What do you think?
Rate this book
The Agapéd Bearer #2
Paragon Games
Ever since Lisa Robbie became the Agapéd Bearer last year, she has dreamed of becoming a Hero—a mighty Mage who uses her magic to save the galaxies and slay Darkness. But after she returns to Boolavogue to continue her training with Gaius and the Hunters, she begins to doubt if she is even worthy of such a grand title after a real Hero visits the Kingdom. After all, Heroes are always confident, rippled with muscles, and gallant with smiles even in the face of fear. They especially don’t have nightmares on a weekly basis or fear talking with their own peers… right?
I couldn’t even defeat Darkness without Gaius’ help, so how could I ever save a life, a town, or even a country all on my own? I can’t even win a spar against the brawny Keeper of Stars!
As the yearly Paragon Games returns, grabbing the attention of every magical heart on Planet Kalm, something else is stirring underneath the pageantry of the magical sport. These gladiator games are meant for fun, but as Lisa becomes more invested in the battles and players, she lets curiosity take control of her actions and begins to unravel secrets that risk more than her life.
A new fire burns inside Lisa, and now, it doesn’t matter if she is good enough to become a Hero. She has to be, or the Agapéd Magic will be lost forever.
I couldn’t even defeat Darkness without Gaius’ help, so how could I ever save a life, a town, or even a country all on my own? I can’t even win a spar against the brawny Keeper of Stars!
As the yearly Paragon Games returns, grabbing the attention of every magical heart on Planet Kalm, something else is stirring underneath the pageantry of the magical sport. These gladiator games are meant for fun, but as Lisa becomes more invested in the battles and players, she lets curiosity take control of her actions and begins to unravel secrets that risk more than her life.
A new fire burns inside Lisa, and now, it doesn’t matter if she is good enough to become a Hero. She has to be, or the Agapéd Magic will be lost forever.
736 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 11, 2024
38 people are currently reading
1129 people want to read
About the author
Hannah Taylor Lindsey
4 books285 followersHannah Lindsey is the author of the Agapéd Bearer Saga, a YA coming-of-age fantasy with a wonderful mentor/mentee, the chosen one, and found family trope. And of course, tons of magic.
Hannah also illustrates her story and characters, showcasing her artwork on Instagram (@hmnnah.art) and on her website hmnnahart.com.
She lives with her husband in the Great Smoky Mountains of East Tennessee.
WISHING STARS (book 1) and PARAGON GAMES (book 2) is out now!
Hannah also illustrates her story and characters, showcasing her artwork on Instagram (@hmnnah.art) and on her website hmnnahart.com.
She lives with her husband in the Great Smoky Mountains of East Tennessee.
WISHING STARS (book 1) and PARAGON GAMES (book 2) is out now!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews
September 30, 2024
I loved the first book so much, and somehow, this one was even better! The stakes just keep getting higher and all the characters and world building are some of my favorites. Truly, Lisa, Cal, and Gaius have my heart 🥲
Can’t wait for book 3!
Content:
Some sparring battles which turn intense (expect some blood and whatnot)
Can’t wait for book 3!
Content:
Some sparring battles which turn intense (expect some blood and whatnot)
December 20, 2023
After reading the first Agaped Bearer book, I was very excited to jump into the sequel and I was not disappointed! The Paragon Games dives right into where we left off after the Wishing Star with Lisa back on Earth and impatiently waiting to return to the world of magic. In this book, we are able to watch Lisa grow more confident in herself and her magic skills while also navigating the everyday life of starting high school. I loved getting to dive deeper into the word building that Lindsey has created and being able to see the illustrations come together with the story through her Instagram! It was so much fun to meet some new characters, explore so new worlds, and strengthen my love for all the old characters like Gaius, Cal, The Hunters, and Lisa’s mom. Once again I am impatiently awaiting (*much like Lisa awaiting magic training😉) the third installment in this coming of age, fantasy world and will continue to obsess over the little hints posted throughout Lindsey’s Instagram through her art until I am able to get my hands on the next one! I so enjoyed being able to be an ARC reader and hope everyone enjoys reading The Paragon Games as much as I did❤️
December 23, 2023
AAAAHHH i LOVE these books! they are so wholesome and wonderful and keep me reading for houurrrrs.
the way hannah writes these characters makes them
actually feel like real people. it really puts you right there with the characters.
this book delves deep into the world building/cultures of these awesome planets and it’s so friggin cool to learn more about all these little details that contribute to the larger story.
if you’re wanting a super awesome wintery read with hunger games style magic battles, an adorable lil romance and a wholesome mentor/student relationship then this book will GIVE IT TO YOU!!
❄️🔥💜💚💙
the way hannah writes these characters makes them
actually feel like real people. it really puts you right there with the characters.
this book delves deep into the world building/cultures of these awesome planets and it’s so friggin cool to learn more about all these little details that contribute to the larger story.
if you’re wanting a super awesome wintery read with hunger games style magic battles, an adorable lil romance and a wholesome mentor/student relationship then this book will GIVE IT TO YOU!!
❄️🔥💜💚💙
February 5, 2024
I can't get enough of these books and this magical world💞 And book 2 was so epic! Gave me Percy Jackson vibes throughout and the ending was so satisfying, especially when Gaius stepped in 🤜🏽🤛🏼. I loved every second of this book. I read the entire thing in about a week or less
What I loved about this most was that if you haven't read the first book, you could read this one! Though, you'd miss the best LisaxGaius moments from Wishing Stars and some magical world-building foundation.
If you aren't sure about reading this long book, this is your sign! There's action, in-depth friendship, tons of magic, Lisa becoming a great hero, hinting of future romance between Lisa and the Prince (though... If Ayker was younger, I'd root for him), and I just love the found family aspect.
So excited for book 3 whenever it will be released!
What I loved about this most was that if you haven't read the first book, you could read this one! Though, you'd miss the best LisaxGaius moments from Wishing Stars and some magical world-building foundation.
If you aren't sure about reading this long book, this is your sign! There's action, in-depth friendship, tons of magic, Lisa becoming a great hero, hinting of future romance between Lisa and the Prince (though... If Ayker was younger, I'd root for him), and I just love the found family aspect.
