I initially gave Waking Forever 3 stars. After sleeping on it, I had to go with my gut and give it two. It wasn't so much that I didn't like the story, as there was definitely some potential for it (I am an avid horror/dark fiction/sci-fi fan). My biggest issue was the characters and their lack of depth. I'm not a writer, and I can't begin to know how hard it is to actually create and characterize a person. However, as a reader, if I don't like the character(s), whether it's because they seem fake, shallow, unrealistic, etc., it's pretty much all over for me. I could not stand Sarah. If she were a real person and I had the displeasure of meeting her, I would turn around and walk the other way. She acted like a spoiled teenager. I kind of like Rachel, but for someone who was supposed to be super-smart, um, Sarah? Really? I did not want Rachel anywhere near Sarah. (ALERT! POTENTIAL SPOILER ALERT! THE NEXT SENTENCE IS A POTENTIAL SPOILER!!!) I wanted Ela (the "bad girl") to win (I don't consider this a spoiler because, well, come on, everyone knows in this type of novel that "good" triumphs over "evil", but anyway, it's better to be considerate). (SPOILER OVER) I think Colleen was one of the most interesting characters.
I'm a Lesbian who LOVES the horror/dark fiction/sci-fi genres. Do you know how frustrating it is to to read books you like and even love but not be able to identify with the characters, especially when men (and sometimes women!) with a really great story feel the need to write every single woman as helpless? What's more frustrating? I can read novels with characters I can (or am supposed to) identify with, but be completely dissatisfied because what is supposedly a spec fic or sci-fi story is actually a vehicle for a romance that involves vapid characters.
I apologize to Ms. McVea if my review seems scathing. I'm not trying to castigate, I really am trying to be constructive in my criticism. I'm just a really frustrated reader who would love to support her community by buying their books but feels slighted 80-90% of the time because I'm not getting what I thought I was getting.
All that being said, I have a feeling there are a lot of women (possibly even some men) that would enjoy Waking Forever. I know I'm in the minority when it comes to what I like to read. So - if you like romance, but with a few vampires thrown in - go for it! This just wasn't for me.