I've been teaching about and working with consent issues since the 1990s myself, so I was thrilled to see this book geared toward tweens and teens. However, it had some technical problems and and I had a couple of disagreements with the arguments.
While a bright and colorful scheme may seem eye-catching and engaging, it actually made the small font type of most of the text challenging to read. Talking about consent in a world where so many of us lack the power to have many choices, shouldn't a book about it make it easy to read the words themselves, not harder? I did life the general flow of the book from one subject to another, it felt logical and approachable. However, the pizza metaphor went on for quite some time and time was something often ignored in the reasons why most of us don't invest in getting fully informed consent for everything.
I was impressed that identity (both one's own and that which others label us with) was addressed as challenges to giving consent. I actually wish more pages were spent on those issues and that it was placed earlier in the book. There was a contradiction that shocked me. Earlier we are told that only saying "yes" is giving consent and yet in the section about sex we are told that is it okay to say "maybe" and to accept "maybe"... Of all the activities that can harm us by having consent denied or ignored, I'd argue that sex is a major arena where deep damage can be done. Furthermore, a great deal is made of the person asking figuring out when consent stops or isn't given by using ridiculous things like facial expressions, eye contact, body language, tone of voice, etc, even though the book also admits that some people have problem understanding all of that context and that indeed all of those signals vary by person and by experience. I think we are more helpful and empowering if we teach people to clearly communicate and say what they mean, not assume that someone will understand them looking away or making a different type of noise.
I do want to applaud author Justin Hancock for tackling this subject matter in an engaging and, for the most part, an honest way. It isn't easy and sadly after decades of work, it often feels like little has been changed, so we need more books like this that also improve upon this one.