Jonny Garrett, cofounder of the YouTube sensation Craft Beer Channel, travels in search of the deeper cultural impact of brewing—how it has become one of the world’s most important inventions and shaped our lives for millennia.
What’s the oldest and most consumed alcoholic beverage on earth? Beer, of course. And it might just be one of our more important inventions.
Since its creation thirteen thousand years ago, our love of beer has shaped everything from religious ceremonies to advertising, and architecture to bioengineering. The people who built the pyramids were paid in ale; the first fridge was built for beer, not food; bacteria was discovered while investigating sour beer; Germany’s beer halls hosted Hitler’s rise to power; and brewer’s yeast may yet be the answer to climate change.
In The Meaning of Beer, award-winning beer writer Jonny Garrett tells the stories of these incredible human moments and inventions, taking readers to some of the best-known beer destinations in the world—Munich and Oktoberfest, Carlsberg Brewery’s historic laboratory, St. Louis and the home of Budweiser—as well as those lesser known, from a five-thousand-year-old brewery in the Egyptian desert to Arctic Svalbard, home to the world’s most northerly pub.
Ultimately, this is not a book about how we made beer, but how beer made us.
A must read for any beer lover, especially one who worries about the future of brewing. It is so much bigger than we realize. As an American I especially enjoyed the worldly look at beer.
Very interesting book on the many facets of beer and how it has impacted the world. I particularly enjoyed the historical sections and the stories about some of the author's beer trips.
a good read, covering a choice of beer topics that are important in beer and brewing. Would like to delve deeper into a few of the topics raised, well worth your time even if you're not a beer drinker.
"He who does not know beer, does not know what is good." - The Epic of Gilgamesh
Beer is bigger than enjoying a pint in your local and this excellent book sets out to show (over a few pints or their metric equivalent) how human civilization has been molded and built through grains, yeast and water carefully nurtured into a thirst quenching, life preserving beverage. The book is divided into broad chapters dealing with issues such as civilisation, politics, identity, science, culture etcetera, with specific regions, cities, breweries and brewers used to illustrate the argument along the way.
The origins of focussed beer making go back further than most people probably imagine with the first evidence of brewery beer dating back to some 13000 years ago (predating "bread and civilisation itself") easily beating wine and spirits and making its production one of the oldest, and perhaps most respectable professions. Beer, the author notes, is the "...ancient world's safest source of liquid" with the bonus that "...it gets you drunk" giving it an important cultural significance. I had not realised that ancient Egypt was home to a huge brewing industry and home to the oldest industrial brewery (apparently largely buried under sand dunes now) as well as having a healthy beer drenched culture and entertainment sector built on beer.
"So it was housewives and monks who developed beer from Abydo's wild pomegranate wheat ales to what we might start to recognise as beer today."
Exploring the various themes which provide the chapter headings we globe trot to the key places in the history of the development of beer and the places where beer has had an important impact on human civilisation. As well as providing safe liquid to drink, beer has had important spin offs in the medical and human health sector contributing to the work of Pasteur and Lister providing an understanding of the dangers of germs in medicine and surgery. The development of refrigeration also owes much to the brewing industry.
Of course not all of beer's contributions to human society have been positive. The role of the beer hall in the rise to power of humanity's worst mass murderers and creators of industrial genocide is explored in Munich. As the author notes: "Populist politicians have long understood the power of being seen amongst the people, pretending to know and love the things they love. As a symbol of identity, freedom and camaraderie across Bavaria, the Hofbrauhaus was constantly visited by people with ulterior motives. In fact the Nazi Party was born there." And today history seems to be repeating itself, beer glass in hand, in many places.
The history of beer in Germany is fascinating, especially the origins of the German Rheinheitsgebot. Germans have certainly had more success taking the world through beer than bullet, even if many of those successes have become somewhat watered down and tasteless. Interestingly even Czech beer seems to have German knowhow to thank for transforming Pilsen from "the home of rotten beer" to something that remains the envy of the world.
I have a pretty dim view of most of the major beer brands - Becks, Carlsberg, Heineken, Budweiser - however as this book reveals there are interesting stories behind all of them and while they have become faceless tasteless brands they have interesting histories and in some cases have made valuable contributions to science and culture. I don't have much time for organised religion either however certain religious orders have produced some of the most savourable brews available, especially the Trappist orders. The descriptions in this book got me looking at maps and planning pilgrimages and not only to the religious orders but to some of the more out of the way breweries including inn Svalbard, the world's most northerly brewery.