So excited for book 3 whenever it will be released!
January 12, 2024
Well as this is the first book I have ever been an ARC reader for…it was so amazing and did not disappoint!! I’ll keep this review spoiler free but WOW!!! The vibes of different scenes were akin to Percy Jackson and Keeper of the Lost Cities—kept me on the edge of my seat for sure! And all the relationships were so wholesome and just AAAAH!!! So so so amazing!!!
Awesome job to you, Hannah!!
And to the readers who are waiting on with bated breath for this book to hit the shelves, I hope you enjoy it too!!
Awesome job to you, Hannah!!
And to the readers who are waiting on with bated breath for this book to hit the shelves, I hope you enjoy it too!!
December 18, 2023
A fantastic wintery read! Characters are so relatable and the world building is so wonderful that it makes magic seem possible!
November 29, 2024
After finishing Wishing Stars earlier this year, I looked forward to where Lisa’s journey will take her in the second year of having magic. And I was amazed by the grand plot and adventures that awaited her and the growth that she goes through as she’s starting high school and dealing with more dark magical threats.
It’s been three months since the end of Wishing Stars and Lisa is anxious to resume magical training and start her first year of high school. However, as she continues her adventures, she finds herself a contestant in the Paragon Games for the beings with the most magical potential to fight it out in the ring. I was quite impressed in how the plot came together, though it does have a jigsaw puzzle feel to it in the first half, but it made the last parts all that more exciting. Everything is important and not just some throwaway side adventure. It’s well paced as well, as we’re not in one thing for too long. Once again, this book is beefy, but slightly shorter than the first book, but still kept me interested. We get to learn more of the world and love returning to old places and seeing new areas and more magic and history being explained, especially the northern area that Lisa visits early in the book. The characters were fun as well, starting with Lisa. There’s an air of maturity around her for this installment, as she has to confront with aspects of growing up more in this installment. The rest of the characters were interesting, especially Gaius being her father figure, and her budding romance with Cal. One part I really liked was the Christmas segment of the story around the halfway point. The action scenes were well done and kept me engaged, even if most of them were in an arena. The prose has improved and I loved the narration by Emily Turtle and Sebastian Brown once again, both pleasant to the ears. I’m really excited for what’s next for Lisa in the saga!
*I received a review copy from the author. All opinions are my own.*
It’s been three months since the end of Wishing Stars and Lisa is anxious to resume magical training and start her first year of high school. However, as she continues her adventures, she finds herself a contestant in the Paragon Games for the beings with the most magical potential to fight it out in the ring. I was quite impressed in how the plot came together, though it does have a jigsaw puzzle feel to it in the first half, but it made the last parts all that more exciting. Everything is important and not just some throwaway side adventure. It’s well paced as well, as we’re not in one thing for too long. Once again, this book is beefy, but slightly shorter than the first book, but still kept me interested. We get to learn more of the world and love returning to old places and seeing new areas and more magic and history being explained, especially the northern area that Lisa visits early in the book. The characters were fun as well, starting with Lisa. There’s an air of maturity around her for this installment, as she has to confront with aspects of growing up more in this installment. The rest of the characters were interesting, especially Gaius being her father figure, and her budding romance with Cal. One part I really liked was the Christmas segment of the story around the halfway point. The action scenes were well done and kept me engaged, even if most of them were in an arena. The prose has improved and I loved the narration by Emily Turtle and Sebastian Brown once again, both pleasant to the ears. I’m really excited for what’s next for Lisa in the saga!
*I received a review copy from the author. All opinions are my own.*
February 5, 2024
You are a part of my life now because I want you to be. Never have you been a burden, Lisa, and I never want you to think that. Not for a second.
I loved this book, maybe more than the first one. It's too hard to pick! But MAN this had me jumping off the bed and shouting in my room especially when the villain reveals their secrets—OOO—I hate them (and I love that). Lisa is growning into probably my favorite main character of all time. I love her and want her to stop getting hurt (cough cough Hannah Lindsey cough cough)
Lisa is a year older, and in this book, she struggles with finding where she belongs. Lindsey wrote this so well. I have never related to a character more in my life. She thinks people only like her for her magic, and at school, her friends suck. And when she told her mom she just wants friends like in the movies I CRIED. MY POOR BABY!
The action!!!! Lindsey can WRITE action scenes so well. It isn't just a punch here and a kick there. She incorporates emotions and pain and Lisa's inner thoughts. I loved the second match in the Paragon Games
Realistic female hero standards. Kids should not win against adults if physical strength is involved. For Lisa, that is still the case. She even states multiple times "I couldn't win if I didn't have magic" and when her magic fails, she is just a kid. I love that. I don't like when a character has no weaknesses.
GAIUS GAIUS GAIUS!! He is becoming the over-protective dad and I love it. When he and when the whole thing with Zephan happens in his office, oh I loved that. Love the gritty brute side of the man.
Lindsey has hinted that book 3 will involve the romance between Lisa and the Prince (Lisa will probably be 16 years old if I'm guessing) and Lindsey stated this was her favorite book. I am excited!!!!!!!
March 12, 2024
In this installment of The Agapéd Bearer, Lisa is excited to return to her magic training anxiously awaiting being called back. She’s not long back into her training when exciting things start happening. She’s offered the gift of a lifetime, joined a Hunters Guild with Cal, sent on a journey to form a guild alliance with a little known reclusive group from the north. Things start taking a turn from there.
Her limits are tested. Her heart is tested. Will she be able to overcome fear, expectations, adult bullies, others’ doubts of her?
Read to find out! I promise you won’t be disappointed. This book not only lived up to the first, but was even better! I think this will be a series that just gets better with each book!
I can’t describe how much I love this series. Perfect for adults and kids alike! Get your tissues, stress squeeze toys, and comfy reading nook ready for this read! You’ll laugh, cry, and clutch your squeeze toy in anxiety of what’s to come! (Don’t say I didn’t warn you!)
The plot, the characters, the settings. It is all beautifully and expertly written. The characters are so real and make you feel like you are right there with them.
