What do you think?
Rate this book
You've Been Summoned
A suspicious host. A skeptical guest list. A historical manor. Everyone’s hiding something. It's up to you to solve the mystery in this interactive puzzle.
During a long weekend in March, a group of twentysomethings from Virginia meet for an overnight costume party. For their venue, the host has rented the historical Sophomore a place where the most prestigious socialites of the 1940's and ‘50s partied until the celebrity owners mysteriously went missing.
The event began innocently enough: cocktail toasts, elaborate costumes, and exchanged pleasantries. But at the height of the party, Jane Parks notices her twin has vanished from the scene. It isn’t until Jane finds her sister’s body that the real guessing game begins.
That’s where you come in. It’s up to you, detective, to expose a present-day link between the victim, the guest list, and Sophomore Manor’s unsolved history.
This interactive novel casts the reader as the detective. With integrated clues to examine and entangled interviews to analyze, the reader must make a case in this whodunit novel turned criminal investigation.
During a long weekend in March, a group of twentysomethings from Virginia meet for an overnight costume party. For their venue, the host has rented the historical Sophomore a place where the most prestigious socialites of the 1940's and ‘50s partied until the celebrity owners mysteriously went missing.
The event began innocently enough: cocktail toasts, elaborate costumes, and exchanged pleasantries. But at the height of the party, Jane Parks notices her twin has vanished from the scene. It isn’t until Jane finds her sister’s body that the real guessing game begins.
That’s where you come in. It’s up to you, detective, to expose a present-day link between the victim, the guest list, and Sophomore Manor’s unsolved history.
This interactive novel casts the reader as the detective. With integrated clues to examine and entangled interviews to analyze, the reader must make a case in this whodunit novel turned criminal investigation.
376 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2024
198 people are currently reading
21704 people want to read
About the author
Lindsey Lamar
2 books135 followersLindsey Lamar is a mystery writer in her twenties from Austin, Texas. Her first interactive mystery novel was released in February 2024, and her next will be released in 2026.
Learn more about Lindsey's work on her website www.lindseywritesbooks.com
Learn more about Lindsey's work on her website www.lindseywritesbooks.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 303 reviews
January 31, 2024
1.5 stars
This was an interesting premise. I love playing murder mystery games. There are parts of the story I really liked and some that had me rolling my eyes. The idea of having the reader be the detective is a good one. For me it just wasn’t executed well. The overall story wasn’t very interesting. If not for Macie and Mary I probably would have DNF’d the book. The story and characters needed more depth. MAJOR SPOILERS after this point……
I preferred Mary and Macie’s story over Jane and Sillian. With the exception of Jane, I didn’t like anyone in the story. Even though we never really see much of Sillian she is an annoying, persistent presence throughout their storyline. Macie is a coward and a pushover. Mary is controlling and cold, but she really did get the shaft. How could Macie be alright with her sister being raped and beaten? It’s no wonder Mary is willing to kill to escape her fate. I suppose that makes Macie a selfish psychopath as well as a coward.
This really needs to be proof read. At times it was confusing whom was talking or being referred to. Names were mixed up. From a technical standpoint there were glaring issues with the story. For one, there was no DNA in 1966. They never would have been able to tell if it were Macie or Mary’s body they found by the creek. Since they were identical twins, their DNA would be an exact match for one another anyways.
Backing up a little, how the hell does no one notice a fire in the woods behind the manor? The detectives on the case never find the burnt up car or the bodies of the reporter and Mary. That’s almost impossible. The women can’t even going swimming in the creek without having tabs kept on them. Yet they are able to move a dead body and a vehicle into the woods far enough away it’s never found? All this while a huge party is taking place as well. No one notices Mary coming back into the manor covered in blood? How does someone murder another person with the pin on the back of a brooch? Was it backed with a blade? Not impossible I suppose, but extremely improbable. Even a hat pin would have been more believable.
Todd, Jane and Sillian’s father, would have been born in 1945-46. He would have had to be in his 50’s to have daughters in their early to mid twenties in 2023. It does say he had them older, but it’s a bit of a stretch. Then there is the 23&Me match. How did they get a match? There would be no DNA from 1966. Not unless Macie’s body was exhumed and DNA taken for some reason and then entered into 23&Me. Mary and Macie’s mother was dead the year they turned one. Definitely no DNA taken then. It never said she had other children or siblings. Basically this entire plot line hinges on DNA testing being around in 1966. Without that Sillian never finds out they’re related and never gets involved in the story. Even if it were a thing, DNA of dead people and even victims of crimes is not entered into 23&Me. It’s a privacy thing. You can’t submit someone’s DNA to any of the testing sites without their permission.
Police have a database now, but it’s not the same as testing sites. It’s not public.
I can’t find anywhere that it is mentioned that Sillian’s costume has a pink jacket instead of yellow. I guessed that it was Sillian’s coat that Jane saw at Dakota’s when it’s revealed that she had been planning on breaking the story with him. Even in her victim profile the coat just has a serial number or something like it listed as the color. The evidence for Jane being the attacker is weak. There was the beige glove found in the staircase and then never brought up again. That would indicate that Elle was involved. The original Carmen Sandiego had beige gloves. None of the other costumes do.
Sillian knows Jane is freaking out looking for her. The police have come and questioned everyone, yet she stays hidden so she can what? Hang out in the secret basement looking for clues? Sleep with Alex without outing Michael? What a bitch. Then Jane sleep walks and somehow attacks Sillian knocking her out. How does Jane get 8 years in prison for that? True story: In 1987 a man drove 15 miles across town and killed his in-laws while sleepwalking. He was acquitted of the murders. His wasn’t the first or last case of sleepwalking and committing crimes either. So Jane doesn’t even kill her sister, but gets more time than others do for murder.
Sillian has hypothermia from lying on the ground for one night. Hypothermia is more likely to preserve brain function than cause damage. Why would it cause paralysis and a lisp in Sillian? She was either hit on the head or pushed and hit her head on the ground. Why not have that be the cause of brain injury? It makes a hell of a lot more sense than hypothermia.
With work this could be a 4 or maybe even 5 star book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thank you to Book Sirens and to the author
This was an interesting premise. I love playing murder mystery games. There are parts of the story I really liked and some that had me rolling my eyes. The idea of having the reader be the detective is a good one. For me it just wasn’t executed well. The overall story wasn’t very interesting. If not for Macie and Mary I probably would have DNF’d the book. The story and characters needed more depth. MAJOR SPOILERS after this point……
I preferred Mary and Macie’s story over Jane and Sillian. With the exception of Jane, I didn’t like anyone in the story. Even though we never really see much of Sillian she is an annoying, persistent presence throughout their storyline. Macie is a coward and a pushover. Mary is controlling and cold, but she really did get the shaft. How could Macie be alright with her sister being raped and beaten? It’s no wonder Mary is willing to kill to escape her fate. I suppose that makes Macie a selfish psychopath as well as a coward.
