine share separated for most of the book but their gifts grow and expand. The testing of their love and devotion, not knowing if the other is dead or alive, is painful and Conor's insecurity is so real and heart-breaking. The first book concentrated mostly on Conor's warrior training and status but this book created a more deeply layered Conor with his scholarly knowledge, intelligence, and musical gifts that bring out God's power. Aine becomes more perceptive and her increasing gifts are almost astounding. There are plenty of surprising twists and turns in the plot and the group of secondary characters, though quite a few in number, is excellent. As their war against the evil forces rages on, the prophecy regarding 'sword and song' bringing peace for a time and the coming of the High King is still a mystery. I can't wait for the third book!
I received the book from the author and Enclave Publishing and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are solely my own.
August 16, 2015
“Beneath the Forsaken City” was a different read for me. I enjoyed seeing these characters again, even though it was a whirlwind of action in the beginning. It left me doubting if I would be happy for their upcoming journey.
It was through there journey’s though that the Gospel message and truths were able to shine. It was amazing! I felt this was a deeper fantasy read that presented the Gospel of Jesus Christ clearly throughout events Conor and Aine went through. I liked them both, but Conor blew me away in how he took a stand for his faith. He had a lot of regrets and was far from perfect, but he still held on to his faith and obeyed God, no matter the price.
Despite all the ongoing action, I didn’t feel comfortable with all the talk of witchcraft. I know it was mentioned in the first book, but there were many more scenes where the dark magic played a big role with a certain character or two. I understand it was necessary, but I didn’t necessarily agree with some of the description of its work.
This was a great action read with a powerful story of trusting God and demonstrating faith in uncertainty.
*(I received this novel from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own and I was not required to write a positive review.)*
It was through there journey’s though that the Gospel message and truths were able to shine. It was amazing! I felt this was a deeper fantasy read that presented the Gospel of Jesus Christ clearly throughout events Conor and Aine went through. I liked them both, but Conor blew me away in how he took a stand for his faith. He had a lot of regrets and was far from perfect, but he still held on to his faith and obeyed God, no matter the price.
Despite all the ongoing action, I didn’t feel comfortable with all the talk of witchcraft. I know it was mentioned in the first book, but there were many more scenes where the dark magic played a big role with a certain character or two. I understand it was necessary, but I didn’t necessarily agree with some of the description of its work.
This was a great action read with a powerful story of trusting God and demonstrating faith in uncertainty.
*(I received this novel from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own and I was not required to write a positive review.)*
April 8, 2017
This book, not compared to the first one, was fantastic! Compared, it was very good, but not quite as good as the first one. Four, I can't wait to see how the trilogy ends, stars!
This book kept this nervous flier so enrapt that I did not notice take offs or landings. So solid four stars. I DID jump over a few scenes that irked me, more so with the female MC than male, but I did skip one of his too. Still, read WAY more than I skipped. A worthy second book. :)
This book kept this nervous flier so enrapt that I did not notice take offs or landings. So solid four stars. I DID jump over a few scenes that irked me, more so with the female MC than male, but I did skip one of his too. Still, read WAY more than I skipped. A worthy second book. :)
June 8, 2021
I read the 1st book in The Song of Seare trilogy and loved it, even though I didn't think I'd like Christian fantasy. It was really great because it was set in the Dark Ages and I love reading about that era.
Now, I've read the 2nd book in the series, Beneath the Forsaken City. This one was amazingly good! It truly deserves more than the 5 stars I'm allowed to give it. This books takes up where the first left off and hits the ground running and never lets up. Even to the last sentence.
Now I'm left to sit on pins and needles until the 3rd and final book comes out in the fall.
Beaneath the Forsaken City is set in the Dark Ages, in a time of myth, magic and sorcery. There are some, however, who believe in the true god, Comdiu and His Son, Balus. This book takes the reader on a journey both frightening and thrilling at the same time.
Conor and Aine have just barely escaped Seare before being killed. Married by the captain of the vessel in which they leave, they hope for a new life that is happy, but fear the worst because of the war back in their homeland. Soon, they are parted again cruelly, each left to wonder long months if the other is even alive. Conor knows he must return to Seare at some point to find the harp and hopefully end the reign of terror began by the malicious Red Druid. Aine, too, knows that she must return to find Conor for their future lies in Seare. Both despair of on their own and find themselves in grave danger. The enemy tries to kill their love for one another and their hope in Comdiu. The danger is from both mortal and sorcery avenues. Will Conor and Aine give in to the despair surrounding them or will they trust Comdiu to fulfill His plans for their lives? Even if it means they never see each other again?
C.E.Laureano weaves a tale full and rich that draws the reader in from the very first sentences and does not let go, even when the book ends! Because you're so desperately longing for the third book to see what happens! She has created a land much as Tolkien created Middle Earth. She has also created characters that get down into your heart, characters that leave you thinking about them long after you finish the book. I am finding it hard to pick up another book because I'm still concentrating on the folks in Beneath The Forsaken City. I don't want to leave them, actually. As a matter of fact, I re-read Oath of the Brotherhood before reading this second novel because I wanted to refresh my memory. I'll probably re-read both the first two before I read the third and final book, too.
The authors draws the reader into the story so well that I felt as if I were there, seeing the destruction, feeling the dismay and heartache. This was a mighty fine book and I hated to see it end, but I'm very much looking forward to book three. Very well written novel, one that made me think about my own relationship with God and how I react to Him during difficult times.
I guarantee you will not be disappointed with either book. If you do read them, you must start with Oath of the Brotherhood; otherwise the second book will not make sense.
*I was given a copy of the book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
Now, I've read the 2nd book in the series, Beneath the Forsaken City. This one was amazingly good! It truly deserves more than the 5 stars I'm allowed to give it. This books takes up where the first left off and hits the ground running and never lets up. Even to the last sentence.
Now I'm left to sit on pins and needles until the 3rd and final book comes out in the fall.
Beaneath the Forsaken City is set in the Dark Ages, in a time of myth, magic and sorcery. There are some, however, who believe in the true god, Comdiu and His Son, Balus. This book takes the reader on a journey both frightening and thrilling at the same time.
