WE ALL DESERVE TO BE FREEOnce upon a time, we were free to go wherever we chose. It wasn’t so long ago. The history of humanity, is a tale of constant motion.People are supposed to move about. We have imaginations which encourage us to dream about life in other places, bodies which are built to roam, and hands which can make an array of vehicles. A few of us even possess the “Wanderlust Gene”, which encourages us to take risks – to sail across unchartered oceans, and launch ourselves towards faraway planets.Some of us are forced to relocate. Lots of us choose to migrate. A few of us belong to nomadic communities.But if one thing is clear, it’s that mobility improves our societies. Emigrants send back billions in remittances – helping to reduce poverty, and inspiring their peers to upskill. Immigrants do the work that their hosts are unwilling or unable to perform. They sustain economies which have ageing populations. They establish industries, invent products, create jobs, increase wages, fuel growth, pay taxes, and enrich our cultures – enhancing our music, arts, sports, languages and cuisine.It's time to celebrate movement! It’s time to demand our freedom! It’s time for open borders!This book explains why – making the historical, scientific, economic, cultural, political and philosophical cases for free movement.
Joss Sheldon is a scruffy nomad, unchained free-thinker, and post-modernist radical. Born in 1982, he was raised in one of the anonymous suburbs that wrap themselves around London's beating heart. Then he escaped!
With a degree from the London School of Economics to his name, Sheldon had spells selling falafel at music festivals, being a ski-bum, and failing to turn the English Midlands into a haven of rugby league.
Then, in 2013, he stumbled upon McLeod Ganj; an Indian village which is home to thousands of angry monkeys, hundreds of Tibetan refugees, and the Dalai Lama himself. It was there that Sheldon wrote his debut novel, 'Involution & Evolution'.
Eleven years down the line, he's penned eight titles in total, including two works of non-fiction: "DEMOCRACY: A User's Guide", and his latest release, "FREEDOM: The Case For Open Borders".
Thanks to Joss for sending me an ARC copy! Definitely a five-star for the thoughtfulness and the detailed evidence supporting the argument!
Having lived in multiple countries, as someone born to foreign nationals, and as an IR graduate student, the book resonates well with me. The book bridges a tremendous gap in International Relations by incorporating comprehensive research from various perspectives. It dissects and seeks solution to an issue that traces back to the 1900s. As a law student, on the other hand, I expect this very issue to be brought up more frequently in the coming years. It is well-researched, and everything is in order. Each chapters can be read separately, but they also form a coherent whole.
Initially, I did not like the hypothetical Clinton campaign that begins the book: to me it felt a bit forced with tons of quotations and statistics crammed together. However, as I read along, it all started making sense. I suppose I just don't click with stats, and I'm not taking points off for the apparent over-reliance on quotes in the first few chapters. The book would lose its flavor without them.
I'm drawn particularly to books that stimulate my brain, but I understand that some people prefer light reads. This book is on the academic end. It makes a great resource for future academics interested in relevant topics. But it could be a dense read, and it requires the readers' commitment to follow the logic and make the connections. It surely isn't to everyone's taste, but it's a really inspiring book.
An essential read for our times. Humanity is at the beginning of probably the largest migration to more habitable zones of the northern hemisphere. We must accept that the merging and change of cultures is a thing that is constantly happening, and Joss Sheldon shows us very clearly that it is a good thing. The book is beautifully written and leaves no doubt about its message: do not build walls but bridges.
Joss Sheldon’s book opens with a hypothetical campaign launch speech by Hillary Clinton in which she makes an impassioned appeal for Americans to adopt a pro-immigration stance. Backed up by slogans such as “Immigrants Make America Great”, “Open the Borders” and “Make America the Land of the Free”, she soon has the crowd enthusiastically on her side. America, she reminds them, is after all a nation of immigrants. Comparing this with Trump’s actual campaign speech in which he blames illegal immigrants for everything that ails America, Sheldon suggests that Clinton missed an opportunity, making his point emphatically right from the outset.
A far-reaching argument in support of immigration and open borders, the book is intensively researched and well written. Sheldon has clearly done his homework. In chapters examining the history of the establishment of nation states, nomadic culture, genetic differences, the political, economic and philosophical justifications for open borders and how such a future scenario could be promoted and implemented, he’s put together a persuasive case.
