What do you think?
Rate this book
The Spider and the Stone: A Novel of Scotland's Black Douglas
As the 14th century dawns, the brutal Edward Longshanks of England schemes to steal Scotland. But inspired by a headstrong lass, a frail, dark-skinned boy named James Douglas defies three Plantagenet kings and champions the cause of his wavering friend, Robert Bruce, to lead the armies to the bloody field of Bannockburn. A thrilling epic of star-crossed love and heroic sacrifice set during the Scottish Wars of Independence.
The Spider and the Stone: A Novel of Scotland's Black Douglas
Historical fiction
432 pages/3 maps
The Spider and the Stone: A Novel of Scotland's Black Douglas
Historical fiction
432 pages/3 maps
433 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2014
146 people are currently reading
2692 people want to read
About the author
Glen Craney
11 books155 followers
A native Hoosier, GLEN CRANEY is a novelist, screenwriter, journalist, and lawyer. He caught the history bug as a boy while tracing the steps of his ancestors on Civil War battlefields and the reconstructed forts of the first Kentucky pioneers.
His travels around the world have found him playing baseball in Cuba, walking the biblical sites of Israel, exploring the Secret Vatican Archives in Rome, and climbing Templar castles in Scotland and France. His books have taken readers to Occitania during the Albigensian Crusade, to the Scotland of Robert the Bruce, to Portugal during the Age of Discovery, to the trenches of France during World War I, and to the American Hoovervilles of the Great Depression.
He graduated from Hanover College with a major in history and holds graduate degrees from Indiana University School of Law-Indianapolis and Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism. After a stint as a trial lawyer, he joined the Washington, D.C. press corps to report on national politics and the Iran-contra trial for Congressional Quarterly magazine. He then moved to California to write movie scripts, and his feature screenplay, Whisper the Wind, about the Navajo codetalkers of World War II, was awarded the Nicholl Fellowship Prize by the Academy of Motion Pictures, Arts and Sciences for best new screenwriting.
With the encouragement of his mentor, Hollywood legend Harry Essex, he tried his hand at historical fiction and mystery-thrillers, and has never looked back. His debut historical novel, The Fire and the Light, was named Best New Fiction by the National Indie Excellence Awards. He is also a three-time indieBRAG Medallion Honoree, a Chaucer Award First-Place Winner, a three-time Foreword Reviews Book-of-the-Year Award Finalist, a Scéal Mystery-Thriller Award Finalist, a Nautilus Silver Award Winner, an IPPY Silver Award Winner, an Eric Hoffer Finalist and Honorable Mention Winner, a Da Vinci Eye Award Finalist, and a BTS Readers Choice Award Honorable Mention.
For latest news and updates on deals and releases, please join me on:
Glen's Newsletter
Glen's Facebook Page
Glen's Bookbub Page
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 95 reviews
April 11, 2015
Brilliant!
This is an excellent novel set in the 14th century with the ruthless King Edward Longshanks sitting on the English throne. Edward, together with his corrupted cronies is determined to squash the uprising in Scotland and capture Robert the Bruce and his supporter The Black Douglas. The author has done a tremendous job of portraying this time period and bringing it alive for the readers with characters described in such depth and detail you could certainly feel their despair and suffering. Glen Craney weaves a fine tale along with intriguing mysticism scattered throughout the book. I found many parts so mesmerizing I had to re-read these pages a second and even a third time. It is one of the best historical fiction books I’ve had the pleasure of reading! Highly recommended!
This is an excellent novel set in the 14th century with the ruthless King Edward Longshanks sitting on the English throne. Edward, together with his corrupted cronies is determined to squash the uprising in Scotland and capture Robert the Bruce and his supporter The Black Douglas. The author has done a tremendous job of portraying this time period and bringing it alive for the readers with characters described in such depth and detail you could certainly feel their despair and suffering. Glen Craney weaves a fine tale along with intriguing mysticism scattered throughout the book. I found many parts so mesmerizing I had to re-read these pages a second and even a third time. It is one of the best historical fiction books I’ve had the pleasure of reading! Highly recommended!
August 2, 2019
Book Reviewed on www.whisperingstories.com
‘The Spider and the Stone’ is an historical novel by Californian-based writer, Glen Craney. We see events unfold in the third person, mainly from the viewpoints of James Douglas and Belle MacDuff.
The author manages to convey a strong sense of rivalry and intrigue between the waring Scottish clans, vying for the crown and it’s against this backdrop that James and Belle meet. However, there is no denying that the Scots have a common enemy in the form of Edward Plantagenet, King of England and a fragmented, strained and unhappy temporary alliance is formed behind William Wallace, to try to rebuff English incursions into Scottish territory.
The star-crossed lovers are driven apart by circumstances beyond their control, with James travelling to France and Belle being trapped in a loveless marriage. Events then play out within the historical framework with fiction mixed with fact, as we witness treachery and deception, love and loss, heartache and despair. In fact, if you’re looking for a light-hearted read, this most certainly isn’t it.
Inevitably, when telling a tale based on true life events, there are many names to grapple with, so I was grateful for the ‘Roll of Honour’ at the beginning of the book. There were some hugely colourful players in this drama for the author to explore and whist the descriptive passages were very atmospheric, I would have liked more depth to some of the characters. However, to do that, a swingeing edit of arguably expendable material would have been necessary.
I was intrigued by the synopsis as my knowledge of thirteenth and fourteenth century Scottish history is poor. As the story is told from this angle, maybe the author can be forgiven for portraying the early Plantagenet regime as the more barbaric of the two, rather than trying to deliver a balanced view. However, if the intention was to have readers delving into their search engines for additional information about the time, then it certainly worked in my case.
Rich in misdirection, symbolism and pathos, the author gives us a lot of action-packed scenes, with dialogue which is liberally sprinkled with irony, cynicism, suspicion and mistrust. I presume the Scots would have used a form of Gaelic language and by and large, the author has attempted British-English with the occasional American-English phrase or word which will not perturb an international audience.
By way of contrast to the battle scenes, we see a strong partnership build between James Douglas and Robert Bruce. I was also particularly touched by the spasmodic yet burgeoning respectful relationship between Belle and Isabella, the wife of Edward II. War and brutality walk hand-in-hand at this time, with Belle’s treatment at the hands of her captors being indicative of a blatant disregard for life. In Isabella, we see a glimpse of humanity, as she tries desperately to help a kindred spirit.
If you enjoy the historical genre, then you will doubtless find The Spider and the Stone worthwhile. Underpinning the action is a series of romantic encounters for James and some readers might find this a bit tedious. The book has 432 pages but it seemed a lot longer. I enjoyed the story in some places but found it hard work in others. For the amount of research and effort that clearly went into producing this novel, I award the author four stars.
‘The Spider and the Stone’ is an historical novel by Californian-based writer, Glen Craney. We see events unfold in the third person, mainly from the viewpoints of James Douglas and Belle MacDuff.
The author manages to convey a strong sense of rivalry and intrigue between the waring Scottish clans, vying for the crown and it’s against this backdrop that James and Belle meet. However, there is no denying that the Scots have a common enemy in the form of Edward Plantagenet, King of England and a fragmented, strained and unhappy temporary alliance is formed behind William Wallace, to try to rebuff English incursions into Scottish territory.
The star-crossed lovers are driven apart by circumstances beyond their control, with James travelling to France and Belle being trapped in a loveless marriage. Events then play out within the historical framework with fiction mixed with fact, as we witness treachery and deception, love and loss, heartache and despair. In fact, if you’re looking for a light-hearted read, this most certainly isn’t it.
