A good if overdone concept, but execution was poor.
If the book had focused less on the whole ghostfinding story (quite irrelevant, an arc that leads nowhere) and less on characters that have little to do with the dead student, it would have been greatly improved. An exploration of the psyches and traumas of 鑫磊 and the dead student’s sister might not be too age appropriate, but the removal of these essential details leaves a large bulk of the story lifeless and monotonous. The portrayal of gay people as being “born as the other sex in their previous life” is rather laughable, though, and still puts forth heterosexuality as the ideal. The book seems aware of its preachiness, but the awareness of a problem doesn’t mean the absence of a problem. It’s especially hard to forget that the problem is there when the narrator reminds us that the book is preaching after every few pages or so.
There are some stretches of the book that are rather funny, but there’s a difference between laughing with a book and laughing at a book. I don’t know which one I was doing.
Again, there are certainly some good ideas here. 林老师’s lessons allude to the way people turn to religion in grief, with 大同’s disbelief and subsequent realisation that religion brings people comfort whether truthful or not being surprisingly deep for a children’s novel. However, once again, since we don’t connect with the people grieving, there isn’t enough investment for us to really care.
This book does have a saving grace, which is its ending. The last two chapters (ironically, this is when most of the characters are gone) are some rather well, and I actually liked the “now we can cry” idea, although again execution was a little shaky (the idea is passed of as part of a lover’s quarrel).
Instead of reading this book, people should simply watch the anime Anohana instead. The ideas of grief and letting go are more poignant, and I’d argue that the theme of innocence and experience present in Anohana is far more heartrending than whatever “technology is bad, look at how spoiled the youth are” message that 鹅卵石 seems to put forth.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Beautiful story about friendship and love with lots of turns and surprises to keep you guessing what the nature of this story about pebbles will be. The author accurately and humorously depicts a thirteen year old boy and his exciting journey in the discovering the truth about a 17 year old boy's death at a "forget your worries farm". The whimsy and teasing tone in many of the situations lightens up the mood of the book, especially for the heavy subjects with which it addresses that allows the topics to seem easier to discuss with young youth.
A little inappropriate for children reader for the first half. Some concepts among the plots can be misleading to the children's believe if lacking supervision. (Yes, almost all cartoons and comics are not real, but a novel based on actual location and culture is a little bit different.)
The story is pretty dark. Spiritual, ghostly happenings. I just can't understand how all the characters except one (the main character; my only connection in the book :( ) could believe the woman?! My family is very superstitious but I've never heard of a place where dead beloveds meet and discuss their reborn... Anyways, I love the character relationships here. There's so much discovery and friendship, and love. It's a slow book, but still overall, a good book.