When booksellers Molly O'Donnell and Emma Clarke meet at an estate sale in the posh Sherwood Forest neighborhood of Atlanta, they are both there for the books. But when they venture into a closed-off basement room full of antiquarian occult books and find the dead body of a notorious book thief, they learn that searching for old books may sometimes lead to murder. As they team up to find a killer and a missing manuscript, they discover that their feelings for each other are growing into more than friendship.
3.25 Stars. This was a good but not great cozy mystery. This is a start to a series and I’m hoping it will find its groove more as the books continue. Another reviewer mentioned this, and I have to agree, that this feels like the Sunday night mysteries that the Hallmark Movies and Mysteries channel likes to play. They have a series about a librarian who solves crimes and they even had one with a crime solving antique dealer –but the staring actress got arrested in that college bribery scandal so that series was canceled-. So my point is this cozy mystery, about two booksellers trying to solve a murder, would fit HMM to a T if Hallmark was not afraid of lesbians.
I found that this book had my attention right from the beginning. I picked it up to read just a chapter or two before bed and found myself flying past that prediction. However, as the book went on it had some pacing issues. I felt it got a bit bogged down in the middle. That can happen in mysteries, the beginning crime/murder is exciting, but then the book slows until you reach the climatic ending. I think it felt a little slower here than normal since these were booksellers so they were trying to solve the mystery by reading information and doing research. We as readers are reading along with the characters so it felt a little info dumpy just reading blocks of history. I don’t think the authors can do away with this in the next book, because of who the character are, but if they could do less of it or mix it up a bit to get the pace back up would be better.
While this book stars two lesbians, I would not call this a romance. It is a growing friendship with a light attraction. This is something I hope will improve in future books since I didn’t feel a connection beyond friendship between them. While I’m a big fan of having romance in books I read, I almost didn’t want anything to happen since there wasn’t any connection yet and it was feeling a bit forced to push for one. I could see these women eventually together but that connection needs to be built.
Another area I would like to see explored more is who these main characters are. I think it was almost the 75% mark before we hardly got any background for one of the mains. I know both characters have some grey in their hair but I don’t even know ages or anything. I had trouble even picturing what they looked like in my mind. Since this was the start of the series this was the set-up book and I think the authors forgot to do something as simple as really building up the two main characters. The book is very plot driven which is fine for one book, but if I am going to want to keep reading about these women, I need to learn about them and connect with them in book 2 or I won’t care about a book 3.
If you are a fan of cozy mysteries, especially they kind you might watch on HMM, you might enjoy this book. I was entertained by the read, but there is work here that still needs to be done. I can’t even count the times I have struggled with a first book in a series but loved the rest so I will be reading book 2. But, I’m keeping my fingers crossed for some good changes and improvements from this writing duo.
Had some mixed feelings about this title, but I'm going to try to lean more towards the positives because there were a few "new" things the author brought to the table for the genre. This cozy mystery features two middle aged (or close to it--ages aren't really clear other than mentions of graying hair and lines on the face) LGBT women who are both book sellers. Chapters each begin with a somewhat relevant description of a book, more or less on theme with the chapter. However, since this mystery has an occult/mystical element all of these books pertain to divination, demonology, astrology, etc. The story itself was okay, but pacing was inconsistent. The opening chapters were a sprint to establish characters, the murder, and the reason behind the sleuthing but the remaining 85% of the book felt like a long drag. Much of the middle is an investigation into Black/White magic history with dates and names that I pretty much lost track of early on. It was less sleuthing and more "to the library!" Picture Buffy, if all she did was sit with Giles in the library reading about Vampire history. This book is mainly set-up of the series but I didn't feel like Book 1 gave us all that much to be interested in with the main characters of Molly and Emma. Aside from investigating this murder (and still not entirely sure why or whether it even made sense--but that's the genre!), they were rather dull and their conversations and interactions with each other are a bit strange. For instance, there is quite a bit of anger, possessiveness, and frowning between the two of them for two people who are friends bordering on "more". Again, this book is just setting the stage for this series, so not much in the way of romance happens between these leads, but this is a rare time where I really wish nothing would happen and they'd remain friends. I just don't see the chemistry there for anything more than a book-selling, murder-solving, friendly-ish duo.
I received an ARC copy of this book from the Publisher via Netgalley and voluntarily leaving my review.
Emma and Molly are booksellers when they meet at a sale estate. While there Emma tumble upon a dead body in the basement of the estate and learns the murder victim is notorious book thief Buck Hubbell.