Conor and Aine have just barely escaped Seare before being killed. Married by the captain of the vessel in which they leave, they hope for a new life that is happy, but fear the worst because of the war back in their homeland. Soon, they are parted again cruelly, each left to wonder long months if the other is even alive. Conor knows he must return to Seare at some point to find the harp and hopefully end the reign of terror began by the malicious Red Druid. Aine, too, knows that she must return to find Conor for their future lies in Seare. Both despair of on their own and find themselves in grave danger. The enemy tries to kill their love for one another and their hope in Comdiu. The danger is from both mortal and sorcery avenues. Will Conor and Aine give in to the despair surrounding them or will they trust Comdiu to fulfill His plans for their lives? Even if it means they never see each other again?
C.E.Laureano weaves a tale full and rich that draws the reader in from the very first sentences and does not let go, even when the book ends! Because you're so desperately longing for the third book to see what happens! She has created a land much as Tolkien created Middle Earth. She has also created characters that get down into your heart, characters that leave you thinking about them long after you finish the book. I am finding it hard to pick up another book because I'm still concentrating on the folks in Beneath The Forsaken City. I don't want to leave them, actually. As a matter of fact, I re-read Oath of the Brotherhood before reading this second novel because I wanted to refresh my memory. I'll probably re-read both the first two before I read the third and final book, too.
The authors draws the reader into the story so well that I felt as if I were there, seeing the destruction, feeling the dismay and heartache. This was a mighty fine book and I hated to see it end, but I'm very much looking forward to book three. Very well written novel, one that made me think about my own relationship with God and how I react to Him during difficult times.
I guarantee you will not be disappointed with either book. If you do read them, you must start with Oath of the Brotherhood; otherwise the second book will not make sense.
*I was given a copy of the book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
July 7, 2021
Picking up shortly after the end of the previous book, Conor and Aine are separated by a storm that sends them on separate journeys where they are challenged and tested by temptations. I loved how this book features one of my favorite characters Eoghan even more prominently as he does what he can to serve the brotherhood and aid Conor and Aine. I loved how his humbleness shines through, as his future becomes more uncertain.
I would definitely read this series in order as much of this story relies on past events and relationships formed in the previous book. The stakes raise as war becomes imminent, and they learn more about their God-given gifts. The lore of the story becomes clearer, though I still struggled with pronunciations despite a handy guide, and I liked the twists along the way.
Overall, a great installment to the series and did a good job adding to the main storyline, with character growth and more insight into the setting. Plenty of action, more magic, and constantly raising stakes, and excellent choice for fans of Christian fantasy.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
I would definitely read this series in order as much of this story relies on past events and relationships formed in the previous book. The stakes raise as war becomes imminent, and they learn more about their God-given gifts. The lore of the story becomes clearer, though I still struggled with pronunciations despite a handy guide, and I liked the twists along the way.
Overall, a great installment to the series and did a good job adding to the main storyline, with character growth and more insight into the setting. Plenty of action, more magic, and constantly raising stakes, and excellent choice for fans of Christian fantasy.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
November 20, 2022
I was not sure if I’d like this book. It started fast, and I was into it, and then the plot slowed and there were some scenes I was not a fan of. I was planning on maybe giving this a three, (being generous) And it stayed that way till the end. Then it became 4. And I did like it, but there were times it did make me uncomfortable.
But that aside, I loved the faith aspects and what the characters learned. I could have just done without the other scenes.
Content wise, there was women who was attacked, and it was only slightly detailed. Nothing happened, thankfully. And there were times the characters seemed unfaithful to their spouse. But nothing happened and everything was resolved.
But that aside, I loved the faith aspects and what the characters learned. I could have just done without the other scenes.
Content wise, there was women who was attacked, and it was only slightly detailed. Nothing happened, thankfully. And there were times the characters seemed unfaithful to their spouse. But nothing happened and everything was resolved.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 13, 2021
An incredible story of searching and finding, love, loyalty, and more.
Full review to come
Full review to come
February 4, 2015
This was quite a book! I can't wait for "The Sword and the Song".
{My Review}
Rating: 5 stars.
Beneath the Forsaken City continues right after Oath of the Brotherhood ends. And as the synopsis says they have barely escaped Seare alive. Book #2 is full of almost non-stop action, which is what I love about the second in a series, there's always a ton of stuff going on. The author's characters, setting, writing is utterly captivating and once I finished it did not want to let me go any time soon. Beneath the Forsaken City is a rich tale weaved with action, romance, and magic. I'm ready for Book #3!
{My Review}
Rating: 5 stars.
Beneath the Forsaken City continues right after Oath of the Brotherhood ends. And as the synopsis says they have barely escaped Seare alive. Book #2 is full of almost non-stop action, which is what I love about the second in a series, there's always a ton of stuff going on. The author's characters, setting, writing is utterly captivating and once I finished it did not want to let me go any time soon. Beneath the Forsaken City is a rich tale weaved with action, romance, and magic. I'm ready for Book #3!
June 8, 2021
I read the 1st book in The Song of Seare trilogy and loved it, even though I didn't think I'd like Christian fantasy. It was really great because it was set in the Dark Ages and I love reading about that era.
Now, I've read the 2nd book in the series, Beneath the Forsaken City. This one was amazingly good! It truly deserves more than the 5 stars I'm allowed to give it. This books takes up where the first left off and hits the ground running and never lets up. Even to the last sentence.
Now I'm left to sit on pins and needles until the 3rd and final book comes out in the fall.
Beaneath the Forsaken City is set in the Dark Ages, in a time of myth, magic and sorcery. There are some, however, who believe in the true god, Comdiu and His Son, Balus. This book takes the reader on a journey both frightening and thrilling at the same time.
Conor and Aine have just barely escaped Seare before being killed. Married by the captain of the vessel in which they leave, they hope for a new life that is happy, but fear the worst because of the war back in their homeland. Soon, they are parted again cruelly, each left to wonder long months if the other is even alive. Conor knows he must return to Seare at some point to find the harp and hopefully end the reign of terror began by the malicious Red Druid. Aine, too, knows that she must return to find Conor for their future lies in Seare. Both despair of on their own and find themselves in grave danger. The enemy tries to kill their love for one another and their hope in Comdiu. The danger is from both mortal and sorcery avenues. Will Conor and Aine give in to the despair surrounding them or will they trust Comdiu to fulfill His plans for their lives? Even if it means they never see each other again?
