In His Majesty's Service

Temeraire #1-3+2.5

by Naomi Novik

Capt. Will Laurence is serving with honor in the British Navy when his ship captures a French frigate harboring most a unusual cargo–an incalculably valuable dragon egg. When the egg hatches, Laurence unexpectedly becomes the master of the young dragon Temeraire and finds himself on an extraordinary journey that will shatter his orderly, respectable life and alter the course of his nation’s history.

Thrust into England’s Aerial Corps, Laurence and Temeraire undergo rigorous training while staving off French forces intent on breaching British soil. But the pair has more than France to contend with when China learns that an imperial dragon intended for Napoleon–Temeraire himself– has fallen into British hands. The emperor summons the new pilot and his dragon to the Far East, a long voyage fraught with peril and intrigue. From England’s shores to China’s palaces, from the Silk Road’s outer limits to the embattled borders of Prussia and Poland, Laurence and Temeraire must defend their partnership and their country from powerful adversaries around the globe. But can they succeed against the massed forces of Bonaparte’s implacable army?

Together in one volume, here are the first three novels in Naomi Novik’s New York Times bestselling Temeraire series, combining the gripping history of the Napoleonic era, the thrill of Anne McCaffrey’s Dragonriders of Pern books, and the excitement of Patrick O’Brian’s seafaring adventures. In His Majesty’s Service also includes an exclusive original Temeraire short story - "In Autumn, a White Dragon Looks over the Wide River".

Genres: Fantasy, Dragons, Historical Fiction, Alternate History, Fiction, Historical, Adventure

823 pages, Hardcover

First published October 16, 2009

About the author

An avid reader of fantasy literature since age six, when she first made her way through The Lord of the Rings, Naomi Novik is also a history buff with a particular interest in the Napoleonic era and a fondness for the work of Patrick O’Brian and Jane Austen. She studied English literature at Brown University, and did graduate work in computer science at Columbia University before leaving to participate in the design and development of the computer game Neverwinter Nights: Shadow of Undrentide. Over the course of a brief winter sojourn spent working on the game in Edmonton, Canada (accompanied by a truly alarming coat that now lives brooding in the depths of her closet), she realized she preferred writing to programming, and on returning to New York, decided to try her hand at novels.

Naomi lives in New York City with her husband and six computers. Her website is at naominovik.com

Reviews

[Meg · Rating 5 out of 5]

Best. Dragon. Book. Ever.

I have read a lot of dragon books over the years, from Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders of Pern series to the more recent Christopher Paolini's Inheritance Cycle and many others. This series outshines them all.

First off, there is no magic. None. I know, I know, how can a world with dragons possibly exist without a little magic thrown in? Don't those two go hand-in-hand? Novik, however, brilliantly uses biology, anthropology, geography, sociology, Darwinism, and so much more to describe a world -- our world -- in which dragons are conceivable without relying on the flimsy excuse of mystical powers. Furthermore, she then seamlessly weaves an entire draconic culture into our history books.

Secondly, while the use of dragons in aerial combat, prior to the creation of airplanes, is not a novel idea by any means, Novik presents the most amazingly obvious notion yet: dragon crews, harnesses, whole teams of men (and women) devoted to the care and combat-readiness of a single dragon! No more single, solitary dragonriders! It is almost like she took one of Laurence's Navy ships, complete with sailors and soldiers, and gave it wings and a somewhat revolutionary personality.

Thus we come to Temeraire himself and his absolutely endearing captain, Will Laurence. When describing Laurence, words like "genteel," "respectable," and "honorable" come to mind. One might also call him a "stick in the mud" with slight OCD fastidiousness. In other words, the sort of man parents dream of their daughters bringing home: ordinary, boring, and the perfect gentleman. Enter Temeraire, a newly hatched dragon with an IQ that puts most to shame, which is then further bolstered by an inquisitive nature, the aggressive fighting streak that seems to be prevalent in excess in young male dragons, and stubbornness the width and breadth of the continent. I could hardly get through the first few chapters of Throne of Jade from all the hilarity that ensued from Laurence desperately trying to do the respectable and soldierly thing only to be, seemingly at every turn, thwarted by Temeraire's stubborn and resounding: "NO!" Novik couldn't have created a more unlikely, nor enchanting pair.