Molly decide to find out what happens after finding a something that doesn’t make sense and teams up with Emma to learn the truth. As they follow clues their friendship starts to become more.
This was a great cozy mystery story that reminds me of the movies on hallmark mystery movies channel and totally see this on that channel if only hallmark was brave enough to do a same sex couples stories.
[Ebook ARC recieved from NetGalley and publisher for review.]
I will always be a sucker for a cozy mystery. Do they feel realistic at all? No! Do I still love them? Yes!
A murder at an estate sale filled with book sellers, enough book talk to make me want to start collecting old books, and a lot of occult mixed in. You dont have to tell me twice to read this book. A fun little story that was just nice to read.
I am a mystery reader fan. I enjoy figuring out whodunit. This is a nice easy read with two likable characters. I was hooked from the beginning as Emma Clarke and Molly O'Donnell were introduced. Their personalities were so different yet complementary. This read takes you on a book lovers quest to find unique books, an unexpected murder, and even more unexpected, magical beliefs/practices.
Emma is easy going and not looking for adventure. Molly is out front and looking for adventure. The push and pull between the two makes for a wonderful dynamic. This is not a romance but there is some I like you and I like you too. So, lets take it slow and see where this goes. The story did drag a little as it moved from Emma and Molly to the whodunit. all the background information about the occult and authors was informative but in my opinion a little too much. I was entertained enough that I plan to read the next book in the series.
I was given an ARC of this book by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Molly’s a seasoned bookseller; Emma’s newer to the Atlanta bookseller scene. When Emma discovers the dead body of a rumored book thief at an estate sale, Emma and Molly’s lives intertwine in more ways than one. Molly insists they must return the ephemera of a mysterious warning note to the book it belongs to, which leads them on a chase to find a highly coveted grimoire. Murder at the Estate Sale is equal parts bibliomystery and blossoming friendship-possibly-romance, rife with intrigue and romantic tension.
This book is for you if you like mysteries, books about books, and the slightest hint of friends to maybe-something-more.
Content warnings: murder, kidnapping, nonconsensual drugging of a character
Can I be honest? I’ve never read a straight-up cozy mystery before. I requested an ARC of Murder at the Estate Sale on a whim because I love books about books and I was in the mood for something new (to me). I have no regrets.
Molly and Emma’s distinct personalities jump off the page from the beginning. Molly is curious, funny, and flirtatious, while Emma seems to be more soft-spoken and cautious. If I had to put them on an alignment chart, Molly would be chaotic good and Emma lawful good—it’s a fun dynamic to explore, especially when you throw in a murder mystery and a library full of occult books to the mix.
I like that we see the characters officially meet in the first chapter and are obviously attracted to one another, but they never break the friendship boundary in the first book of the series. Slow burn is my jam, and it feels realistic for who Molly and Emma are. If you’re going into this expecting a steamy romance, this is not the book for you. However, it’s only the first book in the series, and there’s plenty of palpable romantic tension to hold you over until the next installment (though I'm not sure Molly and Emma would ever be what you call "steamy").
The authors do a splendid job of keeping the reader on their toes. I had guesses as to who may have committed the murder in the first chapter, but I was never certain in my assumptions. When the Big Reveal happened at the end, I was surprised to find that I was wrong. It’s never any fun reading a book where all of the intrigue is predictable, so I appreciated the care taken to lead me away from the truth behind the mystery. (Maybe a more experienced reader of mystery would have a different opinion, though?)
The writing style is simple, but it definitely gets the job done. The level of detail given to the books, the setting, and the characters help to solidify the worldbuilding and add to the atmosphere of the overall novel.
One aspect that I especially liked about Murder at the Estate Sale is that most of the books mentioned are all books that actually exist—as far as I could tell from my googling. I will definitely be looking into the titles further sometime.
Overall… Murder at the Estate Sale is an enjoyable, lightweight mystery, perfect for your next summer read.
When Emma Clarke and Molly O'Donnell meet at a book sale in a posh neighborhood, in Atlanta, they could never imagine that they would discover the dead body of an infamous book thief which would set them on a path of sleuthing and friendship!
The book has a charming classic mystery tone with two vibrant new characters. As the mystery evolves, so does the feeling between the two main characters but before they can build a friendship into something more, they must find out who murdered the book thief before they're the next victims. I liked the personalities of Molly and Emma and they make a perfect duo. A new mystery solving team that will keep you reading!
I received an ARC from Netgalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
Thanks to Elizabeth Silver (Elizabeth Silver's Reviews).
Despite having the word ARC printed largely and diagonally every page, it wasn't a big of a distraction as I thought it would be when I was reading it.