This really needs to be proof read. At times it was confusing whom was talking or being referred to. Names were mixed up. From a technical standpoint there were glaring issues with the story. For one, there was no DNA in 1966. They never would have been able to tell if it were Macie or Mary’s body they found by the creek. Since they were identical twins, their DNA would be an exact match for one another anyways.
Backing up a little, how the hell does no one notice a fire in the woods behind the manor? The detectives on the case never find the burnt up car or the bodies of the reporter and Mary. That’s almost impossible. The women can’t even going swimming in the creek without having tabs kept on them. Yet they are able to move a dead body and a vehicle into the woods far enough away it’s never found? All this while a huge party is taking place as well. No one notices Mary coming back into the manor covered in blood? How does someone murder another person with the pin on the back of a brooch? Was it backed with a blade? Not impossible I suppose, but extremely improbable. Even a hat pin would have been more believable.
Todd, Jane and Sillian’s father, would have been born in 1945-46. He would have had to be in his 50’s to have daughters in their early to mid twenties in 2023. It does say he had them older, but it’s a bit of a stretch. Then there is the 23&Me match. How did they get a match? There would be no DNA from 1966. Not unless Macie’s body was exhumed and DNA taken for some reason and then entered into 23&Me. Mary and Macie’s mother was dead the year they turned one. Definitely no DNA taken then. It never said she had other children or siblings. Basically this entire plot line hinges on DNA testing being around in 1966. Without that Sillian never finds out they’re related and never gets involved in the story. Even if it were a thing, DNA of dead people and even victims of crimes is not entered into 23&Me. It’s a privacy thing. You can’t submit someone’s DNA to any of the testing sites without their permission.
Police have a database now, but it’s not the same as testing sites. It’s not public.
I can’t find anywhere that it is mentioned that Sillian’s costume has a pink jacket instead of yellow. I guessed that it was Sillian’s coat that Jane saw at Dakota’s when it’s revealed that she had been planning on breaking the story with him. Even in her victim profile the coat just has a serial number or something like it listed as the color. The evidence for Jane being the attacker is weak. There was the beige glove found in the staircase and then never brought up again. That would indicate that Elle was involved. The original Carmen Sandiego had beige gloves. None of the other costumes do.
Sillian knows Jane is freaking out looking for her. The police have come and questioned everyone, yet she stays hidden so she can what? Hang out in the secret basement looking for clues? Sleep with Alex without outing Michael? What a bitch. Then Jane sleep walks and somehow attacks Sillian knocking her out. How does Jane get 8 years in prison for that? True story: In 1987 a man drove 15 miles across town and killed his in-laws while sleepwalking. He was acquitted of the murders. His wasn’t the first or last case of sleepwalking and committing crimes either. So Jane doesn’t even kill her sister, but gets more time than others do for murder.
Sillian has hypothermia from lying on the ground for one night. Hypothermia is more likely to preserve brain function than cause damage. Why would it cause paralysis and a lisp in Sillian? She was either hit on the head or pushed and hit her head on the ground. Why not have that be the cause of brain injury? It makes a hell of a lot more sense than hypothermia.
With work this could be a 4 or maybe even 5 star book.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Thank you to Book Sirens and to the author
May 9, 2024
The book I recently read was an interactive mystery novel that had me hooked from the very beginning. It was my first time reading an interactive mystery book, and I must say, it was an exhilarating experience that I would love to repeat. The cover of the book instantly caught my eye, and I couldn't resist diving into the pages.
The book had an intriguing plot that kept me engaged throughout the entire story. Every character in the book was a suspect, which added to the suspense and mystery of the story. To solve the crime, I had to keep track of all the clues and evidence that was provided along the way. The book had diagrams and drawings that helped me connect the dots and solve the puzzle.
As I delved deeper into the story, I became the detective, and it was up to me to solve the case. The book was challenging, and I had to pay close attention to every detail to solve the mystery. Initially, I didn't take notes, but as the story progressed, I realized that I needed to start taking notes to keep track of all the clues and suspects.
Overall, I had a great time reading this book, and I was thrilled to have been able to solve the mystery. I hope the author, Lindsey Lamar, has many more books planned for the future. I received this book from NetGalley for an honest review, and I must say, it was a fantastic read that I highly recommend to anyone who loves a good mystery.
The book had an intriguing plot that kept me engaged throughout the entire story. Every character in the book was a suspect, which added to the suspense and mystery of the story. To solve the crime, I had to keep track of all the clues and evidence that was provided along the way. The book had diagrams and drawings that helped me connect the dots and solve the puzzle.
As I delved deeper into the story, I became the detective, and it was up to me to solve the case. The book was challenging, and I had to pay close attention to every detail to solve the mystery. Initially, I didn't take notes, but as the story progressed, I realized that I needed to start taking notes to keep track of all the clues and suspects.
Overall, I had a great time reading this book, and I was thrilled to have been able to solve the mystery. I hope the author, Lindsey Lamar, has many more books planned for the future. I received this book from NetGalley for an honest review, and I must say, it was a fantastic read that I highly recommend to anyone who loves a good mystery.
January 10, 2024
The cover art drew me in, but the description is what got me hooked. I’ve never seen an interactive mystery novel before - such a cool concept. It’s like a murder mystery party for introverts! If you’re always flipping back in your book to check on a clue or theory, this was written for you. It would make a great buddy read since you can share theories along the way.
Jane’s twin sister Sillian goes missing during her Halloween in March party at an old mansion. YOU - yes, you, the reader - are a detective working on the case. By reviewing firsthand accounts, interviews, and other artifacts, you’ll crack the case and find out what happened to Sillian.
As you read, keep track of the suspects and clues. After being presented with all the evidence, you’re asked to make a recommendation - who had the means, motive, and opportunity to commit this crime? Once you’re finished, the mystery is explained, so you can see if you’ve got the right suspect and find out which clues you overlooked.
Despite being wrapped up in a neat package at the end, the story itself is a well-crafted, dual-timeline mystery with a solid smattering of believable yet misleading clues. I would have thoroughly enjoyed this as a straightforward novel, but the interactive element bumps it up to a spectacular reading experience. I applaud the author for taking the risk on this concept - I think it totally paid off.
Thanks to NetGalley and the author for the ARC.
Jane’s twin sister Sillian goes missing during her Halloween in March party at an old mansion. YOU - yes, you, the reader - are a detective working on the case. By reviewing firsthand accounts, interviews, and other artifacts, you’ll crack the case and find out what happened to Sillian.
As you read, keep track of the suspects and clues. After being presented with all the evidence, you’re asked to make a recommendation - who had the means, motive, and opportunity to commit this crime? Once you’re finished, the mystery is explained, so you can see if you’ve got the right suspect and find out which clues you overlooked.