Inevitably, when telling a tale based on true life events, there are many names to grapple with, so I was grateful for the ‘Roll of Honour’ at the beginning of the book. There were some hugely colourful players in this drama for the author to explore and whist the descriptive passages were very atmospheric, I would have liked more depth to some of the characters. However, to do that, a swingeing edit of arguably expendable material would have been necessary.
I was intrigued by the synopsis as my knowledge of thirteenth and fourteenth century Scottish history is poor. As the story is told from this angle, maybe the author can be forgiven for portraying the early Plantagenet regime as the more barbaric of the two, rather than trying to deliver a balanced view. However, if the intention was to have readers delving into their search engines for additional information about the time, then it certainly worked in my case.
Rich in misdirection, symbolism and pathos, the author gives us a lot of action-packed scenes, with dialogue which is liberally sprinkled with irony, cynicism, suspicion and mistrust. I presume the Scots would have used a form of Gaelic language and by and large, the author has attempted British-English with the occasional American-English phrase or word which will not perturb an international audience.
By way of contrast to the battle scenes, we see a strong partnership build between James Douglas and Robert Bruce. I was also particularly touched by the spasmodic yet burgeoning respectful relationship between Belle and Isabella, the wife of Edward II. War and brutality walk hand-in-hand at this time, with Belle’s treatment at the hands of her captors being indicative of a blatant disregard for life. In Isabella, we see a glimpse of humanity, as she tries desperately to help a kindred spirit.
If you enjoy the historical genre, then you will doubtless find The Spider and the Stone worthwhile. Underpinning the action is a series of romantic encounters for James and some readers might find this a bit tedious. The book has 432 pages but it seemed a lot longer. I enjoyed the story in some places but found it hard work in others. For the amount of research and effort that clearly went into producing this novel, I award the author four stars.
August 16, 2019
If you have EVER been drawn to the history of brave men who shaped the world for generations to come, if you have ever wanted to feel what it may have been like to live in an era where battles were personal, where men braved the enemy’s onslaught on the battlefield or in the private chambers of both men of the cloth and kings, this is your read. From the horrors of war to the horrors humanity is capable of inflicting and enduring, to the loyalties of clans, the power of fighting for freedom and home, this is your read.
Glen Craney’s THE SPIDER AND THE STONE is the story of England’s invasion of Scotland in the fourteenth century. It is a story of heroes, of deceivers, of cowards and of love. It is the story of history that comes alive in a fictional tale of what may have happened, what could have happened and it is expertly blended into true events as Scotland tries to push back the English and one man becomes figurehead for his countrymen.
Absolutely riveting! These characters come to life, the battles are vividly detailed, the emotions are raw and real, gut-clenching. The love that survives is incredible as both men and women face the worst that England has to offer and the nightmares their own Scottish brothers will inflict in the name of power.
This one is going to stay high on my favorites list and I cannot recommend it enough! Glen Craney has done an amazing job bringing the past to life with care!
I received a complimentary copy from Glen Craney! This is my honest and voluntary review.
Publisher: Brigid's Fire Press (October 26, 2013)
Publication Date: October 26, 2013
Genre: Historical Fiction
Print Length: 433 pages
Available from: Amazon | Barnes & Noble
For Reviews, Giveaways, Fabulous Book News, follow: http://tometender.blogspot.com
Glen Craney’s THE SPIDER AND THE STONE is the story of England’s invasion of Scotland in the fourteenth century. It is a story of heroes, of deceivers, of cowards and of love. It is the story of history that comes alive in a fictional tale of what may have happened, what could have happened and it is expertly blended into true events as Scotland tries to push back the English and one man becomes figurehead for his countrymen.
Absolutely riveting! These characters come to life, the battles are vividly detailed, the emotions are raw and real, gut-clenching. The love that survives is incredible as both men and women face the worst that England has to offer and the nightmares their own Scottish brothers will inflict in the name of power.
This one is going to stay high on my favorites list and I cannot recommend it enough! Glen Craney has done an amazing job bringing the past to life with care!
I received a complimentary copy from Glen Craney! This is my honest and voluntary review.
Publisher: Brigid's Fire Press (October 26, 2013)
Publication Date: October 26, 2013
Genre: Historical Fiction
Print Length: 433 pages
Available from: Amazon | Barnes & Noble
For Reviews, Giveaways, Fabulous Book News, follow: http://tometender.blogspot.com
April 18, 2017
A tantalizing look at the life of James Douglas, or The Black Douglas as he was called by those who feared him. My only real venture into this part of history was Braveheart, but that centers on William Wallace, not the man who rose to become the right hand of Robert the Bruce in the long standing war with Edward Longshanks and his son Edward Caernarvon. I was drawn into this epic tale right from the start; the intensity of the narrative grabbed and never let go. The characters are beautifully written, from the morose, melancholic Bruce, the savage brutality of Longshanks, the effervescent monk Ned Sweeney, the redoubtable Belle, the scheming Isabella, and of course, the continually torn Jamie Douglas. The author presents the events and the time such that one can feel the thunderous approach of Longshank's heavy horse, or the bitter Scottish weather confronting the fleeing Bruce and Douglas. An entertaining book to be sure; one that demands your attention to the detriment of sleep or other obligations. 4.8 stars
September 20, 2016
I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.
I have only recently become interested in Scottish history after being hooked on the Outlander series. Braveheart is actually one of my favorite movies so when I read the summary, a few names struck a cord with me so I jumped at the chance to read this book. Almost immediately you can tell that the author researched the time period and subjects very well. I was easily transported to 14th century Scotland and felt like I was there in the thick of it. Jamie Douglas quickly became my favorite character. I immediately felt for him in the first part of the book when the English gave him the impossible choice of his father or his friend. And then when he met Isabelle and fell in love with her, I wanted them to get a happy ending. I’m also a huge fan of the fantasy genre so I loved seeing the mystical parts associated with ancient Scotland like the Stone of Destiny. There were only a few times while I was reading that I found my attention wandering elsewhere when the story got a little slow but overall I really enjoyed reading this story and will definitely be adding other books by this author to my endless reading list.
I have only recently become interested in Scottish history after being hooked on the Outlander series. Braveheart is actually one of my favorite movies so when I read the summary, a few names struck a cord with me so I jumped at the chance to read this book. Almost immediately you can tell that the author researched the time period and subjects very well. I was easily transported to 14th century Scotland and felt like I was there in the thick of it. Jamie Douglas quickly became my favorite character. I immediately felt for him in the first part of the book when the English gave him the impossible choice of his father or his friend. And then when he met Isabelle and fell in love with her, I wanted them to get a happy ending. I’m also a huge fan of the fantasy genre so I loved seeing the mystical parts associated with ancient Scotland like the Stone of Destiny. There were only a few times while I was reading that I found my attention wandering elsewhere when the story got a little slow but overall I really enjoyed reading this story and will definitely be adding other books by this author to my endless reading list.
August 6, 2014
I needed to read up on Electric Scotland so that I understood the Culdees, the Stone of Scone and other aspects of this important era and this book gave me a leg up on that. Everything I needed to know about the Black Douglas and did not know who to ask, and then some I learned or looked up while reading. What was Scotland like in Jamie Douglas's childhood ? How about Isabel McDuff and what was that story all about? Most importantly was the divisions between the Scottish clans at this time and what it meant to this era.