I liked the concept of the book plot but it was way over my head with the Wiccan, the note that was found by the dead person's head, and the combination of putting it all together, the people involved, and the curiosity of two women maybe interested in each other romantically. This was a collaboration of two authors and now I can see why it was all over the place with subjects.
This is the first book in the series, and needless to say, I won't be reading the second one.
So, so bad. The references to the old books at the beginning of each chapter was the only interesting thing. The characters were one dimensional and nothing about either of the main characters compels me to read more. Thank goodness this was a short book or I would have put it down. The authors need to remain bibliophiles, not writers.
Bookseller Molly O’Donnell is hitting up an estate sale to find stock for her business. While in line she meets Emma Clarke, another bookseller, and strikes up a conversation. During the sale she sees Emma coming out of the basement door where Emma has discovered a dead man. While the basement, filled with old occult books, was off limits Emma heard something that made her go downstairs. Finding a note on the floor by the body, Molly sticks it in her bag and they call the police.
Feeling guilty for not giving the note with the police, Molly and Emma agree that they will reunite the note with the book it was in and then turn it over the police. Though as they search they discover that dark practitioners are willing to kill again to get their hands on the book. Both Molly and Emma are kidnapped separately by different seekers and fight to find the truth as well as their attraction to each other.
The first book in a new series, the mystery was well written and tied in well to historical books and practitioners. The budding relationship between Emma and Molly was well written and sweet. I look forward to more from this writing duo!
Those who enjoy cozy mysteries that revolve around books will really enjoy this story. It takes place, as the title indicates, at an estate sale, and the major characters are book collectors and dealers. When another dealer is killed while the others are looking at the books they wish to purchase, the mystery of not only who killed him, but what happened to a valuable mysterious occult manuscript becomes the focus of the two main characters.
Molly O’Donnell and Emma Clarke meet at while standing in line waiting to get into the estate sale, but they become fast friends, and partners in trying to solve the murder. Though only slightly considered suspects, the biggest motivation for their solving the mystery is the missing occult book, which they believe might be the reason he was killed, though the victim was also known to be a book thief, so they know that that could have been a motivation for his killing as well.
I really enjoyed the mystery, but even more so I enjoyed the details in the book collecting, and the details of the occult book market that gave both characters full well rounded motivations. I also enjoyed the fact that the women were older, and had lives before they met that helped to establish their relationship, as well as their drive to find the missing tome.
Like most cozies, this has a mild romance. It is well done, and sweet as you would expect from cozy mysteries, as romance is not the focus of this kind of story, but instead, secondary in the series. I liked how the author moved them slowly, building their friendship, and moving into a stronger relationship. I expect that as the series progresses, that we will find grow even further
As the first in a new series, I am definitely intrigued to read more. I liked the way this author built her clues, and storyline. I felt it was well executed, and had a rewarding reveal. The minor characters, and even the red herrings, were all perfectly placed, and helped the reader to be pulled in.
I highly recommend this book to cozy mystery lovers who wish to begin a new series that is sure to be a winner.
Molly is a bookseller who finds books at places like the estate sale she is currently at. She is lightly flirting with a newcomer to the scene, Emma when Buck, an obnoxious bookseller who is known among the booksellers' group as a thief. When Molly later finds Emma in a cordoned off area standing over Buck who is dead from a blow to the head, she immediately believes Emma's innocence. She sees a piece of paper laying next to the body and instinctively grabs it and puts it in her own pocket. Together, the two start looking into why Buck was killed. I really liked the description of this book. Booksellers? Awesome. Probably a budding relationship? My catnip. Between two females? That seems new. But I have to admit that the author used one of my least favorite plot development devices, amateur detectives that put themselves into danger and that took away a lot of the enjoyment that I expected from this book. Emma and Molly hide evidence from the police, sneak into houses, and keep investigating a murder after they are in danger. I would have enjoyed this book so much more if they had already had some detective experience (i.e. some expertise in sneaking around) or had been more open with the police. And the fact that Molly just inherently trusts Emma because she's attracted to her doesn't make her seem any smarter. I'll probably give the series another try because I really do like the underlying premise and there was some realization of what they were doing at the end but I hope the author makes that carry over to the next book and the two ladies will have a little more common sense.