The influence of beer on cuisine is interesting and explored in some detail noting that beer houses have "...had a huge influence on national cuisine. In fact most of them were developed there. It would have been essentially home-cooked inventions, created by whoever was in the kitchen, influenced by what was available to them, and carried away in the minds of travellers". The place of beer and food in the past and present is discussed as is the supplanting relatively recently of expensive wine over cheaper beer as an accompaniment to food. The author defends the trend towards gastro pubs arguing that food and beer were traditionally together. He also says "you'd never have Marmite with your beer" which makes me wonder if he ever came across Camden 'Love Hate Marmite Ale'.
In closing it is noted that brewers yeast was the fifth organism to have its DNA sequenced and the first eukaryotes. There is a long relationship between humans and yeasts as a source of preservation and the production of food and drink, a relationship that continues to develop and not just amongst brewers,
"Yeast is a simple and malleable eukaryote that's able to accept changes to its DNA easier than most, and our close relationship means we understand it better than pretty much any other cell on earth."
Anyone who likes the occasional pint and wonders where it originates could do a lot worse than settling back with a pint of two and this book. It is also a fascinating exploration of the place of beer in human development and as such a great bit of social and scientific history, a book for the disapproving teetotallers you may know who think beer is just about getting tipsy. A thoroughly interesting and inspirational read.
I don't really drink, so the subjective elements of this did nothing for me, but the historical parts were generally interesting. Bit skeptical that it repeats the bacteria thing which is, to my knowledge, not accurate.
The Meaning of Beer is indeed an essential read for anyone interested in the greatest beverage on the planet. It contains many examples on how beer has been important in different ways through history and continue to be so today. The writing is engaging throughout, particularly when it involves Garrett's travels and experiences of beer and brewing, whether it be in Dublin, Copenhagen, Czechia, or Svalbard. These section are some of the clear highlights for me and really give the book something extra compared to other similar popular histories. However, the book doesn't come without its flaws.
One of my major gripes comes from a place of similarly being a beer researcher and historian, summed up in the problems of writing popular history (compared to scientific history). For one, as always in this type of histories - it is sorely lacking in references and proper literature list. Granted, there is a short one towards the end, but it is rarely noted where historical examples and facts are taken from. This is a shame since there are quite a few facts and factoids I want to and will come back to again. My second, more major critique has to do with the overall theme of the book, or lack thereof. All the chapters are well-chosen and interesting, but barely holds together into a coherent story about the meaning and importance of beer. What is it actually been through history? The conclusion that life would have been worse and sadder without beer is an easy one to agree with as a fellow beer-lover, but it leaves me wanting a lot more of analysis and more thorough conclusions. There is also some overlap between chapters, and not all fit their theme - the community chapter is definitely more political than the politics chapter, with more reads as a collection of a few interesting historical facts and anecdotes. I miss some on the political regulation of beer and the several ways this beverage has been targeted by politicians.
Despite these gripes about the popular format and lack of coherence, it is one of the best popular histories of beer, interesting and at times deeply engaging, and one I will keep coming back to many times.
Who are we without beer? Where would we be as a civilization - a species! - without beer. And what is it that makes beer so special in human history and culture?
These are among the questions beer journalist/content creator Jonny Garrett sets out to explore in this exceptional book. Part history, part travelogue, part culinary exploration, part social and cultural exploration, part science book, Garrett's book kinda defies easy definition (just like beer itself, ultimately, defies pigeonholing into just one thing). Garrett makes an excellent case that beer has been one of the most important "inventions/discoveries" in human history - right up there with fire and the wheel. From the importance of brewing to early civilization to the importance of brewing in the scientific revolutions of the 19th and 20th centuries, to the role the beverage has had in identity, politics and even the history of advertising...Garrett leaves no corner unexplored.