It was a marvelous book and I was moved to tears at the long and sad ending. Glen Craney did a very fine job of encapsulating the life of James Douglas in one volume.The vignettes of Isabella of France at the beginning and end set a very apt and distinct historical tone.
Very moving also to me was the utter devotion of William Wallace, Robert Bruce and James Douglas to the Scottish homeland. Yes I saw Braveheart and knew about many things the Hammer of the Scots did at Berwick and other places.These interrelationships were different and far reaching as I discovered as continued to read.
I learned so much from this book about Medieval Scotland which was why I close to read it and I would read it again for the marvelous prose.The relationships described are unique to this novel but possible and even plausible since much about this time is undocumented.
We do not know exactly either, how Isabel MacDuff exactly came into this story. Isabel, hearing that Robert Bruce, her cousin was being crowned King at Scone, after slaying John Comyn, her cousin by marriage at Greyfriars, got on a horse and rode to perform her family function as crowner of kings of Scotland. Isabel, the Countess of Buchan chooses patriotism for Scotland over sure disaster as a result.
I will not share it all with you, you must now get the book yourself and read about this time in history. I am so very happy that I received such an excellent book for a review from such an accomplished author.
It was a marvelous book and I was moved to tears at the long and sad ending. Glen Craney did a very fine job of encapsulating the life of James Douglas in one volume.The vignettes of Isabella of France at the beginning and end set a very apt and distinct historical tone.
Very moving also to me was the utter devotion of William Wallace, Robert Bruce and James Douglas to the Scottish homeland. Yes I saw Braveheart and knew about many things the Hammer of the Scots did at Berwick and other places.These interrelationships were different and far reaching as I discovered as continued to read.
I learned so much from this book about Medieval Scotland which was why I close to read it and I would read it again for the marvelous prose.The relationships described are unique to this novel but possible and even plausible since much about this time is undocumented.
We do not know exactly either, how Isabel MacDuff exactly came into this story. Isabel, hearing that Robert Bruce, her cousin was being crowned King at Scone, after slaying John Comyn, her cousin by marriage at Greyfriars, got on a horse and rode to perform her family function as crowner of kings of Scotland. Isabel, the Countess of Buchan chooses patriotism for Scotland over sure disaster as a result.
I will not share it all with you, you must now get the book yourself and read about this time in history. I am so very happy that I received such an excellent book for a review from such an accomplished author.
July 26, 2016
Medieval Scotland can have that haunting, mystical quality about it that calls to our deeper selves. In the days when Christianity just had a foothold on the borders and the word of a chieftain was more important than a distant king, Scotland was clawing its difficult way out of its pagan past. The ancient sect of Culdees, much removed from the medieval Pope, still practiced their secret knowledge at the time when the Bruce and Comyn clans were vying for the crown. Far away Edward Plantagenet was about to become the scourge of the Scots when we meet the playful Jamie Douglas, who teases and captures of the heart of Belle MacDuff and starts a love affair that carries them both through some of the most shattering events of any time.
Childhood ended early for James Douglas, whose own reckless behavior precipitated the surrender of Berwick to the ruthless Edward I. His father was eventually captured and brought to London where he met his untimely end. Belle was forced to marry the repugnant Tabhann Comyn to cement an alliance between her father and James’s enemy. James had no choice but to throw in his lot with his friend Robert Bruce, whose fortunes looked none too promising but whose destiny could not be denied. But the Black Douglas, as James was called, ultimately showed himself to be champion of his whole country against the rapacious English, whether his country liked it or not. And they certainly did not like it in the early days, when Comyn and his allies did everything in their power to destroy the wretched Robert Bruce. Only James and his undeniable will kept Robert alive, though at such a cost he never forgave his vacillating king or himself. More than once James was in a position where he had to choose between Robert or Belle—either save his king or abandon Robert and save his woman. Alas, Belle paid a bitter and tragic price for The Bruce’s kingship, for she was the unfortunate prisoner forced to live seven long years hung in a cage over conquered Berwick. How any person could last through such a trial is beyond my understanding. She was most certainly the most stalwart of the many strong Scottish women in James’s life. As Christiana, the Islandwoman who came to Robert’s aid said, “For you to prevail in this war, the women of your land must prove stronger than the men of your enemy.” And so it did prove—though Isabella, queen of Edward II, was no slouch, herself.
This novel is rich in folklore, with occasional moments when our characters get caught up in their superstitions. These moments are delicious and serve to enhance the brooding atmosphere, while reminding us why they cling so tenaciously to their ancient rights. Alas, the history of The Bruce is long and arduous, and it’s very difficult to lighten up its telling. I found it hard to get through to the end, but I’m glad I finished for it is a story worth knowing.
Childhood ended early for James Douglas, whose own reckless behavior precipitated the surrender of Berwick to the ruthless Edward I. His father was eventually captured and brought to London where he met his untimely end. Belle was forced to marry the repugnant Tabhann Comyn to cement an alliance between her father and James’s enemy. James had no choice but to throw in his lot with his friend Robert Bruce, whose fortunes looked none too promising but whose destiny could not be denied. But the Black Douglas, as James was called, ultimately showed himself to be champion of his whole country against the rapacious English, whether his country liked it or not. And they certainly did not like it in the early days, when Comyn and his allies did everything in their power to destroy the wretched Robert Bruce. Only James and his undeniable will kept Robert alive, though at such a cost he never forgave his vacillating king or himself. More than once James was in a position where he had to choose between Robert or Belle—either save his king or abandon Robert and save his woman. Alas, Belle paid a bitter and tragic price for The Bruce’s kingship, for she was the unfortunate prisoner forced to live seven long years hung in a cage over conquered Berwick. How any person could last through such a trial is beyond my understanding. She was most certainly the most stalwart of the many strong Scottish women in James’s life. As Christiana, the Islandwoman who came to Robert’s aid said, “For you to prevail in this war, the women of your land must prove stronger than the men of your enemy.” And so it did prove—though Isabella, queen of Edward II, was no slouch, herself.
This novel is rich in folklore, with occasional moments when our characters get caught up in their superstitions. These moments are delicious and serve to enhance the brooding atmosphere, while reminding us why they cling so tenaciously to their ancient rights. Alas, the history of The Bruce is long and arduous, and it’s very difficult to lighten up its telling. I found it hard to get through to the end, but I’m glad I finished for it is a story worth knowing.
September 11, 2015
Sons of Scotland, take me away!
Some ladies desire scented flimsy bubbles when they wish to escape or relax at stressful times but for me, just give me roaring men with Claymores and Lochaber axes battling on the fog draped Highlands of Scotland. I could never say no if offered that and if you can afford it, give me: thunders of war, battles of allegiances, history come alive, moments when I can hear powerful and emotional notes of tradition and finally if you can- give me romance worthy of Shakespeare. If anyone can provide me with all of these aforementioned elements and details, they rightly deserve applause and have earned a humble lady’s recommendation; and that’s exactly what Mr. Craney has done with this brilliant novel that has taken my breath away and has become one read I sorely wish I enjoyed sooner. Never underestimate the persuasion or importance of reading a good book blurb or sadly in my case paying attention to a bad one. After seeing a very brief early description of this novel on another site, I honestly thought this title was going to turn into a silly superficial romp into the 13th-14th century and I am ashamed to say, I overlooked this work based entirely on that disappointing false summary and almost missed this striking experience.
