What do you think?
Rate this book
The Ballantyne Legacy #3
Love's Fortune
Sheltered since birth at her Kentucky home, Rowena Ballantyne has heard only whispered rumors of her grandfather Silas's vast fortune and grand manor in Pennsylvania. When her father receives a rare letter summoning him to New Hope, Rowena makes the journey with him and quickly finds herself in a whole new world--filled with family members she's never met, dances she's never learned, and a new side to the father she thought she knew. As she struggles to fit in during their extended stay, she finds a friend in James Sackett, the most valued steamship pilot of the Ballantynes' shipping line. Even with his help, Rowena feels she may never be comfortable in high society. Will she go her own way . . . to her peril?
With her signature attention to historical detail, Laura Frantz brings 1850s Pennsylvania alive with a tender story of loss, love, and loyalty. Fans will cheer for this final installment of the Ballatyne saga.
With her signature attention to historical detail, Laura Frantz brings 1850s Pennsylvania alive with a tender story of loss, love, and loyalty. Fans will cheer for this final installment of the Ballatyne saga.
398 pages, Paperback
First published September 9, 2014
120 people are currently reading
2132 people want to read
About the author
Laura Frantz
21 books2,766 followersLaura Frantz is passionate about all things historical, particularly the 18th-century, and writes her manuscripts in longhand first. Her stories often incorporate Scottish themes that reflect her family heritage. She is a direct descendant of George Hume, Wedderburn Castle, Berwickshire, Scotland, who was exiled to the American colonies for his role in the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715, settled in Virginia, and is credited with teaching George Washington surveying in the years 1748-1750. Frantz lives and writes in a log cabin in the heart of Kentucky.According to Publishers Weekly, "Frantz has done her historical homework." With her signature attention to historical detail and emotional depth, she is represented by Janet Kobobel Grant, Literary Agent & Founder, Books & Such Literary Agency of Santa Rosa, California.Readers can find Laura Frantz at www.laurafrantz.net.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 309 reviews
September 12, 2021
This was a 4.5 ⭐️ For me! I loved the conclusion to the Ballantyne Legacy and I am so sad it’s over. I don’t know why I was sleeping on this series and had delayed in picking these books up…all 3 of them were SO good and uniquely different!!
With this story in particular I felt like I was watching a movie, the scenes and the essence of the characters and their conversations was captured so well, I could hear the emotion in their voices and the passion in their words. I also really loved the main character, Wren. Loved her personality. She was kind, yet, honest and spoke her mind easily. She was also so down-to-earth and the love that blossomed between her and James was so innocent and pure. Laura Frantz writes such beautiful stories with such depth. Her characters are often so good and noble, kind and yet imperfect and relatable. I wish I could meet them in real life! Additionally, I love how Laura always, consistently weaves in sound, Biblical truths in her stories. I often find myself feeling uplifted and encouraged when the characters talk about the Lord and their relationship with Him.
These books can be read alone but it would be best to read in order, it’s so much more fulfilling read in sequence. With each book you continue to see the same characters and learn ‘how they’re doing’ … not to mention you grow attached to everyone and it’s fun to continue seeing them pop in and out!
With this story in particular I felt like I was watching a movie, the scenes and the essence of the characters and their conversations was captured so well, I could hear the emotion in their voices and the passion in their words. I also really loved the main character, Wren. Loved her personality. She was kind, yet, honest and spoke her mind easily. She was also so down-to-earth and the love that blossomed between her and James was so innocent and pure. Laura Frantz writes such beautiful stories with such depth. Her characters are often so good and noble, kind and yet imperfect and relatable. I wish I could meet them in real life! Additionally, I love how Laura always, consistently weaves in sound, Biblical truths in her stories. I often find myself feeling uplifted and encouraged when the characters talk about the Lord and their relationship with Him.
These books can be read alone but it would be best to read in order, it’s so much more fulfilling read in sequence. With each book you continue to see the same characters and learn ‘how they’re doing’ … not to mention you grow attached to everyone and it’s fun to continue seeing them pop in and out!
October 21, 2020
The only problem with an expertly crafted series is that now I'm sad to say goodbye to these beloved characters. (Mission accomplished, dear author!) Wren is a wholly lovable heroine. I think we can all relate to her as she is thrust into unfamiliar circumstances beyond her control. She is vulernable, yet displays a satisfying strength and moxie when it counts most.
I loved the lush settings for this novel, deftly painted by Laura Frantz. I also enjoyed so much that we got to know three generations of this family of characters, including the noble and the black sheep. Laura has a way of making us care about each one of them, and I loved getting to know Ellie's daughter Izannah, as well.
As far as series go, this novel brings a beautiful conclusion that I refuse to spoil for you, but let's just say it made my heart sing. Ah, for the love of story!
I loved the lush settings for this novel, deftly painted by Laura Frantz. I also enjoyed so much that we got to know three generations of this family of characters, including the noble and the black sheep. Laura has a way of making us care about each one of them, and I loved getting to know Ellie's daughter Izannah, as well.
As far as series go, this novel brings a beautiful conclusion that I refuse to spoil for you, but let's just say it made my heart sing. Ah, for the love of story!
January 2, 2015
Inspirational historical fiction doesn't get any better than a Laura Frantz novel, and Love’s Fortune is no exception. Frantz’s novels are my favorite for two important reasons – the rich historical details and the gradually-built, tension-filled romance. Her characters are always memorable and their motivations realistic. After getting to know the Ballantyne’s over the course of their three novels, I was sad to say goodbye to them, but utterly satisfied with the conclusion of their story.
With Wren Ballantyne, Frantz seemed to take the things I most loved about Eden and Ellie, and place them realistically into Wren’s character. Wren was raised in Kentucky, so her southern speech and unpretentious manner set her apart from her Pennsylvania family. Though sheltered and naïve, much like her grandmother Eden was as a girl, she still has a spark of defiance, but also desire to make her father proud and be worthy of the Ballantyne legacy. Though matter of fact about her duties as a Ballantyne, Wren can’t help but yearn for something more for her life, and yet, she knows that isn’t to be found in wealth and excess.