It is also somehow very poignant and funny at the same time (I laughed audibly at him saying, towards the end: "I’m not going to lie: there’s a lot more Hitler in this book than I envisaged." But it is important to include him - beer's role in Hitler's rise shouldn't be ignored - nor should the importance of Budvar to Czech culture and identity (and politics!). But the book is about more than that. It battles the beer snobbery that has (at times) infected modern culinary writing/reviews. It tackles the difficult question of why wine took over at restaurants (a relatively recent thing!). But it also strongly argues that beer, throughout human history, has been with us for all our moments - and that a world without it not only can't be imagined...it might not have even been possible!
I found myself desperately wishing I could sit down and share a beer (and this book) with my late dad. One of the very last times I was able to sit with him and just talk, father-son, before the cancer that took his life rapidly destroyed his body was over a few pints at a bar in Woodstock, GA. Some of my favorite memories of him involve the two of us with beer in hand at one bar or brewery or another (I worry that I will break down the next time I'm at Monk's in Philadelphia).
If there was any complaint, and this is so minor, it would be that the craft beer revolution in America is given only a small amount of space (a whole chapter could be written on Sam Adams, Sierra Nevada, Dogfish Head and the other breweries that completely turned American beer culture on its head). But maybe as a Brit, that's a secondary thing...and maybe that's outside the realm of what this book was about. Or maybe it's a story for another book.
All I know is that tonight...I'll be lifting a pint and thinking of both my dad and the author of this exceptional book. 5 stars. Highly recommended.
Thank you to NetGalley and Hanover Square Press for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this. Out November 26th. You can preorder it here.
I listened to this on Audible. I don't recommend you do that as there are just too many Names of Beers and on audio it's not always easy to catch them.
Overall I thought this excellent. He's a relatively rare popular historian who seems to actually do his research over all periods (the book I'm listening to at the moment, Factfullness, gets wrong pretty much anything before 1800). Garrett makes a really persuasive argument for the importance of beer in human civilisation as foodstuff, and basis for everything from bread to our understanding of bacteria (tho I would add in cheese as rather relevant there).
[Small issue: like so many people he assumes the Puritans were anti alcohol, but it's the Puritan Ministers in the American colonies who are distilling the spirits he mentions as being the common drink, and Samuel Adams, one of the founding fathers, was a maltster.)
But there is one thing that really irritated me: Garrett kept insisting that beer was universally important the world over. Not in Muslim countries it's not! One way to divide the world (with a nice overlapping Venn diagram) might be the coffee countries and the beer countries. There are many, many places where coffee serves similar social functions (and at times tea has as well).
The Meaning of Beer starts off strong with a personal anecdote that clearly shows Garrett’s genuine passion for beer (which I loved, cause same). It immediately drew me in. Unfortunately, that energy doesn’t fully carry through the rest of the book. As the chapters go on, the focus becomes increasingly diffuse, and despite my own love for beer, I ultimately did lose interest.
Garrett repeatedly argues that beer plays a foundational role in history, and while that idea is both interesting and largely true, several chapters felt unfocused or didn’t clearly tie back to the book’s broader argument. When the writing becomes overly technical, Garrett often tries to compensate with summaries and takeaways, but these feel more like quick editorial fixes than integrated parts of the structure. Honestly, where was the editor in all of this?
The book seems torn between being academically thorough and broadly accessible, and in trying to do both, it doesn’t fully succeed at either. Overall, it would have benefited from tighter editing, clearer focus, and stronger structural choices.
Está bien, seguramente si lo lees es porque ya vas dispuesto a que te guste. A su favor, no es un recorrido histórico, sino que está dividido en temas: la ciencia, por ejemplo, es el capítulo más interesante.
En su contra, casi todo el libro habla sobre países muy cerveceros y extrapola a todo el mundo. Por ejemplo, habla de campañas publicitarias super exitosas pero que en España nos son desconocidas (aquí me acuerdo de la piensa en verde o la de carls y berg, que el autor no menciona) Uno de los mejores pasajes es cuando habla sobre China, y deja con ganas de que hubiera hablado de otros sitios con menos cultura cervecera (se me ocurre, por no decir solo España, no sé, Italia, Turquía, Marruecos, México, Corea... será por sitios)
También hace una afirmación (que el consumo de poca cerveza es más saludable que el consumo cero) que no respalda con datos y que directamente creo que se ha inventado, o maneja datos de varias décadas de antigüedad.
This was my first book about beer, and it definitely left me wanting more written like this exact one. I received it as a gift from Josca, who really enjoyed reading it herself. And I completely agree with her. The author’s narrative style is engaging and immersive.