I need more of these books ASAP❤️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Her limits are tested. Her heart is tested. Will she be able to overcome fear, expectations, adult bullies, others’ doubts of her?
Read to find out! I promise you won’t be disappointed. This book not only lived up to the first, but was even better! I think this will be a series that just gets better with each book!
I can’t describe how much I love this series. Perfect for adults and kids alike! Get your tissues, stress squeeze toys, and comfy reading nook ready for this read! You’ll laugh, cry, and clutch your squeeze toy in anxiety of what’s to come! (Don’t say I didn’t warn you!)
The plot, the characters, the settings. It is all beautifully and expertly written. The characters are so real and make you feel like you are right there with them.
I need more of these books ASAP❤️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
September 18, 2024
4.5 ⭐
The perfect balance between a cosy and an epic coming-of-age fantasy and it made me feel so many emotions.
Everything got even better than the first book.
I feel like this is going to be one of my favourite series and I can't wait for book three!
The perfect balance between a cosy and an epic coming-of-age fantasy and it made me feel so many emotions.
Everything got even better than the first book.
I feel like this is going to be one of my favourite series and I can't wait for book three!
June 19, 2025
I can confidently say after the second book I am obsessed with this series. Fantasy that feels like Avatar: The Last Airbender and Percy Jackson. I love Lisa and she feels so relatable! It’s refreshing to have a main character who we see stepping into their confidence.
August 23, 2024
Loved it amazing fantasy can’t wait for the third to come out recommend filled with tournament style games and mystery and adventure
April 23, 2024
Really beautiful and well written. I love Lisa and Gaius, Hannah has a unique pen to describe characters and their personalities. Loved all of them
March 23, 2024
" So, if you believe you cannot win, den you nevah will. If you believe you can, den you can. Yo's greatest enemy will always be yourself, and it be a hard one to say 'bug off' " - Kamari
I was in love with this story since book 1, with few and almost no filler bits TAB: PG keeps her teenage essence and, although I was very frustrated with Lisa at times and her immense desire of "not being a bother" I realized that this is how all teenagers are (as adults we are the same), again what prevails in the story is how Lisa grows, in power, age and responsibility, along the story and proves that the Agapéd wasn't wrong in choosing her.
Let's be as brave as Lisa, as wise as Kamari, as loyal as Caelum Sonon and as protective as Gaius.
-----
Quedé enamorada de esta historia desde el libro 1, con pocos y casi nulos fragmentos de relleno TAB: PG mantiene su esencia de adolescente y, aunque me frustraba mucho Lisa en ocasiones y su inmenso deseo de "no ser una molestia" me di cuenta que así somos todos los adolescentes (de adultos somos igual), nuevamente lo que prevalece en la historia es como Lisa va creciendo, en poder, edad y responsabilidad, a lo largo de la historia y demuestra que el Agapéd no se equivocó en elegirla
Seamos tan valientes como Lisa, tan sabios como Kamari, tan leales como Caelum Sonon y tan protectores como Gaius
I was in love with this story since book 1, with few and almost no filler bits TAB: PG keeps her teenage essence and, although I was very frustrated with Lisa at times and her immense desire of "not being a bother" I realized that this is how all teenagers are (as adults we are the same), again what prevails in the story is how Lisa grows, in power, age and responsibility, along the story and proves that the Agapéd wasn't wrong in choosing her.
Let's be as brave as Lisa, as wise as Kamari, as loyal as Caelum Sonon and as protective as Gaius.
-----
Quedé enamorada de esta historia desde el libro 1, con pocos y casi nulos fragmentos de relleno TAB: PG mantiene su esencia de adolescente y, aunque me frustraba mucho Lisa en ocasiones y su inmenso deseo de "no ser una molestia" me di cuenta que así somos todos los adolescentes (de adultos somos igual), nuevamente lo que prevalece en la historia es como Lisa va creciendo, en poder, edad y responsabilidad, a lo largo de la historia y demuestra que el Agapéd no se equivocó en elegirla
Seamos tan valientes como Lisa, tan sabios como Kamari, tan leales como Caelum Sonon y tan protectores como Gaius
June 25, 2024
Okay the writing was a notch better than book 1, but I feel similarly about it.
Unfortunately the big bad was too too predictable and his final fight was a bit of a let down. Actually the fight with Rongo I felt was far more interesting. I feel like there was a desperation in that fight that was lacking in the final battle.
I REALLY felt growth in the characters between book 1 and 2 and I felt like the middle school to high school transition was flawless. The anxiety. The not knowing which friends to pick. The isolation. The cute boys. All very real feelings that bring Lisa so much life.
Lisa still makes questionable decisions, as expected from a 14-15 year old, but what REALLY stumps me is how she feels SO guilty about Giaus becoming mortal to save her life, yet she’s so careless with it by ignoring a life threatening curse.
Overall, a super fun read—the third longest book I’ve ever read and I knocked it out in like 4 days. I’m here for the coming of age magical adventure and that does not disappoint. My expectations for growth in writing are higher for book 3 and I’m looking forward to reading it.
Unfortunately the big bad was too too predictable and his final fight was a bit of a let down. Actually the fight with Rongo I felt was far more interesting. I feel like there was a desperation in that fight that was lacking in the final battle.
I REALLY felt growth in the characters between book 1 and 2 and I felt like the middle school to high school transition was flawless. The anxiety. The not knowing which friends to pick. The isolation. The cute boys. All very real feelings that bring Lisa so much life.
Lisa still makes questionable decisions, as expected from a 14-15 year old, but what REALLY stumps me is how she feels SO guilty about Giaus becoming mortal to save her life, yet she’s so careless with it by ignoring a life threatening curse.
Overall, a super fun read—the third longest book I’ve ever read and I knocked it out in like 4 days. I’m here for the coming of age magical adventure and that does not disappoint. My expectations for growth in writing are higher for book 3 and I’m looking forward to reading it.
March 24, 2024
This is a slice of life coming of age fantasy story that straddles the line between cosy and epic fantasy.
The teenage angst was strong in this book!
We continue to follow Lisa on her journey to become a hero, and it's not easy juggling a new beginning at high school with the pressure that comes with being the Agapéd Bearer.
