***I received this book from the author, Sophie Avett, in exchange for an honest review.***
My first exposure to Sophie Avett's world of New Gotham was via her Cry Wolf books, which focused on an unlikely pair and their interactions with each other.
I've had the unfortunate experience where some authors are unable to give each character different personalities, making characters and environments all seem one dimensional and, in my opinion, redundant.
However, the more I read about New Gotham and its inhabitants, the more I'm sucked into Avett's world, and my imagination is taken beyond the limits. I couldn't stop reading this book! I found both Elsa and Marshall to be relate-able in their own ways, and I especially was able to relate to Elsa, a short, chubby witch with a penchant for eating sweet things, and staying far away from anyone who could possibly hurt her. I especially appreciated that Elsa isn't a wispy damsel-in-distress type, and is a powerhouse. Marshall is no weakling either, and I love their chemistry, I love that they know that there is chemistry, and I love that neither will act upon it because of their own deep seated reasons, which is a refreshing change in my opinion.
You should definitely give this book/series a read if you are in love with Terry Pratchett's work, except there is far more sex and graphic details and (if you have delicate sensitivities against this sort of thing) blatant swearing, two things which I personally don't mind and love, as they leave nothing to a reader's imagination, and makes each character's personality stronger.
I look forward to delving into the next instalment of the saga!
AMMENDMENT: REST OF REVIEW CONTAINS IMPRESSIONS OF BOOKS 2-4
After reading the rest of TDH books, I found it harder and harder to continue reading. By book four, I was agonizing over the different issues I found with the story thus far. I found there to be more detail in the sex having, rather than in any description of the surroundings. I often forgot they were even on a boat, because there was hardly any movement, save to buck just in time to throw someone against someone else in a timely fashion to intensify mood.
The repetition of particular tropes/metaphors (aka, angsty male plays violin, has violent tendencies, spends 4 books wanting to know what love is, and wanting female to show him) slowly frustrated me, and I felt that by the fourth book, which was intended to be, I assume, a wrap up of events, it was stretched longer than necessary with Marshall and his own internal struggle, which I had had enough of hearing about by book 3. That's just me.
Furthermore, I found that many of the characters shared the same 'voice'. The Sinister Stiches trio, brother and mother all acted similarly. There seemed to be no difference between the three of them save what interested them, and who they were mated with. Even the mother seemed less of an aged, mature individual, but as crazy as her children, making the brain behind the entire organization seem less interesting. Even the quest in having to find her was more mundane than I expected. It was said that the fey didn't show herself in public, that no one knew who she was, yet here she is, without glamour, in the middle of a Christmas Show... Elsa wasn't even needed. Sally shows up at the last minute, but unnecessarily. Even Marshall's enlistment of Gwyneth's help was unnecessary, since, again, the fey revealed herself unnecessarily.
Overall, the 4 books felt like one long book that, do not get me wrong, has promise, but needs reworking to include more description to give us ambience and setting. As it stands, the book seems to be focused on whatever sexual exploits between Marshall and Elsa (which, I agree with another reviewer, starts with rape), and seems more like a tribute to Fifty Shades of Grey and Twilight (both of which are referred to due to the author's likeable penchant for using pop culture references in her work), or rather, a lengthy fanfiction that combined the two.