Murder at the Estate Sale is a pretty effective cozy mystery. We have all the basics:one (or two) busy body person with a job besides a detective, a murder that happens right in front of them, lots of poor decision making, a whodunnit type explanation right at the end. My biggest criticism is that the book starts out too fast paced. Chapter one is the introduction of both main characters( who barely know each other), Chapter two we have a body, Chapter three the main characters talk about breaking back into the crime scene, Chapter four they break into said crime scene. That wouldn't be so bad but this is all before 10%. The book does spend some time afterwards acknowledging how reckless and quick that was. But I think it would have been better to just do it better and let it take a bit longer. The rest of the book does some weird things that others may like but weren't my thing. It has some elements that are maybe speculative but also maybe not. This is a personal preference but I either want things to be speculative or not. I don't want some in-between. However to the positives: this has two main queer women. That's not very common in this genre and they are decent characters. They could use more building but that can come with other books as it often does in series like this. The book also was pretty enjoyable and fun for the most part and at times could be gripping. If you love cozy mysteries and want some queer rep definitely try this out!
An ad for an estate sale in Atlanta brags “tons of books,” so a long line of book dealers show up to sift through potential treasures. Not long after the first 25 bargain hunters enter the house, Emma Clarke asks Molly O’Donnell to follow her down into the basement where bookseller and alleged book thief Buck Hubbell lies dead near the bottom of the stairs.
Molly discovers she inadvertently stuffed a clue – a page from an occult volume - in her pocket when they were examining the body and feels it is significant. Thrown together by the circumstances of the murder, the two women find they have a lot in common – collecting and selling books and wanting to identify Buck’s killer. The two women’s sleuthing takes them back to the basement where they find an extensive collection of books on the occult and witchcraft along with a secret entrance.
Lily Charles, the writing team of Charlene Ball and Libby Ware, devises a compelling mystery, incorporating details about occult books that, at times, slow the pace. That said, the author provides a captivating look at the world of rare books along with well-drawn characters and appropriate red herrings. The developing relationship between Molly and Emma, along with the tagline - Molly & Emma Bookseller Series – promises this is the beginning of a delightful new set of cozy mysteries.
#Murder at the Estate Sale. When Molly O’Donnell and Emma Clarke meet at an estate sale of a local book collector they bond over being female book sellers in a mostly male dominated profession. This bond deepens when Emma finds the body of a notorious book thief in the basement that had been declared off limits to the shopping public. The room is filled with books on the occult, Molly's specialty. This adds to Molly wanting to discover the identity of the murderer.
Over time the ladies become close friends. The mystery is filled with twists and turns. The requisite budding romance is seen thru out the story as is the beloved pets. I enjoyed getting to know the characters. The side plot of the budding romance was refreshing with a slow pace being set by both ladies. The issues faced in the past of these main characters added to its creditability.
I did have an issue with the inclusion of book catalog listings at the beginning of each chapter. I found myself going back rereading these listings trying to figure out the meaning each had to the chapter. It was a distraction for me from the story.
I would recommend the story to others. It was well thought out and the characters were believable.
Murder at the Estate Sale is an entertaining cozy mystery that combines bookselling, murder, a missing manuscript, antiquarian occult books, and an emerging romantic connection between two amateur investigators.
The premise immediately gives the story a distinctive hook. Molly O’Donnell and Emma Clarke arrive at an upscale Atlanta estate sale searching for books, only to discover the body of a notorious book thief in a restricted basement filled with unusual antiquarian occult volumes. What begins as a hunt for books quickly becomes a dangerous search for a murderer and a missing manuscript.
The relationship between Molly and Emma adds another engaging dimension to the mystery. As they work together to uncover the truth, their partnership gradually develops into something more personal, giving the investigation an emotional thread alongside the suspense.
A fun choice for readers who enjoy cozy mysteries with literary settings, amateur sleuths, unusual crimes, romantic tension, and quirky discoveries. The combination of rare books, an estate sale, occult literature, murder, and a developing romance gives the story several appealing elements for mystery readers.
I selected this book for review after skimming the information. I expected a typical cozy: two nosy, middle aged book sellers, insights into the world of book collectors and sellers, the murder of an unpleasant character, the solution of the murder by main characters Molly and Emma. These elements were certainly present but there were unexpected twists and turns: the information and descriptions of an occult/mystical book beginning each chapter, the LGBT elements, the information on CS Lewis (one of my favorite authors), the descriptions of extensive and interesting research on several themes, poor editing around the titles of each chapter, and the occult rites. I agree with other reviewers that the book started out fast introducing characters and themes but slowed way down and dragged in the middle. The finale was well written. It was obvious that this book was written to introduce a series of Molly and Emma books. I will probably read the next one in the series just to see what Molly and Emma get up to in their next adventure.
I received an ARC copy of this book from the Publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
Emma and Molly are booksellers who meet at an estate sale, stumble upon a dead body, and decide to team up to solve a mystery steeped in the occult.