Despite being wrapped up in a neat package at the end, the story itself is a well-crafted, dual-timeline mystery with a solid smattering of believable yet misleading clues. I would have thoroughly enjoyed this as a straightforward novel, but the interactive element bumps it up to a spectacular reading experience. I applaud the author for taking the risk on this concept - I think it totally paid off.
Thanks to NetGalley and the author for the ARC.
December 13, 2023
READ THIS BOOK
Oh my gosh, it is so sharp, interesting and delightful.
A big costume party, a gothic mansion, a group of 20 something friends with few worries and lots of money, what could go wrong?
Quite a bit, actually. Welcome to the historical Sophomore Manor where you will have a front row seat to the party. Remember the old "choose your own adventure" style novels? This sort of reminds me of the same. Lindsey Lamar has created a book that invites you to solve the case. Each chapter is filled with police files, interviews and documents that depict the events that transpired. Best yet, there is a series of historical files that depict a long ago mystery/tragedy that seem to feature in the current mystery.
If you ever fancied yourself a detective, now is your chance!
Pick up this novel to support an Indy author, and a publishing experiment, you won't be sorry!
Ready for the next one Lindsey, I am a huge fan!
#Youvebeensummoned #lindseylamar #Experiment42 #IndependentBookPublishersAssociation #IBPA
Oh my gosh, it is so sharp, interesting and delightful.
A big costume party, a gothic mansion, a group of 20 something friends with few worries and lots of money, what could go wrong?
Quite a bit, actually. Welcome to the historical Sophomore Manor where you will have a front row seat to the party. Remember the old "choose your own adventure" style novels? This sort of reminds me of the same. Lindsey Lamar has created a book that invites you to solve the case. Each chapter is filled with police files, interviews and documents that depict the events that transpired. Best yet, there is a series of historical files that depict a long ago mystery/tragedy that seem to feature in the current mystery.
If you ever fancied yourself a detective, now is your chance!
Pick up this novel to support an Indy author, and a publishing experiment, you won't be sorry!
Ready for the next one Lindsey, I am a huge fan!
#Youvebeensummoned #lindseylamar #Experiment42 #IndependentBookPublishersAssociation #IBPA
August 16, 2024
There are so many mistakes in this book that I found it hard to know what was a genuine red herring and just an author error. At one point a passage is repeated twice and there are a few glaringly obvious errors. Throughout the book one of the main characters is described as being 24, 25 and 26 over the time span of a week.
I was really looking forward to reading this ARC but I found that I had already guessed what had happened just over halfway through so I lost interest and had to force myself to finish the book. I read this alongside my friend and if it hadn’t been for finishing it with her I wouldn’t of bothered. It could be a great story it just needs some editing and making sure that all the details are correct and consistent as the evidence needs to not be all over the place and confusing in an interactive whodunnit.
I was really looking forward to reading this ARC but I found that I had already guessed what had happened just over halfway through so I lost interest and had to force myself to finish the book. I read this alongside my friend and if it hadn’t been for finishing it with her I wouldn’t of bothered. It could be a great story it just needs some editing and making sure that all the details are correct and consistent as the evidence needs to not be all over the place and confusing in an interactive whodunnit.
dnf
March 24, 2025DNF around 20%.
May 8, 2024
***I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review***
I had no idea what to expect before starting this book, but I was thrilled to find out. An interactive mystery novel??? I absolutely adore the concept, and I'm really impressed at how well all the media, files, and narratives of the novel fit together. While this novel does use time jumps as a plot device, these jumps helped propel the story forward, and honestly had me hanging on to every word.
This book had me annotating like crazy, going back and forth between files so that I could do this mystery justice. I didn't end up suspecting the right person, but that's okay, because I had a blast reading it.
I had no idea what to expect before starting this book, but I was thrilled to find out. An interactive mystery novel??? I absolutely adore the concept, and I'm really impressed at how well all the media, files, and narratives of the novel fit together. While this novel does use time jumps as a plot device, these jumps helped propel the story forward, and honestly had me hanging on to every word.
This book had me annotating like crazy, going back and forth between files so that I could do this mystery justice. I didn't end up suspecting the right person, but that's okay, because I had a blast reading it.
Want to read
April 30, 2024An interactive mystery novel where I’m the detective?!
sign me up ✍️
sign me up ✍️
January 24, 2024
A book full of beautiful clues to study, interviews to read, and conclusions to draw this mystery definitely hits mark for 'interactive'!
I enjoyed every moment of this book and really found myself getting invested to figure out who the culprit was, and it was tough. I was especially pleased at the fact that it was really a solvable mystery, but you will have to pay attention and take note of the details in some of the clues as they are very important. I found myself going back over the clues and noting small details that were key clues. This book would be a ton of fun to read with friends!
Would definitely recommend. The interactive elements really make this read a one-of-a-kind experience for the reader. An awesome concept and brilliant execution, thank you Lindsey!
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review
I enjoyed every moment of this book and really found myself getting invested to figure out who the culprit was, and it was tough. I was especially pleased at the fact that it was really a solvable mystery, but you will have to pay attention and take note of the details in some of the clues as they are very important. I found myself going back over the clues and noting small details that were key clues. This book would be a ton of fun to read with friends!
Would definitely recommend. The interactive elements really make this read a one-of-a-kind experience for the reader. An awesome concept and brilliant execution, thank you Lindsey!
I received this ARC in exchange for an honest review
February 7, 2024
Content Warnings:
Thank you to Netgalley and the author for this eARC!
Before I get to my thoughts on this book, I just want to say that I appreciate the effort that the author put into this story and that I have nothing but respect for indie authors. I think this author has great potential for future endeavors and I wish them nothing but success.
However, this book was not for me.
You’ve Been Summoned is described as an “interactive mystery” that contains two plotlines: one in the present day, focused on the disappearance of Sillian Parks, and one in the 1940’s, focused on the disappearance of Mary and Macie Sophomore.
Initially, I was intrigued. I love mystery, I love stories about sisters, I love dual timelines, and I love books that experiment with formatting! What could possibly go wrong?
My first problem was that the writing felt incredibly juvenile. Although all the characters in both timelines are meant to be in their mid- to late-twenties, they all read like teenagers. Especially Jane and her sister’s friends. I also felt that the writing of the 1940’s storyline — particularly the dialogue — was inaccurate and not well researched.
Another problem I had, though, was that I was continuously taken out of the story by blatant contradictions throughout the narrative. This is an uncorrected ARC so I have accepted there will be typos, misspellings, and mistakes, but at some point it just becomes frustrating. The same event will be described as having taken place a month ago, and then exactly a page later it will say it was a year ago. This happened more than once and I often found myself swiping back and forth between pages to confirm that I was not misremembering and it was, in fact, the book itself.