The plot in this story isn’t filled with action, but rather focuses on the family dynamics and issues of the time. Frantz is particular about what details she chooses to impart, but for me, it is the perfect amount of setting description and historical detail. I loved the atmosphere that she created in the novel, and it’s clear that she does extensive research into the time period and setting. Wherever I “was” in the story, I was truly immersed. I loved the details about steamships as a mode of transport, and felt the sting of the rapidly increasing progress of the railroad predicted to overtake it. I never would have thought that I would find a noble steamship captain within these pages, but Captain James Sackett was the epitome of understated gentleman. Though I don’t think any Frantz hero will top Silas Ballantyne (sigh!), James certainly held his own.
Obviously a historical romance wouldn’t be complete without that romantic element, and Love’s Fortune happens to have one of the most tension-filled kiss scenes I’ve read in a long time. Laura Frantz just proves once again that longing and desire can be communicated in such a beautiful way. She also focused a bit on some of the side characters, and since their story was tied up with Wren’s, it added a lot to the story. The ending was spot-on for the story and so fitting to Wren’s character. The Ballantyne Legacy is a wonderful trilogy and is on my keeper shelf. I will definitely be re-reading them and am eagerly waiting for whatever story Laura’s pens next.
I loved Wren Ballantyne’s simple, heartfelt prayer: “For all that Thy love has yet in store for me, O God, I give Thee gracious thanks.”
5 stars!
With Wren Ballantyne, Frantz seemed to take the things I most loved about Eden and Ellie, and place them realistically into Wren’s character. Wren was raised in Kentucky, so her southern speech and unpretentious manner set her apart from her Pennsylvania family. Though sheltered and naïve, much like her grandmother Eden was as a girl, she still has a spark of defiance, but also desire to make her father proud and be worthy of the Ballantyne legacy. Though matter of fact about her duties as a Ballantyne, Wren can’t help but yearn for something more for her life, and yet, she knows that isn’t to be found in wealth and excess.
The plot in this story isn’t filled with action, but rather focuses on the family dynamics and issues of the time. Frantz is particular about what details she chooses to impart, but for me, it is the perfect amount of setting description and historical detail. I loved the atmosphere that she created in the novel, and it’s clear that she does extensive research into the time period and setting. Wherever I “was” in the story, I was truly immersed. I loved the details about steamships as a mode of transport, and felt the sting of the rapidly increasing progress of the railroad predicted to overtake it. I never would have thought that I would find a noble steamship captain within these pages, but Captain James Sackett was the epitome of understated gentleman. Though I don’t think any Frantz hero will top Silas Ballantyne (sigh!), James certainly held his own.
Obviously a historical romance wouldn’t be complete without that romantic element, and Love’s Fortune happens to have one of the most tension-filled kiss scenes I’ve read in a long time. Laura Frantz just proves once again that longing and desire can be communicated in such a beautiful way. She also focused a bit on some of the side characters, and since their story was tied up with Wren’s, it added a lot to the story. The ending was spot-on for the story and so fitting to Wren’s character. The Ballantyne Legacy is a wonderful trilogy and is on my keeper shelf. I will definitely be re-reading them and am eagerly waiting for whatever story Laura’s pens next.
I loved Wren Ballantyne’s simple, heartfelt prayer: “For all that Thy love has yet in store for me, O God, I give Thee gracious thanks.”
5 stars!
September 6, 2014
Guys, you know if you've visited my blog at any given time, you can find a post about romance. Be it in book form or a movie or TV miniseries, I'm pretty much addicted to a good love story. There's a reason why Laura Frantz is one of my favorite writers. It's not because she pens good romances, it's because she pens epic, unforgettable, heart-tugging, amaaaazing romances.
Since I first read The Frontiersman's Daughter way back when, I'm beginning to think that nobody knows the frontier better than Frantz! While Love's Fortune isn't set in the frontier, but rather in the burgeoning industrial city of mid-19th century Pittsburgh, it still had an air of wildness and unpredictability about it. Living in the city with its dank back alleyways and cloying puffs of smoke was equally as dangerous as the woods of Kentucky and Laura Frantz deftly brings both to life.
As with any of her stories, amid the daring and danger, the sweet, gentle romance manages to weave its way into your heart. This time there's not just one love story, but a pair between two couples you can't help but root for. A few times the gentlemen in the story were frustrating to the point of asking for a smack from this reader to prod them in the right direction, but what's a good book if you don't feel passionately about the characters in it? The entire Ballantyne Legacy series has been full of characters who are easy to relate to and authentic. If you've enjoyed the previous two books, you will more than likely love this tale and wish it wasn't the last book in the series!
~ My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars ~
*I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
Since I first read The Frontiersman's Daughter way back when, I'm beginning to think that nobody knows the frontier better than Frantz! While Love's Fortune isn't set in the frontier, but rather in the burgeoning industrial city of mid-19th century Pittsburgh, it still had an air of wildness and unpredictability about it. Living in the city with its dank back alleyways and cloying puffs of smoke was equally as dangerous as the woods of Kentucky and Laura Frantz deftly brings both to life.
As with any of her stories, amid the daring and danger, the sweet, gentle romance manages to weave its way into your heart. This time there's not just one love story, but a pair between two couples you can't help but root for. A few times the gentlemen in the story were frustrating to the point of asking for a smack from this reader to prod them in the right direction, but what's a good book if you don't feel passionately about the characters in it? The entire Ballantyne Legacy series has been full of characters who are easy to relate to and authentic. If you've enjoyed the previous two books, you will more than likely love this tale and wish it wasn't the last book in the series!
~ My Rating: 5 out of 5 stars ~
*I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
December 29, 2018
I just could not finish this one. A disappointing end to an otherwise great series. Everything felt forced and the main characters were disappointing.
January 16, 2023
4 stars ✨
Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear—not absence of fear. MARK TWAIN
Another book, and now series in the books by Mrs. Frantz. I’m so glad I tried this author. Her writing is amazing and the history so lush, I will definitely be binging on more of her books in the future.
Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear—not absence of fear. MARK TWAIN
Another book, and now series in the books by Mrs. Frantz. I’m so glad I tried this author. Her writing is amazing and the history so lush, I will definitely be binging on more of her books in the future.