C.E.Laureano weaves a tale full and rich that draws the reader in from the very first sentences and does not let go, even when the book ends! Because you're so desperately longing for the third book to see what happens! She has created a land much as Tolkien created Middle Earth. She has also created characters that get down into your heart, characters that leave you thinking about them long after you finish the book. I am finding it hard to pick up another book because I'm still concentrating on the folks in Beneath The Forsaken City. I don't want to leave them, actually. As a matter of fact, I re-read Oath of the Brotherhood before reading this second novel because I wanted to refresh my memory. I'll probably re-read both the first two before I read the third and final book, too.
The authors draws the reader into the story so well that I felt as if I were there, seeing the destruction, feeling the dismay and heartache. This was a mighty fine book and I hated to see it end, but I'm very much looking forward to book three. Very well written novel, one that made me think about my own relationship with God and how I react to Him during difficult times.
I guarantee you will not be disappointed with either book. If you do read them, you must start with Oath of the Brotherhood; otherwise the second book will not make sense.
*I was given a copy of the book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
Now, I've read the 2nd book in the series, Beneath the Forsaken City. This one was amazingly good! It truly deserves more than the 5 stars I'm allowed to give it. This books takes up where the first left off and hits the ground running and never lets up. Even to the last sentence.
Now I'm left to sit on pins and needles until the 3rd and final book comes out in the fall.
Beaneath the Forsaken City is set in the Dark Ages, in a time of myth, magic and sorcery. There are some, however, who believe in the true god, Comdiu and His Son, Balus. This book takes the reader on a journey both frightening and thrilling at the same time.
Conor and Aine have just barely escaped Seare before being killed. Married by the captain of the vessel in which they leave, they hope for a new life that is happy, but fear the worst because of the war back in their homeland. Soon, they are parted again cruelly, each left to wonder long months if the other is even alive. Conor knows he must return to Seare at some point to find the harp and hopefully end the reign of terror began by the malicious Red Druid. Aine, too, knows that she must return to find Conor for their future lies in Seare. Both despair of on their own and find themselves in grave danger. The enemy tries to kill their love for one another and their hope in Comdiu. The danger is from both mortal and sorcery avenues. Will Conor and Aine give in to the despair surrounding them or will they trust Comdiu to fulfill His plans for their lives? Even if it means they never see each other again?
C.E.Laureano weaves a tale full and rich that draws the reader in from the very first sentences and does not let go, even when the book ends! Because you're so desperately longing for the third book to see what happens! She has created a land much as Tolkien created Middle Earth. She has also created characters that get down into your heart, characters that leave you thinking about them long after you finish the book. I am finding it hard to pick up another book because I'm still concentrating on the folks in Beneath The Forsaken City. I don't want to leave them, actually. As a matter of fact, I re-read Oath of the Brotherhood before reading this second novel because I wanted to refresh my memory. I'll probably re-read both the first two before I read the third and final book, too.
The authors draws the reader into the story so well that I felt as if I were there, seeing the destruction, feeling the dismay and heartache. This was a mighty fine book and I hated to see it end, but I'm very much looking forward to book three. Very well written novel, one that made me think about my own relationship with God and how I react to Him during difficult times.
I guarantee you will not be disappointed with either book. If you do read them, you must start with Oath of the Brotherhood; otherwise the second book will not make sense.
*I was given a copy of the book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
July 9, 2021
Let me start by saying this is part of a series, and needs to be read in order (this is book two). If you don’t read book one first, you will be lost! Or at least missing out on a lot. This book starts off very fast paced and doesn’t let up. I’m talking sitting on the edge of your seat until the end! There is action, suspense, magic, and fun. Now, amongst this is some difficult things to read. But Laureano does a great job of writing it in a way that lets the reader know what’s happening without getting too graphic.
I love how Laureano shares the gospel in this series. I know most people probably like the series for the characters (they are wonderful), the plot (it is so fascinating), or for the pure entertainment of it (it is so entertaining!), but this was my favorite part. I love seeing the gospel presented in such unique ways, and in the fantasy genre it’s so hard. But Laureano does it flawlessly. And not only that, she shows the importance of listening to God’s voice, and relying on Him. I know I’ll be reading this series again and again, and sharing it with some young adults that I know would like to read a fantasy book.
I highly recommend this book, well series actually, to adults, young adults, fantasy fans and fans of a good story. I’m anxiously awaiting the opportunity to read book three and know if cannot get here fast enough! I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I love how Laureano shares the gospel in this series. I know most people probably like the series for the characters (they are wonderful), the plot (it is so fascinating), or for the pure entertainment of it (it is so entertaining!), but this was my favorite part. I love seeing the gospel presented in such unique ways, and in the fantasy genre it’s so hard. But Laureano does it flawlessly. And not only that, she shows the importance of listening to God’s voice, and relying on Him. I know I’ll be reading this series again and again, and sharing it with some young adults that I know would like to read a fantasy book.
I highly recommend this book, well series actually, to adults, young adults, fantasy fans and fans of a good story. I’m anxiously awaiting the opportunity to read book three and know if cannot get here fast enough! I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 19, 2025
2.5-3⭐️
I have mixed feelings about this book. The first one was amazing and so I was excited to continue the series. However…. It sorta felt like the whole story was just one chaotic event after another, in addition to it being just straight up confusing with its detailed world building and all the Celtic names and words (which aren’t necessarily a bad things in my opinion, they just made it a little harder to follow the story).
Also Aine... I still loved her character but girl made some pretty foolish decisions that ended up putting her life, as well as several others’, in serious danger! She felt almost like a completely different character from the first book at times. Also why did every single guy that she met in this entire book fall in love with her? That got old pretty fast.
