**Many thanks to Berkley and Kerry Rea for an ARC of this book provided via NetGalley!**
Like Rose Dewitt-Bukater was dubbed by handsome Jack Dawson in the Titanic film, Emily Edwards is also definitely what you'd call an 'indoor girl.' Never one to venture forth in the name of adventure, her idea of camping probably more closely resembles glamping...meaning she is diametrically opposed from her sky's-the-limit-father. Tragically, though, Emily's father has passed away...and his dreams of completing a very ambitious bucket list have been dashed as well. But Emily has an idea of how she can continue her father's goal to visit every national park: she can spread his ashes at one of the national parks he HADN'T made it to: Isle Royale Park in Michigan.
But Emily's lack of nature know-how and her general intelligence (she works as a physician) tell her that she needs a tour guide to be able to lead the way and keep her safe from the dangerous wildlife that COULD be lurking. When she starts to desperately search for a guide, though, it seems that they are all booked...save for one agency, Fleet Outdoor Adventures. And luckily for Emily (or so she thinks) Ryder Fleet, owner, is set to meet her at the dock and provide all the guidance she could ever need. What she doesn't know, however, is that Ryder's brother Caleb was the TRUE tour guru...and ever since his untimely passing, Fleet Outdoor Adventures has been pretty quiet...and certainly hasn't had any tour requests. As a marketing whiz, Ryder is much better at taking a pretty PICTURE of an outdoor adventure than actually living it.
Too embarrassed to admit the truth, Ryder's pride and desperation to do his brother's legacy proud inspires him to keep this fact to himself and attempt to lead the way for Emily. What neither of them could have predicted, however, was that a precious and rare jewel is said to be somewhere in the park...and there are a couple of their fellow travelers who would do JUST ABOUT ANYTHING to get their paws on it...even commit murder. After witnessing a horrifying crime, Ryder and Emily are forced to TRULY band together to outsmart their common enemy. But as the danger increases and the perps become even more desperate, the connection between Ryder and Emily is deepening too...and might resemble something powerful and REAL. Will this unlikely duo be able to reign as King and Queen of the Isle and keep the jewel out of greedy hands? Or will the fact that they've seen (and that they know) far too much make them the killer's NEXT targets...and leave them trapped in the park...for good?
From this book's sugary, cartoon-y cover, it should be FAIRLY clear what you're getting, and after completing this book, it IS essentially what I thought it was going to be...minus one very important thing.
ALL. OF. THE. LAUGHS.
As much as I wanted to dig in and chuckle at the campy nature (pardon the pun) of the premise and the general mishaps of two very inexperienced adventurers, I had a hard time really finding any of the predicaments COMICAL. While our two main characters felt fairly grounded in reality, the villain might as well have been twirling a swirling black mustache: he was just THAT cliché. I don't necessarily mind this in general, because it could have been a lot of fun. But I think what felt most 'off' to me about this one was just the balance of four important elements: grief, romance, comedy, and the adventure/mystery aspect of the book. The author couldn't quite decide which tone would be the overarching one, and therefore sort of 'lost me in the forest' along the way.
Let's start with the romance: this is VERY much an insta-love kind of story. From the first time Ryder encounters Emily on the dock he is BASICALLY in love with her already because she's so dreamy. Again, that's all well and good...but I don't think this sort of connection was really necessary. With so much going on just in terms of plot, a slow build would have been PERFECT here! I know both characters found each other devastatingly attractive but still: less is often more. While not overly spicy, it was still more than I felt I personally needed after meeting these characters and also just felt a bit jarring in contrast to what truly bonded these two in the first place...
GRIEF. This is really a book about characters battling their own experiences of grief, and not only was it difficult to dig into and unpack these ideas in such a short period of time; tonally, it gave me whiplash. While this certainly COULD be a bonding force in a budding relationship, it was very clear that both of our MCs probably needed more time to work on themselves before they dove headfirst into a relationship. I both liked all of the background we got on Emily's father and Ryder's brother and simultaneously felt like it was just TOO much with the zany adventure plot line going on. I think I would have felt more at home with some of this behavior if these two met at a grief support group: it just didn't feel at home in the throes of the jungle.
And then of course, the main theme (?) of the book itself: the Jewel of the Isle. As much as the plot was borderline goofy at times, it WAS somewhat thrilling...but like many adventure movies, by the last third, I was basically counting the minutes until it was over. The twists and turns are enough to keep you invested, but never enough to read as insanely clever or unexpected in any way
(okay, so this was probably my overly picky thriller loving side coming out...I can't turn it off entirely!).
As with romances in general, it's perfectly serviceable to have this sort of predictability...but the flip side of this predictability is that nothing about this ending was particularly memorable. (But hey, I can't remember the end of the Indiana Jones films either...everything after the big ball rolls down the mountain is a LITTLE blurry! 🗻)
For those looking for a silly, slightly spicy, sweet, sad, and perfectly sufficient adventurous rom-com, the Jewel of the Isle just might be your diamond in the rough. 💎
But as for me, 'Isle' be dreaming of visiting a REAL one instead.
3.5 stars