January 1, 2016
SUMMARY: Sheltered since birth at her Kentucky home, Rowena Ballantyne has heard only whispered rumors of her grandfather Silas's vast fortune and grand manor in Pennsylvania. When her father receives a rare letter summoning him to New Hope, Rowena makes the journey with him and quickly finds herself in a whole new world--filled with family members she's never met, dances she's never learned, and a new side to the father she thought she knew. As she struggles to fit in during their extended stay, she finds a friend in James Sackett, the most valued steamship pilot of the Ballantynes' shipping line. Even with his help, Rowena feels she may never be comfortable in high society. Will she go her own way . . . to her peril?
With her signature attention to historical detail, Laura Frantz brings 1850s Pennsylvania alive with a tender story of loss, love, and loyalty. Fans will cheer for this final installment of the Ballatyne saga.
REVIEW: First and foremost I must say I hate to see this series end and definitely could see how it could be continued from where the author ended it. Once again with finesse and great attention to historical detail, Frantz has penned a historical romance that bring the time period to life. From rich heiresses who must ply the social scene (including all the proper rules and constrictions) to find a husband before they are considered placed on the shelf to the tension between the pro-slavery people and the abolitionists, each page is filled with history come to life.
There are characters to love and watch grow, develop and strengthen in their faith (Rowena, James, Silas) and there are characters who will fill you with dislike (Audra, Bennett, Elspeth) But their disparities are what makes this tale come alive and feel so real.
The detail in the plot regarding the society of the that period makes the reader appreciate the good changes time has brought to the role of women in society.
I did feel the ending was wrapped up rather abruptly after all the tension and build up. It almost could have been written to leave the reader hanging and continued on to one more book to conclude some of the story lines.
FAVORITE QUOTES:
"For all that Thy love has yet in store for me, O God, I give Thee gracious thanks.
"Love was a chancy endeavor, best left to two hearts and the Lord."
"Somehow amid the pressures and protocols of business and society, he'd stop listening. stopped responding, stopped taking the gospel to heart."
With her signature attention to historical detail, Laura Frantz brings 1850s Pennsylvania alive with a tender story of loss, love, and loyalty. Fans will cheer for this final installment of the Ballatyne saga.
REVIEW: First and foremost I must say I hate to see this series end and definitely could see how it could be continued from where the author ended it. Once again with finesse and great attention to historical detail, Frantz has penned a historical romance that bring the time period to life. From rich heiresses who must ply the social scene (including all the proper rules and constrictions) to find a husband before they are considered placed on the shelf to the tension between the pro-slavery people and the abolitionists, each page is filled with history come to life.
There are characters to love and watch grow, develop and strengthen in their faith (Rowena, James, Silas) and there are characters who will fill you with dislike (Audra, Bennett, Elspeth) But their disparities are what makes this tale come alive and feel so real.
The detail in the plot regarding the society of the that period makes the reader appreciate the good changes time has brought to the role of women in society.
I did feel the ending was wrapped up rather abruptly after all the tension and build up. It almost could have been written to leave the reader hanging and continued on to one more book to conclude some of the story lines.
FAVORITE QUOTES:
"For all that Thy love has yet in store for me, O God, I give Thee gracious thanks.
"Love was a chancy endeavor, best left to two hearts and the Lord."
"Somehow amid the pressures and protocols of business and society, he'd stop listening. stopped responding, stopped taking the gospel to heart."
August 28, 2017
I'm sad to say that this book was disappointing. While I enjoyed the historical backdrop, the dual povs, seeing characters from previous books again, and the engaging writing, the MCs failed to compel me in any way. There was also a big grey cloud of melancholy hanging over this entire book and it was definitely a downer. The h spends more than half of the book being ungrateful and feeling sorry for herself. Her father, Ansel, a favourite character of mine from the previous book, was frustratingly absent, and the H's inner monologue was just depressing. And all of his issues were confusing to me as the author couldn't pick one to focus on. He wasn't the same class as the h. He was a man with a target on his back. His vocation was dangerous and he could be blown up to bits at any time. Any of those reasons would have been compelling had the author merely made one of them the H's main concern. As it was written, his hang ups were a little schizophrenic. Add to that the villains of this story (not true villains, but merely selfish/tunnel visioned people) were too single faceted to be believable. Bennett and Aunt Andra didn't seem to have any redeeming qualities and therefore read like caricatures.
The angst was annoying, due to lack of communication or the mantra of society at that time: people of good breeding don't talk about anything important such as politics, religion, money, or feelings. That, unfortunately, lead to a lot of misunderstandings and relationships that had to be saved by eleventh hour declarations. The h's ill treatment of one of her suitors was also wrong. It rubbed me the wrong way that the author let the situation with him go as far as it did. I didn't love that character, but he deserved better than what she did to him. The endings that the author wrote to tie up the various story lines were rushed and a bit inelegant. I appreciate that she wanted us to know what ultimately happened with all the characters, but it was almost better not knowing. I know...it's weird that I don't want to know every thing.
Overall, I'm glad this series is over. If this had not been the last book, I would have been bothered by the fact that there was more story to read but I had chosen not to. I will be more careful in choosing to read this author's books in the future. It seems like most of her books have a sad bent to them without a sufficient counterbalance of encouraging times.
The angst was annoying, due to lack of communication or the mantra of society at that time: people of good breeding don't talk about anything important such as politics, religion, money, or feelings. That, unfortunately, lead to a lot of misunderstandings and relationships that had to be saved by eleventh hour declarations. The h's ill treatment of one of her suitors was also wrong. It rubbed me the wrong way that the author let the situation with him go as far as it did. I didn't love that character, but he deserved better than what she did to him. The endings that the author wrote to tie up the various story lines were rushed and a bit inelegant. I appreciate that she wanted us to know what ultimately happened with all the characters, but it was almost better not knowing. I know...it's weird that I don't want to know every thing.
Overall, I'm glad this series is over. If this had not been the last book, I would have been bothered by the fact that there was more story to read but I had chosen not to. I will be more careful in choosing to read this author's books in the future. It seems like most of her books have a sad bent to them without a sufficient counterbalance of encouraging times.
December 7, 2014
Wren's story was an enjoyable journey. It was also rewarding to get updated on characters from the prior Ballantyne novels.
May 6, 2019
Rating 3.5 stars.
In this final installment of the Ballantyne legacy, we meet up with Eden and Silas' grandchildren. The author had me in some roller-coaster moments, where I found myself liking and loving some characters (Wren, Izannah and James), to getting irritated with some of them (Malachi) and disliking others. It was so clear again that "the fathers" do not make the children. You can do your best but at the end each person is responsible for their own decisions and actions.
