Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Karl Marx's Capital

Rate this book
This small book is intended, as were the lectures in which it first took form, to be an introduction to the study of Marxs Capital. It is not meant to be a substitute for such study. It is the fate of all great books tp get bcdleA-down and served up cold in text-books, which purport to tell exactly what the great book comes to, as though a mans conclusions were worth very much apart from the way in which he arrived at them. We must all have had the experience, after reading even appreciative books about great authors, of going back to the authors themselves and finding how much more there is in them than their commentators lead us to expect. Marxs Capital is obviously a book of historical importance, and any one who reads it impartially will find it greater and far more illuminating than most critics of Marx would like us, or most Marxian writers allow us to believe. There are two ways in which it is indefensible to treat a great book, ways which seem nevertheless to characterize much of what is said of Marx in this country the way of uncritical condemnation and the way. of uncritical praise. There are some books on Marx in which are collected all his inconsistencies and nothing else, as though there was nothing in Marx but inconsistencies. Such books give the impression that Marx was one of the most muddle-headed, idiots that ever lived. On the other hand, some of his interpreters seem to have given up the belief in the verbal insgiratipn of scripture for the belief in the verbal inspiration of Capital and try to maintain that there are no inconsistencies in Marx at all. We might surely be prepared, without having read a word of Marx, to reject both these extreme views. Mere inconsistent thinking has never made history as Capital has made it. But no man who has brought about a great revolution in thought has ever been without inconsistencies. The original thinker is too much occupied in trying to express the creative thought which is welling up in him to trouble himself about getting it all straightened out. There are always parts of his work which he has taken over as they stood from other people...

128 pages, Paperback

First published September 24, 1973

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Alexander Dunlop Lindsay

40 books4 followers
Alexander Dunlop (Sandy) Lindsay was born in Glasgow, Scotland, on 14th May, 1879. Educated at Glasgow University he obtained his first degree in classics in 1899. He then won a scholarship to University College, and as well as getting a double first was president of the student union.

Lindsay taught philosophy at Glasgow University (1902-1904), Edinburgh University (1904-09) and at Balliol, Oxford. Along with his friend, William Temple, he became a tutor at the Workers' Educational Association.

During the First World War Lindsay served in the British Army and in 1917 was promoted to deputy controller of labour in France.

After the war Lindsay was professor of moral philosophy at Glasgow University before returning to Oxford University. A socialist, Lindsay became a national figure in 1926 when he joined with William Temple in urging the government to seek a negotiated agreement to the General Strike.

An educational adviser to the Labour Party, Lindsay was chairman of the National Council of Social Service. He was also involved in setting up several unemployment clubs and was vice-chancellor of Oxford University (1935-38).

Lindsay, a strong opponent of appeasement, he stood as the anti-Munich candidate in the by-election that took place in Oxford in October, 1938. Although defeated by the Conservative Party candidate, Quintin Hogg, he reduced the majority from 6,645 to 3,434.

On the outbreak of the Second World War Lindsay became chairman of the Joint Recruiting Board, with the task of allocating conscientious objectors to work of national importance other than military service. He also played an important role in organizing education for the armed forces.

As well as being a regular contributor to the Manchester Guardian he wrote several books including The Philosophy of Bergson (1911), The Philosophy of Immanuel Kant (1913), The Essentials of Democracy (1929), Kant (1934), The Modern Democratic State (1943) and Religion, Science and Society in the Modern World (1943).

He was created 1st Baron of Lindsay of Birker of Low Ground by Clement Attlee on 13 November 1945.

Alexander Dunlop Lindsay died on 18th March, 1952. His son, Michael Lindsay, a specialist in Chinese economics, succeeded to the title and became the 2nd Baron of Lindsay of Birker.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
2 (15%)
4 stars
5 (38%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
4 (30%)
1 star
2 (15%)
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
466 reviews1 follower
October 25, 2011
This is certainly a dense book, but worth the read. Marx provides a great historical account of the evolution of capitalism in England up to the mid-nineteenth century. Capital chronicles the exploitation of children and women, 18 hour and even greater work days, below-subsistence pay, unsafe work practices, limited worker rights, hoarding of profits and other unsavory practices that sadly seem to have been swept away from England, only to persist in other parts of the world today. Capital chronicles the transformation of England and the world to a society dependant on the capital model, and draws many enlightening parallels to the rapid global changes at the time.

A number of the book's central premises still resonate today. The push towards greater centralization is very prevalent, with scale today equating to profits in many industries. Wealth continues to be concentrated. Workers continue to be exploited in parts of the world and inequity is very much widespread. Worker specialization continues to lead to dependency and diminishing self-suffiency.

This book is not an argument against capitalism, rather a call for protecting human rights. Marx recognizes the benefits of capitalism throughout, but like too much of a good thing, unbridled capitalism clearly can be bad.
Profile Image for Ben Dunn.
Author 13 books18 followers
January 3, 2026
Excellent little read. Starts off with a look at how Hegel influenced Marx and how Mark turned Hegel's Dialectic 'the right way up' moving it from Idealism to Dialectic Materialism. Fascinating stuff.

Later has a go at explaining why the Labour Theory of Value is a real weakness in Capital, and Marx's thinking in general.

A brief comparison with Locke, a bit of Hobbes thrown in. And how Marx is able to combine Ricardo into his work.

The final chapter on Marx and Rousseau is eye-opening.

A typical quote:
"Capitalism is, in his eyes, an unstable system because it assumes the notion of human equality and yet produces ever-growing inequality."

All of this written in 1925 in an accessible style.

If you want a thoughtful critique of Capital, this is something to consider.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews