Rating: 4.5 stars
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Tropes:
🎪Carnivale
🎪Witch/Necromancer
🎪Magic/Curiosities
🎪Found family
🎪Murder mystery
🎪Slow burn
🎪Gothic paranormal
🎪Elements of horror
Cricket Wakefield was gruesomely murdered, then brought back to life to perform alongside a cast of other revived cast members in a traveling carnival. For the first year of her revival, she’s asleep for reasons unknown. When she finally wakes, she has none of the “curiosities” her cast mates have, nor shows any sign of the gift she’s been foretold to have by the necromancer who brought her back. She was supposed to produce red roses from her body, but instead they’re black dahlias, a macabre reminder of her own demise. While she struggles to master her gift and earn her place in the carnival, a string of new murders comes to light in her hometown—and they’re all copycat murders just like hers, the victims blond and blue-eyed and left covered with rare black dahlias. Now Cricket and her friends are in a race against time to discover who the murderer is and conquer her own inner demons and traumas to allow her dahlias to become the red roses they should be before either the carnival is shut down, or someone she loves becomes the next victim.
This book was excellent. Brilliant. Incredible. Amazing. Show-stopping. Spectacular. Anyway, memes aside, this story really was awesome. The gothic horror elements woven into a tapestry of macabre carnivale was brilliant. The slow-burn romance, though the MMC is super flirty and has the hots for our FMC almost immediately, was very well executed. Their banter was always on point, never cringy. The found family of those at the carnival was beautiful. Our FMC Cricket is just so appropriate for lack of a better word. She’s so confused when she wakes on how she should feel about everything; should she just try to resume the life she had before she was murdered? Or take advantage of the one she has now? But at the same time, she’s not a Mary Sue just letting the plot happen to her. She’s an active participant in her life, she’s flirty and funny and determined to better herself and earn her keep. The MMC is so fun and over-the-top flirty. The one aspect I loved the most was the murder mystery. I’m a lover of true crime as it is, and this book despite being a romantasy first and foremost read almost like a nail-biting true crime investigation story. You’re left guessing and two steps behind the murderer the entire time, and false hints are dropped to mislead throughout. I had the wrong person pegged for almost half the book! The real murderer came as a shock to even me, and I predict the ending for most books these days even if I still love them.
The one and only downside I can find to this book is that it’s too short! I needed about 200 more pages to be fully satisfied. I feel like we could have had so much more tension build up and the reveal itself could have been a bit more drawn-out. As it stands now, it feels like we reveal the murderer, get the backstory, and BAM it’s all over and concluded within a few pages. I just wish we could have gotten a little more of everything, I was totally vibing in this world. And that’s not a bad criticism to have! No other notes. This book was so fun to read. I highly recommend!