James was such a gentlemen with an unselfish heart, even giving up his happiness to ensure Wren will be save and well-cared for. I liked Izannah from the start and found my heart breaking along with hers at one point. Wren was such a strong character, but had to learn who she is and not to fit into the box others want to squeeze her in. Silas had again so much wisdom to impart - one think which stood out was where he told James he shouldn't be afraid to live just because he is afraid of things happening which is also not certain (paraphrasing here).
I was quite surprised about the English influence there was among the rich and privilege - where eligible young women had a season etc. I know USA started with British influence, but was quite surprising how that part was still very important in the social world.
The ending was quite different to what I expected.
Recommended to fans of historical fiction.
In this final installment of the Ballantyne legacy, we meet up with Eden and Silas' grandchildren. The author had me in some roller-coaster moments, where I found myself liking and loving some characters (Wren, Izannah and James), to getting irritated with some of them (Malachi) and disliking others. It was so clear again that "the fathers" do not make the children. You can do your best but at the end each person is responsible for their own decisions and actions.
James was such a gentlemen with an unselfish heart, even giving up his happiness to ensure Wren will be save and well-cared for. I liked Izannah from the start and found my heart breaking along with hers at one point. Wren was such a strong character, but had to learn who she is and not to fit into the box others want to squeeze her in. Silas had again so much wisdom to impart - one think which stood out was where he told James he shouldn't be afraid to live just because he is afraid of things happening which is also not certain (paraphrasing here).
I was quite surprised about the English influence there was among the rich and privilege - where eligible young women had a season etc. I know USA started with British influence, but was quite surprising how that part was still very important in the social world.
The ending was quite different to what I expected.
Recommended to fans of historical fiction.
September 20, 2014
Love’s Fortune is the third book in the Ballantyne Legacy series. If you have not read the previous books, I encourage you to do so simply because Love’s Reckoning and Love’s Awakening are beautifully written and contain characters who have stayed with me, long after I returned the books to my bookshelf. Love’s Fortune can now be placed in that same category…with characters who were able to burrow into my heart for keeps.
Rowena “Wren” Ballantyne is a character that I could not help but love. Her parents raised and sheltered her in a small Kentucky town. In Love’s Fortune, Wren finds herself dropped into a large, powerful family and all of the society trappings she is unfamiliar with. Wren’s sweet and loving nature are evident in this book. The choices she makes, some of them naïve, are usually to help someone she cares for.
James Sackett, successful steamboat pilot and employee for Silas Ballantyne, knows that he owes his successes to the Ballantyne family. It takes a while for him to recognize God’s hand in his life experiences. He is brooding at times and feels unworthy of desiring Wren as a wife. This inner turmoil makes him an excellent hero for the novel. Sometimes there is nothing better than a man with a sacrificial heart toward a heroine, wanting what he feels is best for her.
The tension between these two is great. I really liked their personalities and loved the portions of the book when they were in each other’s company. The ending of the novel is sweet, satisfying, and beautifully written.
My thanks to the author and Revell for the complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review, which I have given.
You can read this review on my blog at:
http://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.co...
Rowena “Wren” Ballantyne is a character that I could not help but love. Her parents raised and sheltered her in a small Kentucky town. In Love’s Fortune, Wren finds herself dropped into a large, powerful family and all of the society trappings she is unfamiliar with. Wren’s sweet and loving nature are evident in this book. The choices she makes, some of them naïve, are usually to help someone she cares for.
James Sackett, successful steamboat pilot and employee for Silas Ballantyne, knows that he owes his successes to the Ballantyne family. It takes a while for him to recognize God’s hand in his life experiences. He is brooding at times and feels unworthy of desiring Wren as a wife. This inner turmoil makes him an excellent hero for the novel. Sometimes there is nothing better than a man with a sacrificial heart toward a heroine, wanting what he feels is best for her.
The tension between these two is great. I really liked their personalities and loved the portions of the book when they were in each other’s company. The ending of the novel is sweet, satisfying, and beautifully written.
My thanks to the author and Revell for the complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review, which I have given.
You can read this review on my blog at:
http://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.co...
September 8, 2017
Love's Fortune by Laura Frantz
Time Frame: 1823-1850
Location: Kentucky and Pittsburgh, PA
Main Characters:
Wren Ballantyne aka Rowena
Ansel Ballantyne: Wren's father
James Sackett: Single, handsome steamboat captain, close friend to Ballantynes
Silas Ballantyne: Grandfather, patriarch
Benett Ballantyne: Grandson to Silas, and heir
Izannah Turlock: Wren's cousin, and now best friend
Andra Ballantyne: Aunt who attempts to make her over for the Pittsburgh "season"
Synopsis
The rest is for the reader of this delightful book to enjoy.
I loved much of this book. Wonderful story, wonderful characters (except Bennett) and a loving family that rally around each other (except Bennett… pffft…what a piece of poo.). My only desire for this book would have been a bit more detail about a few things.
- Perhaps a bit more regarding the particular "cargo" on the boats, like where they were from, how the crew got them on, where they went, how did they live onboard, and exit the boats.
- Details about who wanted James harmed, why, and the reason it took so long to catch and harm him, and why it took such an elaborate ruse to get him to a place where they finally got him (a second time).
- Also, what was all this about Charlotte? Seemed like this side story needed more explanation. It just sort of happened, someone was suspected to be at fault, but nothing came of that, nor why it happened at all?
- Then, no one seemed to realize Wren was Bennett's pawn for his own financial gain? And she told no one of his threats?
- And after she realized Bennett had sent her on a wild goose chase, why did she run away from James when he found her? That made no sense.
I suppose those made for some intrigue, but still, it all made me wonder.
However, in spite of my head-cocking over these issues, I could not think of this as anything but a delightful book, which I highly recommend.
Time Frame: 1823-1850
Location: Kentucky and Pittsburgh, PA
Main Characters:
Wren Ballantyne aka Rowena
Ansel Ballantyne: Wren's father
James Sackett: Single, handsome steamboat captain, close friend to Ballantynes
Silas Ballantyne: Grandfather, patriarch
Benett Ballantyne: Grandson to Silas, and heir
Izannah Turlock: Wren's cousin, and now best friend
Andra Ballantyne: Aunt who attempts to make her over for the Pittsburgh "season"
Synopsis
The rest is for the reader of this delightful book to enjoy.
