I recently read Bare Knuckle: The Story of Bobby Gunn by Stayton Bonner, which I discovered through a podcast interview he did with Mathew McKay on the Art of Manliness.
I finished the book between June 26, 2024, and August 1, 2024. The book spans 308 pages and is published by Black Stone Publishing.
Bobby Gunn, a champion of bare-knuckle boxing, might initially evoke images of the 19th-century Wild West and legends like John L. Sullivan. However, Gunn was born in 1973, and his life begins during his Traveler family move from Niagara Falls to Tampa, Florida in search of seasonal work. Bonner skillfully intertwines Gunn’s personal biography with the broader history of the Travelers, the evolution of bare-knuckle boxing, and a social commentary on a segment of America that remains largely unseen and mythic. The narrative also explores Gunn’s personal struggles with identity, self-respect, and the values and weaknesses that define him: discipline, honor, resilience, faith, family commitment, love, generosity, mercy, but also shame, addiction, violence, and, as Winston Churchill described, the “Black Dog” of depression.
Two aspects of Bonner’s work are particularly noteworthy. First, his ability to gain access to and earn the trust of Gunn and his community is impressive. Second, Bonner refrains from portraying Gunn as a conventional hero. While there are admirable and compelling qualities in Gunn, Bonner's portrayal does not romanticize his life or make it seem enviable. Instead, the book fosters a deep respect and understanding of both Gunn and his community without idealizing their experiences.
Would I recommend this book? Absolutely. In my rating system, it’s a 4/4: very worthwhile and I’m glad I read it. However, if you are sensitive to graphic descriptions of violence, this book may not be for you.