Thank you to Netgalley and The School of Life for providing an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I had high hopes for this book. Having previously read a School of Life book that broke down a complex topic in a clear, memorable way, I expected a similarly thoughtful approach here. I also enjoyed Permission to Feel by Marc Brackett and was looking for something that would expand my understanding of emotional intelligence. Unfortunately, this book didn’t quite deliver.
The structure alternates between a questionnaire and short essays on the corresponding topics, but the execution left me frustrated. The questionnaire felt oddly designed—rather than straightforward yes/no responses, many answers were phrased in a way that seemed to prioritize cleverness over clarity. This made it difficult to see myself in the results, and at times, the options felt so far removed from how people actually think and behave that they lost their usefulness. A more direct or nuanced scale would have been much more effective.
The essays, meanwhile, felt oversimplified. Rather than offering research-based insights or compelling new perspectives, they read like introductory reflections for someone entirely new to the concept of emotional intelligence. Take this passage, for example:
"Truly clever people know that they can only be clever some of the time. Scepticism towards oneself lies at the heart of emotional intelligence."
It’s not necessarily wrong, but it’s not particularly thought-provoking either. Many sections felt like they were restating common wisdom rather than engaging with the complexities of emotional maturity. I kept waiting for a deeper exploration—something that would challenge or expand my thinking—but that moment never really arrived.
While I can see this being useful for someone encountering these ideas for the first time, I was hoping for something with more depth. Instead, it felt like a surface-level guide that never quite engaged with the richness of the topic.