I loved much of this book. Wonderful story, wonderful characters (except Bennett) and a loving family that rally around each other (except Bennett… pffft…what a piece of poo.). My only desire for this book would have been a bit more detail about a few things.
- Perhaps a bit more regarding the particular "cargo" on the boats, like where they were from, how the crew got them on, where they went, how did they live onboard, and exit the boats.
- Details about who wanted James harmed, why, and the reason it took so long to catch and harm him, and why it took such an elaborate ruse to get him to a place where they finally got him (a second time).
- Also, what was all this about Charlotte? Seemed like this side story needed more explanation. It just sort of happened, someone was suspected to be at fault, but nothing came of that, nor why it happened at all?
- Then, no one seemed to realize Wren was Bennett's pawn for his own financial gain? And she told no one of his threats?
- And after she realized Bennett had sent her on a wild goose chase, why did she run away from James when he found her? That made no sense.
I suppose those made for some intrigue, but still, it all made me wonder.
However, in spite of my head-cocking over these issues, I could not think of this as anything but a delightful book, which I highly recommend.
January 31, 2018
4.5 stars
November 24, 2015
Exquisite. Enthralling. Laura Frantz pens yet another novel rich with emotion, beauty, and historical depth.
Book three in the Ballantyne Legacy series, Love's Fortune delves into the life of Rowena (Wren) Ballantyne, who lives a simple existence in Kentucky with her father, Ansel. Though missing her mother, she loves her home. Then everything changes with a letter from her father's family... family she scarcely remembers. Grandfather Silas and Grandmother Eden Ballantyne. Uncle Jack and Aunt Ellie Turlock. As Wren is thrust into Pittsburgh high society, she's in danger of loosing not only her heart, but also herself, in the web of schemes some of her own relatives create.
Meanwhile, things are heating up in America as a whole. Rumors of war are whispered of. Anti-abolitionists are growing more bold and vicious; a grand problem for steamship pilot James Sackett, who secrets slaves to freedom from the Ballantynes' shipping line.
Not much is as it seems, yet love remains...
Each time I pick up one of Laura Frantz's books, it feels kind of like meeting up with an old friend, yet going on a fresh adventure all at the same time. She writes with such a captivating charm, its so easy to get lost in her sentences; in the simplistic wilderness of Kentucky, the intrigues of Pittsburgh, the homeyness of Scotland. Her characters are not easily forgotten. The gentle and quiet spirits of the women always delight me afresh... their innocence, sweetness, inner strength... it seems you seldom find that in novels these days. The love stories are always so deep and heartfelt. I especially noticed that in Love's Fortune, of Wren's romance. It tugged at my heartstrings for sure! :)
I really appreciated the faith elements of this novel. They were woven in so flawlessly, yet so fully. I saw growth in both Wren and some of the other characters' lives, and it was beautiful.
There was sort of four main characters in Love's Fortune. Rowena Ballantyne. Her cousin, Izannah Turlock. James Sackett. And Malachi Cameron. Both men are acquainted with the Ballantynes and Turlocks. It was a little different following the lives of four characters, I don't think Laura Frantz did that in her other novels; yet it didn't take away from the book. It was sweet to watch Izannah's story unfold additionally.
I don't know what else to say without revealing parts of the story that I shouldn't! :) I very much enjoyed Love's Fortune. It was lovely really, with fascinating history, intriguing plots, heart-melting romance, beautiful characters, and just flawless writing.
I heard somewhere that Love's Fortune is the last book of the Ballantyne Legacy series (coming after Love's Reckoning and Love's Awakening). That saddens me... :( However, it was a satisfying and beautiful conclusion to the series.
In any case, I eagerly await Laura Frantz's next release, whatever that may be! Let's hope it comes soon, anyway! :)
I received a copy of Love's Fortune from Revell in exchange for my honest review.
Book three in the Ballantyne Legacy series, Love's Fortune delves into the life of Rowena (Wren) Ballantyne, who lives a simple existence in Kentucky with her father, Ansel. Though missing her mother, she loves her home. Then everything changes with a letter from her father's family... family she scarcely remembers. Grandfather Silas and Grandmother Eden Ballantyne. Uncle Jack and Aunt Ellie Turlock. As Wren is thrust into Pittsburgh high society, she's in danger of loosing not only her heart, but also herself, in the web of schemes some of her own relatives create.
Meanwhile, things are heating up in America as a whole. Rumors of war are whispered of. Anti-abolitionists are growing more bold and vicious; a grand problem for steamship pilot James Sackett, who secrets slaves to freedom from the Ballantynes' shipping line.
Not much is as it seems, yet love remains...
Each time I pick up one of Laura Frantz's books, it feels kind of like meeting up with an old friend, yet going on a fresh adventure all at the same time. She writes with such a captivating charm, its so easy to get lost in her sentences; in the simplistic wilderness of Kentucky, the intrigues of Pittsburgh, the homeyness of Scotland. Her characters are not easily forgotten. The gentle and quiet spirits of the women always delight me afresh... their innocence, sweetness, inner strength... it seems you seldom find that in novels these days. The love stories are always so deep and heartfelt. I especially noticed that in Love's Fortune, of Wren's romance. It tugged at my heartstrings for sure! :)
I really appreciated the faith elements of this novel. They were woven in so flawlessly, yet so fully. I saw growth in both Wren and some of the other characters' lives, and it was beautiful.
There was sort of four main characters in Love's Fortune. Rowena Ballantyne. Her cousin, Izannah Turlock. James Sackett. And Malachi Cameron. Both men are acquainted with the Ballantynes and Turlocks. It was a little different following the lives of four characters, I don't think Laura Frantz did that in her other novels; yet it didn't take away from the book. It was sweet to watch Izannah's story unfold additionally.
I don't know what else to say without revealing parts of the story that I shouldn't! :) I very much enjoyed Love's Fortune. It was lovely really, with fascinating history, intriguing plots, heart-melting romance, beautiful characters, and just flawless writing.
