My 3-star rating is simply a composite of the two ratings I'd prefer to give this book. I was skeptical after I glanced through this book at my church. I'm careful (some would say picky) about the books I read about my faith, and this one didn't seem particularly well-researched. I could find no sanction from any priest or a sign that what the book contained was "valid Catholic teaching." I took it home anyway - couldn't hurt, right? - and let it sit on my bookshelf for a few months. Only after two friends, whose opinions I respect, recommended the book to me did I finally sit down and read it. It is a fairly quick read, but I tried the whole time not to judge it prematurely. I just finished it, and the final verdict is that I both like and dislike this book.
Reasons for a 2-star rating: My main problem going into this book is that there are no citations of religious texts, nor endorsements from the Church or from any priests or anyone reliable in the Church. The short biography of Mr Kelly doesn't give much information on where he picked up his Catholic education. I wondered if the information in the book would be accurate Catholic teaching. After reading the book - the entirety of which reads like the transcript of a motivational speech - it's apparent that these citations I sought were not really necessary. Mr Kelly simply discusses what Catholics can do to reignite the faith, instead of trying to explain Church teachings to a world that has forgotten their relevance.
Another issue I had with this book is that it is not really my style of reading. Motivational speeches just aren't my thing. Throughout the book, Mr Kelly makes frequent references to things such as "the-best-version-of-yourself," "the Classroom of Silence," "Our Spiritual North Star," and "Journey of the Soul." I have a tendency to shy away from language like that and it caused me to scoff at the text sometimes (especially when the author made a reference to Jesus "opening his divine lips slowly [with] calm assurance" (p. 29)). I felt that language like this would not help those already skeptical about the Church to take this book seriously.
Reasons for a 4-star rating: If you can get past Mr Kelly's style of writing and listen to his message instead of his wording, this book really does have an excellent message. Mr Kelly discusses the modern philosophies that have greatly eaten away at Catholicism: individualism, hedonism, and minimalism. I can see those philosophies well represented in my own life, so I could easily make a connection, and that helped to make the entire book very relevant. I'd like to pretend other people need to hear this book's message more than I do but honestly, I am not doing a thing to help the Church or my faith in my daily life. Mr Kelly's book offers reasons why that could be as well as suggestions and encouragements - not demands, not rules - on how to evolve into a good, inspiring, active Catholic, and that is a very valuable message.