Series review. I really didn't like the last half of the last book, so I'm trying to judge that against all the earlier things I did enjoy. I expected this series to be about the Mongols, Jin, and Song, but it really wasn't. It was essentially the story of the Four Greats with bits of the war tacked onto the beginning and end. But the conflicts between the Greats were Jin Yong doing what he does best.
The ending was overall unsatisfying to me. The repeated breakups in Guo Jing and Huang Rong's relationship were tedious, the war was not particularly interesting, everything about the Mongols and morality felt trite, and even the rematch among the Four Greats didn't land for me.
I feel like everything this series did, Smiling Proud Wanderer did better. This makes me uncertain about reading more of Jin Yong's earlier works, though I still intend to eventually.
Misc:
- I think it's morally strange that Huang Rong three times ruins the lives of mostly innocent villagers and the text expects us to find this charming.
- It's odd to me that it expects us to keep track of a dozen unimportant martial artists but re-explains Ouyeng Ke's real father every time.
- This one has explicitly "millions" of sharks. You can apparently herd snakes by the tens of thousands as well.
- "In embarrassment, he vomited a mouthful of blood."
- Dramatic suicides to make a point or deescalate/escalate a situation: 6
- 8 if you count failed attempts