The aerial battles themselves were magnificent, and towards the end of Black Powder War became so entrancing that, whenever forced to put the book down for a moment, I couldn't tear my brain away from visions of wedge formations and boarding parties! The world building utterly captivated my inner history buff, and Novik didn't disappoint when transferring from England to China to the Sahara Desert and Turkish palaces. The writing style itself was more scholarly than the average reader is used to, and in many respects intimidating for the sheer correctness of grammar usage, but it surprisingly worked. Once I adjusted, the flow of words and sentences sucked me in with little effort on my part (although I did have my iPhone handy to look up any words I didn't know -- which were a lot, but I honestly delighted in each and every one of them). As a pleasant surprise, I noticed a significant improvement in my formal writing skills after having spent an afternoon of reading.

I cannot wait to begin the next book in the series and see where Novik, Laurence, and Temeraire will take me. For this is the best dragon book I have ever read. Do not begrudge yourself a quick peek, for if you are anything like me, that quick peek will turn into something far more precious and memorable.

[Scottsdale Public Library]

Alternative historical fantasy at its best. What if dragons had been available as aerial troops during the Napoleonic Wars?
Novik provides the answer to that question as well as some excellent action and character evolution. Especially in the first book, the historical details are so well done that the reader might forget for a moment that dragons were not used during the Napoleonic War. --Rebekka J.

[The Chapter Conundrum (Stacey) · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have such mixed feelings on this bind up oh my goodness and almost need to make separate comments for each of the original books included to make sense of everything!

The first book included, His Majesty's Dragon, is definitely a 4 star book for me. Temeraire is adorable and it's really enjoyable to read about him experiencing the world + the taste of battle scenes was interesting.

The second book included, Throne of Jade, is more of a 2 star read. I was largely bored during this section and was frustrated at various things but mostly that the main conflict of the story was just basically brushed off entirely with a much too simple solution after so much tension and that other conflicts were resolved super conveniently. We really didn't need an entire book in the series just for the purpose of introducing a new dragon into the mix and to get an idea of dragon life in other parts of the world which is essentially all that this book did for the series.

The third book included, Black Powder War, is more of a 2.5-3 star read for me. I found this one more enjoyable than Throne of Jade and enjoyed the pacing of and that it included more action in the second half but I was still pretty disappointed overall especially in regards to its' predictability. The first half was also basically more travelling like the bulk of the second book.

This series has basically gone downhill for me since the first installment and I'm not sure if I'll be continuing it in the future sadly despite really enjoying the first book.

Also of note, I don't recommend the scribd version of the audiobook! I found that certain portions were repeated, certain portions were missing and the final chapter of Black Powder War is missing entirely!! Thankfully I had the ebooks to fill in the gaps!

[J.A. McLachlan · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a somewhat unusual book. I think something between military historical fiction (alternative history) and fantasy and maybe a little steampunk thrown in. The history aspect was a quite thoroughly-researched background of the Napoleonic wars. The alternative/fantasy aspect was that there were dragons, that acted pretty much like the early airplanes of WWI, with crews and riggings and bombs and rifles. I'm not really into military fiction in any form, but the saving grace that kept me reading was the strong emotional rapport between the dragon and its 'captain' - a bond formed at hatching, obviously taken from the dragonriders of Pern series. No problem with that- we all build upon earlier tropes, and this was otherwise nothing like Pern, an imaginary world; it was very realistic (other than the dragons, of course).
I did get drawn into it, and one of the most astounding aspects was the writing - not a word that wasn't from that era, whether narative or direct quotes. It was letter-perfect, never stepping out of period. At one point I actually found myself checking the publication date to see if it had been writted back then, then - duh! - dragons, lady! And besides I know the author's name as a current writer. But for a moment the spell of language and description was so strong...
So even though I don't care for military fiction, this was quite a good read, and the characters, men and dragons both, were so well-drawn and captivating I couldn't help caring about them.
Only one thing bothered me. The dragons are as sentient as humans, self-aware and intelligent, somethimes more so (and sometimes less, as humans vary). But they were used and put at mortal risk, as war machines in a purely human war, like the horses of the cavalry.
Even so, if this sounds like your kind of book, read it - it is excellently written and you won't be dissappointed.