I heard somewhere that Love's Fortune is the last book of the Ballantyne Legacy series (coming after Love's Reckoning and Love's Awakening). That saddens me... :( However, it was a satisfying and beautiful conclusion to the series.
In any case, I eagerly await Laura Frantz's next release, whatever that may be! Let's hope it comes soon, anyway! :)
I received a copy of Love's Fortune from Revell in exchange for my honest review.
September 24, 2014
Breathtaking and intoxicating. Surely there are other words to describe Laura’s writings, but I can think of no others at the moment. The moment I met Wren Ballantyne—Silas and Eden Ballantyne’s granddaughter—I knew I would love her. Her personality, I felt, was similar to Eden’s. Wren was sweet, innocent, and unpretentious.
Wren’s love interest was James Sackett, an old friend of her father’s. I could not help but admire and like James from the very beginning. He had a certain aura of authority about him that I do not find in other male characters in books I read. The thing about this author is that she doesn’t tell it so much as show it. She means every word she writes and every detail adds either beauty or reinforcement to her characters and theme. I enjoy the way Laura adds heart-rending desperation to her stories. It draws the reader in unequivocally. Every time I read one of Laura’s books, I sigh at the end, sorry that it’s over.
I really like how this trilogy carries through three generations. It allows for new characters to be created, though the much-loved old ones will still be at least somewhat present in the story. Seeing what Laura has done with this series, I cannot wait for her next novel. Whatever it will be about, I know that it will be wonderful.
I give Love’s Fortune 5 out of 5 stars.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publishers, for my honest review, which I have given. The opinions expressed in this review are mine and mine alone.*
Wren’s love interest was James Sackett, an old friend of her father’s. I could not help but admire and like James from the very beginning. He had a certain aura of authority about him that I do not find in other male characters in books I read. The thing about this author is that she doesn’t tell it so much as show it. She means every word she writes and every detail adds either beauty or reinforcement to her characters and theme. I enjoy the way Laura adds heart-rending desperation to her stories. It draws the reader in unequivocally. Every time I read one of Laura’s books, I sigh at the end, sorry that it’s over.
I really like how this trilogy carries through three generations. It allows for new characters to be created, though the much-loved old ones will still be at least somewhat present in the story. Seeing what Laura has done with this series, I cannot wait for her next novel. Whatever it will be about, I know that it will be wonderful.
I give Love’s Fortune 5 out of 5 stars.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publishers, for my honest review, which I have given. The opinions expressed in this review are mine and mine alone.*
April 28, 2016
I have read all of the books in this series but this one might just be my favorite. While you could read the books apart from each others, since it is a family, I recommend starting at the first book.
This book grabbed me and sucked me in until the end, I don't think I ever set it down. Rowena or Wren is a great character and I loved reading about her life. Her attitude with life and simple ways make this book so much better. James is also a great lead male character. He is smart and not an over the top hero type. Laura has made all of her characters realistic with real problems but creates a beautiful story continuing on the Ballatyne legacy.
I loved the setting and getting to imagine being on a steamship. Silas and Eden are also strongly in the story line which I also enjoyed. Wren struggles with living in high society and she has to decide if she wants to marry as a business transaction, for love, or perhaps go her own way.
This is a sweeping story of family and love-beautifully written.
Highly recommend this book and the rest of the series!
Watch a video on how the cover was made!
"I received this book from Revell for free in exchange for an honest review."
December 10, 2015
This was not a favorite; but still a very well written Laura Frantz read. I think I would have enjoyed Wren's story more had she been in Kentucky. The square going on around Izannah and Wren and James and Malachi did annoy me. I don't much care for that type of story-line. Frantz does create moments of whimsy and creativity in her writing that will keep me returning for more. I also would have loved to have finally read that Andra was keeping company with something other than bitterness and disdain. I think her story would have been quite interesting.
April 15, 2023
I have such a book hangover that I had to email Laura and tell her. I absolutely love the Ballantyne family and could read about them forever. Three strong men with three equally strong wives that were treated as partners, not just arm candy.
Because the synopsis didn't say who Wren's father was, I thought for sure it was
It is solidified in this third installment (I am truly hoping for at least one more book in this series!!) that Andra is just...not a nice person. How did Eden and Silas get two jerks for children?! Don't get me started on Benjamin and what he got away with! I would have disowned the lot of them.
Rowena is so much like her grandmother, though she doesn't realize it. I wish she would have put Andra in her place, but then again, that's not really her style. I love how sweet she is with Addie, a girl at the orphanage. I just love Wren lol
I love James. You get to meet him towards the end of Love's Awakening. While he grew up in the orphanage, when his parentage is mentioned it's not a huge surprise.
Silas and Eden...could there be a better patriarch and matriarch? No, there could not. They are full of God's love and are just the sweetest people.
Because the synopsis didn't say who Wren's father was, I thought for sure it was
It is solidified in this third installment (I am truly hoping for at least one more book in this series!!) that Andra is just...not a nice person. How did Eden and Silas get two jerks for children?! Don't get me started on Benjamin and what he got away with! I would have disowned the lot of them.
Rowena is so much like her grandmother, though she doesn't realize it. I wish she would have put Andra in her place, but then again, that's not really her style. I love how sweet she is with Addie, a girl at the orphanage. I just love Wren lol
I love James. You get to meet him towards the end of Love's Awakening. While he grew up in the orphanage, when his parentage is mentioned it's not a huge surprise.
Silas and Eden...could there be a better patriarch and matriarch? No, there could not. They are full of God's love and are just the sweetest people.
December 3, 2025
Lekker ff ontspannen in drukke tijden
April 28, 2024
Shame on me for never having reviewed any of Laura Frantz's books before. I've read and enjoyed each and every one and couldn't believe, when it came time to write this review, that I've never devoted a blog review to her before!
Time to fix that--and what better time to do it than with the book that quickly became my favorite of Laura's.
With a heroine I could well relate to and a sweeping love story that beckoned me to read it slowly (when usually I devour books in a few days), Love's Fortune has become one of my favorite books of the year.
I love Wren. Rowena Ballantyne is her birth name, but that is almost too royal-sounding for the girl raised in Cane Run, Kentucky, where she wore simple dresses and made violins. But Wren must become Rowena Ballantyne when her father forsakes Cane Run for Pittsburgh, the home of all the other Ballantynes, who are as good as royalty in Pennsylvania.
