Considering the cover and cheesy romantic line thereon, I expected this to be a rather run-of-the-mill romance replete with your regular western scenery descriptions.
What I got was a hit-the-ground-running, exciting, mysterious novel, and I started to seriously get annoyed when I was too addicted to put down the book. It just kept going.
Setting: New Mexico (besides a quick introduction in and later references to Syracuse, New York), specifically on a ranch and on a Navajo Indian reservation. The time period, 1935, has little obvious significance on the plot, but I assume the general attitude toward Indians was era-accurate, and the Great Depression was mentioned here and there. The more interesting aspect of the setting was the contrast between New Mexico (especially the Indian perspective) and Syracuse, which I thought was nicely portrayed.
Characters: I loved Tahoma Benally more than I've loved a fictional hero in a while. His native heritage, combined with a new Christian faith--as well as past bad experiences--combined to bring together spiritual struggles, plain romantic attraction, and victory over his problems. The resulting character arc was very well done, aside from a totally bone-headed decision near the end. That was so dumb I'm not convinced it was at all realistic. But, he was Navajo-handsome. That definitely helped.
Eva was a relatively well-balanced character, and I don't think she bugged me all that much. Her one big decision, while I was angry with her at the time, was actually probably wise. And not based on romantic whims, which was nice (even if it hurt my emotions). She, too, did sometime quite dumb near the end, which I 98% disapproved of (the other two percent is relative approval because the situation did show a certain important character trait of another character).
The other characters, for the most part, were appropriately developed. I liked Tahoma's parents quite a lot, and though I of course wished for a better conclusion, it was satisfactorily realistic and heart-rending. The various spiritual viewpoints of the minor characters were interesting and not at all cliche Christian viewpoints.
Plot: There was always something going on; it never got boring, and plot twists were for the most part unexpected. The romance took prominence, but the suspenseful mystery was equally important, and these two aspects supported each other quite splendidly. Tahoma's doctor struggles were not really a driving force, but even that was resolved fairly well.
Faith Content: The characters' spiritual arcs were well done; the salvation question was addressed, as well as being bold in sharing of the faith. The heathen practices of the Indians were not ignored, and thankfully not condoned at all. Not many details regarding the Navajo rituals were given--aside from the general pagan goal--but the author succeeded in portraying an incorrect worldview without condemning an ethnic group's entire way of living. I was glad to see Tahoma not compromise his faith. Other non-Christian beliefs were presented through various characters, and I appreciated the diversity of opinions in even the good characters, all while being presented as incorrect. At times I did feel bad for Eva for having so few spiritual mentors.
Time will tell if this book will become a timeless favorite, but I definitely enjoyed the first time around.