I came across this book when I was asked to interview the author for Missing Perspectives’ podcast Book Smart. I instantly said yes, of course — not only do I adore whales, but I especially love biology and anything related to wildlife, as that’s the path I wanted to go down before I became a writer (I actually did work experience at Taronga Zoo!). Thank you to New South for the arc.
I read Humpback Highway in about four hours (it’s a pretty short read), and I really enjoyed the science and ocean adventure elements — Pirotta’s enthusiasm for marine biology is infectious. However, it's interesting that some of the most intriguing elements of her story were the least explored (like when she says motherhood radically shifted her perspective as a whale scientist — um, tell me more!). I'm not sure why — maybe the purpose of this book was to be less autobiographical, more science-y, but I think Pirotta is a super interesting person so that was a shame! The good news is that I was able to just ask Pirotta myself about the parts of her story that I wanted to know more about, like the above and also her experience as a woman in STEM (she alludes to sexism in the workplace in the book but doesn’t elaborate much), but of course, that's not going to be the average reader experience.
From a more technical side, the book was quite repetitive at times, with certain phrases repeated in multiple chapters as if the author was being pushed to meet a word count. The structure was also odd too, though I think this has more to do with the editor.
There was something that was bothering me a little as I continued to read, and I think the problem is that the contents of this book could have been a meaty feature article or series of coloumns, but instead were stretched into a rather anemic book. If it was shorter and punchier, I think it would have been perfect.
Is it worth the read? Yes. Pirotta has all kinds of expertise to share about whales, and some pretty harrowing information on how climate change and ocean pollution threaten their existence. She is also just really cool, and I'm awaiting the day she gets her own David Attenborough-style docu-series!