It's an engaging read, written in a lively style and made more relatable by numerous insights into his own life of travelling and living in many different destinations. The idea that some of us have a “wanderlust” gene that encourages this kind of adventurous rambling is intriguing, although there are of course many more compelling reasons for people to want to leave their country of birth. Given that the vast majority of controversy about open borders has been fomented by supporters or opponents of asylum seekers, more attention perhaps could have been devoted to the dilemma of how nations can best provide humanitarian solutions to those fleeing war and persecution without compromising their own economic, environmental and infrastructural priorities.
As Sheldon points out, much of the opposition to immigration is fuelled by public misperceptions about foreigners stealing jobs, creating unemployment, boosting crime, putting pressure on social services and exacerbating the housing crisis. These in turn create fears which are ripe for exploitation by manipulative politicians (Trump being a case in point) and others.
Nowhere is this more true than in Australia where I live, and I was surprised the book paid scant attention to our situation, where border control policies have been widely criticised and condemned from the days of “White Australia” to the present day. Slogans such as “Keeping Australia in Safe Hands”, “Stop the Boats”, “Getting Control of our Borders” have proved winning strategies in several federal elections.
Overall however this is a thought-provoking and invigorating read and will appeal to readers regardless of their political or national orientation.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is a powerful read which hopes to explain what freedom means to everyone. It will explain how some see what their freedom means. A great read I received an advance copy from hidden gems and I want to review
Being a child of immigrants, this book was an interesting read for me. It’s baffling how politics use immigration to feed fear upon commoners, as if they were the plague. As the author says, when it comes to politics the truth is secondary. Freedom means having the right to move, no human should ever be called “illegal” as if there were different kinds of human rights on this planet. The author fills the gap between politician’s narratives and pleads for free migration. An invitation to stick to the facts, and challenge the politics of fear.
In Freedom The Case for Open Borders, the author, Sheldon, presents a solid case and thesis. His primary point that immigrant populations have offered major contributions, and that we would do well to not label them as intruders, is rather timely in this day and age. Sheldon further enhances his point by demonstrating how diversity has helped rather than hindered past civilizations. The newcomers bring a different spin on old ideas, and a fresh spin at that. They help enhance our societal flavor. Would that I could afford enough copies for ever member of Congress, The President, and all nine justices as well as the governor's of all fifty states. This work is that critically important.
This is an amazingly interesting book. I feel a must read for all educated people. Full of facts & figures but done in a lightly amusing way! I think this should be part of all school curriculum course work, internationally that is; so a more balanced & understanding society could be obtained. I do recommend!
A superb book which accredits the advantages of immigration and freedom.A very eye-opening and important message,which helps question some of the weaknesses in current systems and policies.
I would recommend this book as an open minded approach to advocate a more humane world.
This book certainly makes a lot of sense. Most migrants are not migrating so they can be lazy and live off welfare in a foreign land. Most would rather stay in their own country and work and live there. This book explains that and other concepts very well.
Suicidal Empathy: The Case for Ignoring Human Psychology and Millennia of History
The call for open borders, as championed in Freedom: A Case for Open Borders, represents a utopian vision of human interconnectedness and a transcendent humanitarian ideal. Yet, when subjected to historical, psychological, civilizational, and political scrutiny, it becomes clear that open borders, despite their noble intentions, threaten to unravel the very fabric of civilization. This review contends that the embrace of open borders—though driven by a deep empathy for human suffering—amounts to a self-destructive path that disregards centuries of human history, psychological realities, and the hard lessons of History.
The failure to reconcile the psychological realities of human nature with political theory is one of the key flaws of open Borders. The core of any civilization is its shared identity—the values, traditions, and social contracts that bind people together.
Cultural homogeneity is not an arbitrary luxury but a necessity for long-term stability. Historical examples abound of multicultural experiments that led to civil unrest, societal fragmentation, and even civil war. The former Yugoslavia is a tragic example: a country that tried to unify diverse ethnic groups under a single political system, only to see it collapse in brutal ethnic conflict. The U.S. experience with slavery, segregation, and racial tensions shows how difficult it is to reconcile deep cultural divides within a single polity. Open borders, with their promise of seamless integration, ignore the complexity of these deep-rooted cultural and historical divides.
From a civilizational perspective, open borders represent a kind of self-destruction. It is not just about allowing people to cross a physical line; it is about dismantling the very distinctions that define a civilization. If every civilization is an expression of shared history and values, then erasing borders is tantamount to erasing the civilization itself.