[Casey · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have mixed feelings about these three books.

His Majesty's Dragon was a great story and I could barely put it down. The whole experience of Laurence and Temeraire first meeting and training together made me excited for what was to come.

Throne of Jade created the background for Temeraire, the type of dragon he is, and a major enemy that appears in the next book. However, the pace slowed down dramatically. Spending the whole book in China didn't seem like the best use of time - maybe historically speaking Novik needed that span of time before the next battles begun?

Black Powder War took me forever to get through. The style of Novik's sentences really started to wear on me. For some reason, I found it challenging to follow and I couldn't read it with ease. The overland journey was boring and I thought about not finishing it. Once Laurence gets back to Europe, things get interesting again! I liked the end.

I like the premise - dragons and Napoleonic wars. I don't mind reading historical fiction, even in regards to battles and wars, but for some reason everything in between is so drawn out that it's hard to keep engaged in the story.

Laurence is hard to like. He is really stiff and didn't make much progression over three books. He is dutiful and noble - super straightlaced! He needs a love interest! I had a hard time distinguishing among all the characters. Minor ones were always dying and quite frankly I couldn't even remember who they were during the scene.

I would have liked more of the impact of dragons on the world. Some folklore or popular culture? The battle scenes were my favorite, but they seem sparse compared to everything else.

[JT · Rating 4 out of 5]

First two books are quite strong: Very much in the tradition of the Aubrey-Maturin, Hornblower, and Sharpes series, with Dragons, of course. Smack dab in the middle of the Napoleonic Wars. Hits the points anyone with vague awareness would know (Austerlitz, f'rinstance.) and leaves one hungry for the Portuguese campaign and, ultimately, Waterloo. Excellent handing of the tension between duty freely given and slavery compelled. Characters develop slowly (except for Temeraire himself and Laurence), but they do develop, and no one but Laurence and Temeraire seems to have plot armor. Resign yourself to hearing a great deal about travelling long distances slowly, but console yourself that the events in these journeys are plot-necessary.

Look sharp for the James Bond reference in Book 3.

The series to date (through 9, I think) was nominated for the experimental series Hugo, so the rest are locked in, and while I didn't enjoy the third as much as the first two, I am rather looking forward to the fourth.

[Jesse Hudson · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a fantastic book- a perfect example of the best of historical fiction. It is informative and interesting and gives the impression that the author has thoroughly researched the time period while still providing plenty of surprises

[Terry Wheeler · Rating 4 out of 5]

I wish I could give these books 4.5 stars. I truly loved them, and can't wait to read the rest of them. Naomi Novik is a wonderfully talented writer, and I've enjoyed everything of hers I've read. My only criticism of these books, really, is that the descriptions of the battles were too long and detailed for my taste. I'm sure there are those who enjoy stuff like that, but, for me, a little battle goes a long way. Don't let that stop you, though - you can always skim those parts.

[Danielle · Rating 2 out of 5]

Abandoned. Everything else I've read by Novik is so good and this was just....kind of boring. I'm not a fan of military strategy books so maybe that was it.

[H. P. · Rating 4 out of 5]

In His Majesty’s Service contains the first three novels—His Majesty’s Dragon, Throne of Jade, and Black Powder War—in the Temeraire Series, currently at five novels, collected in a single volume. Each novel is quite short, so even in a single volume they are manageable (for comparison’s sake, they remain dwarfed by The Way of Kings on my bookshelf). It also contains a new short story set in the same secondary universe.

Set during the Napoleonic Wars, the series begins with a ship from the British navy, captained by William Laurence, capturing a French ship carrying a dragon egg. The egg was to be a gift to Napoleon from the Chinese emperor. A human-dragon bond must be built immediately, the egg is ready to hatch, and they are far from land, so Laurence is forced to become the dragon’s captain (he names him Temeraire) and leave the navy for the British air force, which is populated entirely by dragons and their captains and crews.

