3.5-3.7 stars.
This book is set in New Orleans in late December/early January, right at the end of deb season and the beginning of Carnival. It is told from three different perspectives, those of Piper, Vivian, and April, three debutante "Maids" who get tangled up in the mystery of two debutante queens, Margot (who died mysteriously the year before) and their fellow deb Lily, who goes missing the night of their ball.
I'm really struggling with what to rate this book, because there are so many elements that I love and yet also some things that I had a hard time with. For one, I love the setting! I can feel New Orleans in this piece and I enjoyed that a lot, especially as someone who loves the city. I also really like the way that all of the characters, even Margot, express their feelings about New Orleans, whether they love it or loathe it, because that element really helped me to understand the characters. I learned a lot about Mardi Gras culture and Krewes, as well as a lot about Mardi Gras debutante culture, which I had no idea about, so it was interesting (and at times, unsettling, though I'm sure that's the point). I enjoyed this setting as the back drop for the mystery and thought it was the perfect combination of serious, fun, interesting, and spooky. I think this setting choice also allowed the author to discuss important topics such as the toxic elements of debutante culture, toxic masculinity, and feminism (especially how women are exploited or forced to operate within environments like the Krewe of Deus and debutante culture). I also liked the three main characters and enjoyed getting to know them and watching and their friendship grow.
But, I did struggle at times to understand the characters. I felt as though there weren't many details grounding them, especially Vivian, who felt less well-rounded than the other two and less like a true individual. I also thought that the author struggled with side characters. For example, we meet the parents of all three debs early on, but only Piper's come to play a significant role, which is confusing. Or Savannah or Aiden, who are really interesting side characters, but who aren't very well-rounded and aren't mentioned enough, except for when they need to move the plot forward or make one of the main three seem more interesting, which was a bit hard to follow. It also seems that some plot elements didn't quite line up, and I struggled to follow some details. There were just many small contradictory details that did not seem all the way thought out, given the way that the mystery resolved itself. I also felt a little bit unsatisfied with the ending, given that nothing really changes with the toxic culture of the Krewe of Deus after everything that the three FMCs go through in order to expose the corruption and misogyny at the heart of the organization, even though the Pierrot is destroyed.
All of that said, this book fits in so well with other YA mysteries, like Karen McManus or Jessica Goodman, and I did really enjoy it! The mystery is taut and compelling and the setting was so eerie and vivid!
Thanks to NetGalley and to Wednesday Books for the advanced copy!