I want to end on a nicer note, because I really do believe the author worked hard on this and it is rough out there for indie authors. The actual mystery aspect was fun and kept me hooked. I really did want to know what happened to Sillian and the Sophomore twins. I also really enjoyed the formatting: I love mystery books that incorporate mixed media. Texts, notes, interviews transcripts — sign me up!
I wish the author nothing but success, but sadly, this one just wasn’t for me.
Side note: author, you need to change Robin’s costume for the party. Seriously.
Thank you to Netgalley and the author for this eARC!
Before I get to my thoughts on this book, I just want to say that I appreciate the effort that the author put into this story and that I have nothing but respect for indie authors. I think this author has great potential for future endeavors and I wish them nothing but success.
However, this book was not for me.
You’ve Been Summoned is described as an “interactive mystery” that contains two plotlines: one in the present day, focused on the disappearance of Sillian Parks, and one in the 1940’s, focused on the disappearance of Mary and Macie Sophomore.
Initially, I was intrigued. I love mystery, I love stories about sisters, I love dual timelines, and I love books that experiment with formatting! What could possibly go wrong?
My first problem was that the writing felt incredibly juvenile. Although all the characters in both timelines are meant to be in their mid- to late-twenties, they all read like teenagers. Especially Jane and her sister’s friends. I also felt that the writing of the 1940’s storyline — particularly the dialogue — was inaccurate and not well researched.
Another problem I had, though, was that I was continuously taken out of the story by blatant contradictions throughout the narrative. This is an uncorrected ARC so I have accepted there will be typos, misspellings, and mistakes, but at some point it just becomes frustrating. The same event will be described as having taken place a month ago, and then exactly a page later it will say it was a year ago. This happened more than once and I often found myself swiping back and forth between pages to confirm that I was not misremembering and it was, in fact, the book itself.
I want to end on a nicer note, because I really do believe the author worked hard on this and it is rough out there for indie authors. The actual mystery aspect was fun and kept me hooked. I really did want to know what happened to Sillian and the Sophomore twins. I also really enjoyed the formatting: I love mystery books that incorporate mixed media. Texts, notes, interviews transcripts — sign me up!
I wish the author nothing but success, but sadly, this one just wasn’t for me.
Side note: author, you need to change Robin’s costume for the party. Seriously.
February 16, 2024
what grabbed my attention with this book was the "interactive novel" point, ever since I was 13 I always loved figuring out cases as a detective.
the story itself is action-packed and you really have to think about every little thing! it's a great choice for people who like to solve puzzles on their own or with friends - one evening is all you need!
try solving the case and let me know if you solved it right (because I didn't, I was right about some things but wasn't expecting the ending!). have fun folks and don't forget to bring a pen with you!
───── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─────
💌 E-ARC provided via BookSirens. Big thank you to Lindsey Lamar.
the story itself is action-packed and you really have to think about every little thing! it's a great choice for people who like to solve puzzles on their own or with friends - one evening is all you need!
try solving the case and let me know if you solved it right (because I didn't, I was right about some things but wasn't expecting the ending!). have fun folks and don't forget to bring a pen with you!
───── ⋆⋅☆⋅⋆ ─────
💌 E-ARC provided via BookSirens. Big thank you to Lindsey Lamar.
June 16, 2024
Okay I liked this. I like a murder mystery and especially ones that you get to be interactive with and try and guess yourself.
I liked how it was set out with different clues and case files on the murder mystery but it fell flat for me??? The reveal at the end just didn’t shock me. I didn’t get the WOW or WHAT feeling. It felt weak??? It makes sense the whole “people who give the most information is usually the main suspect” but because she thought her own sister was sleeping with her boyfriend??? That’s why she killed her?? Eh-
It was fun to read but just didn’t interest me enough to care of the reveal
I liked how it was set out with different clues and case files on the murder mystery but it fell flat for me??? The reveal at the end just didn’t shock me. I didn’t get the WOW or WHAT feeling. It felt weak??? It makes sense the whole “people who give the most information is usually the main suspect” but because she thought her own sister was sleeping with her boyfriend??? That’s why she killed her?? Eh-
It was fun to read but just didn’t interest me enough to care of the reveal
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 17, 2024
One of my favourite types of games is interactive games; action, fantasy, crime, etc. They give a whole new level of depth to stories and characters and, depending on the genre, can get you thinking. So when I found Lindsey Lamar's You've Been Summoned I immediately wanted to read and I was not disappointed.
Following a death at a costume party in a historical Manor known for disappearances, you are cast as the detective, following the clues and discover the murderer. A Cluedo-esque novel that had me taking notes and falling further, willingly, into a world of intrigue, mystery and history. I fell in love with Lamar's novel that brings two of my favourite things into one. Lamar locks you into this detailed world where no stone can be left unturned.
Overall, You've Been Summoned was a very interesting read using a concept I haven't read before and now has me looking for more new novels as such. If you enjoy Cluedo, CSI, or True Crimes then this is the novel for you.
Thank you, NetGalley and Experiment 42 for sending me an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Following a death at a costume party in a historical Manor known for disappearances, you are cast as the detective, following the clues and discover the murderer. A Cluedo-esque novel that had me taking notes and falling further, willingly, into a world of intrigue, mystery and history. I fell in love with Lamar's novel that brings two of my favourite things into one. Lamar locks you into this detailed world where no stone can be left unturned.
Overall, You've Been Summoned was a very interesting read using a concept I haven't read before and now has me looking for more new novels as such. If you enjoy Cluedo, CSI, or True Crimes then this is the novel for you.
Thank you, NetGalley and Experiment 42 for sending me an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
April 14, 2024
I need more books written like this IMMEDIATELY!
January 1, 2024
Welcome to the world of "You've Been Summoned" by Lindsay Lamar, where you don’t just read a mystery, you solve it! Imagine a game of Clue came to life, mixed with a dash of Agatha Christie, and you're the star detective. This interactive novel is not just a story; it's your personal invitation to a murder mystery party that you won't forget.
Set in the eerie and glamorous Sophomore Manor, the scene is straight out of a classic whodunit. A group of lively twentysomethings from Virginia, dressed in their costume party best, are ready to revel in the history of this notorious venue. But hold onto your detective hats, because this is no ordinary party. When Jane Parks finds her twin sister's body, the party turns into a crime scene, and guess who's in charge of solving the mystery? You!
Lamar does a fantastic job of setting the stage. The descriptions of Sophomore Manor are so vivid, you can almost hear the echoes of 1940s jazz in the background. The characters are a vibrant mix of personalities, each with their own secrets, making them all suspects in your investigation.
What makes this book stand out is the interactive element. You’re not just passively reading; you’re actively engaging with the story. It's like being in an escape room, but the room is a book. You examine clues, analyze interviews, and connect the dots. Every choice you make takes you down a different path of the narrative, making you feel like Sherlock Holmes with a smartphone.