I absolutely love to be proved wrong and surprised with types of stories and The Spider and the Stone: A Novel of Scotland’s Black Douglas wasted no time to capture my attention and prove its worth as this tale spun history, ancient legends and vibrant imagination together and I couldn’t wait to pick up my kindle and rejoin the epic action and intrigue filled chapters. The further I found myself drawn into this tale of the deadly dance between Scotland and England during the 13th-14th centuries, I couldn’t help but notice this novel reminded me of familiar and treasured cinematic and literary entertainments. However similar to those certain entertainments this title takes the best of those works and improves the faults with shading in lines, adding dedicated research and admitting creative liberties to create a memorable experience that is sure to stand beside this reader’s favorites as it continues to reveal different little pieces of symbolism and messages that I’m sure will stay burning in my mind for days to come.
~*~for more reviews see: http://www.asthefinalpageturns.blogsp...
Some ladies desire scented flimsy bubbles when they wish to escape or relax at stressful times but for me, just give me roaring men with Claymores and Lochaber axes battling on the fog draped Highlands of Scotland. I could never say no if offered that and if you can afford it, give me: thunders of war, battles of allegiances, history come alive, moments when I can hear powerful and emotional notes of tradition and finally if you can- give me romance worthy of Shakespeare. If anyone can provide me with all of these aforementioned elements and details, they rightly deserve applause and have earned a humble lady’s recommendation; and that’s exactly what Mr. Craney has done with this brilliant novel that has taken my breath away and has become one read I sorely wish I enjoyed sooner. Never underestimate the persuasion or importance of reading a good book blurb or sadly in my case paying attention to a bad one. After seeing a very brief early description of this novel on another site, I honestly thought this title was going to turn into a silly superficial romp into the 13th-14th century and I am ashamed to say, I overlooked this work based entirely on that disappointing false summary and almost missed this striking experience.
I absolutely love to be proved wrong and surprised with types of stories and The Spider and the Stone: A Novel of Scotland’s Black Douglas wasted no time to capture my attention and prove its worth as this tale spun history, ancient legends and vibrant imagination together and I couldn’t wait to pick up my kindle and rejoin the epic action and intrigue filled chapters. The further I found myself drawn into this tale of the deadly dance between Scotland and England during the 13th-14th centuries, I couldn’t help but notice this novel reminded me of familiar and treasured cinematic and literary entertainments. However similar to those certain entertainments this title takes the best of those works and improves the faults with shading in lines, adding dedicated research and admitting creative liberties to create a memorable experience that is sure to stand beside this reader’s favorites as it continues to reveal different little pieces of symbolism and messages that I’m sure will stay burning in my mind for days to come.
~*~for more reviews see: http://www.asthefinalpageturns.blogsp...
September 24, 2019
The Spider and the Stone is a quasi-fictional/historical account of Robert de Bruce's reign. The book begins around early 1300 A.D. in Scotland. William Wallace (think Mel Gibson/Braveheart) has died a most horrific hanging/disembowelment, leaving Scotland wide open for a new ruler. The Scottish clans are feuding among themselves while England (King Edward/Longshanks) is vying for control. The hero of this true tale is Black Douglas, or Jamie Douglas, who sides with Robert the Bruce to gain peace among the nation while driving back the English. But the peace doesn't last long.
The title is taken from a famous Scottish legend about Jamie Douglas who is losing. His men are outnumbered, out-financed, and out-weaponed. While sitting in a cave, he sees a spider who is unsuccessfully building a web. The spider never gives up and creates a beautiful masterpiece. In Scottish lore it is Robert the Bruce who was inspired by the spider, and not Jamie Douglas, but all the same, it changed Scotland's future. In the end, if you know your history, Robert's son David becomes Scotland's king at the age of five.
My Review:
This book had everything-tons of history and research, great writing, romance, and a few additional characters Mister Craney threw into the story to make things even more interesting. I especially found the Culdees fascinating. This sect of Druids are said to be the original Christians within Europe-not the Catholics. As a KT buff, I loved the role the Templars played after they were excommunicated from France. Craney gave the Black Douglas a love interest that worked well throughout the story. Other real characters I enjoyed learning about were Isabella from France and the Comyn clan. This is a MUST read for history lovers. I've read Craney's books before and they are all great, but this one is my favorite to date. 5/5 Stars.
The title is taken from a famous Scottish legend about Jamie Douglas who is losing. His men are outnumbered, out-financed, and out-weaponed. While sitting in a cave, he sees a spider who is unsuccessfully building a web. The spider never gives up and creates a beautiful masterpiece. In Scottish lore it is Robert the Bruce who was inspired by the spider, and not Jamie Douglas, but all the same, it changed Scotland's future. In the end, if you know your history, Robert's son David becomes Scotland's king at the age of five.
My Review:
This book had everything-tons of history and research, great writing, romance, and a few additional characters Mister Craney threw into the story to make things even more interesting. I especially found the Culdees fascinating. This sect of Druids are said to be the original Christians within Europe-not the Catholics. As a KT buff, I loved the role the Templars played after they were excommunicated from France. Craney gave the Black Douglas a love interest that worked well throughout the story. Other real characters I enjoyed learning about were Isabella from France and the Comyn clan. This is a MUST read for history lovers. I've read Craney's books before and they are all great, but this one is my favorite to date. 5/5 Stars.
June 9, 2020
Fiction and Fantasy Combine for an Intriguing Story of Scotland’s Independence
Set in the late 13th and 14th centuries, this is the story of Sir James Douglas (“the Black Douglas”) who aligned himself with Robert the Bruce and became a hero on the battlefield.
Graney brings us some wonderful characters, not all of whom are real historical figures, and some delightful episodes of fantasy. I loved the Culdees and their defiance of the Roman Catholic church. And the Scottish women and one from France rise to the fore. Great dialog and some wonderful one liners added to the story, too.
While there is no historical record of it, this version makes a love match out of Douglas and Isabelle (Isabella in history) McDuff, Countess of Buchan, who was married to a Comyn. The beginning where Queen Isabel of England (who was French) is retelling the tale to James Douglas’ son seemed an unnecessary add to what was a good tale by itself. Another detractor was the “head-hopping”, or jumping from one person’s point of view to another’s without a change of scene.
The battle scenes are well done and James Douglas gets in some fictional but wonderful quips when taunting the English. The kings of England named Edward all come off badly, cruel and perverted, which they were. Surprising to me, Robert the Bruce comes across as a melancholy, weak-kneed, reluctant king. Douglas is his backbone.
It’s a well-written story full of excitement, intrigue, betrayal and treachery. It held my interest and will inspire you to praise the courage of the Scots who only wanted freedom from the English.
Set in the late 13th and 14th centuries, this is the story of Sir James Douglas (“the Black Douglas”) who aligned himself with Robert the Bruce and became a hero on the battlefield.
Graney brings us some wonderful characters, not all of whom are real historical figures, and some delightful episodes of fantasy. I loved the Culdees and their defiance of the Roman Catholic church. And the Scottish women and one from France rise to the fore. Great dialog and some wonderful one liners added to the story, too.
While there is no historical record of it, this version makes a love match out of Douglas and Isabelle (Isabella in history) McDuff, Countess of Buchan, who was married to a Comyn. The beginning where Queen Isabel of England (who was French) is retelling the tale to James Douglas’ son seemed an unnecessary add to what was a good tale by itself. Another detractor was the “head-hopping”, or jumping from one person’s point of view to another’s without a change of scene.
The battle scenes are well done and James Douglas gets in some fictional but wonderful quips when taunting the English. The kings of England named Edward all come off badly, cruel and perverted, which they were. Surprising to me, Robert the Bruce comes across as a melancholy, weak-kneed, reluctant king. Douglas is his backbone.