As with the first book though, I loved the Irish setting and the music, as well as the adventure and the spiritual journeys the characters experience. It was a good book, just not my favorite. 😊
I have mixed feelings about this book. The first one was amazing and so I was excited to continue the series. However…. It sorta felt like the whole story was just one chaotic event after another, in addition to it being just straight up confusing with its detailed world building and all the Celtic names and words (which aren’t necessarily a bad things in my opinion, they just made it a little harder to follow the story).
Also Aine... I still loved her character but girl made some pretty foolish decisions that ended up putting her life, as well as several others’, in serious danger! She felt almost like a completely different character from the first book at times. Also why did every single guy that she met in this entire book fall in love with her? That got old pretty fast.
As with the first book though, I loved the Irish setting and the music, as well as the adventure and the spiritual journeys the characters experience. It was a good book, just not my favorite. 😊
April 11, 2015
I love Eoghan. He has offically become my favorite character and I sorely wish he had been the main character in this series. However, I do understand that Conor and Aine were far more involved in the large scale view of world. Still, I found Eoghan to be a relatable character for all his skills and imperfects (particularly his pride).
The major theme in this series is trusting Comdiu, even in the hardest of times. It is an admirable theme which I did appreciate, however, at times I felt it went a little too far. The characters are constantly pushed to the edge, into situations where the average person (and most of the other characters) would give up. Yet somehow, these two manage to only doubt Comdiu for a couple paragraphs before they rally their faith. It would have been far more believable if they had doubted more, and still Comdiu brought about a good end.
I also struggled with Conor and Aine's romance. For most of this book (and the last) they were not even together, so the reader has little opportunity to actually see their relationship as something real and substantive.
The themes and unique setting make this series worth trying. I really enjoyed where Conor kept his word to Haldor, even when everyone else expected him not too. Unfortunately, both Conor and Aine's continued encounters with people of nobility and rank (even in the middle of nowhere), rather than common people, seemed all too perfect.
I wish I could say I loved this book. The idea of a married hero and heroine was what first drew me to this series, but I was disappointed by how little time they spent together. Maybe they will be together more in the next book.
I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
The major theme in this series is trusting Comdiu, even in the hardest of times. It is an admirable theme which I did appreciate, however, at times I felt it went a little too far. The characters are constantly pushed to the edge, into situations where the average person (and most of the other characters) would give up. Yet somehow, these two manage to only doubt Comdiu for a couple paragraphs before they rally their faith. It would have been far more believable if they had doubted more, and still Comdiu brought about a good end.
I also struggled with Conor and Aine's romance. For most of this book (and the last) they were not even together, so the reader has little opportunity to actually see their relationship as something real and substantive.
The themes and unique setting make this series worth trying. I really enjoyed where Conor kept his word to Haldor, even when everyone else expected him not too. Unfortunately, both Conor and Aine's continued encounters with people of nobility and rank (even in the middle of nowhere), rather than common people, seemed all too perfect.
I wish I could say I loved this book. The idea of a married hero and heroine was what first drew me to this series, but I was disappointed by how little time they spent together. Maybe they will be together more in the next book.
I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
February 23, 2015
I have not read the first book in the Song of Seare series, a fault I will definitely seek to remedy after reading Beneath the Forsaken City. C.E. Laureano has crafted a fantasy world that fits well into the Christian allegory/fantasy genre. It’s not straight allegory like Pilgrim’s Progress, but still carries some of the ideas of Christian life wrapped in a good narrative.
Having not read the first book, I was a tad bit lost as I started on this book. Fortunately, the adventure stands decently on its own. One is not entirely sure what’s going on in the universe of Seare, but I was able to fill in the gaps.
Laureano’s characters, Conor and Aine, are presented well. Further, the “bad guys” are clearly bad—there are no doubts about good and evil. That is a positive for fantasy literature. I would suggest having a quick thumb to the back pages with the pronunciation guide…
How well does the allegory stand up? I find no fault in the theology presented through the allegorical moments. It is, most certainly, not perfect. But overall, one ought not get your theology from fiction anyway. As an illumination of the ideas of grace and commitment to God, this one hits that just fine.
Is it worth reading? Absolutely. I’ll be adding this to the shelf for my kids as they hit middle-school reading ranges. There is action, there is good versus evil, there is romance. Everything that a good movie would have…but it’s in your imagination instead.
Sounds like a win to me.
Free book from the publisher.
Having not read the first book, I was a tad bit lost as I started on this book. Fortunately, the adventure stands decently on its own. One is not entirely sure what’s going on in the universe of Seare, but I was able to fill in the gaps.
Laureano’s characters, Conor and Aine, are presented well. Further, the “bad guys” are clearly bad—there are no doubts about good and evil. That is a positive for fantasy literature. I would suggest having a quick thumb to the back pages with the pronunciation guide…
How well does the allegory stand up? I find no fault in the theology presented through the allegorical moments. It is, most certainly, not perfect. But overall, one ought not get your theology from fiction anyway. As an illumination of the ideas of grace and commitment to God, this one hits that just fine.
Is it worth reading? Absolutely. I’ll be adding this to the shelf for my kids as they hit middle-school reading ranges. There is action, there is good versus evil, there is romance. Everything that a good movie would have…but it’s in your imagination instead.
Sounds like a win to me.
Free book from the publisher.
June 13, 2021
Book two in the Song of Seare series picks up right where book one left off. It has a lot of action, including one epic battle scene that is creepy enough to send tingles down your spine. It’s easy to be invested in the lives of the characters and to hope all will turn out well for them. This is definitely a Christian allegory, and readers will see the characters struggling with their faith, and or lack of it. These struggles provide for deeper character growth for Conor, Aine, and Eoghan. What’s more, their struggles are with things we all find challenging at times. That’s really a great element to a book – the ability to relate to the characters’ struggles. All in all, I think this is a superb book with a good message. It’s a cliff-hanger, so know going in you won’t have a resolution until the final book.
September 2, 2023
Wow, this was amazing! We just pick up from when Conor and Aine, finally wedded and fleeing from a rather fierce battle at Seare... only to be separated by dark forces intent on destroying them. Now, as they struggle from enslavement to enemies to navigating political barriers, Conor and Aine discover a shift of their giftings... and that their fight against evil is far from over. They, as well as the reader, must each follow the path Comdiu has laid out for them and trust in Him, even when their hearts ache for each other... neither one knowing if either is alive.