The connection between the Manor's unsolved history and the present-day murder adds layers of intrigue. You'll find yourself flipping back and forth, piecing together the puzzle. Lamar's writing is clever and engaging, making every clue, every interview count in your quest for the truth.
In conclusion, "You've Been Summoned" is a thrilling, immersive experience for anyone who loves a good mystery. Lindsay Lamar has created a novel where you're not just reading about a detective; you are the detective. So, grab your magnifying glass (or just your reading glasses), put on your thinking cap, and get ready to solve the mystery of Sophomore Manor. And remember, everyone's a suspect, even you!
Set in the eerie and glamorous Sophomore Manor, the scene is straight out of a classic whodunit. A group of lively twentysomethings from Virginia, dressed in their costume party best, are ready to revel in the history of this notorious venue. But hold onto your detective hats, because this is no ordinary party. When Jane Parks finds her twin sister's body, the party turns into a crime scene, and guess who's in charge of solving the mystery? You!
Lamar does a fantastic job of setting the stage. The descriptions of Sophomore Manor are so vivid, you can almost hear the echoes of 1940s jazz in the background. The characters are a vibrant mix of personalities, each with their own secrets, making them all suspects in your investigation.
What makes this book stand out is the interactive element. You’re not just passively reading; you’re actively engaging with the story. It's like being in an escape room, but the room is a book. You examine clues, analyze interviews, and connect the dots. Every choice you make takes you down a different path of the narrative, making you feel like Sherlock Holmes with a smartphone.
The connection between the Manor's unsolved history and the present-day murder adds layers of intrigue. You'll find yourself flipping back and forth, piecing together the puzzle. Lamar's writing is clever and engaging, making every clue, every interview count in your quest for the truth.
In conclusion, "You've Been Summoned" is a thrilling, immersive experience for anyone who loves a good mystery. Lindsay Lamar has created a novel where you're not just reading about a detective; you are the detective. So, grab your magnifying glass (or just your reading glasses), put on your thinking cap, and get ready to solve the mystery of Sophomore Manor. And remember, everyone's a suspect, even you!
July 1, 2024
I’m not quite sure how I feel about this one. It was a fun ride. It had interesting formatting and read a little different than your average whodunnit. You’re basically a detective and it’s your job to figure out what happened.
I found myself not caring about the 1940s storyline until the very end. But I liked how it ended up tying in and ultimately made sense.
Overall, this book was like a version of Clue and it was interesting to see how it played out. 3.5/5
I found myself not caring about the 1940s storyline until the very end. But I liked how it ended up tying in and ultimately made sense.
Overall, this book was like a version of Clue and it was interesting to see how it played out. 3.5/5
December 11, 2023
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐.5 (rounded to 5)
"You've Been Summoned" is a literary gem that effortlessly earns its high rating. From start to finish, this novel captivates readers with its unique concept, compelling characters, and skillful storytelling. I usually keep my expectations fairly high for mystery books, and this one surpassed all of them.
What truly sets this book apart is the thrilling concept of allowing readers to piece together the mystery on their own. While these books have existed for a long time, I'd never read one myself - and as a fan of a good challenge, I was immediately drawn in, and Lamar delivered beyond my expectations. Despite correctly guessing the killer halfway through, the suspense and unexpected twists kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end.
My favorite thing about this book, however, would have to be the added element of the dual timelines. Flicking back to the past to explore the lives of Mary, Macie, and the Sophomore brothers was a highlight for me. These characters became my favorites, adding depth and richness to the overall story. I have to admit, I'd often find myself flicking through the present chapters just to return to them and to their past - I had to find out what happened to them. How their story ended. Despite myself, I adored all four of them (not, might I say, as people). Josh, James, Mary and Macie are characters that I know will stay with me; a story as haunting as theirs is bound to.
Speaking of haunting, that final twist at the end left me utterly astonished. I would never have anticipated that. Reflecting back, however, it all made sense. The author's ability to build suspense throughout the book, coupled with morally flawed characters, created a narrative that was both engaging and thought-provoking.
The narration, concise and to the point, allowed the story to unfold seamlessly. While Jane, the narrator, may not be wholly remarkable and exuded a palpable insecurity, her authenticity made her relatable and added to the story's overall charm. Her relationship with Dakota, who is not particularly interesting in his own right, was another highlight for me - the dynamic was quite interesting to observe.
In conclusion, "You've Been Summoned" is a masterfully crafted novel that seamlessly weaves together mystery, suspense, and flawed characters. For those in search of a quick and enthralling read, look no further.
"You've Been Summoned" is a literary gem that effortlessly earns its high rating. From start to finish, this novel captivates readers with its unique concept, compelling characters, and skillful storytelling. I usually keep my expectations fairly high for mystery books, and this one surpassed all of them.
What truly sets this book apart is the thrilling concept of allowing readers to piece together the mystery on their own. While these books have existed for a long time, I'd never read one myself - and as a fan of a good challenge, I was immediately drawn in, and Lamar delivered beyond my expectations. Despite correctly guessing the killer halfway through, the suspense and unexpected twists kept me on the edge of my seat until the very end.
My favorite thing about this book, however, would have to be the added element of the dual timelines. Flicking back to the past to explore the lives of Mary, Macie, and the Sophomore brothers was a highlight for me. These characters became my favorites, adding depth and richness to the overall story. I have to admit, I'd often find myself flicking through the present chapters just to return to them and to their past - I had to find out what happened to them. How their story ended. Despite myself, I adored all four of them (not, might I say, as people). Josh, James, Mary and Macie are characters that I know will stay with me; a story as haunting as theirs is bound to.
Speaking of haunting, that final twist at the end left me utterly astonished. I would never have anticipated that. Reflecting back, however, it all made sense. The author's ability to build suspense throughout the book, coupled with morally flawed characters, created a narrative that was both engaging and thought-provoking.
The narration, concise and to the point, allowed the story to unfold seamlessly. While Jane, the narrator, may not be wholly remarkable and exuded a palpable insecurity, her authenticity made her relatable and added to the story's overall charm. Her relationship with Dakota, who is not particularly interesting in his own right, was another highlight for me - the dynamic was quite interesting to observe.
In conclusion, "You've Been Summoned" is a masterfully crafted novel that seamlessly weaves together mystery, suspense, and flawed characters. For those in search of a quick and enthralling read, look no further.
December 10, 2023
I have admittedly read a lot of books in the mystery and thriller genre. However, when Lindsey Lamar pitched her book as an "interactive mystery" novel, I was intrigued and immediately grabbed this book and didn't stop reading until I was at the last page. The format of "You've Been Summoned" is unique in that the reader is taking on the persona of a junior PI and reading case files to solve two different cases: one from the 1940s and another in the present day.
