My rating for The Heir's Fortune, by Ellie St. Clair: 3 stars
This is an OK historical romance, but it is very unrealistic. I didn't really mind, though, because it was an entertaining read. Most of the characters were likable, and there were a lot of interesting scenes. The reader does need to be prepared for how unrealistic it is, though -- because their behavior doesn't really fit the Regency period, and the way they go about solving the mystery is not very believable.
I liked Gideon, but wanted him to loosen up a little. He was just so fixated on restoring his family fortune that he didn't allow himself to ever really live. Even with the treasure hunt, he wanted to find the treasure so badly that he didn't really have fun hunting with his friends. I also thought he changed his opinion of Madeline a little too quickly to be believable. He had always thought she was kind of plain, and way too unconventional and outspoken for him -- but then he was suddenly in love with her? I didn't believe it.
I liked Madeline, too, but also thought her opinion of Gideon changed a little to quickly. He had always kind of ignored her, and she blamed him for what happened to her friend -- but all of a sudden, she was in love? I just didn't buy it.
The mystery is finally solved in this book. I suspected it would be resolved in the last book of the series, and it was.
My rating system is below.
1 star -- Hated it, or did not finish. I usually only give this rating if some of the content is truly objectionable to me, like if one of the main characters does something really awful, and gets away with it.
2 stars -- Didn't like it. This rating usually means that I thought the writing wasn't very good, the editing was terrible, I didn't like the characters, or it had other major flaws.
3 stars -- I liked it, but had some minor issues with it. This rating means that there were minor editing issues, the story needed more character development, it was just too unrealistic, or had some other fairly minor issue. The majority of books I read get this rating – I do not consider it a bad rating.
4 stars -- I liked it a lot. This is a high rating for me, and I rarely give a higher one.
5 stars -- I loved it, and will probably read it again. Very few books are good enough to get this rating from me. The ones that do are usually classics.