There are really only two characters in the Temeraire books: Captain William Laurence and Temeraire, his dragon. Other characters aren’t nearly as well drawn.

Novik does what any serious author of historical fantasy must do. That is, she gives great thought to what the full, logical implications of the introduced fantastical element would be. The much more informal culture of the English air force, or “Corps” as they are referred to colloquially in the book, offers a modern reader a less jarring prism through which to view the rest of England during the Napoleonic Wars. She also strives to represent English language and mannerisms of the day, as well as real-life events, accurately as well, largely succeeding.

His Majesty’s Dragon
His Majesty’s Dragon begins with the seizure of Temeraire’s egg and follows his and Laurence’s training in the British air force. Novik seems to taken some inspiration from fighter pilot movies. The structure of the story is the same: devoting the bulk of it to training, with a climactic fight at the end.

Throne of Jade
The Chinese emperor demands Temeraire back, and he and Laurence travel to China. The entire opening sequence strains even my credulity, but it does get better. There is again a shortage of action in the bulk of the book. The conflict before they reach China comes from diplomatic tension between the Chinese and English, and antagonism between the sailors and aviators.

Black Powder War
Black Powder War begins where Throne of Jade left off, with Laurence and Temeraire in China. Most of the book takes place in Turkey and Prussia. It is the most closely interwoven with the Napoleonic Wars of the three and features the first “on-screen” appearance of Napoleon. It has by far the most action of the three.

In Autumn, a White Dragon Looks over the Wide River
It is billed as an original Temeraire short story, but that is a bit of a misnomer, as Temeraire does not appear. It takes place during the events of Black Powder War and instead covers the first meeting of Temeraire’s dragon nemesis and Napoleon.

[Jessica · Rating 5 out of 5]

The most captivating story I've read in a while!

I was immediately enthralled by this alternative universe with exactly the right blend of historical accuracy and fantastical reimagining. Novik's Captain Lawrence somehow manages to be very authentic, both as an upstanding British naval officer at the time of the Napoleonic Wars, and subsequently as the companion of a dragon and captain of a crew in the misfit Royal Aerial Corps. He manages to transition into this new post despite the unusual and sometimes scandalous daily life of the airmen (and women), who are forced apart from the conventions of polite society by the demands of caring for dragons and the potential social and political upheaval they could cause. He is quickly established as someone who understands chain of command, but also has the unfailing moral compass that allows him to navigate questionable decision making and do the right thing even while knowing and accepting the personal consequences. In short, the kind of perfect hero that you can't help but admire.

This character development happens throughout the books primarily through the lens of his relationship with his dragon, Temeraire. Temeraire is hatched somewhat naive, but quickly begins to question things that Captain Lawrence has always taken for granted. It is their conversations and their deep bond of trust that often prompt him to genuinely and objectively reconsider the notions of respect, loyalty, and equality that have been programmed into him from a young age.

The writing is excellent, and the blend of history and fantasy is superbly executed, but what really makes these books stand out is the depth of the relationship between man and dragon, and the reminder that any relationship built on mutual trust and admiration can help us grow into a better person.

[Julie · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed reading this historical fantasy which combines Napoleonic wars with the exciting and imaginative addition of dragons as the Air Force. This particular publication includes the first three books in the series. The books focus not only on the time period and battles but also on the relationship between the dragons and their pilots. The protagonists, Temeraire, the celestial dragon and his pilot, Capt. William Lawrence have a fun and developing relationship throughout the three books. The descriptions and varieties of dragons are some of the most entertaining aspects of the books. Not only do they speak and think, but they plot and are part of the emerging war strategy as well. By the end, you begin to think of them much like you would an alien species in a space travel novel rather than as an animal. I found myself exclaiming "no wonder Napoleon beat everyone" then realizing, of course, it wasn't real......but why do we have this persistent myth about dragons and in so many cultures? LOL

[ProgGrrl · Rating 3 out of 5]

I tried to read this, and though the worldbuilding was outstanding, ultimately the intense details of life in army, in navy, of the Napoleonic Wars and battle plans, just bored me.