Let's just say I was on pins and needles the entire read, startled by shocking twists and turns... especially a glimpse of an even deeper view of the spiritual realm of Comapnions (angels) and Sidhe (demons)! Up next, Sword and Song!!!
(NOTE: Read OATH OF THE BROTHERHOOD first if you haven't!)
Let's just say I was on pins and needles the entire read, startled by shocking twists and turns... especially a glimpse of an even deeper view of the spiritual realm of Comapnions (angels) and Sidhe (demons)! Up next, Sword and Song!!!
(NOTE: Read OATH OF THE BROTHERHOOD first if you haven't!)
October 31, 2021
Beneath The Forsaken City is a continuation of the story from the first book and I must say both books have to be read in order so you aren't confused.
I enjoyed getting to know more about Conor and Aine. Their journey and their struggles.
A fascinating world of Magic, a good vs evil kind of tale. I enjoyed the way the author dealt with it and how the story played out. Definitely one for lovers of Fantasy. I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions expressed are solely mine.
I enjoyed getting to know more about Conor and Aine. Their journey and their struggles.
A fascinating world of Magic, a good vs evil kind of tale. I enjoyed the way the author dealt with it and how the story played out. Definitely one for lovers of Fantasy. I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. All opinions expressed are solely mine.
September 17, 2016
A dark force is overtaking Seare, Conor and his wife are parted and dark magic can be tasted in the air. Conor and the Brotherhood have to fix it. I really enjoyed this book, because it was really gripping and full of mysteries.
August 3, 2016
The Song of Seare trilogy follows a young man named Conor Mac Nir and his journey to overcome the evil threatening his world, and, on a more personal level, Conor's journey as a man.
In the first book in the trilogy, The Oath of the Brotherhood, we meet Conor Mac Nir, a puny, scholarly boy who has powerful gifts as a musician. Conor does not really seem to fit in anywhere. When Conor's foster father dies, Conor fakes his own death to cover his trail and joins the Firein, a group of monk-like "brothers" - the difference being that the otherwise monastic brotherhood are trained in the fighting arts as well as spiritual disciplines. But Conor soon grows restless and wants to leave the brotherhood to do something about the darkness that has begun to threaten the outside world. Finally, Conor leaves Ard Dhaimin, to join Calhoun Mac Cuilinn's army. Calhoun is the older half-brother of Aine, a beautiful young girl Conor felt an immediate connection to, and fell in love with in the short time he stayed with her family before joining the brotherhood. Aine, in Conor's absence, has developed her own unique gifts and has gained renown for her incredible healing abilities. When Aine is kidnapped, Conor risks everything to save her and the two are reunited and married aboard a ship that they hope will carry them to a new life.
This first book really sets the stage nicely for the other two books to come. It's a little slow in the beginning but interest really soars when Conor joins the brotherhood and really becomes a hero worth cheering for. I have to say, when a character is described as puny, it kind of gives you a mental picture of that character that is irreversible, even if the we are told that the character really beefs up later on in the story (which, of course, they always do, because where's the attraction in a guy who does not have bulging biceps and a perfect six pack?). Fortunately for Laureano, this is not the case with Conor; his progression from wimpy boy to muscular man is slow enough and convincing enough that your not permanently stuck thinking of Conor as that toothpick-limbed guy we envision when we were first introduced to him.
In the second book in The Song of Seare Trilogy, Beneath the Forsaken City, Conor and Aine have been separated in a storm at sea and now must pursue separate journeys. Conor is made a slave but is set free and escapes with one of his fellow captives, Prince Talfryn, there under cover to save Conor. As his honored guest, Conor remains with Talfryn while he awaits news of Aine. But while there he comes up against unforeseen obstacles - things are not what they seem within the kingdom. Briallu, the only daughter of his friend, holds a strange attraction for Conor that he struggles to resist. Aine makes her way to her native land, where her aunt is currently in power and magic of all kinds - such as Aine now wields with more power than ever - is held in extreme suspicion. While some welcome Aine back, or grow to love her, her aunt's veiled dislike of her serves to make her even more lonely and distraught. Aine struggles desperately against doubt and confusion, and is bewildered when attempts on her life become disturbingly frequent and there seem to be veiled threats on every side. Aine no longer knows who she can trust. Both of their paths eventually lead them both back to Seare, however, and Aine and Conor are finally reunited once more.
Beneath the Forsaken City builds well on the first book. Separating Conor and Aine the way she does is a masterful move on Laureano's part - it allows readers a chance to get to know them as individuals, apart from one another, something we got to do in Oath of the Brotherhood with Conor, obviously, but not as much with Aine, and since her role is only increasing, it's important that we really get behind Aine. This is the closest thing to a flaw that I foresee for this trilogy. That we won't ever get to know Aine enough to ever like her. Honestly, when we first met her back in Oath of the Brotherhood, she never appealed to me. I like her better in this book, but the connection between her and the reader is not as strong as it should be - something Laureano will have to remedy quickly if she wishes to redeem Aine.
That is the trouble with reserved, sweet characters. While the writer may just think of them as quiet or shy, or just kindhearted and compassionate, they come across to the reader as boring and dull, lacking life and personality. Such characters give us very little reason to get behind them, to laugh when they laugh and cry when they cry, because we don't really know what would make them laugh or cry. They have remained so aloof and distant, hiding behind that facade of reserve or kindness, that We The Reader don't really know them at all.