What stood out to me most was the historical perspective. Beer is more than just a drink: it’s interwoven with our culture and history (At least very much so according to Jonny Garrett). That makes the book interesting even if you're not a beer geek for it's (sort of funny) biased way of retelling history. The author also does a great job conveying the passion and knowledge of the people he meets.
I’d recommend this book to anyone with a casual interest in beer. It’s an easy, engaging read that stays light without getting too technical, but with some great technical fun facts
What Jonny Garrett has crafted with this book delivers on multiple levels. History lesson, beer handbook and travel guide; all packaged up in the funniest read all year!
Garrett has an almost unnatural talent for soaking up copious amounts of information and then distilling it into thoughtful storytelling. I struggle with in-depth historical non-fiction but this is far from that, far more entertaining and far more insightful. From trips to ancient Egyptian temples through to the farthest reaches of the Arctic.
Crucially it'll speak to almost anyone with even a whiff of interest in beer. So whether you consider yourself a beer geek or you're shopping for Christmas presents for family members who are bound to have the Biere D'Or waiting, this'll be a winner!
I've been struggling to get back into reading for a while, I just couldn't find anything that I really enjoyed. This book solved that - I've been barely able to put it down.
The research that has gone into this book is incredible - and the anecdotes told are more than likely to stir up some conversation on the next pub trip. If you like beer, and want to learn about how it essentially plays a part in pretty much all of modern life, I can't recommend this enough.
An excellent book on how the history of beer and brewing has helped the rise of human civilization. I ordered the book after hearing the author on the (recently now ended) Moon Under Water podcast, and found the episode engaging. The book did not disappoint. From 11,000 BCE up to this year’s (2024h developments of the yeast genome project, it’s a fun ride with the author having traveled the globe to talk to dozens of brewers and getting into the historical aspects.
Such a fun and informative read. Jonny is a knowledgable and affable host who not only tells us about the origins of beer in Egypt, or the most northern brewery in the world, but takes us there too as he travels the world, stopping for a chat and a few beers with the locals along the way. I challenge anyone to read the chapter on Pilsner and not be compelled to immediately run to the fridge. Learned a ton from this book, while thoroughly enjoying the journey.
Chapters are a bit inconsistent in quality but the book is full of interesting anecdotes and stories you can share with your mates on the next pub visit. Jonny really succeeds in telling a story of how beer was a constant companion of humanity and while some of the claims may be a bit of a reach it was fun to read. It's best when he talks about meeting other people that are so committed to this beverage.
Some interesting stories on beer’s influence in various events and developments in history. Need to get use to the authors conversational style which can grate and detract from the story being told. Last few chapters lose their way and focus, becoming a bit of a ramble. Overall interesting with chapters I’ll return to and read again
Great book! The history of beer is very long, but this book puts it into perspective. Good storytelling, and well researched. I'll be sure to check out the authors podcast and YouTube Channel. Highly recommended!
It’s a great book about beer, but also about much more than beer. It’s about civilisation, from its start to now and how a drink has helped and shaped it throughout our shared history. Well worth a read!
Jonny does a great job of weaving humor and history together to make a very fun read. Great tales, very jealous of his travels, especially to Svalbard. Ending chapter was great. Thank god we found yeast.
Starts out with shorter episodes, the later chapters are more in one piece and a bit more serious. The final chapter I almost ignored: it's not bad but I know most of the stuff and don't need to reread it just because yeast is involved somewhere.
I really enjoyed this book. I thought it would be a history of beer but it's more the story of how beer made us, with everything from how beer changed modern medicine to how beer stopped Munich being sacked during the 30 Years War. Highly reccommended.
A fascinating, amazing exposition of the effect that beer and brewing has had on the histofy of the human race from 13,000 years ago and fotging into the future. Is beer the saviour of the human race?
Très intéressant point de vue sur l’évolution de l’humanité. J’ai bien aimé. Très facile a lire également. Un page turner… toutefois c’est pas de la fiction, mais plutôt un doculivre!
Informative and entertaining is hard to do. Jonny Garret does this with ease, an engaging book delving into the history of beer without being hard to read. Throughly enjoyable read even for someone who's has been in the trade for nearly 30 years.