I was very excited to find this title in the Radium Age series—the book itself is very well constructed, which is not always the case with obscure reprints! I recently read Claimed! by the same author (Gertrude Barrows Bennett), which I thought was excellent, so I was eager to see more of her writing. Ultimately I did not enjoy Heads of Cerberus as much as I had hoped to, though it did have some really unusual and striking imagery. I’ll also admit that as a resident of Philadelphia, I was particularly interested in what someone writing in 1919 would imagine as a dystopian future for the city. This is where I felt somewhat disappointed; typically this sort of time travel/dystopian future scenario is used to cast light on (or satirize) the author’s present (like Wells in The Time Machine, or many other authors writing since Barrows Bennett). Here, I was left feeling that she wasn’t quite sure what critique she wanted to make, unless it was too specific to the politics of the city at the time (which is distinctly possible). Certainly the sense that Philadelphia could consist of a small number of powerful elites taking what they want at will while the majority of the population is reduced to numbers, feels just as realistic now as it might have in 1919. Maybe it’s just that this sort of narrative has been so common in the second half of the 20th Century that it’s just harder to feel the impact of something that was far less precedented when it was first published.
For me, Barrows Bennett really shines when she leans into “Weirdness”—and the short stories gave her more room to explore this. My favorite story in this collection was Unseen—Unfeared, which deserves to be more widely known. The Elf-Trap and Friend Island were also both top-tier stories for me.