It’s a well-written story full of excitement, intrigue, betrayal and treachery. It held my interest and will inspire you to praise the courage of the Scots who only wanted freedom from the English.
September 26, 2016
This is one of the best historical fiction novels I have read in a long time. The characters are so real that I found myself getting angry with them, crying with them and loving or disliking them. At first I was worried when I saw the long list of characters at the beginning - a little daunting BUT Glen Craney did a remarkable job of creating all the characters that I didn't get lost as to who was who. We all have been there - when there are so many characters that we get lost. That is definitely not the case here.
The story takes place in the 14th century. Scotland is in turmoil within itself and England is invading. A young boy who is puny and mocked by his piers wins a race and falls in love all in a day. James Douglas grows to be a very important part of Scotland's history. Black Douglas as he is eventually called is responsible for much of Scotland's successes during this period of time. I won't go into more because that would be revealing spoilers.
The Spider and the Stone is a wonderful weaving of history, adventure, love, conflict and more. I highly recommend it to all readers even if historical fiction is not one of the genre's you read often. This book just might change your mind.
I received this book from the author for review purposes. To find out more about Glen Craney and his books check here http://www.glencraney.com/
The story takes place in the 14th century. Scotland is in turmoil within itself and England is invading. A young boy who is puny and mocked by his piers wins a race and falls in love all in a day. James Douglas grows to be a very important part of Scotland's history. Black Douglas as he is eventually called is responsible for much of Scotland's successes during this period of time. I won't go into more because that would be revealing spoilers.
The Spider and the Stone is a wonderful weaving of history, adventure, love, conflict and more. I highly recommend it to all readers even if historical fiction is not one of the genre's you read often. This book just might change your mind.
I received this book from the author for review purposes. To find out more about Glen Craney and his books check here http://www.glencraney.com/
September 20, 2016
One of the issues I usually have with historical fiction is that often the scenarios and backdrops described in a story don't quite have the historical accuracy and detail that they really need in order to effectively blend in the fictional aspect. This book does not have this problem in any way. Craney's extensive research and attention to detail comes through during the entire book. His vivid descriptions of the passion of the Scottish people were emotional and powerful. The battle scenes are exciting and well written.
As this was my first time visiting this specific period of history, I found that I had very little trouble following the events described, and was completely wrapped up in this book as it drew me in. I had actually set aside some time from my schedule in order to be able to read through this in one sitting and I am so glad I did. It is a perfect blend of history, adventure, love, and faith. I look forward to reading more of Mr. Craney's books in the future!
As this was my first time visiting this specific period of history, I found that I had very little trouble following the events described, and was completely wrapped up in this book as it drew me in. I had actually set aside some time from my schedule in order to be able to read through this in one sitting and I am so glad I did. It is a perfect blend of history, adventure, love, and faith. I look forward to reading more of Mr. Craney's books in the future!
September 8, 2015
Craney brings Black Douglas to life in The Spider and the Stone. Brutal and epic in scope, this novel gives new insights into the personalities of the Scottish War for Independence. Douglas is a sympathetic character, a principled and aggressive man who must work to keep his wavering would-be king on the throne. Yet, must he sacrifice his love for Isabel to do so? It's a compelling read, one which will stick with you for a long time. Highly recommended.
Want to read
May 4, 2015Opening: NORFOLK, ENGLAND, FEBRUARY 1358: Lashed by a morning sleet storm, William Douglas paced behind the frozen earthworks that guarded Castle Rising, an old royal mint so grim and neglected that it made London Tower seem hospitable.
Thanks Wanda, lovely of you!
dnf
October 7, 2021Look, I'm just going to have to give up on this book for now. While I'm not not enjoying this - the book is over 1,000 pages on my e-reader and I'm finding it too hard to keep track of. I've been uninspired to pick it up for over a year so I'm calling it quits. Maybe I'll give it a go in the future again, but for now, I'm admitting defeat and putting this aside.
July 9, 2015
Edward Longshanks, the king of England, has invaded Scotland. Scottish subjects had suffered severely from the English tyranny. With the death of William Wallace, also known as Braveheart, many had lost hope of Scotland ever being free. However, two people, James Douglas and Isabella MacDuff, fight to defy the English, and to place their own king, Robert the Bruce, on the Scottish throne. This inspires the Scottish people to take up arms against the English, and to fight for their independence.
The two main characters in this novel are James Douglas and Isabella MacDuff. James is furious against the English when they killed his father for treason because of fighting with William Wallace, and sacked his home. He decides to work under Bishop Lamberton because the bishop is a staunch fighter for Scotland’s independence, and chooses his best friend, Robert the Bruce, as his rightful king. He also holds a loyal and unwavering love for Isabella.
Isabella is a MacDuff, and the Scottish contract states that a MacDuff chooses who is to be the King of Scotland. Because of her lineage, Isabella was born to be a pivotal pawn to those who covet the Scottish crown. However, Isabella takes matters into her own hands and decide the destiny of Scotland. She is strong-willed and very outspoken. She is not afraid to stand up against the English king. She is also very compassionate and selfless and would often sacrifice her own happiness for those of others. She has deep love for James because she is willing to leave her husband and family to be with James and his cause.
The story is brilliantly told. The setting of Scotland is very lush, and their culture and history comes alive. James is a classic underdog, who the readers root for to save Scotland. His friendship with Robert the Bruce is very realistic and true. While their friendship was complicated with a few fallouts, they never stopped being friends. They trusted each other and believed in each other. I also loved the romance between James and Isabella. Their star-crossed romance was very reminiscent of Romeo and Juliet.
Overall, this book is filled with hope, friendship, forbidden love, and their patriotic love to their country. The message of the book is to never given up even if it seems impossible. I also like how the story showed it was the strength of the Scottish women that helped the men win their independence. The characters are very complicated, and the setting is beautiful. While there are some scenes that seem unnecessary and the plot is slow-paced and often drawn out, the story is worth reading because the story itself comes alive. I recommend this book to anyone who is interested in Scottish history, culture, or anyone who is interested in the after events of William Wallace.
(Note: This book was given to me in exchange for an honest review.)
The two main characters in this novel are James Douglas and Isabella MacDuff. James is furious against the English when they killed his father for treason because of fighting with William Wallace, and sacked his home. He decides to work under Bishop Lamberton because the bishop is a staunch fighter for Scotland’s independence, and chooses his best friend, Robert the Bruce, as his rightful king. He also holds a loyal and unwavering love for Isabella.
Isabella is a MacDuff, and the Scottish contract states that a MacDuff chooses who is to be the King of Scotland. Because of her lineage, Isabella was born to be a pivotal pawn to those who covet the Scottish crown. However, Isabella takes matters into her own hands and decide the destiny of Scotland. She is strong-willed and very outspoken. She is not afraid to stand up against the English king. She is also very compassionate and selfless and would often sacrifice her own happiness for those of others. She has deep love for James because she is willing to leave her husband and family to be with James and his cause.
The story is brilliantly told. The setting of Scotland is very lush, and their culture and history comes alive. James is a classic underdog, who the readers root for to save Scotland. His friendship with Robert the Bruce is very realistic and true. While their friendship was complicated with a few fallouts, they never stopped being friends. They trusted each other and believed in each other. I also loved the romance between James and Isabella. Their star-crossed romance was very reminiscent of Romeo and Juliet.
