“A New Lease on Death” is one of those books that came to my attention through several media promotions as the beginning of a quirky new supernatural mystery series. Although I had not read this particular author before, it sounded interesting enough that I reserved it through my local library and just finished it last night in one of those enjoyable late night reading sessions.
This first book in a new genre-blending series introduces two bumbling and chaotic female characters – Cordelia Graves and Ruby Young – one dead and one very much alive. Cordelia died in her rundown Boston apartment a couple of months ago from what appears to be a suicide. However, that wasn’t the end of her. She’s found herself taking on the form of a ghost, and being very comfortable in hanging out in her apartment watching her plants die. Soon after, twenty-year-old Ruby Young, running away from a bad relationship, heads to the big city of Boston and moves into Cordelia’s apartment.
Even though Cordelia tries her best to scare Ruby away, nothing works. The problem is that Ruby believes completely in the existence of ghosts and wants to communicate with Cordelia, even though the previous owner wants nothing to do with her.
All that changes in one night when their neighbor across the hall, Jake Macintyre, a serious ladies’ man who orders a lot of pizza, is shot in front of the apartment building in what appears to be a mugging gone terribly bad. Cordelia doesn’t see who killed Jake, but arrives in time to see him leave his body and spends a few minutes talking with him before he disappears for good. She’s left her with the feeling there is more to his murder than just a mugging and is determined to find who killed him.
However, being dead really limits Cordelia’s ability to solve the crime alone. She needs help, and the only person she has to turn to is the very person she’s been trying to remove from her apartment – the young and obnoxious, Ruby. It’s up Cordelia to figure out how to communicate with the living and create a working partnership that will effectively help the two of them to investigate and hunt down a killer that wants to keep dangerous secrets from being made public….
My thoughts are mixed on this one. There were some good things that drew me in and provided an entertaining mix of a cozy mystery with supernatural elements. On the other hand, there was some areas that could use improvement if it is to become a successful series.
From a character standpoint, I liked Ruby from the very beginning, finding her easy to relate to and cheer on as she proactively stumbled through their amateurish investigation. I found her upbeat personality and outlook refreshing, especially her rebellious dress style. In contrast, it took me longer to connect with Cordelia, who was a bit less fleshed out as a character, and the author revealed her history slowly throughout the investigation. Once enough of it was shared, it turned out to be rather sad and depressing so that I just felt bad for her, which was both good and bad. By the end, Ruby and Cordelia were starting to bond create some interesting synergy that gives hope for future mysteries, especially with Ruby’s announcement on the last page that left the readers with a cliffhanger that’s purpose was to get them to read the next book in the series.
From a plotting standpoint, it was cute, fairly light with a cozy feel until the latter third, and included some things that held the pacing in a slower gear at times. For example, the first third of the book was slower than I would have liked, as the author needed some time to get things going. Several times things got tedious and a little repetitive, which held the investigation from moving forward. One thing that I appreciated was the way the author developed her death mythology (the afterlife elements). I liked the way that she peeled the onion on those aspects and I found myself wanting to see more of those aspects explored. For example, I was drawn to Harp’s character and am interested to know more about him and his backstory. That helped offset what I felt like was a weaker murder mystery story line that didn’t play out as strongly as I would have liked.
Overall, this was an enjoyable, but not great read. I felt more like a work in progress that was close, but still not in a state that would deliver all that it intended to. Even the last page cliffhanger ending was not a surprise to most readers who already saw it coming. Still, there is definitely potential. Raw potential that could develop into something special. We’ll see.
Let’s be honest. Writing the first book in a new series is not easy. You have to introduce new characters, new settings, and create a unique style and atmosphere for the audience. It usually takes writers a while to find their creative rhythm and flow, so I don’t want to sound too hard or critical in my comments. The key question to answer is this – did I enjoy it enough to read the next book in this series when it gets published? Honestly, I’ll have to think about it a bit, but my guess is that I will be more likely to give Cordelia and Ruby another chance to keep my attention.
For now, I give “A New Lease on Death” 2.5 out of 5-stars. (and yes, Goodreads rounds it up…)