Brutal is a dark, dirty, and intense cat and mouse mafia romance between Pavel and Elizabeth. It is hard to determine who is playing who in this game. They both vow, to themselves, to trick each other so they can be together. Elizabeth Small is a 20-year-old snarky, virgin college student studying philosophy who attends a press conference about a large contributor (Pavel) to her university. Pavel Reznichenko is a 36 years old “entrepreneur” but in actuality is a morally grey mafia don. Pavel and Elizabeth share two eye catching moments during and after the press conference, but do not actually speak until he follows her and tries to give her a ride home. She agrees, but he takes Elizabeth to his home instead. Did she go willingly or was she abducted? Pavel takes many actions that could be considered questionable in the book. Not surprisingly, the author stuns us with multiple dubious consent moments, one being the losing of Elizabeth’s virginity. Pavel is not used to women refusing him, so he is confused by Elizabeth. Ultimately, she agrees, but not until after he says he will take her by force if needed. Other dubious consent moments include breaking and entering, stalking, hidden cameras, etc. Pavel is frequently frustrated with Elizabeth, and when he can’t get his way with her, he resorts to brute force.
We get a couple of clues about Elizabeth when, at the end of the Prologue, she calls her mother and asks for a favor, but we do not know what the favor was because it happens off the page. Later, we get more clues when Elizabeth’s mother is mentioned. It is not stated, but implied, that her mother is also affiliated with organized crime, but we never find out for sure. We just keep getting mentions of her mother every now and then, but they are all powerful moments. It is fitting, therefore, that her mother is mentioned again at the end of the book, but once again not being specific and leaving her mother a mystery.
The plot has many twists and kept me guessing what would happen next. There is lots of angst, tension, toxicity, witty banter, and spice simmering throughout. Although the story is brutal at times, it is all in context with the characters. Enough of Elizabeth and Pavel’s pasts were brought up to give insight into their characters. Some parts of the story might be shocking because of how brutal the relationship will become. Please check the trigger warnings and skip this book if it will make you uncomfortable, rather than give it a negative review. My last thought is that the author nailed it with the choice of a scary looking cover model with a dark background. It is easy to imagine the cover model as the character of Pavel.