Both cases revolve around a pair of twin sisters, and the files contain red herrings, delicious lies, notable suspects, and puzzles galore. When transported to the 1940s, the reader is able to get an inside look into the limitations that women faced in this decade and how this led to cunning decisions and, ultimately, manipulation at the hands of devious men. Step inside the gothic atmosphere of Sophmore Manor and see if you can solve one (or both!) of the mysteries within the mansion's walls.
This novel is perfect if you are a fan of:
-Locked room mysteries
-Being an armchair detective
-Historical fiction mixed in with murder, deceit, and tons of twists
I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Both cases revolve around a pair of twin sisters, and the files contain red herrings, delicious lies, notable suspects, and puzzles galore. When transported to the 1940s, the reader is able to get an inside look into the limitations that women faced in this decade and how this led to cunning decisions and, ultimately, manipulation at the hands of devious men. Step inside the gothic atmosphere of Sophmore Manor and see if you can solve one (or both!) of the mysteries within the mansion's walls.
This novel is perfect if you are a fan of:
-Locked room mysteries
-Being an armchair detective
-Historical fiction mixed in with murder, deceit, and tons of twists
I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
June 7, 2024
I wanted so badly to like this book. This seemed extremely up my alley, putting me in the driver’s seat of a murder mystery and making it interactive. I think the concept is brilliant, however the execution fell flat for me.
None of the characters felt fully formed or honestly that likable. I wasn’t endeared to any of them in a way i wanted to be.
There were also issues with the writing itself: names being swapped, apostrophes where they didn’t need to be, etc. Other reviews pointed out timeline and technology inconsistencies, which takes away from the story’s realness.
And the reveal? I guess I should have seen it coming, but it just feels so weak. Jane did it in her sleep for what? Because she thought Sillian was sleeping with Dakota?? Seems insane for her to switch up that much. I understand that’s the whole point of an unreliable narrator situation (which is one of my favorite plot devices), but i feel there should have been more clues. There was not much at all pointing us to thinking that Jane could have a temper in that way. It felt half baked and unsatisfying as a reader.
All of this being said, I tore through this book as it was a fast and engaging read. I would have liked to have at least gotten some of it right, but no dice. I think if i would have taken the time to fully analyze and take detailed notes, I might have been able to get there. I did point out that two people said she smelled nice the next morning, but never put anything together with that.
None of the characters felt fully formed or honestly that likable. I wasn’t endeared to any of them in a way i wanted to be.
There were also issues with the writing itself: names being swapped, apostrophes where they didn’t need to be, etc. Other reviews pointed out timeline and technology inconsistencies, which takes away from the story’s realness.
And the reveal? I guess I should have seen it coming, but it just feels so weak. Jane did it in her sleep for what? Because she thought Sillian was sleeping with Dakota?? Seems insane for her to switch up that much. I understand that’s the whole point of an unreliable narrator situation (which is one of my favorite plot devices), but i feel there should have been more clues. There was not much at all pointing us to thinking that Jane could have a temper in that way. It felt half baked and unsatisfying as a reader.
All of this being said, I tore through this book as it was a fast and engaging read. I would have liked to have at least gotten some of it right, but no dice. I think if i would have taken the time to fully analyze and take detailed notes, I might have been able to get there. I did point out that two people said she smelled nice the next morning, but never put anything together with that.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 1, 2024
An engaging and unique story!
I love when a book sucks you in by making you a part of the story. This is a mystery - a party in a house with a past. It's a costume party - and in the morning, the host is missing! The story is broken into cases and, as you go along, you will be reading interviews, reading text messages, articles and photos. There are parts that read like a typical novel, so it's not all notes pictures.
There are 2 stories here - 2 timelines. One is the previous inhabitants of the house - and they also mysteriously disappeared. The other story it the one you are trying to solve. The story starts with you being hired as a P.I and you needing to go through the case information. It's such a fun way to tell the story and had me completely pulled in. I had few guesses until the very end. Even then, I love that it laid out all the clues I should have caught and how the conclusions could be drawn. Such a fun story! I loved it!
A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.
I love when a book sucks you in by making you a part of the story. This is a mystery - a party in a house with a past. It's a costume party - and in the morning, the host is missing! The story is broken into cases and, as you go along, you will be reading interviews, reading text messages, articles and photos. There are parts that read like a typical novel, so it's not all notes pictures.
There are 2 stories here - 2 timelines. One is the previous inhabitants of the house - and they also mysteriously disappeared. The other story it the one you are trying to solve. The story starts with you being hired as a P.I and you needing to go through the case information. It's such a fun way to tell the story and had me completely pulled in. I had few guesses until the very end. Even then, I love that it laid out all the clues I should have caught and how the conclusions could be drawn. Such a fun story! I loved it!
A huge thank you to the author and publisher for providing an e-ARC via Netgalley. This does not affect my opinion regarding the book.
June 4, 2024
3.5 stars
June 20, 2025
I was really rooting for this book. It had a great premise, but sadly fell short for me.
Things That Worked for Me
Breaking up the book into case files, and each case file containing diary entries, witness recountings, police questionings, news articles, and other items was pretty cool. It was a great break from each chapter and gave me something new to look at.
Things That Did NOT Work for Me
Sadly this portion of the review is long, and will contain lots of spoilers. I will do my best to blur them out.
First, what had me so interested in this book was that it was advertised as "An Interactive Mystery Novel". I wouldn't call breaking the story up into case files interactive. I can see where it was trying to be interactive by having Detective Philip Beacons leave notes encouraging you along the way, but honestly it just felt condescending. I'm specifically talking about at the end of Case File Six, when I read a letter he had left. In it, he said Yet two sentences later says I was pretty much told I should know who the culprit was, yet then told I have many suspects. It made me feel dumb and confused. Of course I didn't know who the culprit was. And of course I had many suspects!
By Interactive, I thought You've Been Summoned was going to be an adult version of choose your own adventure, and is even marked as a Choose Your Own Adventure under its genres on Goodreads. It is not, and I feel it would've been better if it had been. If I the reader had been able to branch off and follow a suspect to see where it led, opposed to just given one trail to follow throughout the whole novel.
Secondly, You've Been Summoned is marked as a YAF at my library, which just confused me. The book refers to the main group of characters/suspects as 20-somethings over and over, so the characters are well out of the Young Adult category of books. The phrase of "20-somethings" was repeated to the point of excess. Maybe the novel falls under New Adult, but I felt that should make it just Adult Mystery. I supposed this is more of a side note opposed to something I didn't like since the author can't help how a library categorized her novel, but it did give me a conflicting perspective while reading. Mentally, I'm aware I reading about adults, yet the label on the spine tells me I'm reading about older teens.