Lisa's a smart, headstrong girl, and her biggest enemy is she herself. She doesn't want to be a source of worry to the people around her, which leads to her keeping secrets from the adults in her life. I was happy to see Caelum and her working together and that she wasn't going through everything alone. I thoroughly enjoy watching Lisa grow up. It's like she's one of my younger cousins, and I'm really excited to be on this journey with her.
The teenage angst was strong in this book!
We continue to follow Lisa on her journey to become a hero, and it's not easy juggling a new beginning at high school with the pressure that comes with being the Agapéd Bearer.
Lisa's a smart, headstrong girl, and her biggest enemy is she herself. She doesn't want to be a source of worry to the people around her, which leads to her keeping secrets from the adults in her life. I was happy to see Caelum and her working together and that she wasn't going through everything alone. I thoroughly enjoy watching Lisa grow up. It's like she's one of my younger cousins, and I'm really excited to be on this journey with her.
July 26, 2025
After finishing Wishing Stars, I had the luxury of diving straight into The Paragon Games without having to endure the agonizing wait between releases, which I now recognize as significant, because returning to Hannah Lindsey’s world feels much like slipping back into a dreamscape you never wanted to wake from.
Right from the start, The Paragon Games eases readers gently back into the world of the Agapéd Bearer. For those who’ve taken a break between books, the re-entry is thoughtful and deliberate: characters are reintroduced with just enough warmth and clarity to reestablish connection without ever feeling repetitive, and the world breathes with familiar wonder. Lindsey has a rare gift for atmosphere. Her settings are not just backdrops — they are experiences. From the frostbitten magic of Nuolja to the quiet internality of character moments, you can feel the places Lisa walks through. The texture, the color, even the scent of these spaces... Lindsey brings it all to life with remarkable grace.
At its heart, The Paragon Games follows Lisa as she enters a magical tournament designed not only to test her growing abilities, but to draw her deeper into the reality of her role as an Agapéd Bearer. The stakes are personal and political, and the book navigates this balance with emotional maturity. It’s not just about power. It’s about visibility, secrecy, and how much of herself Lisa is willing (or forced) to reveal to a world that isn’t quite ready for her. The way her identity slowly unfurls over the course of the story is both moving and impactful.
The introduction of new characters is one of the book’s great strengths. Ayker and his loyal Widmoos are standouts. Charming, original, and instantly lovable. Their dynamic injects both heart and levity into the story. I found Ayker’s arc to be one of the most emotionally compelling in the book, and I suspect he’ll become a fan favorite (if he isn’t already).
Another element that really worked for me was the slow-burning romance between Lisa and Prince Cal. Knowing in advance from Instagram teasers that something might eventually develop between them made it especially rewarding to see those early emotional seeds take root. The relationship is handled with subtlety and care; there’s no rush to get to a “moment,” no heavy-handed tropes. Just a quiet, growing intimacy between two people who see and respect one another. Their bond feels earned, and I genuinely look forward to seeing how this connection evolves.
Now, for the critique: Many of the stylistic issues that held Wishing Stars back are still present here. Lindsey’s prose remains lush, but at times, the level of descriptive detail crosses a line. Beautiful imagery and emotional insight are certainly welcome in a character-driven fantasy, but when nearly every line of dialogue is followed by a paragraph of internal reaction, narrative interpretation, or repeated emotional clarification, the pacing suffers. Momentum is lost in moments where urgency should build. The story pauses too frequently to explain what readers have already been shown and in doing so, it undercuts its own dramatic rhythm.
It’s a bit like watching a film where the pause button is constantly being hit, followed by a voiceover explaining what just happened in case you missed it. And while this approach might stem from a genuine desire to be thorough or emotionally precise, it also suggests a lack of trust in the reader. Characters like Gaius, Odette Cal, or Lisa herself are by now well-established. We know what they look like, we understand their motivations, yet their appearances and thoughts are reiterated in minute detail far more often than necessary.
One specific example that stood out to me was the repeated use of the word 'perfect' or 'perfectly' to describe everything from places to gestures to people. It’s a lovely word in moderation, but here, it began to feel overused, even ornamental. Especially in emotionally charged scenes, such repetition can unintentionally flatten the impact of the moment by removing nuance.
The structure of the book also warrants some critique. For a novel titled 'The Paragon Games', it was surprising to find that the actual games don’t begin until well into the second half of the book. The first half, while rich in worldbuilding and character development, feels somewhat stretched. There’s a sense that the story meanders before it finds its core momentum. I truly believe much of this could have been streamlined, particularly by trimming down some of the over-description and leaning more confidently into subtext.
That being said, Lindsey’s strengths remain compelling: her emotional intelligence, her talent for evoking mood, and her deep empathy for her characters shine throughout. There is genuine growth here — not just in Lisa, but in many members of the cast. The development is subtle yet meaningful, and Lindsay’s understanding of grief, love, fear, and longing gives the novel its heart. For all its excesses, this is a book that feels deeply and that feeling is contagious.
The Paragon Games is an ambitious, emotionally rich continuation of Lisa’s journey. While it carries forward some of the stylistic excesses of its predecessor, it also expands the world and deepens the narrative in rewarding ways. It’s a story full of sincerity, imagination, and heart, and I can’t help but admire Lindsey’s willingness to tell it exactly the way she wants to, even if that means indulging in a bit too much description now and then.
I remain genuinely invested in this series, and I look forward to wherever Lisa’s path leads next.
Right from the start, The Paragon Games eases readers gently back into the world of the Agapéd Bearer. For those who’ve taken a break between books, the re-entry is thoughtful and deliberate: characters are reintroduced with just enough warmth and clarity to reestablish connection without ever feeling repetitive, and the world breathes with familiar wonder. Lindsey has a rare gift for atmosphere. Her settings are not just backdrops — they are experiences. From the frostbitten magic of Nuolja to the quiet internality of character moments, you can feel the places Lisa walks through. The texture, the color, even the scent of these spaces... Lindsey brings it all to life with remarkable grace.