If you read this perhaps the best way would be to do one book, then stop for a while, and then another book. Then take another breather for a while, etc.

Her writing in Napoleonic period style is incredibly good, she manages to keep the prose lively for a modern reader while also being extremely true to that historical period.

[Mary · Rating 3 out of 5]

This omnibus edition includes the first three novels of the Temeraire series: His Majesty's Dragon, Throne of Jade, and Black Powder War. All of these novels are set during the Napoleonic Wars between Britain and France in the early 19th century.

Book 1 His Majesty's Dragon: British Captain Will Laurence boards a captured French warship and discovers a dragon's egg in the hold. The egg is transferred to his own ship but before they reach shore, it hatches. The newborn dragon bonds with Laurence immediately and he names it Temeraire. When they come into port, Laurence is told that he is expected to bring the dragon to Scotland for training in the dragon air corps. At the air corps "boot camp" they join other dragons and their handlers in preparing to go into battle against Napoleon's French dragons. The storyline follows Laurence and Temeraire's developing relationship as well as their experiences in the military/warfare atmosphere of the Napoleonic wars. The story is straightforward enough to be considered a young adult novel but the prose is quite literary. The dragons are presented uniquely as fully developed characters with intelligent dialogue and independent thought. The simple plot is generally not very fast-paced but still entertaining.

Book 2 Throne of Jade: The dragon egg that Captain Laurence captured from a French ship was a gift from the Chinese emperor to Napoleon. When the Chinese government demands the return of the dragon Temeraire, the British goverment acquiesces. However to avoid a court martial and a diplomatic quarrel, Laurence must accompany Temeraire on his journey to China, which he does along with most of his crew. Interesting aspects of this story are the extensive details of 19th century British naval operations as well as the creation of a world where dragons are ubiquitous and part of the culture. A large portion of the book consists of a fairly slow-paced journey via ship from Britain to China followed by descriptions of Chinese dragon breeds and dragon habitats. There's a bit of drama at the end but enough left unresolved for the next book in the series.

Book 3 Black Powder War: Preparing to leave China and return to Britain, the British ship suffers a devastating fire which delays their departure by two more months. A few days later, Captain Laurence receives a message from the British Air Corps, asking them to depart with haste and head to Istanbul. Instead of waiting for repairs to be completed on their ship, Laurence decides to travel overland through the mountains and vast deserts of western China and central Asia. They encounter and overcome natural hazards of sandstorms and avalanches as well as bandits and feral dragons. A white dragon named Lien was introduced in the previous book and continues in this one as a significant antagonist.There's much to find interesting about travel along silk road routes and interactions with nomadic tribes, turbaned vezirs, and royal sultans. This is a straightforward story of dragon culture, political intrigue, and extensive battle scenes for those enjoying those kinds of elements. Personally I felt that the details of regimental organization, battles and troop movements dragged on too long and seemed tedious. Someone who likes reading about military engagements and details might feel quite differently.

Short story In Autumn, A White Dragon Looks Over The Wide River: The story of how the French ambassador to China, De Guignes, brought the Chinese white dragon Lien to France and to the service of Napoleon Bonaparte. Since the death of her Chinese companion Lien has a deep hatred for Temeraire (whom she blames) and wants nothing more than to destroy him and Britain. She persuades Napoleon to reorganize his dragon aerial corps and deploy them more efficiently, using her superior planning skills and experiences in China to gain a valuable position as a trusted advisor.

[Danielle · Rating 4 out of 5]

I had read and loved Novik's standalone novels and so decided to give this series a try. I'm normally not a huge reader of historical fiction, especially with a military setting, but I enjoyed these books (this edition being the first three books in the series).

The first book is probably still my favorite. I loved reading about Temeraire and Laurence's developing relationship, and both of them figuring out their new place in the world together. Their relationship is surprisingly sweet. Watching stiff Navy-man Laurence try to settle into aviator life was fun too. The scenes with the dragon battles are exciting and fun to read.

