Middle-earth Lore: Tolkien's Legends Revealed

by Jeb Smith, Lloyd R. Hedberg Jr (editor)

There are fans of J.R.R. Tolkien, and then there are those who would trade a genuine elven sword for a chance to visit Middle-earth. Those in the latter camp are certain to find Jeb Smith’s new vividly-illustrated book Middle-earth Lore to be a wonderfully satisfying quest worthy of even the geekiest Tolkienite—the “One book to rule them all.”Our journey begins by entering Tolkien’s mind, where we will come to realize that he did not consider himself the creator of Middle-earth but its discoverer. Tolkien desired that his tales be digested as historical events. We will then be walked through Peter Jackson's portrayal of The Lord of the Rings in his filmography, where there is much to praise – but also some sacrilegious exaggerations in dire need of mending.Tunneling deeper than Dwarves mining for Mithril, we'll expose the core—the very root of the mountain—that is the heart and soul of this Tolkien’s Legendarium. As we dig, be prepared for an unearthing and examination of many long-held assumptions, including those on subjects from the strength of the Valar, the Mumakil, Balrogs, and the Númenóreans, to the true identity of Gandalf and much more. In the concluding section, Smith provides an overview of the military prowess of Middle-earth's different realms and creatures during The War of the Ring. This chapter delves into the weapons, tactics, units, commanders and number of troops of the various realms, as well as the might of creatures such as trolls and ents and much more, offering a better understanding of the military aspect of Tolkien's renowned saga.As a result of our quest, our excavation leaves us with a distinct appreciation for why these clarifications of Lore are necessary to make Middle-earth truly come to life in all its inspired brilliance.

Paperback

Reviews

[Markus McDowell · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is one of many books written about J.R.R. Tolkien’s fiction. The author has written a previous book about Tolkien’s work, The Road Goes Ever On and On: A New Perspective on J. R. R. Tolkien and Middle-earth. This one focused on “Middle Earth” itself—the world inhabited by Tolkien’s characters and plots. Smith notes that Tolkien did not so much see that he was “world-building” as he was discovering a world. Perhaps Smith takes this too literally—this is how many of the best fiction writers describe writing—a partially mystical endeavor that often seems more about the story writing itself.

The book is thorough and detailed, drawing from The Hobbit, the Lord of the Rings trilogy, The Silmarillion, and other writings of Tolkien (fiction and nonfiction), as well as Peter Jackson's films based on The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, and even the artists who drew the lands and creatures of Middle Earth.

It is detailed and technical, and if you are not a “Tolkien nerd” (as the author writes), you might find it a bit too much so. If you love everything about mIddle Earth, you should read this book, which is a fine addition to the large corpus of material surrounding Tolkien’s classic works.

(Read a more detailed review at https://markusmcdowell.com/book-revie...)

[Chris · Rating 5 out of 5]

As a fan of Tolkien since the age of 12 (now 47), this was a very fun book to read. This is a great volume for those who have questions or want an easy to read, quick reference "encyclopedia" of Tolkien's world.

The author tackled a review of the LOTR movies, and then ignored the Hobbit films. While some may take issue with this, I believe he made the right decision. Keep in mind, there is no examination of the Amazon series, either, though I believe he might choose to avoid it altogether.

There is a lot of information in this book. This "thesis" work is less about an individual's opinions and more of connecting dots through the Ages of Middle-Earth. Each time he discusses an individual or group, his paints a picture of information from the entirety of what is available, not just a specific angle from a specific story. While there are many times when I thought, "Yes, I thought that," there are also many instances of, "Whoa, what? That's new information for me."

I only had one difficulty when reading the book. There are not a lot of breaks in the volume. There are only four chapters, which breaks off well. However, in chapter 4, I would have liked to see a little more consolidation of similar themes to break into one or more additional chapters. The chapter felt a bit like reading an encyclopedia (thus the statement earlier), instead of connected information. There are also a few instances of these smaller sections repeating information stated within a few previous pages.

But, don't let that stop you from grabbing this valuable resource. I am very grateful for the chance to have and read Middle-Earth Lore. It will be returned to often.

[Janae O'Shields · Rating 5 out of 5]

I received a complimentary copy of this book through LibraryThing’s Early Reviewers program; my review is voluntary.

Author Jeb Smith is clearly devoted to the work of Tolkien—not simply his bestselling fiction, but also his autobiographical writings. This is evidenced by his meticulously researched and presented explanations and commentary in this book. The text reads almost as a dissertation, and with such a level and depth of research. True fans will find great enjoyment and discussion points herein.

Be aware: Middle-earth Lore is not intended for the casual Tolkien consumer. If you fall into the category of “Just Watched the Movies,” you will be in over your head here.

[Isaac Bishop · Rating 5 out of 5]

In depth look into Middle-earth correcting many false assumptions and showing us Middle-earth as its author intended.