Overall, this book is filled with hope, friendship, forbidden love, and their patriotic love to their country. The message of the book is to never given up even if it seems impossible. I also like how the story showed it was the strength of the Scottish women that helped the men win their independence. The characters are very complicated, and the setting is beautiful. While there are some scenes that seem unnecessary and the plot is slow-paced and often drawn out, the story is worth reading because the story itself comes alive. I recommend this book to anyone who is interested in Scottish history, culture, or anyone who is interested in the after events of William Wallace.
(Note: This book was given to me in exchange for an honest review.)
September 25, 2015
First off I must say Robert Bruce has to be one of my favourite historical figures. I’ve not read much on the subject of the Scottish Wars of Independence but the little I know has always fascinated me.
This book focuses on James Douglas otherwise known as Black Douglas. I won’t lie.. I knew nothing of the man. Everything I’ve read always focuses on either Robert Bruce or William
Wallace (who also makes an appearance in this book) so it was great to read a story focused on someone else
Glen has written this book starting from James and his boyhood years and admits filling in some of the gaps in Douglas’s life where we just don’t have any information to go on. I know some people don’t like when authors speculate but I believe this is where authors shine.. and Glen is no exception
One of the best parts throughout the books was the relationship between Isabelle MacDuff and
James, the author explains why he decided to write that a relationship between the two could have existed and it made for an excellent and plausible read, it gave real depth to the story
Throughout the book we see the stress James is put under, which threatens his relationship with both Isabelle and Robert. I can’t imagine what it would have been like but Glen manages to get across how hard it must have been at time for the people of Scotland.
I really liked how Glen managed to bring everything to life.. the period, the setting, the people. It brought home that although some of this book maybe fiction that the overall subject of Scotland versus England actually happened and has sowed the seed in me to read more on the subject.
I’d highly recommend this book, it has everything you could want, war, love, death, betrayal, patriotism and some awesome dogs (Cull & Chullan, I loved those mutts)
My only advice to the reader is to make sure you read the authors notes at the end of the book. I always think it’s important to distinguish fact from fiction. Personally I think what Glen added to this book just gave something extra to the tale that made it the gripping read it was and hopefully you’ll agree
This book focuses on James Douglas otherwise known as Black Douglas. I won’t lie.. I knew nothing of the man. Everything I’ve read always focuses on either Robert Bruce or William
Wallace (who also makes an appearance in this book) so it was great to read a story focused on someone else
Glen has written this book starting from James and his boyhood years and admits filling in some of the gaps in Douglas’s life where we just don’t have any information to go on. I know some people don’t like when authors speculate but I believe this is where authors shine.. and Glen is no exception
One of the best parts throughout the books was the relationship between Isabelle MacDuff and
James, the author explains why he decided to write that a relationship between the two could have existed and it made for an excellent and plausible read, it gave real depth to the story
Throughout the book we see the stress James is put under, which threatens his relationship with both Isabelle and Robert. I can’t imagine what it would have been like but Glen manages to get across how hard it must have been at time for the people of Scotland.
I really liked how Glen managed to bring everything to life.. the period, the setting, the people. It brought home that although some of this book maybe fiction that the overall subject of Scotland versus England actually happened and has sowed the seed in me to read more on the subject.
I’d highly recommend this book, it has everything you could want, war, love, death, betrayal, patriotism and some awesome dogs (Cull & Chullan, I loved those mutts)
My only advice to the reader is to make sure you read the authors notes at the end of the book. I always think it’s important to distinguish fact from fiction. Personally I think what Glen added to this book just gave something extra to the tale that made it the gripping read it was and hopefully you’ll agree
February 1, 2015
I don't think I've met a single person who hadn't seen the movie Braveheart. At the end of the film it mentions how Scotland came back and retook their land after Wallace's death. Ever wondered how they did that?
The main character of this historical tale is James Douglas, otherwise known as the Black Douglas. He has more than enough reasons to hate the English - or rather, King Edward Longshanks.
I will note that this is not an academic historical and is written as fiction. Fiction with far less inaccuracies than "Braveheart"! Because it takes place in the late 1200's and early 1300's, history can be a bit disjointed and different stories are told by different countries. The author brought together both the historical timelines and used some of his creative license to fill in grey areas or assumptions. I liked the political schemes, the new romance, the new points of view (especially Isabella of France) and the epic battles that took place over the course of many years.
Driven by a timeline, it can be a bit long as it's telling a story of a rather mixed and layered lifetime but Craney also breathes life into names, titles and battles that when reading a textbook can be daunting.
The intrigue brought on by Isabella of France, the constant battle for Scotland and learning a bit more about the history behind the War of Independence was fascinating. The author did a lot of homework on this one and I'm very happy to have read it.
Full Review @ thereadershollow.com
The main character of this historical tale is James Douglas, otherwise known as the Black Douglas. He has more than enough reasons to hate the English - or rather, King Edward Longshanks.
I will note that this is not an academic historical and is written as fiction. Fiction with far less inaccuracies than "Braveheart"! Because it takes place in the late 1200's and early 1300's, history can be a bit disjointed and different stories are told by different countries. The author brought together both the historical timelines and used some of his creative license to fill in grey areas or assumptions. I liked the political schemes, the new romance, the new points of view (especially Isabella of France) and the epic battles that took place over the course of many years.
Driven by a timeline, it can be a bit long as it's telling a story of a rather mixed and layered lifetime but Craney also breathes life into names, titles and battles that when reading a textbook can be daunting.
The intrigue brought on by Isabella of France, the constant battle for Scotland and learning a bit more about the history behind the War of Independence was fascinating. The author did a lot of homework on this one and I'm very happy to have read it.
Full Review @ thereadershollow.com
August 23, 2019
I have always been intrigued by the story of Robert the Bruce and yet he seemed a shadowy figure, but the Black Douglas, or James Douglas the Good, as the Scots called him, is an even more mysterious character. In this saga, Glen Craney interweaves, known facts with imagination and mysticism to play out the tortuous life of love and devotion of James Douglas. Ever loyal to his friend and later King, Robert, he suspends his own happiness for the sake of Scotland. In Isabelle Macduff he has found his one true love, but she also puts her country before her own desires.
This is a story of guerrilla warfare, skirmishes and bloody battle. The cruelty of the English Kings and disloyal Scots is met by brotherhood, sacrifice and persistence. The intensity of the plot is lightened by fascinating historical figures such as the She-Wolf, Isabella of France, who married an unworthy English King, and humour is provided by Ned Sweeney, the lively and faithful monk.
The intense suffering of the women is matched by the heroism and violent death of so many of the soldiers. Every scene rings true as if you were there struggling through the mud or shivering in a castle too, and I wanted James and Belle to find a way to free Scotland and themselves. A recommended read for those who wish to know more about early Scottish history and the hand of fate.
This is a story of guerrilla warfare, skirmishes and bloody battle. The cruelty of the English Kings and disloyal Scots is met by brotherhood, sacrifice and persistence. The intensity of the plot is lightened by fascinating historical figures such as the She-Wolf, Isabella of France, who married an unworthy English King, and humour is provided by Ned Sweeney, the lively and faithful monk.
The intense suffering of the women is matched by the heroism and violent death of so many of the soldiers. Every scene rings true as if you were there struggling through the mud or shivering in a castle too, and I wanted James and Belle to find a way to free Scotland and themselves. A recommended read for those who wish to know more about early Scottish history and the hand of fate.