In the last book in the Song of Seare Trilogy, The Sword and the Song, Aine and Conor are reunited in Ard Dhaimin and the future is looking bright for them. The couple is expecting their first child, they are happy, and Ard Dhaimin has become a refuge for many fleeing the darkness and danger that has become rampant in Seare. But it soons becomes apparent that everything is not as perfect as it seems. Eoghan, Conor's closest friend, is the fulfillment of the prophecy, and as such, he should be taking leadership of the Firein. But Eoghan is hesitant to step up, which causes friction between Conor and him. Eoghan reached out to Conor when he first arrived friendless in Ard Dhaimin, Eoghan mentored and trained Conor until he became a better swordsman than Eoghan himself, Eoghan risked severe punishment to leave Ard Dhaimin and help Conor, saving his life, and Eoghan saved Aine's life when she returned to Seare after struggling with doubt and defeat in her homeland. So the bond between the two men is still strong... but it's strength is being tested. Especially as it becomes more and more obvious to everyone, Conor, Aine, and Eoghan himself, that Eoghan is falling for Aine - the pregnant wife of his best friend. Conor has thought of a way to protect Seare and fight back against the Red Druid, Diarmuid - but it requires leaving Ard Dhaimin. He gets back in plenty of time to witness the birth of his child - but almost as soon as he returns, he has to leave again. On an even longer journey this time. Conor's mission is almost complete when Diarmuid attacks Ard Dhaimin. His goal is to kidnap Aine's soon-to-be born, specially gifted child. Because of Aine's growing powers, she is able to communicate mentally with Conor - but he is experiencing difficulty as well: he has been badly wounded, and help cannot reach him. In an unexpected twist, Conor's foster sister who has been living in Ard Dhaimin, once a confederate of Diarmuid, turns on him suddenly, killing him. But it is too late for Conor. With his last words, he names the son he wanted to desperately to witness the birth of, the son he so desperately wanted to be a good father to, the son he will now never meet... his son is born only minutes later.
Wow. I did not even see this ending coming. It is superb. I was so close to tears. I've read a lot of books, a lot of endings, a lot of good endings, even. But I don't know that I've ever read an ending quite like this one. It is unique and so oddly moving. I think because it really is very surprising. Conor is so very afraid that if he dies, Aine and Eoghan will be together and forget him, that you never think that that will actually happen! You just assume that because they want it so much, because Conor and Aine deserve it so much after all they have been through, all the separation and pain and doubting each other and not knowing if the other is even alive, and feeling unworthy of the other's love, you just naturally assume that they will get that happy ending... You want them to have that happy ending. You want Conor so see his son. You want them to be able to be a family. And so it is really depressing when Conor dies when he is so close to achieving this dream.
This last book really highlights Conor's strength as a character. He has become the hero. And that is something I find rather fascinating: Conor didn't start out the hero that you were hoping for - he becomes that hero. You really begin to see his depth in this last book, his brokenness and disappointment with himself, his frustration and anger as he starts to really snap and kind of lose his grip on sanity. I don't believe there's any such thing as a completely sane hero anyway:)
Aine, though, actually regressed, in my opinion. She effectively loses all the ground she gained in the second book.
Overall, this last book was not only by far the best but was a great way to end the series; Laureano got better with each succeeding book.
For more reviews like this one, check out my blog at http://storyanddarkchocolate.blogspot...
June 30, 2021
In the depths of magic and characters who try to survive in this world the author has made, lays truth and understanding in the Spiritual World. The story is fast paced and danger seems to be everywhere. A fatal shipwreck pulls two people in love apart. I liked that we get to follow Conor and Anie as they travel through their own journey to reunite.
Anie is rescued from certain death but I wasn’t sure if she was better off with these men. They are dangerous and have no problem taking revenge on someone. I gasped when one of them is painfully murdered before Aine’s eyes. She must be thinking what is to become of her after witnessing a horrible scene. I couldn’t wait to follow her as she tries to figure out who to trust. The shock of finding out something very important about her heritage places her in more danger along with her ability to heal. I liked that the author shared a glimpse of what revenge can do to someone who only wants peace when harm comes their way.
Conor is desperate to find Aine but first he needs to escape from his captures. You witness how much he cares for Aine as he confesses that he would kill for her or die for her. That kind of love is unconditional and Conor will go through much pain and hard decisions as he searches for her. He is a warrior that will not give up so I knew we were in for an adventure that would take us to the brink of danger and temptation.
The story is filled with twists as the characters are guided by deceit, pride and prophecy that will change the course for many. I enjoyed reading the undertones of faith in the book and how creative the author is. The ending is good and I can’t wait til the next book comes out.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
Anie is rescued from certain death but I wasn’t sure if she was better off with these men. They are dangerous and have no problem taking revenge on someone. I gasped when one of them is painfully murdered before Aine’s eyes. She must be thinking what is to become of her after witnessing a horrible scene. I couldn’t wait to follow her as she tries to figure out who to trust. The shock of finding out something very important about her heritage places her in more danger along with her ability to heal. I liked that the author shared a glimpse of what revenge can do to someone who only wants peace when harm comes their way.
Conor is desperate to find Aine but first he needs to escape from his captures. You witness how much he cares for Aine as he confesses that he would kill for her or die for her. That kind of love is unconditional and Conor will go through much pain and hard decisions as he searches for her. He is a warrior that will not give up so I knew we were in for an adventure that would take us to the brink of danger and temptation.
The story is filled with twists as the characters are guided by deceit, pride and prophecy that will change the course for many. I enjoyed reading the undertones of faith in the book and how creative the author is. The ending is good and I can’t wait til the next book comes out.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
June 7, 2021
Award-winning author Carla Laureano’s second novel in her medieval Celtic-inspired epic fantasy series is filled with adventure, romance, magic, faith, and superstition.
In Beneath the Forsaken City, Conor is separated from his bride, Aine, during a violent storm while they are sailing towards Aine’s homeland. They don’t know if the other one even survived. Now they face danger on their own, especially not knowing who to trust as they try to follow Comdiu’s leading. Will they be reunited? Will they play their role in overcoming darkness?
Laureano weaves in Celtic elements (ancient history, mythology, druids, etc.) in the Sword of Seare trilogy. Originally published in 2015 under C. E. Laureano, this faith-based series is back in print with a new publisher and some additional material. The author’s note about her research is particularly interesting.
Known for her inspirational contemporary romances, Laureano creates a fantasy world that will delight epic fantasy and Christian fiction readers because it includes strong main characters, as well as a clear battle between good and evil. Her characters face betrayal, faithfulness, death, and love as they continue on their journey. The books should be read in order, as they build on one another. The second book is filled with more emotion, more faith journeys, more action, testing of their devotion to one another, and more hope for the future, despite the overwhelming odds against them.
