In Brief
In this contemporary fiction novel that reads like women’s fiction but with a male lead, one man undergoes a transformative journey, bringing him back home and back to those who love him best. John Fisher is undeniably successful after leaving his small home town for the big city, with a beautiful girlfriend, an expensive condo, a fancy car, and the very real possibility of making partner at an esteemed accounting firm. But his life is turned on its head after being diagnosed and treated for leukemia, leading to a forced vacation that takes him back to his hometown. He reunites with his grandparents and the father he’s always hated, as well as two friends who can and will drop everything to join him on an impromptu trip to find the woman who donated the blood marrow that saved his life, because he believes she’s his soul mate. But there are twists and turns thrown in his path, and revelations that turn his childhood on its head, as well as the real love of his life being there all along. Back to You reads like a women’s fiction novel, but it proves to be a masterful gender switch full of emotional and lighthearted moments that offer the perfect balance. While the pacing is a little off now and then and the introduction to John and his dilemma felt longer than necessary, this is a sweet story full of second chances, adventure, and a return to what’s really important in life.
Extended Thoughts
One of my favorite genres is women’s fiction, with it’s focus on friendships, usually some kind of return to one’s roots, and sometimes a sweet romance. Back to You introduced me to a twist on that, offering me everything I love in women’s fiction, but doing a gender swap. Here, the man is the main character, but, if I pretend he’s a woman, I can see all of my favorite things in the genre, and it does a remarkable job of doing it. Despite an initially truly unlikable main character, I found Back to You to be a delightful read with fun characters, a rather harebrained trip with friends, and a fantastic romance that really put the main character in hot water.
John Fisher’s life changed when he was diagnosed with leukemia. Unfortunately, it was for the worse. Despite being highly successful and ambitious, and on the verge of making partner at the accounting firm he’s spent years at, things take a downturn when his girlfriend leaves him, his boss forces a long vacation on him, and his estranged father might be dying. With nothing else to do, John returns home, the one place he always dreamed of leaving and never dreamed of returning to. But now he also has the chance to reconnect with his grandparents and a couple of old friends, who jump at the chance to help him reach for a pipe dream he’s held: to find the woman who donated the bone marrow that saved his life because he believes she’s his soul mate. All the while, John comes face to face with his past, present, and future, forcing him to re-evaluate everything he believed and where he wants to go next.
This was such a fun twist on women’s fiction, and I liked the feeling of getting a women’s fiction novel from the man’s perspective. It was great to get to see what was going through his head during his big gesture, and fascinating to see the woman who would usually be telling the story react to him from the other side. I’ll admit I really didn’t like John at the beginning. He was callous, selfish, and ambitious in a way where he used people for his own ends more than anything else. He’s also bitter and has created such a strong narrative of his entire life that he comes off as self-righteous, and the reader can only shake their head at his behavior. I found his character really hard to read about for the first third of the book, but, once he reconnected with his family and his past, he slowly started to redeem himself, and I found Back to You to be a joy to read. It was fantastic to see his growth, and just as much fun to see him with his old friends.
While John wasn’t the easiest to come to like, I found the exact opposite to be true of his childhood friends, Daniel and Emma, and Emma’s little girl Mary. I adored seeing John with Mary; it was such a counterpoint to his behavior at the beginning of the novel, and I loved that it softened him, and addressed the awkwardness a man might feel when confronted with a little girl. And Mary was such a delight. I wish she had been a bigger player in the novel, but, when she was on page, she just wrapped my heart around her, just like she did with John. Daniel and Emma were a lot of fun, with Daniel having not really outgrown his adolescent ways and only feeling like he was sparking with maturity now and then, and Emma being the ever responsible one, even when she wasn’t exactly acting in the confines of the law. The three of them were a ton of fun, and I enjoyed their trips together to hunt down John’s anonymous donor. They almost felt like they regressed back to their teen selves, so it was fun when they had to bounce back and become adults with adult problems.
One such problem is a rather odd love triangle they found themselves in. It’s complicated by things like a little girl and John’s weird obsession with a woman he doesn’t even know in any way, shape, or form. But it also kind of felt like it was just dropped in, because it took a while for me to find the hints to it, almost as though a decision hadn’t been made until later on in the writing. There wasn’t a ton of build up to it, so a part of it did catch me off guard. The other part of it, though, since I’ve read this type of novel so many times, was something I fully expected for at least half of the novel, because it took about that long for John to return to his roots and to actually set out on his journey to find this woman. The description made me think the romance would be a bigger part of the novel, but it doesn’t really get started until about halfway through. The love triangle, though, was fascinatingly different. It felt more like a snake chasing its tail around cinder blocks, and never quite reaching it as I never felt the triangle was fully closed, but, rather, dealt with and then the characters moved on. But I kind of liked it, because it was different, and I enjoyed watching them chase after different things at different times.
I was also charmed by John’s family and the revelations he had, which helped to completely refrain his entire life’s narrative. When the reader first meets John, he’s surly, uncompromising, and those around him clearly indicate his leukemia diagnosis and treatment have changed him into something that feels like it more closely resembles a monster. It’s not easy for the reader to get to know him, or even feel sympathetic towards him, and it’s compounded by the recollections he shares about his childhood with a father who seemed to hate him and see him as a disappointment. When he does end up traveling back home, he’s first reunited with his mother’s parents, and I loved how it showed him in a different light. This reunion and John’s own behavior indicate a shift for him, making him likable little by little from there on out. I loved getting to know him after this, and I adored his grandparents, though I wish they had played bigger roles, because they were really lovely. But the main part of his family story line had to do with his father. While I thought this progressed rather quickly, and was resolved far too fast considering all the emotions that went into it, I liked that it offered a perspective shift for John, and it helped make him feel more human and flawed. This turned out to be really sweet, and I enjoyed how it played out.
The road trips John went on with Emma and Daniel were my favorite parts, though going around his hometown with him was a close second. I loved them together, and I really enjoyed how these trips played out, first to get the donor information and then to find the donor. It felt like teenage shenanigans, but I liked how it was all probably a lot more thought out than teens would have planned everything. It was fun to get to know all three of them as a group because their dynamics were delightful and the love triangle found its place couched in there. There’s a twist here that I really liked that’s tied into the road trips and the love triangle and John’s search for his soul mate. I thought the whole thing started a lot later than it should have, but the ending proved me wrong, and I really adored it, even if I felt some of the information at the end was far too contrived. It was a little less believable than the rest of the novel, which was kind of a disappointment, considering everything to that point had been so strong.
Back to You is really a fantastic read, especially for anyone who enjoys reading women’s fiction. I loved this gender twist, and I enjoyed the journey John went on, even if some of it felt paced a little wrong with an extended introduction that meant later events felt like they had to be sped up. Otherwise this was a lot of fun to read and I found myself delighted more than anything else. John really grew on me, and I was disappointed when the story ended.
Thank you to the author for a review copy. All opinions expressed are my own.