There Wren is pulled between society and who she really is, what is expected of her and what she really wants.
And what she really wants? Well, that is really James Sackett, who is an honorable man from less-than-honorable circumstances, who is hated by some for his abolitionist work. Wren and James both see through the trappings others place on them--and see they are the same. But near-tragedy and danger and duty threaten to pull them apart.
Complete with the attention to historical detail that I love about Laura's work (did you know Pittsburgh was so dark with soot during the Industrial Revolution that they wrapped white-clad brides in sheets to protect them from the blackening?), this book sings. Wren is the type of heroine you want to remain loyal to, even with her flaws. And James is not so bad himself.
Couple that with the danger and intrigue subtly swinging its way behind the scenes. I loved how I wasn't sure until the last page how it would all turn out.
Treat yourself with this book. If you're at all a fan of history, grand love stories, or family sagas, this one will put you squarely in Laura Frantz's corner.
Time to fix that--and what better time to do it than with the book that quickly became my favorite of Laura's.
With a heroine I could well relate to and a sweeping love story that beckoned me to read it slowly (when usually I devour books in a few days), Love's Fortune has become one of my favorite books of the year.
I love Wren. Rowena Ballantyne is her birth name, but that is almost too royal-sounding for the girl raised in Cane Run, Kentucky, where she wore simple dresses and made violins. But Wren must become Rowena Ballantyne when her father forsakes Cane Run for Pittsburgh, the home of all the other Ballantynes, who are as good as royalty in Pennsylvania.
There Wren is pulled between society and who she really is, what is expected of her and what she really wants.
And what she really wants? Well, that is really James Sackett, who is an honorable man from less-than-honorable circumstances, who is hated by some for his abolitionist work. Wren and James both see through the trappings others place on them--and see they are the same. But near-tragedy and danger and duty threaten to pull them apart.
Complete with the attention to historical detail that I love about Laura's work (did you know Pittsburgh was so dark with soot during the Industrial Revolution that they wrapped white-clad brides in sheets to protect them from the blackening?), this book sings. Wren is the type of heroine you want to remain loyal to, even with her flaws. And James is not so bad himself.
Couple that with the danger and intrigue subtly swinging its way behind the scenes. I loved how I wasn't sure until the last page how it would all turn out.
Treat yourself with this book. If you're at all a fan of history, grand love stories, or family sagas, this one will put you squarely in Laura Frantz's corner.
August 30, 2014
This book is everything I hoped it would be and more. What better way to end the Ballantyne Legacy series than with a sweet story that covers three generations, giving you a connection to the characters you knew and loved before, while not diminishing the individual journey of Rowena "Wren" Ballantyne and braw James Sackett. I will confess I am a "Frantz-natic" but all that aside, I simply loved this book. Who can't relate to having their world turned upside down? What happens when home and everything good and familiar is taken away, and the unknown looms like the dark churning waters of the Ohio river? What happens when someone we love betrays us? When we are cut so deeply that the only way to survive is to move on- never forgetting the wound- never forgetting the love.
I fell in love with Wren and her simple, honest heart. Her passion for life is contagious. I fell in love with James (not hard, honestly ;D ) and his loyalty- deep & strong like the river currents he navigates. I fell in love with Silas and Eden, and Ellie and Jack all over again.
The melody of Love's Fortune will play on in your heart long after you've turned the last page, lingering like the sweet, whistled song of a wren. You don't want to miss this delightful final chapter of The Ballantyne Legacy.
*I was given a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts, opinions, and views expressed here are entirely my own, and in no way influenced by Revell Publishing, or anyone affiliated with this book.*
I fell in love with Wren and her simple, honest heart. Her passion for life is contagious. I fell in love with James (not hard, honestly ;D ) and his loyalty- deep & strong like the river currents he navigates. I fell in love with Silas and Eden, and Ellie and Jack all over again.
The melody of Love's Fortune will play on in your heart long after you've turned the last page, lingering like the sweet, whistled song of a wren. You don't want to miss this delightful final chapter of The Ballantyne Legacy.
*I was given a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts, opinions, and views expressed here are entirely my own, and in no way influenced by Revell Publishing, or anyone affiliated with this book.*
September 1, 2015
{About the Book}
Sheltered since birth at her Kentucky home, Rowena Ballantyne has heard only whispered rumors of her grandfather Silas's vast fortune and grand manor in Pennsylvania. When her father receives a rare letter summoning him to New Hope, Rowena makes the journey with him and quickly finds herself in a whole new world--filled with family members she's never met, dances she's never learned, and a new side to the father she thought she knew. As she struggles to fit in during their extended stay, she finds a friend in James Sackett, the most valued steamship pilot of the Ballantynes' shipping line. Even with his help, Rowena feels she may never be comfortable in high society. Will she go her own way . . . to her peril?
With her signature attention to historical detail, Laura Frantz brings 1850s Pennsylvania alive with a tender story of loss, love, and loyalty. Fans will cheer for this final installment of the Ballatyne saga.
{My Review}
I have so many people telling me this series is so amazing and I have to try it. Well, as an avid fan of Historical Romance I thought to give it a shot. It was an okay read at best. The writing was good to a point and odd at other times. This isn't a series I'll be continuing.
Sheltered since birth at her Kentucky home, Rowena Ballantyne has heard only whispered rumors of her grandfather Silas's vast fortune and grand manor in Pennsylvania. When her father receives a rare letter summoning him to New Hope, Rowena makes the journey with him and quickly finds herself in a whole new world--filled with family members she's never met, dances she's never learned, and a new side to the father she thought she knew. As she struggles to fit in during their extended stay, she finds a friend in James Sackett, the most valued steamship pilot of the Ballantynes' shipping line. Even with his help, Rowena feels she may never be comfortable in high society. Will she go her own way . . . to her peril?
With her signature attention to historical detail, Laura Frantz brings 1850s Pennsylvania alive with a tender story of loss, love, and loyalty. Fans will cheer for this final installment of the Ballatyne saga.
{My Review}
I have so many people telling me this series is so amazing and I have to try it. Well, as an avid fan of Historical Romance I thought to give it a shot. It was an okay read at best. The writing was good to a point and odd at other times. This isn't a series I'll be continuing.