Thirdly, there was too much with twins. I know I referenced twins in my What I Liked section above, but after getting into the story it was disappointing. I can't say if it's just because the trope has been used too many times, or if it was just delivered poorly but I could spot a mile away the two big tropes used: Again, hard to say if the material wasn't written well enough to pull the tropes off, or if the tropes are just so common in regards to twins in film and literature that it felt unoriginal. I truly appreciate the effort for what Lindsey Lamar tried to pull off, but in the end the separate storylines of Macie and Mary, Jane and Sillian, they were just too predictable.
This leads into my fourth problem:
Final Thoughts
Again, I really wanted more out of this book than it gave. I feel like it tried so hard to be something that it just got so lost in details that it became consumed with them. I gave it two stars simply because I saw its potential, and did enjoy a few small portions. I'm sorry this didn't reach its potential.
Things That Worked for Me
Breaking up the book into case files, and each case file containing diary entries, witness recountings, police questionings, news articles, and other items was pretty cool. It was a great break from each chapter and gave me something new to look at.
Things That Did NOT Work for Me
Sadly this portion of the review is long, and will contain lots of spoilers. I will do my best to blur them out.
First, what had me so interested in this book was that it was advertised as "An Interactive Mystery Novel". I wouldn't call breaking the story up into case files interactive. I can see where it was trying to be interactive by having Detective Philip Beacons leave notes encouraging you along the way, but honestly it just felt condescending. I'm specifically talking about at the end of Case File Six, when I read a letter he had left. In it, he said Yet two sentences later says I was pretty much told I should know who the culprit was, yet then told I have many suspects. It made me feel dumb and confused. Of course I didn't know who the culprit was. And of course I had many suspects!
By Interactive, I thought You've Been Summoned was going to be an adult version of choose your own adventure, and is even marked as a Choose Your Own Adventure under its genres on Goodreads. It is not, and I feel it would've been better if it had been. If I the reader had been able to branch off and follow a suspect to see where it led, opposed to just given one trail to follow throughout the whole novel.
Secondly, You've Been Summoned is marked as a YAF at my library, which just confused me. The book refers to the main group of characters/suspects as 20-somethings over and over, so the characters are well out of the Young Adult category of books. The phrase of "20-somethings" was repeated to the point of excess. Maybe the novel falls under New Adult, but I felt that should make it just Adult Mystery. I supposed this is more of a side note opposed to something I didn't like since the author can't help how a library categorized her novel, but it did give me a conflicting perspective while reading. Mentally, I'm aware I reading about adults, yet the label on the spine tells me I'm reading about older teens.
Thirdly, there was too much with twins. I know I referenced twins in my What I Liked section above, but after getting into the story it was disappointing. I can't say if it's just because the trope has been used too many times, or if it was just delivered poorly but I could spot a mile away the two big tropes used: Again, hard to say if the material wasn't written well enough to pull the tropes off, or if the tropes are just so common in regards to twins in film and literature that it felt unoriginal. I truly appreciate the effort for what Lindsey Lamar tried to pull off, but in the end the separate storylines of Macie and Mary, Jane and Sillian, they were just too predictable.
This leads into my fourth problem:
Final Thoughts
Again, I really wanted more out of this book than it gave. I feel like it tried so hard to be something that it just got so lost in details that it became consumed with them. I gave it two stars simply because I saw its potential, and did enjoy a few small portions. I'm sorry this didn't reach its potential.
January 16, 2024
It took me a moment to dive into this book, primarily because I wanted to truly enjoy it the way it was meant to be enjoyed - as a game - where I'm the Private Investigator. Unfortunately, time was not on my side and I ended up reading it like a novel. I LOVED it! The story changes between the historical twins that owned the home and the current day twins (told through Jane's eyes). The historical twins are trying to figure out how to balance a successful life as actors while taking a break from the limelight. They are involved in a bit of a scheme which I anticipate is similar to some of the modern day "faux feuds" that litter Page Six. Bounce to modern day and you have Jane, hopeful journalist, along with her twin Sillian. Somewhat opposites, Sillian is full of life and hijinks - the life of the party (which she throws for a living) while Jane is the opposite - inquisitive and people pleasing in nature. Jane is caught between pleasing her boyfriend or pleasing her sister as she double books herself one weekend. In an effort to do both, she becomes tied up in a missing person's case - notably - her sister.
The book is fast-paced, with stops to thing about what is being read - this is a game of sorts - where the reader is just as much a part of the investigating party as Jane. There were several moments where my head spun as I realized the clues I'd missed, and then some I caught some right away. I'm intrigued to see this in print.
As a special note, I loved the story the Lindsey Lamar shared at the end. The reason behind self publishing. As a kid, I envisioned a book much like this, but with maps to help readers along the way. My vision was less murder mystery and more adventure, but the idea was the same - wanting the reader to be IN the book - engaged in more than just reading. I applaud this effort and will be at the store to see how it came together. I know my true crime obsessed friends will love this book and can't wait to share it with them!
The book is fast-paced, with stops to thing about what is being read - this is a game of sorts - where the reader is just as much a part of the investigating party as Jane. There were several moments where my head spun as I realized the clues I'd missed, and then some I caught some right away. I'm intrigued to see this in print.
As a special note, I loved the story the Lindsey Lamar shared at the end. The reason behind self publishing. As a kid, I envisioned a book much like this, but with maps to help readers along the way. My vision was less murder mystery and more adventure, but the idea was the same - wanting the reader to be IN the book - engaged in more than just reading. I applaud this effort and will be at the store to see how it came together. I know my true crime obsessed friends will love this book and can't wait to share it with them!
February 26, 2024
Wow this book is amazing!
It’s not an ordinary murder mystery but it comes with a unique format that will make a different reading experience!
You can guess the culprit from the evidence and clues scattered throughout the story!
I really have fun making theories, jotting down clues that might be important in determining the real culprit. I have to admit it wasn’t easy, there’s a lot of suspicious characters and each one of them has secrets, it’s hard to know which ones has a malicious intent towards the victim.
There’s two mysteries that you need to solve here, the one in present time and also one in the past.
The big reveal comes with the supported evidence of the culprit's motive and I really like it was also wrapped up nicely with that epilogue.
Overall, this was a fantastic and fun interactive mystery novel!
I love the writing style of this book, it manage to build the suspense of the murder mystery from the beginning until the end.
I would definitely keep an eye out for another book by this author in the future!
I received an advanced review copy for free through Netgalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Huge thank you to the author and publisher!
It’s not an ordinary murder mystery but it comes with a unique format that will make a different reading experience!
You can guess the culprit from the evidence and clues scattered throughout the story!
I really have fun making theories, jotting down clues that might be important in determining the real culprit. I have to admit it wasn’t easy, there’s a lot of suspicious characters and each one of them has secrets, it’s hard to know which ones has a malicious intent towards the victim.
There’s two mysteries that you need to solve here, the one in present time and also one in the past.
The big reveal comes with the supported evidence of the culprit's motive and I really like it was also wrapped up nicely with that epilogue.