At its heart, The Paragon Games follows Lisa as she enters a magical tournament designed not only to test her growing abilities, but to draw her deeper into the reality of her role as an Agapéd Bearer. The stakes are personal and political, and the book navigates this balance with emotional maturity. It’s not just about power. It’s about visibility, secrecy, and how much of herself Lisa is willing (or forced) to reveal to a world that isn’t quite ready for her. The way her identity slowly unfurls over the course of the story is both moving and impactful.
The introduction of new characters is one of the book’s great strengths. Ayker and his loyal Widmoos are standouts. Charming, original, and instantly lovable. Their dynamic injects both heart and levity into the story. I found Ayker’s arc to be one of the most emotionally compelling in the book, and I suspect he’ll become a fan favorite (if he isn’t already).
Another element that really worked for me was the slow-burning romance between Lisa and Prince Cal. Knowing in advance from Instagram teasers that something might eventually develop between them made it especially rewarding to see those early emotional seeds take root. The relationship is handled with subtlety and care; there’s no rush to get to a “moment,” no heavy-handed tropes. Just a quiet, growing intimacy between two people who see and respect one another. Their bond feels earned, and I genuinely look forward to seeing how this connection evolves.
Now, for the critique: Many of the stylistic issues that held Wishing Stars back are still present here. Lindsey’s prose remains lush, but at times, the level of descriptive detail crosses a line. Beautiful imagery and emotional insight are certainly welcome in a character-driven fantasy, but when nearly every line of dialogue is followed by a paragraph of internal reaction, narrative interpretation, or repeated emotional clarification, the pacing suffers. Momentum is lost in moments where urgency should build. The story pauses too frequently to explain what readers have already been shown and in doing so, it undercuts its own dramatic rhythm.
It’s a bit like watching a film where the pause button is constantly being hit, followed by a voiceover explaining what just happened in case you missed it. And while this approach might stem from a genuine desire to be thorough or emotionally precise, it also suggests a lack of trust in the reader. Characters like Gaius, Odette Cal, or Lisa herself are by now well-established. We know what they look like, we understand their motivations, yet their appearances and thoughts are reiterated in minute detail far more often than necessary.
One specific example that stood out to me was the repeated use of the word 'perfect' or 'perfectly' to describe everything from places to gestures to people. It’s a lovely word in moderation, but here, it began to feel overused, even ornamental. Especially in emotionally charged scenes, such repetition can unintentionally flatten the impact of the moment by removing nuance.
The structure of the book also warrants some critique. For a novel titled 'The Paragon Games', it was surprising to find that the actual games don’t begin until well into the second half of the book. The first half, while rich in worldbuilding and character development, feels somewhat stretched. There’s a sense that the story meanders before it finds its core momentum. I truly believe much of this could have been streamlined, particularly by trimming down some of the over-description and leaning more confidently into subtext.
That being said, Lindsey’s strengths remain compelling: her emotional intelligence, her talent for evoking mood, and her deep empathy for her characters shine throughout. There is genuine growth here — not just in Lisa, but in many members of the cast. The development is subtle yet meaningful, and Lindsay’s understanding of grief, love, fear, and longing gives the novel its heart. For all its excesses, this is a book that feels deeply and that feeling is contagious.
The Paragon Games is an ambitious, emotionally rich continuation of Lisa’s journey. While it carries forward some of the stylistic excesses of its predecessor, it also expands the world and deepens the narrative in rewarding ways. It’s a story full of sincerity, imagination, and heart, and I can’t help but admire Lindsey’s willingness to tell it exactly the way she wants to, even if that means indulging in a bit too much description now and then.
I remain genuinely invested in this series, and I look forward to wherever Lisa’s path leads next.
March 13, 2024
I did not expect this when I heard book 2 was out
I had high hopes, but somehow The Paragon Games exceeded them!
This book, in my opinion, perfectly balances flashy and interesting without becoming overbearing and gaudy
I did wish we could have more of Valhalla, and the subjects in some sentences were like x in maths: gone 😅
I am officially obsessed; I can’t wait to see more of Lisa’s (and Tuff’s!) adventures!!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I had high hopes, but somehow The Paragon Games exceeded them!
This book, in my opinion, perfectly balances flashy and interesting without becoming overbearing and gaudy
I did wish we could have more of Valhalla, and the subjects in some sentences were like x in maths: gone 😅
I am officially obsessed; I can’t wait to see more of Lisa’s (and Tuff’s!) adventures!!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
July 23, 2025
This was so much better than the first one. Better writing, better pacing, (still a little too long though) and more action. The characters feel so real. I def will be reading the next books.
February 11, 2025
This is officially my second 5 star read of the year (I’m not joking, I am VERY specific about what books I give a full 5 stars to!!)
Two words: tournament arc
Those two words are my weak spot and so, having watched and read lots of tournament based books and tv, I have grown to be very picky in what I class as worthy of the title. This book absolutely delivered! Usually a fantasy sequel suffers from “second book syndrome” and can struggle to pick up momentum again, often becoming a bit of a filler. Welp, this did NOT! It is one of the best sequels I’ve read in a very long time!!
This book is full of action and coliseum battles (COLISEUM BATTLES GUYS!!!!) and it was actually insane in the best way possible. Lisa pulls a move in this so shocking I let out an audible gasp, looked at the invisible camera in my room in utter shock, reread it about 15 times and only then did I accept the fact I wasn’t going blind or insane (WTF!? Genius but also eewwww😭 the way my gob was smacked).
The pacing of the books main narrative was very well done and weaved in lots of strings from the sidelines to cleverly bring them together. Like I said, it is just as full of action (if not more!) as the first book and continues to build on the world and magic systems while keeping the cosy Ghibli feel!.
The characters in this book… they are going to hold special places in my reader heart for a very long time. Gaius is blunt and funny and such a girl dad. Rongo was a great addition who genuinely shapes Lisa’s outlook on her future as well as helping her with some very cool fighting techniques. Zephan has elite howl vibes that was easily one of my favourites lol. Lisa is kind, empathetic and STANDS UP in this book!! My girl was BATTLING and she was so determined - you guys, I was rooting for her so bad! She really makes you want her to win! I love that she has such incredible strength of person in a way that is feminine and warm (something you don’t really see with the typical “strong fmc” anymore) as well as being magically powerful. Have to say, Ayker gave Cal a run for his money, but Cal is still a prince sooooo… (don’t worry there’s not really a love triangle I’m just delulu)
I won’t say who the villain in this is because I like to write reviews without spoilers, but I can vouch that he is cunning, unpredictable and vile (love that). He’s a great villain that really makes you fear for multiple characters, his cruel instability making for a truly evil villain.
