The role of jazz as a catalyst in rock, pop, funk, new wave, hip-hop, and techno.
From music writer Alex Coles, Fusion! From Alice Coltrane to Moor Mother traces the origins and legacy of blended musical genres by focusing on twelve dynamic collaborations. From Alice Coltrane working with Carlos Santana in 1974 to Moor Mother sharing the mic with Wolf Weston in 2022, the collaborations-cum-chapters reveal how musicians pursue fusion as a process.
With sonic fusion always premised on cultural fusion, each of the collaborations find musicians using the mixing of genres to explore fusions of generations, eras, philosophies, sensibilities, idioms, histories, and even continents. When the musicians hail from contrasting musical genres their collaboration leads to a dynamic tension, typified by free jazz trumpeter Don Cherry recording with Lou Reed, Kendrick Lamar cutting tracks with saxophonist Kamasi Washington, Miles Davis playing with electric guitarist John McLaughlin and synth player Danalogue joining Shabaka Hutchings and Max Hallett to form the Comet is Coming.
Fusion! pushes the music of overlooked musicians—such as post-punk singer and saxophone player Lora Logic—to the fore while emphasizing overlooked aspects of the oeuvres of better-known figures such as Herbie Hancock, Joni Mitchell, Neneh Cherry and FourTet. To characterize their unique approach to fusion, each of the examples Coles explores are driven by a dynamic sonic principle coined by the musicians themselves.
so: first, the good! this is an excellent project as far as its historiography is concerned. plenty of links between relevant musical figures, as well as an in-depth, cross-referenced citation list involving biographies, interviews, lectures, and academic sources. this makes for an excellent envoy into a very broad understanding of the history of "jazz fusion" (loosely, because Coles troubles this term, rightly so). i also enjoyed seeing a combination of familiar artists and new ones (the playlist for this book is phenomenal, and on its own makes it worth the purchase), and placing them in relation to one another and to their own practice through the lens of collaboration, cooperation, compromise, and heritage. altogether, a lot to offer.
that being said: the bad... or meh. Coles doesnt seem to really know, at the root of it all, what constitutes "fusion", and because of this a number of contradictions emerge from his writing. fusion is a practice rather than an aesthetic category? cool, i am partial to that theory. but then to speak of it as the enmeshment of two or more other genres is to presuppose a certain aesthetic emerging at the grain of two other contoured aesthetics; which is to say, to call it a practice means you have to talk about how the artists practice their art, rather than discuss the sound "in itself" as exemplary of this relations (because then youre pulling it back towards an aesthetic understanding rather than a procedural one). and even if this is the case, there's no reason for fusion music to be the only case where this understanding of "genre" as practice occurs (this line of thought goes at least as far back as half a century ago...). i think its particularly bizzare to make these claims when dealing with the intersection of genres that are themselves already so malleable and fluid - jazz, hip-hop, electronic (dance music), etc - and practice-oriented (rather than aesthetic). not to mention that underlying this all are certain aesthetic presuppositions about what is necessary to underpin "fusion" (in broad and paraphrased strokes, Coles relies heavily on the presence of a somehow recogniseable "jazz" which is augmented or supplementary to another genre/practice). there seems to be an unspoken (and i'd argue, entirely arbitrary) aesthetic reason we don't see any discussion of supergroups in rock/RnB/metal/etc, and the type of "fusion" that emerges from those interactions (for instance, thinking through groups like The Sound of Animals Fighting, Isles and Glaciers, or Sufferer).
but, to mediate my own criticism, i may have walked into this read expecting something different. i wanted an academic/theoretical text, and i ought to have expected music criticism (most of these short, and to their credit digestible, essays come from other, more journalistic sources). nonetheless, the writing has consistent grammatical issues (predominantly with regards to maintaining tense within sentences), and could have done with more thorough editing.
Wow.com the way he interweaves beautiful analysis of sound, eg about the use of space in miles’ music particularly, with contextual background of the fusion processes was so intricate and gorgeous