The Second Wife by Sheryl Browne
The Second Wife by Sheryl Browne is dubbed a psychological thriller, but for me, this book fall short of thrilling. Here’s a brief summary. Nicole, who had previously been in an abused marriage, meets and falls in love with Richard. After they marry, Nicole and Richard’s marriage suffers at the hands of Richard’s spoiled, adult daughter Olivia, who seems to hate Nicole. Nicole thinks she is trying to ruin their marriage.
When Nicole dies of suicide, her best friend Rebecca is devastated, and it seems difficult to believe that her friend would kill herself. After the funeral, she sticks around to investigate the circumstances of her friend’s death. But, in meeting Richard, she gets more than she bargained for, and she feels herself falling for him, too.
So first of all, it’s important to note that each chapter switches perspectives (Nicole, Rebecca, Olivia, Richard), and sometimes the perspective is in the present, while other times, the chapter is labeled to have occurred in the past. Many readers seem to have been confused by this, but for me, it wasn’t confusing. It was, however, very boring.
As some readers have mentioned, the book starts very slow, and if I didn’t feel obligated to provide an honest review, I wouldn’t have finished it. The ‘action’ did pick up, however, a little over halfway through the book. Even then, the storyline didn’t enthrall me, and I caught myself skimming through entire pages, just to get the gist, instead of actually reading them.
I’m actually surprised by the positive reviews on Goodreads. Most of those reviews claim that the ‘twist’ blew them away. I wasn’t blown away. For me, this book was indescribably predictable. I even went back and re-read the ending to see if I missed some ‘crazy’ twist. I didn’t. I had predicted this story from the beginning, and I’m surprised that more readers hadn’t as well.
In addition to this story being predictable, the character development is lacking. I didn’t care about any of the characters in the book. That’s a fundamental flaw in characterization.
I also thought that the story was illogical, especially from the characters’ perspectives, which relates to character development. I though Nicole was ridiculously naïve and ignorant. I realize that she had been abused before, but out of all the women that I know who have escaped abusive relationships, none is that guileless and compliant. Rebecca just agreeing to stay with Richard after Nicole’s death was just stupid. Richard wasn’t even suspicious about that? I could continue, but I don’t want to reveal any spoilers.
The ending was rushed and confusing, and it didn’t make a lot of sense. Again, I don’t want to reveal any spoilers, but the police don’t come and go, trusting everyone’s word. ‘Tidy’ endings like that just don’t exist.
I’m an editor for a publisher (obviously not this publisher), so I abhor giving bad reviews because I want to support authors, but I cannot, in good conscience, give this book a good review. If this book came across my desk, I would suggest that the author work on it another year.
I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in return for my honest review.