In democracies, citizens expect the government to prioritize their welfare and security. Open borders, by diluting national sovereignty, undermine this trust. The erosion of state control over immigration is already being felt in many parts of the world, where citizens feel that their governments are no longer in charge of their own future. In this context, the call for open borders is not just impractical—it is politically destabilizing, inviting authoritarian backlash and undermining the very democratic ideals it seeks to promote.
While the humanitarian impulse behind open borders is understandable and commendable, it is ultimately incompatible with the preservation of civilizational integrity, political stability, and social cohesion. The history of empires and nations shows that borders are not mere lines on a map but vital components of a functioning society. Human psychology, grounded in tribal loyalty and in-group empathy, does not lend itself to a borderless world. Open borders, when viewed through the lens of historical, psychological, civilizational, and political realities, represent not a triumph of human compassion, but a reckless gamble with civilization itself.
If we are to build a more compassionate and just world, we must do so by respecting the deep and complex realities of human society—realities that open borders fail to acknowledge. Compassion is necessary, but it must be tempered with wisdom. To ignore these truths is to risk civilizational suicide in the name of a misguided empathy.
Introduction: "FREEDOM: The Case For Open Borders" delves into the multifaceted arguments advocating for unrestricted human mobility. Authored by [Author's Name], the book explores historical, scientific, economic, cultural, political, and philosophical dimensions to elucidate the significance of open borders in contemporary society.
Summary: The book commences by portraying the innate human inclination towards movement, tracing it back through the annals of history. It emphasizes humanity's intrinsic nature to explore, migrate, and establish connections across geographical boundaries. This foundational understanding sets the stage for a comprehensive exploration of the benefits associated with unrestricted migration.
Main Arguments:
1. Human Mobility as a Natural Phenomenon: - The narrative underscores the biological and psychological predispositions towards mobility inherent in human beings. - It highlights how historical migrations have shaped societies and propelled progress.
2. Economic Contributions of Migrants: - The book elucidates how migrants contribute to global economies through remittances, filling labor gaps, and driving innovation. - It emphasizes the role of immigrants in sustaining industries, creating jobs, and fostering economic growth.
3. Cultural Enrichment: - The author contends that open borders foster cultural exchange, leading to a vibrant tapestry of diverse traditions, languages, arts, and cuisines. - Immigrants are portrayed as catalysts for enriching host societies and broadening perspectives.
4. Social Justice and Human Rights: - A moral imperative is presented for recognizing the inherent rights of individuals to seek better opportunities and escape persecution. - The book advocates for dismantling barriers that restrict human movement, aligning with principles of equality and justice.
5. Addressing Concerns and Opposition: - The text acknowledges potential challenges and critiques surrounding open borders, including concerns about security, economic strain, and cultural assimilation. - Counterarguments are presented and addressed with empirical evidence and reasoned analysis.
Conclusion: "FREEDOM: The Case For Open Borders" concludes by reiterating the imperative of embracing open borders as a catalyst for progress, prosperity, and human flourishing. It calls for a paradigm shift in global immigration policies, grounded in principles of freedom, equity, and compassion.
Evaluation: The book presents a compelling case for open borders, drawing upon a diverse range of disciplines to substantiate its arguments. The author's writing style is accessible yet intellectually rigorous, making complex concepts understandable to a broad readership. However, while the book adeptly addresses the benefits of open borders, a more nuanced discussion of potential challenges and implementation strategies could further enhance its comprehensiveness.
Overall, "FREEDOM: The Case For Open Borders" serves as a thought-provoking treatise on a pressing contemporary issue, urging readers to reconsider prevailing notions of immigration and embrace a more inclusive and humane approach towards global mobility.
Anti-immigrant sentiment and nativism have been on the rise over the past decade, infecting even the nations that have heretofore stood as symbols of democracy and havens for those seeking freedom like the US and the UK. Tightening borders and even building walls, previously symbols of totalitarian countries like the Soviet Union and the former East Germany, are ideas that are now tossed about by the leaders of the so-called free world.
In Freedom by British author Joss Sheldon, the whole idea of restricting the flow of people is challenged. The author traces the evolution of borders and immigration control from antiquity to the present day, pointing out, for example, that the first passports didn’t come in to use until the 1700s, and the rates of immigration nowadays are actually lower than they were in the 1800s. People, the author maintains, are biologically and psychologically hardwired to be mobile.