The second book was interesting, but the pacing of the writing felt uneven. The middle of the book, during their voyage, really slogged along for me. I also felt a little frustrated that we weren't really given the narrative clues to figure out what was going on with the prince. We had to wait to be told, essentially right at the end. I really liked the descriptions of China and especially noticing the differences in how dragons were treated in England. After the first book, I had started to ask myself questions about the ethics of forcefully enlisting such intelligent creatures in human wars; I appreciate when an author anticipates my questions and starts writing about them. Dragon rights! Temeraire has a kind of innocence that challenges Laurence -- he asks why we do things a certain way, and often Laurence's only answer is, well, that's just the way it's done. That dynamic helps keep the narrative interesting.

The third book was probably least interesting for me. The narrative seemed scattered, and there were a lot of "loading screen" moments where I felt like I was waiting for the real story to start. I did enjoy learning more about feral dragons, and again Temeraire and Laurence finding reasons to question the Western status quo. I was glad we got to see more development of Laurence and Granby, and Granby's own storyline. The new dragon was a funny and refreshing addition to the group and boosted the plodding pace.

One reservation I had about reading these books is that our protagonist is part of the British Empire, notorious colonizers and slavers. I appreciated that Novik started to address this issue in the second and third books, letting Temeraire's conscience show how clearly repulsive the slave trade is. I'll be interested to see how she continues to write these issues into the books.

The heart of these books is the relationship between Temeraire and Laurence, and that remains my favorite part, watching them challenge each other and learn from each other.

[Leah · Rating 4 out of 5]

Napoleonic wars with dragons. Has there ever been a better idea? THIS is how you write compelling fantasy with dragons.

The action is tensely and effectively written, and the characters are well developed (both human and dragon.) The pacing is perfect. There is enough time spent developing the story to feel as if you have started to know the stakes and the personalities involved, but the action comes on at the right beats and builds steadily. It was so skillfully done that I was invested before I knew what had happened. I will unashamedly admit that I was moved to tears at different points.

I love Temeraire and Lawrence. Their dynamic is entertaining and emotional, and I cared about what happened to them. The side characters are all unique and carefully developed, and none of them are paragons. They all have human flaws and eccentricities. The plot has depth, and tackles some interesting ethical and moral questions through the lens of the dragons. The whole series of books is well done and worth reading. I’m looking forward to counting the series!

[Laurie · Rating 4 out of 5]

The first 3 Temeraire novels, plus a short story - this omnibus edition is great entertainment value!

A highly enjoyable historical fantasy - this takes place during the Napoleonic Wars, and opens with a British sailing ship successfully overwhelming an enemy French vessel - and discovering its cargo, a large dragon-egg, ready to hatch.

Mores and mannerisms of the age makes this read like 'Master and Commander', or 'Belgravia' - affronts managed with seething politeness, one's station being a major determinent of interactions, and so on. The dragon world-view is fully fleshed out, with considerable nuance and depth.

Recommended; and I am sure I will move forward into some of the following volumes of the series.

[Duncan · Rating 5 out of 5]

I adored this first trilogy. It's ostensibly about dragon's civil rights around the world told through the lens of a relationship between a fish-out-of-water dragon pilot and his dragon, Temeraire. I really enjoyed the world it painted and the adventures that happened. The second book didn't feel like a rushed sequel or and it was the same with the third. Naomi has a lot of things to say with dragons. I'd recommend these to anyone. The language does maintain a certain formality of structure in keeping with days of yore which might make a few stumble but if that doesn't bother you, it's family-friendly dragon-y good times.

[Kristi Cramer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Absolutely wonderful

Like reading Master and Commander (the movie... I didn't read that book, though now I might. LOL) mashed up with some Jane Austen sensibilities, and a precocious dragon in the mix. I cannot explain why, but I just kept thinking how wonderful the story was, through nearly every page of all three novels. It is so very well written, well thought out, well researched, just overall ingeniously crafted that even the travel arcs - the long sea voyage and then the overland trek - did not bog down the tale.

I will certainly go now to find the other two books in the series. I must know how Napoleon falls in this alt history.

5 stars all the way.

