Honestly, in terms of content, this book probably should've been a 3-star. Most of the articles are copied directly from the website with no further editing aside from a few fixed typos (though the new ones added for this book are quite good). The articles in the book have the same strengths (attention to detail, incredible memory for hilarious moments in hockey) and weaknesses (a bit too reliant on bait-and-switch jokes).
But in a sport where the current standard for reporting seems to encourage being as boring as possible, McIndoe's articles are a respite from all the bland reporting you'll find on other hockey media sites. Plus, the guy knows his hockey, and often has some pretty insightful observations about the status of the league and the hockey media as a whole.
If you like hockey but think maybe it would be more fun if there were lots of jokes about how awful Mike Milbury is, this is your book.