September 23, 2014
There are only a handful of authors that I adore enough to pre-order their books and read them right away. Laura Frantz is absolutely one of those. Her knowledge of American history is astounding and beautiful. She is so passionate about history and authenticity that she writes her manuscripts in longhand first.
Love's Fortune is the last book in a The Ballantyne Legacy Trilogy. This book revolves around Wren Ballantyne. Raised in the wilds of Kentucky during the early 1800's, she is wild, free and has no aspirations towards wealth and title. She is sent to live in Pitttsburgh with her wealthy grandparents and must learn to become a gentile woman while finding a husband. She is thrown into the path of two exceptional gentlemen and must choose what it is she really wants in life.
Of course, I am sad to see the series end. However, I do look forward to seeing what Laura has next! I am giving this a rare 5 Stars because history is so beautifully intertwined with great storytelling.
Thanks so much, netgalley.com, for this book in return for an honest review. Here's to many more!!!
www.aTransparentMom.blogspot.com
Love's Fortune is the last book in a The Ballantyne Legacy Trilogy. This book revolves around Wren Ballantyne. Raised in the wilds of Kentucky during the early 1800's, she is wild, free and has no aspirations towards wealth and title. She is sent to live in Pitttsburgh with her wealthy grandparents and must learn to become a gentile woman while finding a husband. She is thrown into the path of two exceptional gentlemen and must choose what it is she really wants in life.
Of course, I am sad to see the series end. However, I do look forward to seeing what Laura has next! I am giving this a rare 5 Stars because history is so beautifully intertwined with great storytelling.
Thanks so much, netgalley.com, for this book in return for an honest review. Here's to many more!!!
www.aTransparentMom.blogspot.com
September 6, 2015
Dude, this book was great. I've loved this entire series. Finishing this makes me want to go back and reread the first one. I can't decide though if I like Frantz books that are set earlier in history where they get to be more gritty and crazy and less societally refined. This one was more like a lot of historical romance genre in that way with the ball and the 'season.' It was still great, don't get me wrong, and I was still drawn into the romance and the history, the thing I've always that's made Frantz' books stand out, in addition to her striking character relationships, is the settings, though. Anyway, I'm a Frantz fan for life, I'll always immediately pick up any book she writes. And now I totally want to go back and reread Silas and his wife's story!
August 19, 2018
I really enjoyed reading further into the Ballantyne family! Usually one finishes a novel and never hears about the people they just spent so much time getting to know. After the first book in this series, I was hesitant to continue, as Silas and Eden had such a dark story to get through before they were finally together...I felt dragged down by their experiences. By the time I finished this book, however, I was glad I finished, as I was able to follow them all through their lives. One would definitely need to read this series in order! I'm going back to give the 2nd book 5 stars as it was my favorite in the series.
February 21, 2016
This was a really good historical Christian romance novel. I liked the main woman a lot, and I thought her character was developed well throughout the story, but I thought the main man was not developed nearly as well. However, I still enjoyed the plot and found it entertaining, and I still look to reading more by this author, as I've thoroughly enjoyed all the books I've read by her so far.
September 26, 2023
As always, Laura Frantz's storytelling is nothing short of fantastic! Book 3 in the series The Ballantyne Legacy, Love's Fortune not only allows readers to experience the grander of days gone by, but gives a most satisfying ending. I'm glad to have had the chance to finally read this!
February 13, 2019
This book was the perfect way to end the series. It was a delight to read and I enjoyed every chapter.
November 4, 2025
I’ve been ruminating on this book, mostly Wren and James. While I found them likable, there were some aspects that left me puzzled.
First, Wren. It’s possible I missed something in the first chapter, but I could not have told you how old she was supposed to be for at least 3 chapters. Yes, she’s naive and backwoods, but it comes across as immature. I thought she was in her mid-late teens, but then it’s revealed that she’s 25?
James is sweet, but I’m not buying that with how trusted he is by the Ballantynes that he would never be considered “suitable marriage material” for Wren. He escorts her to the social events, and her dad and grandfather have a special bond with him.
Lastly, Malachi. He is a double minded man when it comes to courting. Pass.
Honorable mention, Bennet. Shady, shady, shady. And no satisfactory conclusion to his storyline.
Now for a positive… Given how much I adored the 2nd book, I adored getting so much page time for Ellie and Jack’s family.🥰
Very good series, lots of suspense in this last installment and I did enjoy it. The ending felt a bit rushed for me, a few more chapters to wrap it up wouldn’t have come amiss.
First, Wren. It’s possible I missed something in the first chapter, but I could not have told you how old she was supposed to be for at least 3 chapters. Yes, she’s naive and backwoods, but it comes across as immature. I thought she was in her mid-late teens, but then it’s revealed that she’s 25?
James is sweet, but I’m not buying that with how trusted he is by the Ballantynes that he would never be considered “suitable marriage material” for Wren. He escorts her to the social events, and her dad and grandfather have a special bond with him.
Lastly, Malachi. He is a double minded man when it comes to courting. Pass.
Honorable mention, Bennet. Shady, shady, shady. And no satisfactory conclusion to his storyline.
Now for a positive… Given how much I adored the 2nd book, I adored getting so much page time for Ellie and Jack’s family.🥰
Very good series, lots of suspense in this last installment and I did enjoy it. The ending felt a bit rushed for me, a few more chapters to wrap it up wouldn’t have come amiss.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 26, 2018
The final book in The Ballantyne Legacy nicely brings the family full circle, and I enjoyed revisiting characters featured in the first two books of the series. Wren and James are featured in Love's Fortune, and I rooted for them to finally find a way clear to each other.
Admittedly, at times I had a hard time understanding James' obstacles, which I think were delineated better later in the book. Most of the time, I just wanted to hug Wren and take her back to Kentucky.
As a native Pittsburgher, I enjoyed the setting, seeing the gateway to the west evolving into a more traditional city with the advent of the railroads.
Fans of historical fiction will enjoy this series!
Admittedly, at times I had a hard time understanding James' obstacles, which I think were delineated better later in the book. Most of the time, I just wanted to hug Wren and take her back to Kentucky.
As a native Pittsburgher, I enjoyed the setting, seeing the gateway to the west evolving into a more traditional city with the advent of the railroads.
Fans of historical fiction will enjoy this series!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 309 reviews