I would like to thank this series for pulling me single-handedly out of a horrific reading slump and making me stay up all night. I read this one under the desk at uni and on the bus (almost cried on public transport which would have been so embarrassing😭).
Overall - 5⭐️
Two words: tournament arc
Those two words are my weak spot and so, having watched and read lots of tournament based books and tv, I have grown to be very picky in what I class as worthy of the title. This book absolutely delivered! Usually a fantasy sequel suffers from “second book syndrome” and can struggle to pick up momentum again, often becoming a bit of a filler. Welp, this did NOT! It is one of the best sequels I’ve read in a very long time!!
This book is full of action and coliseum battles (COLISEUM BATTLES GUYS!!!!) and it was actually insane in the best way possible. Lisa pulls a move in this so shocking I let out an audible gasp, looked at the invisible camera in my room in utter shock, reread it about 15 times and only then did I accept the fact I wasn’t going blind or insane (WTF!? Genius but also eewwww😭 the way my gob was smacked).
The pacing of the books main narrative was very well done and weaved in lots of strings from the sidelines to cleverly bring them together. Like I said, it is just as full of action (if not more!) as the first book and continues to build on the world and magic systems while keeping the cosy Ghibli feel!.
The characters in this book… they are going to hold special places in my reader heart for a very long time. Gaius is blunt and funny and such a girl dad. Rongo was a great addition who genuinely shapes Lisa’s outlook on her future as well as helping her with some very cool fighting techniques. Zephan has elite howl vibes that was easily one of my favourites lol. Lisa is kind, empathetic and STANDS UP in this book!! My girl was BATTLING and she was so determined - you guys, I was rooting for her so bad! She really makes you want her to win! I love that she has such incredible strength of person in a way that is feminine and warm (something you don’t really see with the typical “strong fmc” anymore) as well as being magically powerful. Have to say, Ayker gave Cal a run for his money, but Cal is still a prince sooooo… (don’t worry there’s not really a love triangle I’m just delulu)
I won’t say who the villain in this is because I like to write reviews without spoilers, but I can vouch that he is cunning, unpredictable and vile (love that). He’s a great villain that really makes you fear for multiple characters, his cruel instability making for a truly evil villain.
I would like to thank this series for pulling me single-handedly out of a horrific reading slump and making me stay up all night. I read this one under the desk at uni and on the bus (almost cried on public transport which would have been so embarrassing😭).
Overall - 5⭐️
September 9, 2024
The second book in the Agapéd saga, Paragon Games, takes the excitement and action to a whole new level. While the first book stirred deep emotions and even brought me to tears, this one kept me on the edge of my seat, adrenaline pumping from start to finish. The battles, which I felt were a weaker point in the first book, have been elevated spectacularly, making the fight scenes one of the story’s standout features.
Hannah’s writing has grown tremendously between the two books. The storyline has become less predictable, surprising me time and again with unexpected twists. I loved the shift in tone—it felt like a fresh side of the story, offering new values and lessons while still subtly reinforcing the importance of family bonds. Although not as prominently featured, the theme of family remains present, woven into the narrative in a thoughtful way.
The magical world unfolds even further in this installment, revealing hidden histories that add depth and richness to the setting. As Lisa continues her journey, we’re right there with her, learning and exploring this vast world. Her side mission, which intertwines with the Paragon Games, keeps the reader constantly engaged and in the heart of the action.
I found myself completely engrossed in the vividly described battles. The fight scenes were so well written that they effortlessly painted thrilling images in my mind—I didn’t want to leave this world, and I was always eager to read more, to see more.
Overall, Paragon Games delivers a fast-paced, action-packed experience filled with excitement, tension, humor, and heart. It’s a fantastic follow-up to the first book and an absolute must-read for fans of the saga, magic and adventure!
Hannah’s writing has grown tremendously between the two books. The storyline has become less predictable, surprising me time and again with unexpected twists. I loved the shift in tone—it felt like a fresh side of the story, offering new values and lessons while still subtly reinforcing the importance of family bonds. Although not as prominently featured, the theme of family remains present, woven into the narrative in a thoughtful way.
The magical world unfolds even further in this installment, revealing hidden histories that add depth and richness to the setting. As Lisa continues her journey, we’re right there with her, learning and exploring this vast world. Her side mission, which intertwines with the Paragon Games, keeps the reader constantly engaged and in the heart of the action.
I found myself completely engrossed in the vividly described battles. The fight scenes were so well written that they effortlessly painted thrilling images in my mind—I didn’t want to leave this world, and I was always eager to read more, to see more.
Overall, Paragon Games delivers a fast-paced, action-packed experience filled with excitement, tension, humor, and heart. It’s a fantastic follow-up to the first book and an absolute must-read for fans of the saga, magic and adventure!
October 26, 2024
I picked up this book excited for the Paragon Games plot, but then I was reading and it did not kick start to that. The scenes that I was reading were interesting but I started to become bored because I was itching for the Paragon Games to begin.
And when the games started I didn't mind the scenes I had to go through to get there because it was needed for the plot.
This book, is so much better than book 1. It was such an improvement.
My favourite parts of this book is Lisa's bad ass moments:
Her being shot in the leg by a laser, and then her taking her time to kick of her shoes, her shorts and then blast into the waters with just her bathing suit.
Lisa pulling a katara, and used her sweat and saliva to turn into icicles and stab Rongo in the eye.
Badass and so brutal. I was there rooting for Lisa throughout the whole entire games.
Also I love it how the stakes got higher by the fact that Lisa could lose her Agaped Magic, it made me way more invested.
And it was so funny when the duplication mage activated Lisa's worst fears and he end up losing his powers and him saying: "Losing your magic is your worst fear?" I laughed out loud.