While his argument for free movement and open borders is probably unachievable in its entirety, he does an excellent job of debunking the misinformation and lies that nativist politicians flog about the negative impact of immigrants on societies and economies. Immigrants do not steal jobs from locals. CEOs who outsource production steal jobs. Immigrants are not a negative drain on society, they enrich and enhance societies. So, somewhere between the current nativist anti-immigrant mania and the somewhat pollyannish desire for totally open borders, there’s a middle ground that we could all effectively inhabit.
For me, this book does a number of valuable things. It corrects the record on the misinformation about immigrants and immigration, and it makes the reader think rather than just react to political rhetoric. More importantly, it leaves one with the understanding that we live in an interconnected world that is not made better by jingoistic, nativist thinking, but by accepting that we’re all in it together and we all benefit when we cooperate.
I received a review copy of this book and I highly recommend it.
"FREEDOM: The Case For Open Borders" presents a compelling argument in favor of open borders, weaving together historical, scientific, economic, cultural, political, and philosophical perspectives to advocate for the free movement of people. The author skillfully emphasizes the importance of mobility, celebrating the positive impact of migration on societies.
The historical narrative effectively highlights humanity's inherent desire for exploration and the benefits derived from movement. The acknowledgment of various factors, such as the "Wanderlust Gene" and nomadic communities, adds depth to the discussion. The book adeptly recognizes the positive contributions of immigrants and emigrants, including the economic boost through remittances, addressing labor gaps, and fostering cultural enrichment.
The scientific and philosophical underpinnings are well-articulated, providing readers with a holistic view of the case for open borders. The emphasis on reducing poverty through remittances and the economic roles immigrants play in sustaining aging populations is particularly noteworthy.
However, one area where the book could be strengthened is by delving deeper into potential challenges and addressing counterarguments. A more comprehensive exploration of the potential downsides or concerns related to open borders would provide a more balanced perspective. It's essential to acknowledge the complexity of the issue and engage with possible criticisms to enhance the overall credibility and thoroughness of the argument.
In conclusion, "FREEDOM: The Case For Open Borders" is a well-crafted exploration of the benefits of free movement, effectively blending historical, scientific, economic, cultural, political, and philosophical insights. While celebrating the positives, a more nuanced discussion of potential challenges would contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the subject.
That the subject of open borders and free movement across them is one I feel strongly about should not be surprising given my own background. I was born trapped behind a border wall, in a country that denied its citizens the right to free movement at gunpoint. Unlike my parents' generation, however, I was lucky in when I was born, as less than three years later that border wall - the Berlin Wall - came crumbling down and the borders opened. I got to grow up in a Europe that made travelling its internal borders ever easier and came of age in a EU that allowed me to freely choose to move to another country for no other reason than that I wanted to. It's a freedom I think everyone across the world, wherever they're from and wherever they want to go for whatever reason, should have. Instead, we're seeing a slow erosion of such freedoms. More and more border walls and fortifications are being built rather than torn down, and I will never cease to be viscerally appalled by such decisions.
Presenting an array of solid, convincing and multi-faceted arguments, Joss Sheldon makes an impassioned case for open borders and free movement - one I wholeheartedly applaud and support. The book is well structured, well researched, cogent and engaging. I only wish the author hadn't gone quite so overboard with the use of italics and exclamation marks for emphasis, which were so abundant as to be rather distracting.
*** I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review. ***
I have always been a humongous fan of Josh Sheldon and was so eager to read freedom by him. I don’t agree with some of the things he says in this book but the majority I do from the digital nomads the immigration circle and so much more. My daughter has a great job thanks to a man that immigrated from the Middle East he is so nice and she couldn’t be happier so I definitely have a different opinion when it comes to whether immigrants are taking our jobs and as far is that goes we should all be past such fallacies and he definitely touches on that in the book. This is a well researched very interesting not to mention a very apropos topic and whether you disagree or agree you should still read it. He has some very good ideas and great statistics and so I think anyone who loves nonfiction adult books will enjoyed this one. I read a historical True Crime book earlier where the judge sanctioned the defense for constantly bringing up that some of the witnesses were immigrants and I just find it so sad that we still have this issue in 2024 because this book is about a trial that happened in 1844 but this book is not about racism per se or immigration it’s about solutions and things that people are angry about that are already going on in our country. I do agree that having no borders would solve a lot of problems and I think the author covered it well this is a book I definitely recommend and totally enjoyed. Please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
"FREEDOM: The Case for Open Borders" by Joss Sheldon is a thought-provoking exploration of the benefits and necessity of free movement in today's world. The author builds a compelling argument for open borders by examining historical, scientific, economic, cultural, political, and philosophical perspectives.