Overall, this was a fantastic and fun interactive mystery novel!
I love the writing style of this book, it manage to build the suspense of the murder mystery from the beginning until the end.
I would definitely keep an eye out for another book by this author in the future!
I received an advanced review copy for free through Netgalley, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Huge thank you to the author and publisher!
January 13, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Four stars.
What a trip this was! I can't say very often, after the thousands of books across many genres that I have read, that I often come across something that is truely unique. This book is definitely that, a book that stands on it's own for the creativity, individuality, and creating its own spot on the book food chain.
For someone like me who loves a mystery, loves historical fiction and a dual time line, this book brought these aspects together in a distinctive way of it's very own. I loved that as the reader, I was included in the story, I got to piece together the clues as a private investigator assigned to investigate this case.
I did mark down one star because at times I felt a little lost, I think it would have been easier to read this as a physical copy in which I could flip back and forth and look again at previous clues and testimony. As an ebook, the only way for me to do this was with copious swiping. I keep it all in my head after all. Despite this, did I correctly intuit the culprit? And the answer to this is a big resounding YES!! Go me! Haha. I did feel quite a sense of achievement and satisfaction upon getting this right. And I have to give the book brownie points for that because I don't remember feeling that after finishing a book in a long time.
One more thing. A shout out to Lindsey Lamar - you are clearly a very intelligent and talented woman and author and I will proudly read everything else you ever write. And I have already started telling people to get hold of a copy of this to read for themselves. What an unexpected treat.
Thank you Netgalley, Experiment 42 and the talented Lindsey Lamar for an advance review copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Four stars.
What a trip this was! I can't say very often, after the thousands of books across many genres that I have read, that I often come across something that is truely unique. This book is definitely that, a book that stands on it's own for the creativity, individuality, and creating its own spot on the book food chain.
For someone like me who loves a mystery, loves historical fiction and a dual time line, this book brought these aspects together in a distinctive way of it's very own. I loved that as the reader, I was included in the story, I got to piece together the clues as a private investigator assigned to investigate this case.
I did mark down one star because at times I felt a little lost, I think it would have been easier to read this as a physical copy in which I could flip back and forth and look again at previous clues and testimony. As an ebook, the only way for me to do this was with copious swiping. I keep it all in my head after all. Despite this, did I correctly intuit the culprit? And the answer to this is a big resounding YES!! Go me! Haha. I did feel quite a sense of achievement and satisfaction upon getting this right. And I have to give the book brownie points for that because I don't remember feeling that after finishing a book in a long time.
One more thing. A shout out to Lindsey Lamar - you are clearly a very intelligent and talented woman and author and I will proudly read everything else you ever write. And I have already started telling people to get hold of a copy of this to read for themselves. What an unexpected treat.
Thank you Netgalley, Experiment 42 and the talented Lindsey Lamar for an advance review copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
February 20, 2024
This book was a really fun read. If you like those choose your own adventure books then this is a book you will really enjoy.
Janes sister, Sillian, goes missing during a March Halloween party at a local supposedly haunted mansion. As the reader, you are the detective, by reviewing firsthand accounts, interviews and evidence, you should be able to crack the case and find out what happened to Sillian.
The whole point of the book is to collect evidence and keep track of the suspects and clues. Then at the end you are to make a recommendation on who you believe the culprit to be.
The story itself it well written with a dual timeline. The characters are well written and with the interactive element, it makes for a really great read. I received this book free from Booksirens for an honest review.
Janes sister, Sillian, goes missing during a March Halloween party at a local supposedly haunted mansion. As the reader, you are the detective, by reviewing firsthand accounts, interviews and evidence, you should be able to crack the case and find out what happened to Sillian.
The whole point of the book is to collect evidence and keep track of the suspects and clues. Then at the end you are to make a recommendation on who you believe the culprit to be.
The story itself it well written with a dual timeline. The characters are well written and with the interactive element, it makes for a really great read. I received this book free from Booksirens for an honest review.
May 22, 2025
this was definitely something different. and i’m definitely a bad Nancy Drew.. me gusto más la historia de Mary y Macie maybe i’m bias because i was able to figure that one out. Jane y Sillian there were just a lot going on and maybe if i wasn’t reading more than one book at a time i could’ve caught up on what was happening faster. pero overall it was so entertaining and i loved que fue interactive.
November 19, 2024
Loved this. I really enjoy an interactive book. I had no idea who the culprit was but it’s fun that you can try to guess. I liked how there was a history factor to it, the Sophmore sisters added a double mystery to this book. 10/10, would love to read more books like this.
January 27, 2024
I absolutely loved it - I devoured it. This is a must read for any thriller fans, historical fiction fans and readers in general. A maze of stories, twisted just enough to keep you guessing until the final page.
February 11, 2024
This was such a cool book. I loved the premise. There were two stories going on at once. The story of the Sophmore twins in 1945 and the Parks twins in 2023. The stories mirror eachother in many ways.
In 1945 women had to rely on their husbands to manage their finances, lives and pretty much everything. Twins Mary and Macie are movie stars who decide to take a berak from the silver screen and marry the Sophmore brothers, two well known jazz mucians, ensuring their fincancial future. This is a marriage of convenience but ends up being not what it seems.
In 2023, Sillian Parks plans a raging party at the Sophmore estate. Sillian is known for her parties, whereas Jane is a more reserved and prefers a more quiet life. The party also is not what it seems and when Sillian goes missing, Jane is determined to find her.
Throughout the book, we, the readers are the detectives and are provided with case files and clues to review. At the end of the book we are expected to have solved the mystery. Thre are a unique set of characters throughout both story lines. Much of what we learn is in diary format, which I happen to love. We also learn a lot through interviews with the main detective and news articles.
I really loved how this story was set up. I flew through it, wanting more of the girls' stories. I hope there are more like this. It was a unique set up, but it worked really well!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
In 1945 women had to rely on their husbands to manage their finances, lives and pretty much everything. Twins Mary and Macie are movie stars who decide to take a berak from the silver screen and marry the Sophmore brothers, two well known jazz mucians, ensuring their fincancial future. This is a marriage of convenience but ends up being not what it seems.
In 2023, Sillian Parks plans a raging party at the Sophmore estate. Sillian is known for her parties, whereas Jane is a more reserved and prefers a more quiet life. The party also is not what it seems and when Sillian goes missing, Jane is determined to find her.
Throughout the book, we, the readers are the detectives and are provided with case files and clues to review. At the end of the book we are expected to have solved the mystery. Thre are a unique set of characters throughout both story lines. Much of what we learn is in diary format, which I happen to love. We also learn a lot through interviews with the main detective and news articles.
I really loved how this story was set up. I flew through it, wanting more of the girls' stories. I hope there are more like this. It was a unique set up, but it worked really well!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 303 reviews