The big bad was predictable but it didn't take away from the enjoyment I had.
I'm so excited for the next book in the series because if this book was an improvement to the first one, I'm sure that book 3 will be outstanding!
And when the games started I didn't mind the scenes I had to go through to get there because it was needed for the plot.
This book, is so much better than book 1. It was such an improvement.
My favourite parts of this book is Lisa's bad ass moments:
Her being shot in the leg by a laser, and then her taking her time to kick of her shoes, her shorts and then blast into the waters with just her bathing suit.
Lisa pulling a katara, and used her sweat and saliva to turn into icicles and stab Rongo in the eye.
Badass and so brutal. I was there rooting for Lisa throughout the whole entire games.
Also I love it how the stakes got higher by the fact that Lisa could lose her Agaped Magic, it made me way more invested.
And it was so funny when the duplication mage activated Lisa's worst fears and he end up losing his powers and him saying: "Losing your magic is your worst fear?" I laughed out loud.
The big bad was predictable but it didn't take away from the enjoyment I had.
I'm so excited for the next book in the series because if this book was an improvement to the first one, I'm sure that book 3 will be outstanding!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 8, 2025
🍓 Clean story, first crushes
💬 Mild, "crap" used a couple of times
❗Violence, death, severe injuries, blood (all somewhat detailed, more than in the first book)
.
My thoughts:
I LOVE THIS SERIES!!! And this volume really was written "for those who feel like they don't belong", chapter 34 hit home so much 🥺❤️🩹The new characters are so fun, I especially love a certain family of three, they're the best! Old relationships grow (LOVE THEM SO MUCH!!!) and new ones blossom, each one better than the other! Though I remember being indifferent towards one of the new characters when I read this book for the first time (I felt like he was a forced potential second love interest and didn't care for a love triangle) I've grown to like him more this time around. He's super nice and a well-developed character! ☺️ I'm also not the one into sports and big tournaments, so I liked Wishing Stars a little more, but I have to say that Paragon Games are balanced out super nice, with both calm, magical moments and intense, climax-like battles, even at the beggining of the story! I loved Lisa's growth and I hope she'll trust Gaius with her problems more in the next books! I'm so excited to start reading Hunter Wars!!! 🤩🥳💖 Like I've said in my previous TAB review - PLEASE GO READ THIS SERIES, I PROMISE YOU WILL LOVE IT!!! 😩🙏🥹❤️
💬 Mild, "crap" used a couple of times
❗Violence, death, severe injuries, blood (all somewhat detailed, more than in the first book)
.
My thoughts:
I LOVE THIS SERIES!!! And this volume really was written "for those who feel like they don't belong", chapter 34 hit home so much 🥺❤️🩹The new characters are so fun, I especially love a certain family of three, they're the best! Old relationships grow (LOVE THEM SO MUCH!!!) and new ones blossom, each one better than the other! Though I remember being indifferent towards one of the new characters when I read this book for the first time (I felt like he was a forced potential second love interest and didn't care for a love triangle) I've grown to like him more this time around. He's super nice and a well-developed character! ☺️ I'm also not the one into sports and big tournaments, so I liked Wishing Stars a little more, but I have to say that Paragon Games are balanced out super nice, with both calm, magical moments and intense, climax-like battles, even at the beggining of the story! I loved Lisa's growth and I hope she'll trust Gaius with her problems more in the next books! I'm so excited to start reading Hunter Wars!!! 🤩🥳💖 Like I've said in my previous TAB review - PLEASE GO READ THIS SERIES, I PROMISE YOU WILL LOVE IT!!! 😩🙏🥹❤️
September 3, 2024
𝑬𝑳'𝑺 𝑻𝑯𝑶𝑼𝑮𝑯𝑻𝑺 ✧ ・₊°࿐
𝐎𝐕𝐄𝐑𝐕𝐈𝐄𝐖: LISA. RAE. FREAKING. ROBBIE. Paragon Games has truly tested her and this fourteen year old is just UGH I LOVE HER!
Paragon Games was bigger and better! There was so so much to unpack in the few months this took place but boy was it keeping me on my toes! The world felt so much bigger, we got to meet more characters, and the Games themselves felt like a combination of the Olympics, the Superbowl, and the gladiator fights from way back in the Roman days. The different plots that make up Paragon Games are all intertwined and, and, and.... I just have no words because by golly. You will cry and you will hurt and you will love and you will thoroughly enjoy book two. I cannot wait for book three later this month and am eagerly on the edge of my seat for what comes next for our darling Lisa Robbie.
𝐍𝐎𝐓𝐄𝐒: I'll admit, there were some parts that I struggled to stick with, that felt long and expository which is understandable, but as I did with the first book, I got really into it once we started picking up the plot that made up for it. My only regret was that I didn't finish reading this before Hannah called for ARCs for her third book.
𝐎𝐕𝐄𝐑𝐕𝐈𝐄𝐖: LISA. RAE. FREAKING. ROBBIE. Paragon Games has truly tested her and this fourteen year old is just UGH I LOVE HER!
Paragon Games was bigger and better! There was so so much to unpack in the few months this took place but boy was it keeping me on my toes! The world felt so much bigger, we got to meet more characters, and the Games themselves felt like a combination of the Olympics, the Superbowl, and the gladiator fights from way back in the Roman days. The different plots that make up Paragon Games are all intertwined and, and, and.... I just have no words because by golly. You will cry and you will hurt and you will love and you will thoroughly enjoy book two. I cannot wait for book three later this month and am eagerly on the edge of my seat for what comes next for our darling Lisa Robbie.
𝐍𝐎𝐓𝐄𝐒: I'll admit, there were some parts that I struggled to stick with, that felt long and expository which is understandable, but as I did with the first book, I got really into it once we started picking up the plot that made up for it. My only regret was that I didn't finish reading this before Hannah called for ARCs for her third book.
October 6, 2024
After binging the last 100 pages to find out what happens, I can now say this my favorite book in the series so far. The subplots were so beautifully woven and the layered problems made me crave more. The first book perfectly introduced readers into this universe, and the second book made it come to life.