From the first page, readers encounter plot twists, relatable characters, and a story that will keep them eagerly reading until the book’s conclusion. They will eagerly await the next book, The Sword and the Song, coming in January 2022.
Recommended for Laureano’s fans, as well as fans of epic fantasy.
Disclaimer: Book reviews are my honest opinion of books I either purchased or received free of cost from the publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write reviews, nor to even post positive reviews.
In Beneath the Forsaken City, Conor is separated from his bride, Aine, during a violent storm while they are sailing towards Aine’s homeland. They don’t know if the other one even survived. Now they face danger on their own, especially not knowing who to trust as they try to follow Comdiu’s leading. Will they be reunited? Will they play their role in overcoming darkness?
Laureano weaves in Celtic elements (ancient history, mythology, druids, etc.) in the Sword of Seare trilogy. Originally published in 2015 under C. E. Laureano, this faith-based series is back in print with a new publisher and some additional material. The author’s note about her research is particularly interesting.
Known for her inspirational contemporary romances, Laureano creates a fantasy world that will delight epic fantasy and Christian fiction readers because it includes strong main characters, as well as a clear battle between good and evil. Her characters face betrayal, faithfulness, death, and love as they continue on their journey. The books should be read in order, as they build on one another. The second book is filled with more emotion, more faith journeys, more action, testing of their devotion to one another, and more hope for the future, despite the overwhelming odds against them.
From the first page, readers encounter plot twists, relatable characters, and a story that will keep them eagerly reading until the book’s conclusion. They will eagerly await the next book, The Sword and the Song, coming in January 2022.
Recommended for Laureano’s fans, as well as fans of epic fantasy.
Disclaimer: Book reviews are my honest opinion of books I either purchased or received free of cost from the publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write reviews, nor to even post positive reviews.
July 2, 2021
Beneath the Forsaken City is a Fantasy book that is written by the talented Carla Laureano. This is book 2 in the Song of Seare series. I have read book 1, and I would recommend reading them in order so that you grasp the full effect of the series. The first book in the series looked more at Conor's training to be a warrior and the battle of good and evil. You can read my review for that book: HERE. In this book Conor will use his knowledge and training and will rely on that warrior training. Aine has grown from the first book also. Aine will channel and use the gifts she has been given.
Conor has to fine the harp to end the nightmare that has been brought on by the Red Druid’s reign of terror. First Aine and Conor encounter a storm that separates them. They are now having to navigate separately and its full of danger. I love how many twists and turns there were in this book - I did not know what was going to happen next. I love how the author ended the story - I cannot wait until the next story to come out. The author has done a great job weaving in the Christian faith into this Celtic - era inspired book. I look forward to the other books in the series. I would say this is appropriate to high school kids and up, possibly upper middle grade. It has well written characters.
I received a copy of this book through the Celebrate Lit blogging program - all thoughts are my own.
Conor has to fine the harp to end the nightmare that has been brought on by the Red Druid’s reign of terror. First Aine and Conor encounter a storm that separates them. They are now having to navigate separately and its full of danger. I love how many twists and turns there were in this book - I did not know what was going to happen next. I love how the author ended the story - I cannot wait until the next story to come out. The author has done a great job weaving in the Christian faith into this Celtic - era inspired book. I look forward to the other books in the series. I would say this is appropriate to high school kids and up, possibly upper middle grade. It has well written characters.
I received a copy of this book through the Celebrate Lit blogging program - all thoughts are my own.
July 13, 2021
This is book two of a trilogy. I have to say that I have been enjoying this series even though this genre isn’t my favorite. It might have something to do with the characters names though. We have a little girl named Ainne and a boy named Liam in our little Irish household so I’m partial to the names!
I like the parallel to God and how this book does have a bit of The Lord of the Rings and Narnia flare to it though definitely written for a slightly older audience as you do have the two main characters being married.
For this book and series I would rate them as clean Christian fantasy fiction. The characters are somewhat relatable even though they have mystical powers etc. I like the parallels of the good vs the evil of the magic world as that can even be part of our everyday life now as there are still realms of dark magic.
Overall I think this is a great young adult into adult fiction book and I highly recommend you read the series in order to get the most from the books.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received through Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
I like the parallel to God and how this book does have a bit of The Lord of the Rings and Narnia flare to it though definitely written for a slightly older audience as you do have the two main characters being married.
For this book and series I would rate them as clean Christian fantasy fiction. The characters are somewhat relatable even though they have mystical powers etc. I like the parallels of the good vs the evil of the magic world as that can even be part of our everyday life now as there are still realms of dark magic.
Overall I think this is a great young adult into adult fiction book and I highly recommend you read the series in order to get the most from the books.
I have voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received through Celebrate Lit. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. I was not required to write a positive review nor was I compensated in any other way. All opinions expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the FTC regulations.
Read
June 22, 2021Beneath the Forsaken City is book number two in the Song of Seare series. I had not personally read the first book before this one. If there is one genre in which it is perhaps most important to read a series in order, I would certainly say it would be fantasy. There is just so much world building that goes on in that introduction, that it can be hard to fully appreciate the story as much without it. I must admit, I found myself feeling a bit lost... and I can only blame myself for that!
Despite that, I could tell that this story was very well written. The characters drew me in, and the action kept the story moving from start to finish even if I didn't quite understand all that was going on. The author created a fascinating world of magic and good vs. evil that fans of fantasy are sure to enjoy. I am not the biggest fan of fantasy, but I can appreciate good writing and this certainly is that.
Overall, I would say that this is one that fans of fantasy are going to want to be sure to check out... but only after reading book one first!
**I received a complimentary copy of this book for consideration. All thoughts are my own.
Despite that, I could tell that this story was very well written. The characters drew me in, and the action kept the story moving from start to finish even if I didn't quite understand all that was going on. The author created a fascinating world of magic and good vs. evil that fans of fantasy are sure to enjoy. I am not the biggest fan of fantasy, but I can appreciate good writing and this certainly is that.
Overall, I would say that this is one that fans of fantasy are going to want to be sure to check out... but only after reading book one first!