Sheldon reminds readers that migration has always been a fundamental aspect of human history, driven by necessity, curiosity, and opportunity. The book celebrates mobility as a natural human trait and a force for societal improvement. It highlights how migrants contribute to economic growth, cultural enrichment, and innovation, while also addressing myths and misconceptions surrounding immigration.
With vivid examples, the book showcases the positive impact of migration—from remittances reducing global poverty to immigrants revitalizing aging economies and diversifying cultural landscapes. Sheldon argues that embracing open borders isn’t just about compassion but about creating thriving, interconnected societies.
This book is a call to action for policymakers and readers alike, advocating for a world that values freedom of movement as a cornerstone of human dignity and progress. It’s an essential read for those interested in politics, economics, and human rights.
This book is a profoundly thought-provoking book that challenges conventional wisdom surrounding immigration and borders. In a world where discussions about migration are often mired in political rhetoric and fearmongering, this book serves as a refreshing and timely reminder of the inherent benefits of free movement.
What struck me most about this book is its compelling narrative style, which seamlessly weaves together historical anecdotes, scientific evidence, economic analysis, and philosophical reflections. The author's passion for the subject is palpable on every page, as they make a compelling case for why open borders are not only morally justifiable but also essential for the progress of societies.
Its a must-read for anyone interested in understanding the complexities of immigration and borders. Through its engaging prose and rigorous analysis, the book challenges readers to rethink their assumptions and consider the moral imperative of embracing the freedom of movement. Whether you agree with its conclusions or not, this book is sure to spark lively debate and inspire readers to engage more deeply with one of the defining issues of our time.
This was a fast read. It's a mix of an essay and pop science, both kinds of books I'm fond of. Besides that, being just back from an eye-opening trip to Seychelles and Zanzibar, I've got to say, "Freedom: The Case For Open Borders" by Joss Sheldon hit home hard. This book captures the essence of a borderless world, something I've always felt strongly about. Traveling just reinforces how interconnected we all are, and Sheldon's arguments for opening borders, with all the economic, cultural, and humanitarian benefits, really resonates. It's a five-star recommendation from me – a must-read for anyone who sees the world as one big, inclusive community.
If you've every wondered about the debate on immigrants or considered doing so yourself this book is for you. Josh Sheldon deals in fact and writes an intelligent researched argument for open borders.He delves into not just the historical significance but also the economic, and cultural, benefits and more. A well researched and thoughtful look at immigration. I recieved a complimentary copy and am leaving an honest review
The author brings you a book about diversity and what immigrants can bring to their new country. In Canada and the States Immigrants started their country by working and bargaining with the natives. I would recommend that everyone reads a book that doesn’t share their assumptions about life. This was a very interesting read that open my eyes to the possibilities. Immigrants are not all bad as some would like us to believe. I received a free book and the views and opinions are my own.
An important book in terms of its message, a message that I agree with passionately and have done so for years, but I thought it was very poorly written. I found the style too personal, polemical and very patronising. Maybe the target audience is Sun readers. Abandoned about half way.
I received a copy in advance, and I am leaving this review voluntarily:
This book would make for a great docuseries! It is a compelling exploration of one of the most pressing issues of our time. In a world marked by division and increasing geopolitical tensions, this ebook is thought-provoking, and advocates for a more interconnected and open global society. Sheldon's writing style is both accessible and engaging, making complex political and economic concepts understandable for all readers.
He establishes a strong case for open borders, weaving together historical and natural context, statistical data, genetic truths, and personal narratives to create a compelling book that transcends political boundaries. Sheldon doesn't shy away from addressing the concerns and criticisms often associated with the idea of open borders. Instead, he tackles misconceptions and presents a comprehensive view of the potential benefits that open borders can bring to societies worldwide. Overall, it taught me so much, made me feel like a student again, and helped me better understand my own nomadic tendencies!
It is a must-read for anyone interested in global politics, social justice, and the future of our interconnected world. It's a powerful call to action that challenges perspectives and actively engages in creating a more open and united global community.
As a Canadian immigrant myself, I felt seen by the content in this book. The topics within are ones my husband and I are always discussing; I will be sharing this book with my family and friends.