As an avid reader of fantasy novels, student of theology and a big fan of series with heavy angelic presence, like Supernatural, I was very excited to jump into Archangels Fall, as the premise sounded really interesting and almost tailor made to my likings and interests, and I'm happy to say that the book really didn't disappoint much!
I do feel I have to point that that this is Andrew's first novel (from what I can tell), so some aspects of his writing, such as his prose, is a little bit rough around the edges at times, however, I don't feel that type of issue is significant enough to warrant too much criticism.
Despite being a fairly short book, the story jumps between quite a few different character perspectives, namely Grace, The Damned, Jack, Eddie, Grace's mother and a small handful of other angels, which served as both a pro and con for me. It was a good choice in the sense that it allowed for important world and character building, to help set up future installments and make sure we understood the characters at play, however, it was also a bad choice (in my opinion) as it meant that each chapter was incredibly short, leaving each POV character's story quite fragmented. This kind of writing works well in series like A Song of Ice and Fire because of the length of those books and the enormity of the ongoing story those books tell. In Archangels Fall, however, the book is short, the pace is fairly breakneck and the characters all exist within close proximity of one another, so the rapid jumping between them didn't allow me to really truly connect with any one individual and develop personal favorites. This may not sound inherently bad, and to others it may not be, but for me, it left me largely feeling neutral towards each named character, which lowered the stakes significantly when they were in danger. This isn't to say that the characters themselves weren't developing in a meaningful way, because I feel that they did, and do feel like I understand each of them and their motivations, but I wasn't able to build an emotional connect with any of them, the way I feel I could have if the book was 500+ pages or if the story focused only on 2 or 3 different perspectives.
Essentially, the book was trying to do too much for a novel of its length, however, that doesn't mean the book is bad, I actually really enjoyed my time with it and thought it was quite entertaining, and I'll absolutely buy the sequel whenever it's published, because I do want to know what happens next, it's just that my investment is in the overall plot, not the endgame fate of any of the individuals contained within.
The contrast between the different classes of angels was quite fun, as was the lore behind it all and how it was discovered both literally through the Damned's POV chapters, and theologically through the two professors' POV chapters. Though, the introduction of demons later and their subservience to one particular member of one particular class of angel did raise questions for me the book didn't answer, but I'll assume that'll be addressed in future installments.
As goofy as this might sound, the book also read as a bit anti-American at times, as all but two mentions of Americans are described with negativity, such as "SUV is a ridiculous American term", "cheesy American accent", "American tourists are loud and mindless", and "cheesy American detective shows". This didn't offend me but it did come off as needlessly hostile, and that may not have been the writer's intent, but I felt I should share as I could easily see somebody being bothered by it. Also another minor nitpick is that some dialogue, particularly that of Jade, felt really cheesy and cartoonish at times, though this may have been the author's intent.
Despite much of what I've said so far sounding fairly negative, I really did enjoy this book. It did an excellent job of grabbing my attention with the story of Einstein arguing with his professor, as it helped to properly establish the intended tone of the series. The mix of real life religious lore and new fictional lore to describe the celestial powers at play and their motivations was well written and engaging, and the overarching plot is solid, and left me with enough questions that I anticipate the sequel in hopes for answers, which any good novel (in a series) should do. I also enjoyed that the book itself didn't take place in the USA, as despite being an American, it can get old reading books set in the same cities over and over and over (Las Vegas, Los Angeles, New York, etc), so the setting was a welcome change of pace.
Overall, I think Andrew Bryan is off to a good start here, and while the book is far from perfect, it's definitely one of the better examples I've seen of an author's first published work. And I definitely look forward to reading Dark Angels Rise in January of 2025. I give Archangels Fall as solid 4 out of 5, it's a good first entry and it left me wanting more!