100% a filler entry, but filler done right if that’s a thing.
This entry is a filler, not the first one in the series, but this is probably the entry with the least amount of combat and leveling.
However, that said, this still does a solid job developing the plot and characters of the series. The introduction ceremony was an interesting element. The restaurant scene was a chef’s kiss. Just what makes this series stand out from other LitRPG. And Jake relationships evolve here too, which is important I think.
To me what stands out in this series is that it is funny, that it’s detailed, and it’s grounded in real themes. There’s real exploration of morality and ethics which is barely, if ever, mentioned in other series.
In the end, with all of these series, we know the good guy wins in the end, but it’s the journey that we enjoy and why we come back. And though I think filler novels are ultimately a mistake that undermines an author’s audience, and why I rated this 4 stars, this is an example of if we have to have it, at least it can be interesting with some good laughs.
This is becoming my favorite LitRPG series. They are all similar in many ways, they all either have filler entries or they are being drawn out, so it comes down to what you as a reader enjoy. None of them are perfect, however, and neither is this one.
But I recommend after this Yip of Yore plot plays out that the author consider a big time jump. I don’t want to watch Jake plod through each grade. Let’s jump forward in time, let what happened in the intervening gap unfold throughout the new story without being summarized in exposition. That approach alone could be an interesting, unique and engaging strategy.
If, however, the author is planning this Yip story to play into later grades, then I’d give the same advice for after this Nevermore plot wraps up. Let’s skip ahead, no more fillers please 🙏!
I have read and am caught up with many of these series: HWFWM, Carl, Unbound, Defier, and Primal Hunter, and none of them are using time jumps. Carl doesn’t really count but all of the others could benefit from it as they are all stalling and treading water in my opinion. Carl is stalling in its own way just doing a floor per novel, but I digress.
This is pulp fiction, it’s power fantasy, it’s not literature. But even with those caveats, it stands above most of the rest of the genre. So I will continue to patronize our author and follow Jake’s path.