** The Stephen King Goodreads Discussion Group is doing a re-read of his works from the beginning to the end. It’s been a long time since I have really immersed myself in Uncle Stevie’s world, but a rate of a book a month, I am all in. My goal is to read and review each one with as much honesty and reflection that I can give. **
Background – “The Colorado Kid” was originally published in October 2005 as a Hard Case Crime paperback.
Length-wise - my oversized paperback lists it as 186 pages and my Kindle lists it as 133 pages.
Plotline – This is the story of a man found dead on an island off the coast of Maine. There is no identification found on his body and it is clear that he is not a local member of the community. With a strong local police presence, it is left up to two elderly newspapermen who take on the challenge of trying to discover his identity and cause of death. The problem is the more they figure out about the deceased, the more the mystery deepens and the less they truly understand…
Thoughts and Reflections – This whole novella can be summed up by King’s following quote in the Afterword: “I’m not really interested in the solution but in the mystery. Because it was the mystery that kept bringing me back to the story, day after day.” It is a conceptual exploration of what if a mystery cannot be fully explained away? That is a hard challenge to take on and King takes it on in a direct and head-on manner.
What I liked about it was the journey. The sorting through all of the clues and trying to connect them together in a coherent answer, which we as readers are trained to do. We expect things to come together in the end and have an explanation that provides closure to the reading experience. However, King tried to turn it upside down and explore the theme of reality, in which stories don’t always have nicely wrapped up endings. Life is full of mysteries that are never resolved or explained, at least not in our earthly lifetime. There are so many things that we don’t know or understand, and uncertainties that we can be faced without any explanation, and that is just the way that life works. So, as king is trying to point out, you can either enjoy the journey or not.
What I didn’t like was primarily two things.
The first was the frustration of the ending being so open-ended and unresolved. I think that as King aptly pointed out, this will be one of those stories that people will either love or hate, but there won’t be much in-between. I get what he was trying to do, and maybe my reaction was evidence that helped support his goal of creating discussion and debate over the theme of life being open-ended and not all questions will be answered.
The second thing I struggled a bit with was that the entire mystery was told in a story-telling format, which in some ways made the story less interesting for me because it was a third-party retelling of the events rather than experiencing the events directly as a reader (thank you Kandice for strengthening my description!). I don’t know what could have been done better to make the story more compelling, but it felt like we really didn’t know much about the victim on a personal level, so my interest was really just in solving the mystery itself, and therefore I wasn’t really invested in the victim himself. I was lacking that emotional involvement that would have made the reading connection stronger.
Now, not to ruin my review or your reading experience, but there is talk of another interpretation of the mystery that I will mention briefly. Due to comments made by King on his website in 2005, many fans may connect the Colorado Kid story as being part of King’s “Dark Tower” universe. I leave that for to you to decide.
Other Notes – Following the initial publishing, in 2007, PS Publishing published the novel as a hardcover limited edition in four different states illustrated by three different artists (Edward Miller, J.K. Potter, and Glenn Chadbourne). Hard Case Crime also went on to reissue “The Colorado Kid” as an illustrated paperback edition in May 2019.
EQ Entertainment produced a TV series “Haven”, which was loosely based on the novel. The series ran for five seasons on Syfy from July 2010 until December 2015.
Overall – If I had rated this book on the day that I finished reading it, I honestly would have been tempted to give it only 2 out of 5 stars. Then I reflected on my reading experience for two days, spending time really processing what I liked, what I didn’t like, and why, as well as trying to honestly assess what King was attempting to do, and how well I thought he succeeded. Now that the dust is settling, my perspective has come around a bit. I am giving it 3 out of 5 stars, primarily for its thought-provoking outcome and the quality debate it’s spurred in me and others.