**I received a complimentary copy of this book for consideration. All thoughts are my own.
June 28, 2021
The second book in The Song of Seare series, Beneath the Foresaken City contniues the story of Conor and Aine. This story of faith, love, and willingness to pursue the path they have been set upon caught my attention. This book obviously is a Christian allegory with struggles of faith. The author created relatable characters that you desire to see succeed and find the true path they need to follow.
With the story taking place during the Dark Ages, magic and mystery play a major role in the plot. The suspense in this book will keep you reading on the edge of your seat, unable to put the book down. Filled with action, danger, and adventure, this book lived up to my expectations from the first book. I anticipate reading the third and final book in the series to find out how the series concludes.
So if you enjoy reading Christian fantasy check out this book and this series for yourself. I definitely recommend it.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but it in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
With the story taking place during the Dark Ages, magic and mystery play a major role in the plot. The suspense in this book will keep you reading on the edge of your seat, unable to put the book down. Filled with action, danger, and adventure, this book lived up to my expectations from the first book. I anticipate reading the third and final book in the series to find out how the series concludes.
So if you enjoy reading Christian fantasy check out this book and this series for yourself. I definitely recommend it.
I received a complimentary copy of this book, but it in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.
June 29, 2022
Beneath the Forsaken Sky The Song of Seare Book 2 by C E Laureano
9781612916316
415 Pages
Publisher: Tyndale House Publishers, NavPress
Release Date: February 1, 2015
Fiction, Sci Fi, Fantasy, Teen, Young Adult, Adventure, Magic
Recently married, Conor and Aine are on a ship called the Resolute. They both have magical gifts. The ship goes into a storm and Aine is tossed overboard. Conor goes over after her. He almost reaches her, but a wave sweeps her away. Each begin a journey to find each other but face temptations. Eoghan and Liam are members of the Brotherhood.
This is the second book in the series. I did not read. The first book so I did not know a lot about the character’s histories, but I was able to follow the story without much trouble. The story has a steady pace, the characters are developed, and it is written in the third person point of view I enjoyed the author’s writing style and look forward to reading the first and third books in the series. If you like sci fi & fantasy young adult books, you will enjoy reading this one.
9781612916316
415 Pages
Publisher: Tyndale House Publishers, NavPress
Release Date: February 1, 2015
Fiction, Sci Fi, Fantasy, Teen, Young Adult, Adventure, Magic
Recently married, Conor and Aine are on a ship called the Resolute. They both have magical gifts. The ship goes into a storm and Aine is tossed overboard. Conor goes over after her. He almost reaches her, but a wave sweeps her away. Each begin a journey to find each other but face temptations. Eoghan and Liam are members of the Brotherhood.
This is the second book in the series. I did not read. The first book so I did not know a lot about the character’s histories, but I was able to follow the story without much trouble. The story has a steady pace, the characters are developed, and it is written in the third person point of view I enjoyed the author’s writing style and look forward to reading the first and third books in the series. If you like sci fi & fantasy young adult books, you will enjoy reading this one.
June 27, 2021
I enjoyed reading the first book from Carla Laureano’s Song of Seare series, Oath of the Brotherhood. I was excited to have the opportunity to read the second installment, Beneath the Forsaken City. Even though this is part of a series, I believe it can be read as a stand alone. I thought it was a good read that kept my attention most of the time reading it. It was a nice get away to take with Conor and Aine. They are good characters getting to know and I had to find out what would happen next with them.
I am giving Beneath the Forsaken City four stars. I recommend it for readers who enjoy reading clean fantansy/ science fiction/ magical tales. I look forward to reading the next book from the Song of Seare series, The Sword and the Song, to see what happens next.
I received a digital copy of Beneath the Forsaken City from the publisher. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
I am giving Beneath the Forsaken City four stars. I recommend it for readers who enjoy reading clean fantansy/ science fiction/ magical tales. I look forward to reading the next book from the Song of Seare series, The Sword and the Song, to see what happens next.
I received a digital copy of Beneath the Forsaken City from the publisher. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
July 7, 2021
This second book in this series is even stronger than the first one. I would recommend reading them in order. Moving seamlessly from book one, this picks up with action right where the other book left off. It has so much suspense and progression of what's happening to the characters that you might wind up holding your breath. I did.
Followers of the one true God and his son, magic, evil, and the dark ages; I'm totally taken with this series. Conor and Anie have managed to get married. But how much happily ever-after can you have with the world just about coming apart around you? It made me frequently think of "how great is thy faithfulness" while reading this awesome fantasy story that is a very strong in many allegorical areas.
I can't wait for the next book!
Thanks to Celebrate Lit for my copy of this book. This review is left freely, a positive review is never required.
Followers of the one true God and his son, magic, evil, and the dark ages; I'm totally taken with this series. Conor and Anie have managed to get married. But how much happily ever-after can you have with the world just about coming apart around you? It made me frequently think of "how great is thy faithfulness" while reading this awesome fantasy story that is a very strong in many allegorical areas.
I can't wait for the next book!
Thanks to Celebrate Lit for my copy of this book. This review is left freely, a positive review is never required.
July 7, 2021
This second book in the series does an amazing job of continuing the story. I really do recommend reading them in order so you see the whole picture and don't feel lost (I think you would honestly). I think the author does a great job making a good Christian fantasy.
Conor and Aine are still good characters that are learning to lean on Comdiu. This book has plenty of action and adventure. You won't want to put it down at all. The supporting characters are great as well. There is love, betrayal, action, and a lot more. I like the world this author has created and can't wait to see how all this ends.
4/5
Thank you to the author/publisher for the review copy of this book via Celebrate Lit. I received this book in exchange for an honest review and the opinions stated above are 100% mine.
Conor and Aine are still good characters that are learning to lean on Comdiu. This book has plenty of action and adventure. You won't want to put it down at all. The supporting characters are great as well. There is love, betrayal, action, and a lot more. I like the world this author has created and can't wait to see how all this ends.
4/5
Thank you to the author/publisher for the review copy of this book via Celebrate Lit. I received this book in exchange for an honest review and the opinions stated above are 100% mine.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews