Extraordinary. With the Scarlett & Browne books, we are seeing Jonathan Stroud display his prodigious writing talent, crafting books that make for an exquisite reading experience.
Building on the exciting first installment, this book further develops the titular outlaws as characters by making them face down the demons from their pasts. Each of them has parts of themselves they are eager to keep buried and suppressed – for Albert, it’s his frightening and lethal powers; for Scarlett, it’s the trauma that forged her into the badass she is today. They are both displeased with the other for not owning that part of themselves, leading to some trouble in paradise amid their otherwise rock-solid friendship. But when they find themselves in the deadly crosshairs of Scarlett’s former mentors and Albert’s dark reflection, they are forced to reckon with the parts of themselves they would rather hide away.
There is so much to love here. The characters received such an effective introduction in the first book, and it’s great watching them grow further here. More to the point, the first book cemented their relationship – the unyielding affection, the complete trust, and the funny ribbing between them. The great thing in this book is how the two of them, even while squabbling, always fall back on that – and how they never lose sight of priorities even when immensely frustrated with each other.
Everything in this book is firing on all cylinders. There are action setpieces that will leave your heart pounding. The world keeps expanding, as we see the glimmers of good amid countless atrocities in this dystopian England. Stroud leaves gentle indicators of where the series might go next, but tells satisfyingly complete stories within each book. And of course, there is plenty of humor, including a very funny execution sequence (not a term you often hear!) and some hilarious ballads about our favorite outlaws.
It must also be noted how effective Stroud is at writing denouements – a particular struggle among lots of fantasy books. It is neither an abrupt ending, leaving the reader scratching their head, nor a bloated series of farewells that overstays its welcome. One tidy chapter, twelve pages, wraps up the story, leaves the reader feeling warm and fuzzy inside, and builds excitement for the next book. This book was a pleasure to read from start to finish!
ETA: Upon a reread, this book remains just as impressive. Even knowing what's to come next, the action is still heart-pounding and had me feverishly turning the pages. Stroud's books are so good to reread because they are so exciting the first time, you just want to find out what happens; when rereading, you can luxuriate in the language and the descriptions. As a writer, Stroud's way with words is downright inspiring. His descriptions, his wry wit, his judicious world-building are an absolute masterclass.