December 28, 2014
Set during the time of Scotland’s struggles with England and its iron-fisted ruler, Edward Longshanks, Craney’s novel is a saga that spans the English Channel, and goes from the chill tower strongholds of Scotland to the grand courts of Edward I and King Philip IV of France. He gleefully leads readers into a believable medieval world where a king’s displeasure can get a room full of women palpably terrified for their lives (and the reader with them) as Longshanks – as diabolical a villain as any reader could want – decides whether to lock them up or hang them out in a metal basket to brave the elements and missiles hurled by any passerby. Its chock-a-block full of intrigue, battles, romance and subterfuge, and at times made my heart stutter with terror for its two protagonists, as they sought to save those they loved, possibly find a little happiness together, and survive one of early England’s most tumultuous periods. If you enjoy historicals mixed with a little myth and magic, this one’s a fun read.
Complete review here: https://cynthiarobertson.wordpress.co...
Complete review here: https://cynthiarobertson.wordpress.co...
April 14, 2015
I've been a fan of Craney's since reading the first edition of The Firer and the Light about ten years ago, and I've looked forward to each of his books since then. "Spider & Stone" is his best work yet, but I suspect there is more to come given his mastery of the historical fiction genre.
Craney sets the book in one of the most interesting periods of English - Scottish conflict, the end of the Fourteenth Ccentury. Edward Longshanks of England (who has become one of historical fiction's favorite villains since Mel Gibson's Braveheart) is determined to wrest control of the North from Robert the Bruce. James Douglas will not have it. Our Scottish hero does resemble Mel Gibson's inaccurate portrayal of William Wallace -- in the best sense; he's brave and noble and committed to defeat the the Plantagenet kings by any means necessary. Of course the tale reaches a bloody denouement on the field of Bannockburn. The hearts of Scots and lovers of sweeping historicals will thrill to this epic of the Scottish Wars of Independence.
Craney sets the book in one of the most interesting periods of English - Scottish conflict, the end of the Fourteenth Ccentury. Edward Longshanks of England (who has become one of historical fiction's favorite villains since Mel Gibson's Braveheart) is determined to wrest control of the North from Robert the Bruce. James Douglas will not have it. Our Scottish hero does resemble Mel Gibson's inaccurate portrayal of William Wallace -- in the best sense; he's brave and noble and committed to defeat the the Plantagenet kings by any means necessary. Of course the tale reaches a bloody denouement on the field of Bannockburn. The hearts of Scots and lovers of sweeping historicals will thrill to this epic of the Scottish Wars of Independence.
March 27, 2018
An excellent book that fleshes out real history of the beginnings of the War of Roses and Scotland's emergence as a power in her own right. It is a very thorough "study" of this period from the standpoints of power in Scotland, England, France and the turbulence of the time. This is a complex read, but so well written that you alternatively can't put it down and don't want it to end. It deals with the Lairds of the Scot clans and the internecine warring among them. The great English King Edward I (Longshanks) Plantagenet is the antagonist. King Edward and his son Edward II and their line only faced one indomitable foe - Scotland and her emergent King, Robert the Bruce and his warlord, Jamie Douglas. You also find the duality of Christianity between the Roman and old Celtic Church and their desires for dominance. The book travels from the roots of the English Crown's fervent desire to control Scotland and the determination of her people not to be consumed by the Sassenachs. If this time in British history is of interest, I heartily recommend this book.
January 5, 2015
We are proud to announce that THE SPIDER AND THE STONE by Glen Craney is a B.R.A.G. Medallion Honoree. This tells a reader that this book is well worth their time and money!
August 18, 2020
I was truly surprised at how good this book was. I was expecting summer reading, but the history is absolutely intriguing to my Scottish heritage.
October 2, 2020
EPIC.🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠
September 29, 2018
*I received a free ARC of this book with thanks to the author. The decision to review and my opinions are my own.*
The Spider and the Stone is an epic and immersive fictional account of the Wars of Scottish Independence in the late 13th and early 14th centuries.
Following, and heroising, the exploits and trials of James ‘Black’ Douglas and Robert Bruce (of spider fame) as they try to free Scotland of the English reign of Edward I ‘Longshanks’ Plantagenet and his cruel henchman.
The narrative is fully sympathetic to the Scots cause and the English are portrayed as vacuous, lascivious, bloodthirsty or cowardly. However the author also balances the scales by vividly showing the Scottish in-fighting and jostling for land and position; some turning in whichever the way the wind blows their fortunes best.
There is an overarching theme here of loyalty. Where a man/woman’s loyalty lies and how far they will go in its name. There are conflicts here between religion, country, king (not necessarily the same as country!), family, love, friendship and tradition; all-powerful ties and each in opposition at various points in the narrative. Our main characters have to choose which loyalty they hold dearest, and pay the price in loss of the others.
The story covers almost a full lifetime, from Jamie Douglas’ childhood to his end, framed by the telling of his ‘truth’ to his ancestor by one who knew him well, the She-Wolf, Isabella, English Queen from France. The story touches on the peaks and troughs of events, skipping swathes of time in order to keep the narrative tension, touching on a mixture of political intrigue, personal relationships, and muddy action-packed battles. A bit of something for everyone!
Glen Craney brings this history to living, breathing, sympathetic life, so that you see the events unfolding and hold your breath that your favourites make it out of their many scrapes. I particularly favoured Sweeny, Belle and (of course) Black Douglas himself, and was so anxious on their behalf that I actually exclaimed aloud at some points in the plot, and shed a few tears at others.
Definitely recommended for fans of historical fiction, but also for anyone who enjoys a well-written, far-ranging story with actions, adventure and a bit of romance.
Isabella tapped the floor with the poker to reclaim their attention. She scratched a mark on the southeastern region of her map to indicate the location of a port city at the eastern crease where Scotland and England met. “Four years before this century turned, your throne fell empty and the clans commenced scrapping for it like charnel dogs over a carcass. Amid it all, the Leopard of England stalked the Borders, sniffing blood and champing to pounce when the Lion of Caledonia fell lame from self-inflicted wounds.”
The two men, beguiled by the strangeness of her bardic inflections, edged closer to better hear her.
“But one runt of a lad, inspired by a headstrong maid from Fife, would not sit prey for an easy clawing.”
Isabella stabbed at the crackling log as if gutting a combatant, forcing the earl to shield his eyes from the flying embers. She stared at the flames — was she scrying a memory vision? — and lowered her voice to a whisper taut with emotion. “Nay, sit prey Jamie Douglas would not. The stars had destined him to stalk the stalker.”
– Glen Craney, The Spider and the Stone
Review by Steph Warren of Bookshine and Readbows blog
https://bookshineandreadbows.wordpres...
The Spider and the Stone is an epic and immersive fictional account of the Wars of Scottish Independence in the late 13th and early 14th centuries.
Following, and heroising, the exploits and trials of James ‘Black’ Douglas and Robert Bruce (of spider fame) as they try to free Scotland of the English reign of Edward I ‘Longshanks’ Plantagenet and his cruel henchman.
The narrative is fully sympathetic to the Scots cause and the English are portrayed as vacuous, lascivious, bloodthirsty or cowardly. However the author also balances the scales by vividly showing the Scottish in-fighting and jostling for land and position; some turning in whichever the way the wind blows their fortunes best.
There is an overarching theme here of loyalty. Where a man/woman’s loyalty lies and how far they will go in its name. There are conflicts here between religion, country, king (not necessarily the same as country!), family, love, friendship and tradition; all-powerful ties and each in opposition at various points in the narrative. Our main characters have to choose which loyalty they hold dearest, and pay the price in loss of the others.