Let me just start with the plot because MY GOODNESS I adore the idea of the Paragon Games and the epic magic battles. This is the type of high-stakes fantasy I've been waiting so long for that had me jumping and cheering like all the other fans in the arena. The plot about trying to save Nuolja was so interesting and it helped showcase Lisa's admirable, selfless heart. The subtle details hinting at Lisa's crush on her friend growing into something deeper have me scrambling to get the next book. Revealing so many things that can threaten the Agáped Magic helps intrigue readers on how Lisa will fend them off in future books. The best way to describe my emotions is STUNNED.
The writing is beautiful as always with wonderful comparisons that make the book feel like a dream. I swear this book series needs get picked up by a major production company and turn into a gigantic TV show franchise. Hannah Lindsey knows what she is doing and deserves so much for these masterpieces. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE read this series I beg you it's wonderful.
Let me just start with the plot because MY GOODNESS I adore the idea of the Paragon Games and the epic magic battles. This is the type of high-stakes fantasy I've been waiting so long for that had me jumping and cheering like all the other fans in the arena. The plot about trying to save Nuolja was so interesting and it helped showcase Lisa's admirable, selfless heart. The subtle details hinting at Lisa's crush on her friend growing into something deeper have me scrambling to get the next book. Revealing so many things that can threaten the Agáped Magic helps intrigue readers on how Lisa will fend them off in future books. The best way to describe my emotions is STUNNED.
The writing is beautiful as always with wonderful comparisons that make the book feel like a dream. I swear this book series needs get picked up by a major production company and turn into a gigantic TV show franchise. Hannah Lindsey knows what she is doing and deserves so much for these masterpieces. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE read this series I beg you it's wonderful.
March 12, 2025
“Simply demanded to know why it took them so long to slab beef on a bun and ladle soup into a bowl.” I rolled my eyes. “Let me guess, we can never come here again after today?” He took a slurp of his soup. His nose immediately scrunched. “Wouldn’t want to. Gits can’t make soup properly.”
We all have that one friend who doesn't like restaurants. Apparently it's Gaius.
We get more world exploring! Ayker is a sweetie and the Lisa gets to learn and grow up more before our eyes. Making new friends and seeing more of her grump mentor. I did want to read about him punching a game master in the face, but he has more self control than I do.
Tuff also apparently leaves little orange spots all around the couch, towels, and fabric surfaces in the house. oops.
I have ended up with a bunch of the cutest little highlights in my book.
We all have that one friend who doesn't like restaurants. Apparently it's Gaius.
We get more world exploring! Ayker is a sweetie and the Lisa gets to learn and grow up more before our eyes. Making new friends and seeing more of her grump mentor. I did want to read about him punching a game master in the face, but he has more self control than I do.
Tuff also apparently leaves little orange spots all around the couch, towels, and fabric surfaces in the house. oops.
I have ended up with a bunch of the cutest little highlights in my book.
August 22, 2025
This book was a huge improvement from the first.
I’m happy the writing improved from the first book, although I hope that the author eventually stops using the word “tittered” so much…
More important than the writing style, Lisa’s character was a lot more developed. In the first book, she was so “perfect” - well-behaved, polite, timid, almost always making the right choices - that she was boring and flat as a character. This book fleshed out a Lisa that was braver but taking big risks, both clever and foolish, and more likable. I’m really looking forward to seeing her continue to mature, have bigger adventures, and see her relationships blossom.
I’m happy the writing improved from the first book, although I hope that the author eventually stops using the word “tittered” so much…
More important than the writing style, Lisa’s character was a lot more developed. In the first book, she was so “perfect” - well-behaved, polite, timid, almost always making the right choices - that she was boring and flat as a character. This book fleshed out a Lisa that was braver but taking big risks, both clever and foolish, and more likable. I’m really looking forward to seeing her continue to mature, have bigger adventures, and see her relationships blossom.
June 3, 2025
This is the first sequel I ever read for an independent author. Hannah Lindsey’s series has once again captured my heart in a way an author has not been able to do since C. S. Lewis or Tolkien. I love her characters, the relationships, the dialogue, all of it. The whole time, too, she sends a clear, positive message about love, sacrifice, responsibility, and wonder. I highly recommend the series and this book.
10/10 work. Lowest score I can accept from anyone and still be friends is a 9.5/10.
10/10 work. Lowest score I can accept from anyone and still be friends is a 9.5/10.
August 24, 2024
My love for these characters have gone to astronomical heights.
This book was JAM PACKED with all the epic magic battles and I am HERE FOR IT. One of the best 2nd books in a series I’ve ever read. I tried so hard not to finish this book too quickly (because I’d have to wait for book 3), BUT MY GOSH IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE.
Immersed until the very end, Hannah will transport you into a never-ending thrilling adventure that will literally have your heart pounding!!!
This book was JAM PACKED with all the epic magic battles and I am HERE FOR IT. One of the best 2nd books in a series I’ve ever read. I tried so hard not to finish this book too quickly (because I’d have to wait for book 3), BUT MY GOSH IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE.
Immersed until the very end, Hannah will transport you into a never-ending thrilling adventure that will literally have your heart pounding!!!
September 24, 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
👏 HANNAH 👏 LINDSEY 👏 HAS 👏 DONE 👏 IT 👏 AGAIN 👏 FOLKS 👏
The Agaped Bearer: Paragon Games outshines its remarkable predecessor in more ways than one, exploring more magic, diving head first into new, vibrant worlds, and strengthening the relationships Lindsey has so diligently crafted between her characters. I loved every second of this book, and the magic of this series has firmly taken root in my heart. I won’t ever forget it.
👏 HANNAH 👏 LINDSEY 👏 HAS 👏 DONE 👏 IT 👏 AGAIN 👏 FOLKS 👏
The Agaped Bearer: Paragon Games outshines its remarkable predecessor in more ways than one, exploring more magic, diving head first into new, vibrant worlds, and strengthening the relationships Lindsey has so diligently crafted between her characters. I loved every second of this book, and the magic of this series has firmly taken root in my heart. I won’t ever forget it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 61 reviews