3.5 stars
Jeremy Clarkson is, without a doubt, one of the best in the business when it comes to talking about cars, and, often, society as a whole with his signature mix of sharp humor, biting sarcasm, and complete disregard for political correctness.
The Top Gear Years is a collection of his columns spanning a decade, packed with hilarious observations and genuinely insightful takes on cars, culture, and the absurdities of modern life. Whether he’s ranting about speed limits, eco-warriors, or the latest supercar, Clarkson’s voice loud, hilarious, and purposefully offensive to damn near everyone. Some of the vignettes are downright brilliant, offering not just comedy but also genuine insight into the automotive world and society at large. His ability to weave car reviews with social commentary makes for some truly memorable moments that had me laughing harder than I thought possible, especially when he goes on at length about the amount of idiots in the world or the sheer stupidity of trying to stop terrorism on planes when trains are wide open and have zero security.
Furthermore, his true admiration of cars is on full display as he praises many of the classics as well as newer models, and even goes as far as to begrudgingly take James May’s advice, buy a baby Gallardo Lamborghini, and actually fall in love with it.
However, as entertaining as Clarkson is, the sheer volume of material does start to feel repetitive after a while. Since the book covers a decade’s worth of articles, certain themes and jokes begin to wear a bit thin, making it harder to sustain the same level of enjoyment all the way through. We get to be told more than a few times how much Clarkson hates the Porsche 911, or how terrible traffic cameras are, or how annoyed he is with British government and caravaners. All things that are easy to read in Clarkson’s signature and familiar voice, though also lose their humor after repeating multiple times.
Still, though, it is hard to find a journalist so unapologetic, yet knowledgeable and actually has a passion for the things he talks about. The Top Gear Years can grow to be too much as the collection nears its end, but you would be hard pressed to find such a consistent writer and observer like Clarkson.