The story covers almost a full lifetime, from Jamie Douglas’ childhood to his end, framed by the telling of his ‘truth’ to his ancestor by one who knew him well, the She-Wolf, Isabella, English Queen from France. The story touches on the peaks and troughs of events, skipping swathes of time in order to keep the narrative tension, touching on a mixture of political intrigue, personal relationships, and muddy action-packed battles. A bit of something for everyone!
Glen Craney brings this history to living, breathing, sympathetic life, so that you see the events unfolding and hold your breath that your favourites make it out of their many scrapes. I particularly favoured Sweeny, Belle and (of course) Black Douglas himself, and was so anxious on their behalf that I actually exclaimed aloud at some points in the plot, and shed a few tears at others.
Definitely recommended for fans of historical fiction, but also for anyone who enjoys a well-written, far-ranging story with actions, adventure and a bit of romance.
Isabella tapped the floor with the poker to reclaim their attention. She scratched a mark on the southeastern region of her map to indicate the location of a port city at the eastern crease where Scotland and England met. “Four years before this century turned, your throne fell empty and the clans commenced scrapping for it like charnel dogs over a carcass. Amid it all, the Leopard of England stalked the Borders, sniffing blood and champing to pounce when the Lion of Caledonia fell lame from self-inflicted wounds.”
The two men, beguiled by the strangeness of her bardic inflections, edged closer to better hear her.
“But one runt of a lad, inspired by a headstrong maid from Fife, would not sit prey for an easy clawing.”
Isabella stabbed at the crackling log as if gutting a combatant, forcing the earl to shield his eyes from the flying embers. She stared at the flames — was she scrying a memory vision? — and lowered her voice to a whisper taut with emotion. “Nay, sit prey Jamie Douglas would not. The stars had destined him to stalk the stalker.”
– Glen Craney, The Spider and the Stone
Review by Steph Warren of Bookshine and Readbows blog
https://bookshineandreadbows.wordpres...
January 5, 2020
Outlander and Braveheart fans, this is your next read. Those of you who were able to keep all of the characters straight in Outlander will have no issue in this storyline. Albeit there are a lot of characters, the author graciously listed them out to help with following the lines of connection and give insight before jumping into this in depth historical novel.
This novel is written from the view point of James Douglas, also more known as Black Douglas and his love interest Belle MacDuff. The two meet during the vying for the crown, and unfortunately Belle is trapped in an unwanted marriage, which was not uncommon back then, and James has to then head to France. He soon becomes the symbol his country looks to, for defeat of the English.
James has a reason to hate the English, as they killed his own father. He is out for vengeance and blood, and will hold nothing back to help get his right hand friend, Robert the Bruce on the throne. The battle that James and Robert fought against, only proved the loyalty they had for their cause. During this, James is also fighting a battle within his emotions for his love of Belle. He often has to make decisions of either Belle or Robert.
Belle whoever, can also hold a candle all on her own. Having been born as a MacDuff, they chose who is to King of Scotland. Is Belle willing to risk her own livelihood and name for her lover and his crusade against the English? She quickly learns the battle that she will have to ensue to support James and prove her love and ally towards him. Will imprisionment break her, or does love always prevail in the end?
The novel is not for the faint of heart, and the author did a very good job of going in depth with scenes. Often I felt I was right there in the midst of battle with James, or was enduring the terrible things that happened to Belle.
This is the next chapter after Braveheart, for those who loved that movie and often wondered what happened next. Although this novel was long and I had to do a lot of googling of words and events- I learned a lot! It gave me more knowledge to build upon from Outlander and Braveheart.
I want to thank the author for providing me a free ebook copy for my honest review.
This novel is written from the view point of James Douglas, also more known as Black Douglas and his love interest Belle MacDuff. The two meet during the vying for the crown, and unfortunately Belle is trapped in an unwanted marriage, which was not uncommon back then, and James has to then head to France. He soon becomes the symbol his country looks to, for defeat of the English.
James has a reason to hate the English, as they killed his own father. He is out for vengeance and blood, and will hold nothing back to help get his right hand friend, Robert the Bruce on the throne. The battle that James and Robert fought against, only proved the loyalty they had for their cause. During this, James is also fighting a battle within his emotions for his love of Belle. He often has to make decisions of either Belle or Robert.
Belle whoever, can also hold a candle all on her own. Having been born as a MacDuff, they chose who is to King of Scotland. Is Belle willing to risk her own livelihood and name for her lover and his crusade against the English? She quickly learns the battle that she will have to ensue to support James and prove her love and ally towards him. Will imprisionment break her, or does love always prevail in the end?
The novel is not for the faint of heart, and the author did a very good job of going in depth with scenes. Often I felt I was right there in the midst of battle with James, or was enduring the terrible things that happened to Belle.
This is the next chapter after Braveheart, for those who loved that movie and often wondered what happened next. Although this novel was long and I had to do a lot of googling of words and events- I learned a lot! It gave me more knowledge to build upon from Outlander and Braveheart.
I want to thank the author for providing me a free ebook copy for my honest review.
September 4, 2019
A rollicking good read about James Douglas, more widely known as the Black Douglas and his lady love, Isabelle MacDuff. The time period is roughly starting in 1207 where the young Douglas meets Isabelle and their love story begins. James is instrumental in the fight for Scottish freedom from England and spends his life fighting beside Robert Bruce for this independence and trying to find his way back to his lady love.
This story is told in the narrative style by the Queen of England in her elderly years which brings the story to life as you live it thru her eyes. You are swept up in Scotland’s fight for freedom along with the trials and tribulations of both James and Isabelle. That is only half of the story as the queen has her own adventures to relive along with the many amazing characters and situations that keep you turning pages.
I loved this story and couldn’t stop reading. Not only is the star-crossed lovers’ story engrossing but all the characters have exploits that will keep you on the edge of your seat. If that isn’t enough to keep you reading, the time period during which Scotland fought for their independence is enthralling as you can’t help but root for the underdogs of Scotland to persevere. This book can be enjoyed by teen to adult readers and I highly recommend it.
This story is told in the narrative style by the Queen of England in her elderly years which brings the story to life as you live it thru her eyes. You are swept up in Scotland’s fight for freedom along with the trials and tribulations of both James and Isabelle. That is only half of the story as the queen has her own adventures to relive along with the many amazing characters and situations that keep you turning pages.
I loved this story and couldn’t stop reading. Not only is the star-crossed lovers’ story engrossing but all the characters have exploits that will keep you on the edge of your seat. If that isn’t enough to keep you reading, the time period during which Scotland fought for their independence is enthralling as you can’t help but root for the underdogs of Scotland to persevere. This book can be enjoyed by teen to adult readers and I highly recommend it.
April 22, 2019
All the characters in this book are Scotland’s legends even after almost one thousand years for taking on the English and their allies for attempting to subjugate Scotland. The countryside is littered with shattered castles and cairn stones dedicated to this battle or that. Stirling castle still stands as does the battlefield below it where William Wallace had his greatest victory. Much of this book is really conjecture with some of the relationships but many of the fights are public record. This is a big book, 1200 or more pages, and while the reader may tire of some of the guerilla skirmishes they worked for the Scots in the terrain they had to fight in. A satisfying read.
April 20, 2015
An interesting, well written tale of Scotland's early 14th century struggles. Mr. Craney did an excellent job of developing the character of James Douglas from a boy hood perspective. Pun intended, the story did seem to bog down in the peat of Scotland after the battle of Bannockburn. For me it was not unlike sitting in movie theater looking at my watch wondering if the movie would ever end. Eventually, the novel ended on an emotional note. Do read the author's notes at the end of the book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 95 reviews