[Christina Desalvo · Rating 5 out of 5]

I should begin by saying that I am a fan of Naomi Novik. I began with Uprooted but hadn't read the Temeraire series. Wow. The book is very different from her later novels but again I was drawn into the book's world. Captain Lawrence and the other Aerial Corp are excellent but to me the true stars of the series are the dragons especially Temeraire who is excellent. I particularly enjoyed Temeraire's and Laurence's experience in China which was eye opening for both. I am curious but skeptical of the plans for better treatment of the dragons.

[Silver · Rating 5 out of 5]

I think this is without a doubt the best dragon rider book I've ever read.

The dragons in this story are, for once, colorful characters with agency rather than just flying mounts, and the relationship between Captain Will Laurence and Temeraire was delightful for how consistently funny and heartfelt their interactions are.

The background of the Napoleonic wars is carefully studied. Though if it wasn't for the names of real places, military men and heads of state, one might be tempted to believe they're reading about a fantasy world for how well the dragons are weaved into the setting!

[Sarah · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book took me a really long time to read because I didn’t find it very interesting. I mean, it has dragons in it, which I enjoy, but I didn’t find the setting of the Napoleonic Wars to be all that engaging and I didn’t think any of the characters other than Lien had any depth to them. I did read the preview for book four, which seems to be more about Lien, so I might read that, but I’ll be giving this book away. It’s not one I’ll reread.

[Angela · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed these three novels & read through them at a great clip, but looking ahead & seeing six more books & no end yet of the series, I'm somehow weary. I don't know very much about the real Napoleonic Wars & I read this trilogy expecting Waterloo at the end. Six+ more books before Temeraire can send L'Empereur packing? I'm not sure I'm in. Also: I never ever EVER know how to pronounce French names & therefore I mentally stumble over them every time.

[Peace · Rating 3 out of 5]

Geneology and herpetology experts will be thrilled with this series that dives into the breeding of dragons in an alternate universe of the Napoleonic wars. As an excuse to travel the world of dragons humans are dragged from continent to continent with great loss of life in useless politics and wars.

[Gail · Rating 5 out of 5]

Fascinating stories of dragons and soldiers in the Napoleonic war!

These are fast-paced, action-packed, and suspenseful stories with strong likeable characters. Naomi Novik weaves the scenes to keep you interested to see what will happen next. I love Temeraire and Captain Lawrence, and their special bond. If you like fantasy, you will love this series of books. Happy reading!

[Sally English · Rating 5 out of 5]

Full of daring adventure, intrigue and chivalry. The charcuterie are fully drawn and the heroes gallant, intelligent and admirable. Twist and turns in the plot abound. Interesting themes of the meaning of duty, liberty and autonomy give even more interest to the story. This is the best story featuring a dragon that I have read.

[Scott Christensen · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is the best book on dragonkind I have ever read! The artist way the author Naomi Novik brings the world of dragons and the world of men together is fascinating. The best part I believe is the way she intertwined dragons, culture, and the different social classes into her version of history. I recommend this book to any reader I come across.

[Margaret · Rating 4 out of 5]

Individually reviewed: His Majesty's Dragon, Throne of Jade, and Black Powder War

The short story "In Autumn, A White Dragon Looks Over the Wide River": This short story was the perfect antidote to Black Powder War; Lien's perspective in adapting to her new circumstances brought back the novelty and delight of the first two books.

[Bethany · Rating 3 out of 5]

I enjoyed the first book. It was an interesting take on the Napoleonic wars with dragons thrown into the mix. But I got bored during the second one and just couldn't get myself to finish it. Maybe someday. So perhaps I should have given the first book 4 stars, and the second book 2 stars, and given the third book a chance ... but as it is, I'll give it all a 3 star review.

[Liz · Rating 4 out of 5]

Reread because my Mystery Maccabee is a fan and I was trying to get the color right for something and then I just got sucked in.
I’ve definitely read a good amount of this series and definitely have not read all of it. Maybe I’ll finish it this time…
Dragon and naval battles are fun, and it’s fascinating seeing Novik’s evolution as a writer.