Fifty years after President Lyndon B. Johnson called for a War on Poverty and enlisted Sargent Shriver to oversee it, the most important social issue of our day is once again the dire economic straits of millions of Americans. 1 in 3 Americans today live in poverty or teeter on the brink. 70 million are women and the children who depend on them. The fragile economic status of millions of American women is the shameful secret of the modern era-yet these women are also our greatest hope for change, and our nation's greatest undervalued asset. The Shriver A Woman's Nation Pushes Back from the Brink asks-and answers-big questions. Why are millions of women financially vulnerable when others have made such great progress? Why are millions of women struggling to make ends meet even though they are hard at work? What is it about our nation-government, business, family, and even women themselves-that drives women to the financial brink? And what is at stake? To answer these questions, we examined in detail three major cultural and economic changes over the past 50 - Women work more outside the home, but still earn less than men. - Women lead more families on their own. - Women today need higher education to enter the middle class. To forge a path forward that recognizes this reality, The Shriver Report brought together a power packed roster of big thinkers and talented contributors, including Hillary Clinton, Anne-Marie Slaughter and Lebron James, and challenged them to collaborate with us to develop fresh thinking around practical solutions. This report's unique combination of academic research, personal reflections, authentic photojournalism, groundbreaking poll results, front line workers, and box office celebrities, is all focused on a single issue of national women and the economy. In The Shriver Report , Davos meets Main Street.
While the information and statistics are very useful and actually up-to-date, the fact that many of the pieces are written by those who hold privilege and power was disappointing. While it mentions the hard-working, persevering, and dedicated women who are striving to make the best of everything, the brief synopsis of them comes off disingenuous. Perhaps I expected more heart to be put into the book, or rather my own bias is just getting in the way, either way, this overview of women in the US comes from the viewpoint of those who aren't struggling or who have never struggled. I think an inclusion of more of these womens' stories told by them in their own words and perhaps even a list of available resources to women by state could have made this book leaps and bounds better. I do value it's significance and the work it took to bring such a book together though.
I received a copy of this book for free from the Library Thing Early Reviewers program. While I've spent years regularly visiting many feminist websites, I found this book refreshing in the way that it presented clear solutions to the problems it identified. A lot of the time so much energy gets devoted to raging about problems that it seems like no movement forward is ever made.
At the same time, it's a bit rage inducing that so many of these solutions proposed would cost so little, and yet it's obvious that they'll never be implemented in this current political and economic climate. The Report is really diplomatic in this sense - while it does note that there's extreme partisanship and a damaging affinity for capitalism above all else in this country, it hardly spends any time at all discussing how these two factors are hurting women. The Report provides data (about women, the work women do, and the families women have), identifies what our country needs to improve the lives of women and their families, and then presents specific fixes. The authors don't shame our policy makers or our employers, they don't point fingers or assign blame, they just say, "Here's where we stand, and here's our way out."
The Report does a great job discussing how women of color specifically are faring, something that often gets lost when discussing women as a whole. It also does a great job of demonstrating how women and their families who live in poverty, or one crisis away from poverty, aren't there because of laziness or wanting a "hand out." In the same vein as I noted above, they don't even explicitly make this point too much - they just let the numbers do the talking. One would be hard pressed to read this book and think, "These people are really failing themselves," rather than, "Wow, we are really failing these people."
I was reminded of the book Half the Sky, which had a global look at women's issues - both Half the Sky and this Report found that the key to a country's economic prosperity is investing in women. The more education and financial security a nation's women have, the more a country thrives. It's a message that America is ignoring right now at its own peril as it emphasizes profits at all costs, even when those costs are people.
Perhaps not meant to be read cover to cover, as many essays repeat the same stats (driving home the point, admittedly, but maybe for this reader too repetitive).
It was fun to hear from "celebrities" and Shriver clearly leveraged her connections very well to ensure diverse and compelling voices (come for the Beyonce, stay for the Erenreich).
An important piece of work regardless that's accessible, shareable, and critical.
Did a good job discussing the unique challenges of diverse women, and also balancing academics with those who have more skill at writing for a mainstream audience.
I received this book as part of the early reviewers on Library Thing.
As a 'non-American' I learned quite a lot from this report, especially concerning social security policies (and the lack thereof). The articles were clear and easy to understand, but since a large part of the book consists of short essays, some facts and words repeated themselves too much. Therefore I recommend reading a few essays at a time.
Nevertheless, the report gives a good insight in a sad truth. While we see ourselves as the rich west, poverty is a serious problem. I was especially shocked about the lack of social security in the US, policies I normally take for granted. For example, paid sick leave, a sufficient minimum wage or pregnancy leave are not standard in the US, which can be vital safety nets in the downwards spiral of poverty. The report gives good ideas how the government, businesses and women themselves can act to break this trend. I would have liked to see a bit more about how these policies can be changed in a economic way. Just throwing money at it, hoping it will gain more secondary benefits by increase in spending by the women it helps, does not work.
In the end, I give this report 4 stars. It is an interesting book which makes you think. The report does not throw difficult words at you and tries to show its message via a broad perspective of writers. From Hillary Clinton to experts to a single mom living in poverty, each of them get a chance to contribute. However due to the essays repeating themselves, the book does lose its message a bit. And some of the graphs are a bit confusing because they do not have axis titles.
I will implement the first step to power a woman's nation and share this book via bookcrossing.
I did not read this all the way through. I felt there were very strong and valid points in this report but after a while it became very repetitive and became more of a chore to read. I also found it disappointing that the women writing about struggling women were women of privilege. I wanted to hear from the women that live the life on the brink of poverty and let them have a voice.
A must read! It's even free for your Kindle at amazon! Amazing report - very accessible and with public, private, and individual recommendations. Filled with eye-opening and frightening stats, personal stories, essays by experts from many fields, and action plans to "push back from the brink." Please at least read the Executive Summary if not the entire report. www.shriverreport.org
This is an important issue for our present and future But, i can't say that i enjoyed this book as much as I'd hoped. Repetition may be good to get ideas to stick, but I would have liked to have seen some more varied and nuanced i felt that I just kept seeing the same nu,beta and the same analysis.
Great insight about women living on the brink. Goes into why so many of the people in poverty are women, how they get there, and ways they can get help. Also goes into ways in which we need to change our thinking of poverty and assistance programs that benefit women on the brink.
Interesting analysis of data to support the thesis that policy in the US is still modeled after families with one breadwinner and one stay-at-home parent. Great essays by LeBron James, Jennifer Garner, Jada Pinkett Smith and Hillary Rodham Clinton, and others.
A repetitive compilation of interesting information regarding women and the workforce. Takes too long to read cover to cover. I recommend you read another book and during a chapter break read an essay or two from this report.
This is a great read that really talks about the reality of women living on the brink of economic disaster. Anyone who thinks these women live this way by choice need to read this book.