Let me start my saying that I went into this book completely blind. I actually wanted to read a book about generational trauma, but while searching my library for it, this book was available instead.
I have anxiety, so I thought, "Why not? Maybe it'll help a bit."
Each chapter looks at a different facet of anxiety, whether that be the overthinkers, the ruminators, the worst-case scenario makers, the everything-is-my-faulters, etc. (My words, not his) And following that, he has his recommendations and his many, many references to the website that the worksheets/exercises are under. (As an audiobook listener, I cannot even recall what that website was even named)
I listened to this as an audiobook while I was multitasking, so not all my attention was on this book. Some of the tips were useful (suggestions on how to reframe thoughts). Other times, it was a bit... odd.
Again, not all my attention was on this book, but one section about catastrophizing stated that you should write down your "dream" goal (ex. scared to go to college? What is your dream scenario that can happen at college?), and then recognize that the dream scenario will most likely never happen, but at least the less desirable option is tolerable to you.
And that? That sounds a lot like giving up on your dreams. "Oh, so you hope that everything will go perfectly well and that your life will be sunshine and rainbows? Hate to burst your bubble, but it'll probably suck. But at least it will suck at a level that you can tolerate. Woo!" So instead of going into the situation with high hopes, you go into the situation of, "Everything will suck, but not too badly." Which, wow. Talk about a negative mindset.
Let's take a look at another character/scenario. So there's a guy who thinks the entire world is his responsibility. Dad fell off a ladder? His fault. Wife got a flat tire? His fault. A fire started across the world? Somehow it's his fault.
So the tip was make a list of all the factors that contribute to the event, and identify how likely it was to have caused the event. For example, the dad's decision to get on the ladder? Probably 60% dad's fault. What about the old rickety ladder itself? Probably 20% at fault. And go alllll the way down the list until you get to yourself. You not telling your dad that getting on the ladder is not a good idea? How many percentage points are left? 1%? Okay, guess you're 1% at fault then. Probably wasn't your fault then and you're overreacting.
I'm not saying that's a bad idea or coping strategy. But the issue I had was when he started talking about whose fault it was for his wife's flat tire. Again, not all my attention was on this book, so forgive me if some information is wrong. But the main thing was that it's not the husband's responsibility to ensure all the tires are safe and sound day in and day out. After all, what if there was broken glass on the road? Or nails that could have punctured the tire? If anything, the fault lies with the person who was driving the car: his wife.
Yeah, no. That doesn't vibe with me. Instead of exploring how sometimes accidents happen or are out of our control (Can you control the road conditions? Can you control nature? Can you control junk on the road?), you assign blame to someone else. Wife's at fault. Obviously, she should have been able to see that her wheels were messed up and not driven, or that there was a nail on the road, and she obviously should have known better.
Accidents happen. You can do all you can to mitigate the risks, to avoid catastrophe as much as possible, but things slip through the cracks (Ever heard of the Swiss Cheese Model?). People are not infallible. Life does not align perfectly with all the dominoes falling into place. And it just doesn't do to displace the blame from yourself to someone else, when sometimes things just happen. If this husband blames his wife and [i]verbalizes it[/i], that can lead to bitter feelings and animosity. "Why didn't you see the nail on the road? Why didn't you avoid it?"
I do agree that you shouldn't blame yourself for all of the world's woes. At the same time, displacing the blame onto other people is not the way to go, especially for accidents that sometimes just happen. You can't change the past. Placing blame on a dad for climbing a ladder (Injured dad + blame for bad decisions =/= good times or even a good recovery), or to fault on a wife for a flat tire, none of that is useful for the other people in this guy's life.
Oh. And the OCD chapter. AKA: the germaphobe chapter. When you get past all the ins and outs of ritualizing handwashing and ways to get past it, then the author mentions something else. You know all those "neutralizing agents" that people suggest for anxiety? Thought stopping, reframing thoughts, meditation, think positive outcomes? Yeah, if those are "neutralizing" your anxiety, they could actually be contributing to your anxiety and you're actually just using them as a crutch which is hindering your recovery. You should consider throwing all that to the curb and getting help from a professional.
Anyways. 2.5 stars, rounded up because this was a short audiobook (a little less than 5 hours), and it wasn't as painful as some books I've slogged through. All in all, some tips are useful. Some just suck. Read this with a grain of salt, use your critical thinking skills, don't take everything as gospel. Pick out the bits that are useful to you, and discard the rest. Everyone's anxiety is different. Everyone's journey is different. There is not a one-size fits all model.