Ok, so here's the thing. This book has all the ingredients of something I should love: queer women, all the books, witchy things, and a murder mystery! However, it all seemed to fall apart in the execution.
The pace of the book felt very slow for the first 85% of the book, which is likely due to the fact that there is So Much exposition. So. Much. The characterization fell flat for me; there wasn't much character development or depth. Most of the time, I had trouble distinguishing between the two main characters because neither really had a distinct voice.
Unfortunately, despite a wonderful premise, this book just didn't work for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Murder at the Estate Sale makes you long for the sequel even before you have finished the first chapter. An intriguing plot; a low key and carefully shaded incipient romance between strong but independent female protagonists; and crisp, well crafted writing make this a book you won’t want to put down. Best of all, it lets the reader who loves books into the world of people who have made them their profession. There are so many insights into the world of rare books, even providing a citation at the beginning of each chapter, and lyrical descriptions of the booklover at work. Some readers found that slow-paced, but I relished it. You will be up into the night with this one, and you’ll be glad you did.
This is a lesbian version of a cozy mystery although it does have a dangerous ending. I am always attracted to books about books and booksellers since I was one. But this mystery seemed too contrived for my taste. Two antiquarian booksellers come across a dead body at an estate sale. They don't know each other but their unspoken attraction for each other draws them into trying to find the book they think the murder victim was going to steal. This search takes them into the world of occult and magic (not the good kind). I'm not sure why but I had trouble keeping the two women separate in my head. I think it was because the book didn't have enough character development. This is part of a new series but I don't think I'll be reading more of Molly and Emma.
This is a cute little love story that also includes a murder mystery and knowledge of older books and manuscripts. As someone who took a class on cataloging manuscripts, the beginning of each chapter was an absolute delight for me. The author wrote about bibliophiles and book collectors (sometimes one and the same) in such a well-researched way that I found myself enjoying a murder mystery, which rarely occurs. Also, the cute relationship between Molly and Emma outside of the main plot had me enjoying their characters and sapphic romance all the more.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Disclaimer: I was given an eARC of this book from Black Opal Books via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I felt that this book had a promising premise but ended up lacking. Everything felt rushed and like it was just following a formula for cozy mysteries. The only thing that made this story stand out is that the main characters are lesbians. With that said, I feel like topics for this book were picked out of a hat than made to fit into a basic template.
I don't feel that this book is either good or bad. If you want an easy read, than try this book but don't expect anything spectacular.
This is the first in a new series featuring Emma and Molly, as they solve the death of a fellow antiquarian bookseller. It's a place of finding rare old books, book fairs and the collaborations and rivalries of the sellers. This cozy mystery has a lesbian love story underlying it, but it never veers into preachy territory. The novel is light-hearted, even as Molly and Emma find themselves digging into matters of the occult.
This debut bibliomystery, the first in a series, introduces Molly and Emma, booksellers, who find the body of a notorious book while they are searching for books at an estate sale. Their budding romance grows as they investigate the murder and also search for a missing 400-year-old book of magic. The narrative moves along at a brisk pace, the characters are quirky and engaging, and the setting--the world of bookselling and collecting--will intrigue readers who love old books.
When booksellers Molly O’Donnell and Emma Clarke meet at an estate sale in the Sherwood Forest section of Atlanta, they are both there for the books. When they venture into a closed-off room full of antique books, they find the dead body of a notorious book thief.
I did not enjoy this book. More emphasis was on old books ans their titles than on the murder.
Thank you Net Galley for providing me with an advanced reader’s copy for review.
This was a fun cozy with a few faults. Character development was ok and progressed throughout the book. But, as many other reviewers mentioned, they never really say how old either Molly or Emma are just mentioning grey hairs and a few lines. Molly does seem unnaturally eager to solve the case , her mania for ephemera aside, there seems no reason for her to delve into things However, it was an enjoyable story for the most part and I’m looking into the second book now
Murder mystery with lesbian sleuths! I thought the 1st half of the book was pretty weak, but it got better, and the thriller section kept pulling me back to read the book at inconvenient times during the day. Sexual tension between 2 women as they meet and become friends (but not ready to get into a relationship), plus books, plus a mystery= :) 3.5 stars
This is an entertaining little mystery novel, perfect for people who like an academic flavor to their plots. The two book-collectors, Molly and Emma, meet at an estate sale. They discover a murdered man lying in the basement, surrounded by rare occult books. The answer to the mystery lies in these books, in a secret passageway, and in an old tradition of shadowy magic.