Edit as of May 2021 — btw the author is a trans-man and uses he/him! I updated my review to use his current pronouns.
Old review beings:
This is a good book -- but not a very good romance novel. (if I could, I'd give it 2.5 stars because I feel like my massive 'eh'ness towards it overpowers most good feelings)
Some context: this is a piece of queer fiction published via a kickstarter project, which aimed to give fanfic authors a chance to publish their own original work. The author is this book is known by the web handle "gyzym," and I have been reading his work since 2005.
So, needless to say, I had a "shut up and take my money" reaction when I heard that they were publishing his stuff. In the past, he wrote some gorgeous reworked fairy tales, and I still wish I had a print copy of them.
This... isn't nearly as good.
Don't get me wrong -- there's good stuff in here. One particular scene, of two women having a shouting match over one's murder-cat, had me chuckling to myself. In general, I enjoy the take-that attitude towards wealthy suburbanites. Another good moment is lead woman B wearing a Halloween costume to compliment that of lead woman A, which I found very sweet.
I just wish there was more romance. It feels like an afterthought, developed in the margins. The book ends (spoilers, I guess) with a kiss between the two and tentative plans for a road trip.
In fact, what I found quite upsetting, is how lead woman A spends a significant chunk of the book having an affair with a married man. Which I find kind of gross (especially since it's later described as him using her as a toy which he throws away when he gets bored), and it's off-putting that the book handles it in such a blase manner. I know she does it to get over her abusive ex, but it still makes her kind of a shitty person, so I'm surprised that she's supposed to be one of our leads. Frankly, I feel like the other woman (the one I refer to as lead woman B) deserves better.
Plus I was upset by the lack of discussion about the fact that lead woman A has massive untreated anxiety issues. Apologizing all the time isn't healthy, and it isn't ok, and I'm disconcerted that it isn't really addressed.
Also lead woman B exhibits some meanness towards bi women/biphobia (looking back with regret about her 'fucking so many bicurious women' or some such) which I found bewildering, considering the author himself is bi. Which, on that note, lead woman A comes off as incredibly straight until she mentions "oh btw I'm bi" and even then, she just... doesn't feel like it.
Uhhh what else... There's some interesting stuff here, I imagine, about moving past an abusive partner -- or would be, if I didn't dislike the character so much. The book also has lead woman B struggling with her emotionally abusive parents, though I feel like this isn't really solved or on the path to being ok one day, by the end of the book.
Oh and I wish the illustrations were in colour. I know that'd be super expensive but I feel like they're not nearly as impressive in black and white.
So, yep. My overwhelming feelings towards this book is to be let down. I'm curious to see if this author gets more original stuff published -- he’s won my loyalty to a point that I'll still read whatever original stuff he does next (not his fanfic anymore, because his current otp is a NOTP of mine).
EDIT: I FORGOT TO ADD but the entire book is center-justified which... is kind of terrible at times. it results in the text l o o k i n g l i k e t h i s so short sentences can fit in the same space as the other paragraphs. It means the ebook is actually unreadable. also I found a typo at one point. so that's sure a thing.
(p.s. I made a new shelf - 'technically romance', because it's not romantic slop, but it also isn't good romance so it doesn't deserve a spot on my 'legit romance novels' shelf)