What do you think?
Rate this book
Whitby's Forgotten Victims #1
Forgotten Bones
The first in a new series from bestselling crime author, Wes Markin!
To Detective Chief Inspector Frank Black they’re not just forgotten bones.
They’re forgotten hopes.
Forgotten dreams.
The forgotten voice of an angel.
When buried bones are unearthed by a storm in North Yorkshire’s picturesque coastal town of Whitby, Frank is drawn into an investigation that takes him back to the late eighties and the fiery demise of a popular pub.
Frank is no stranger to vulnerability. With a shattered daughter, he lives with it. With an outsider in Detective Inspector Gerry Carver, he works with it.
And in Charlotte Wilson, a young, eighteen-year-old musician discarded and buried near the old whalebones of Whitby, he recognises it.
At sixty-four, Frank really should be retiring.
But Charlotte had hopes and dreams.
And nobody should be allowed to silence the voice of an angel.
Bestselling Wes Markin is back with the start of an exciting new series, perfect for fans of David Gatward, JD Kirk, Rachel McLean, JM Dalgliesh and Simon McCleave.
'Take shelter! There’s a storm brewing over Whitby. Compelling, atmospheric, characters to root for – this book has everything! ★★★★★' TG Reid, Dark is the Grave
To Detective Chief Inspector Frank Black they’re not just forgotten bones.
They’re forgotten hopes.
Forgotten dreams.
The forgotten voice of an angel.
When buried bones are unearthed by a storm in North Yorkshire’s picturesque coastal town of Whitby, Frank is drawn into an investigation that takes him back to the late eighties and the fiery demise of a popular pub.
Frank is no stranger to vulnerability. With a shattered daughter, he lives with it. With an outsider in Detective Inspector Gerry Carver, he works with it.
And in Charlotte Wilson, a young, eighteen-year-old musician discarded and buried near the old whalebones of Whitby, he recognises it.
At sixty-four, Frank really should be retiring.
But Charlotte had hopes and dreams.
And nobody should be allowed to silence the voice of an angel.
Bestselling Wes Markin is back with the start of an exciting new series, perfect for fans of David Gatward, JD Kirk, Rachel McLean, JM Dalgliesh and Simon McCleave.
'Take shelter! There’s a storm brewing over Whitby. Compelling, atmospheric, characters to root for – this book has everything! ★★★★★' TG Reid, Dark is the Grave
464 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 30, 2024
About the author
Wes Markin
46 books291 followersBe sure to follow Wes on BookBub for the latest on sales: bit.ly/3tFWIHL
Wes Markin lives in Harrogate and is the bestselling author of the DCI Yorke crime novels set in Salisbury. He is also the author of the Jake Pettman series set in New England.
Wes Markin lives in Harrogate and is the bestselling author of the DCI Yorke crime novels set in Salisbury. He is also the author of the Jake Pettman series set in New England.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 175 reviews
July 27, 2024
A fabulous read! Very atmospheric. I love Whitby, it's many years since I visited but the descriptions in this book bring it all back.
DCI Frank Black seems old school in his investigations but he is not adverse to the modern teachings and of the younger generation, he understands all too well of the advantages of modern technology and practices and who better to guide him in that direction than his new partner DI Gerry Carver! What a fantastic character she is! Autistic, very intelligent and a hard worker, helped along the way by her therapy dog Rylan (who is an absolute star!) I warmed to both characters immediately, they both have their own kind of bluntness which is amusing in a light hearted way and after a shaky start I can see their relationship developing beautifully.
The storyline takes us back to the late 1980's when policing ( in this case) wasn't as thorough as it should have been. The remains of a young and talented 18 year have been discovered and it's hit DCI Black hard having a daughter of his own that was once lost....
A crime plot that is full of mystery, intrigue and passion. I flew through the pages!
What a start to a new crime series and I'm very much looking forward to reading the next book. Frank Black better start taking more care of himself, he's not getting any younger! Can't wait to find out!
DCI Frank Black seems old school in his investigations but he is not adverse to the modern teachings and of the younger generation, he understands all too well of the advantages of modern technology and practices and who better to guide him in that direction than his new partner DI Gerry Carver! What a fantastic character she is! Autistic, very intelligent and a hard worker, helped along the way by her therapy dog Rylan (who is an absolute star!) I warmed to both characters immediately, they both have their own kind of bluntness which is amusing in a light hearted way and after a shaky start I can see their relationship developing beautifully.
The storyline takes us back to the late 1980's when policing ( in this case) wasn't as thorough as it should have been. The remains of a young and talented 18 year have been discovered and it's hit DCI Black hard having a daughter of his own that was once lost....
A crime plot that is full of mystery, intrigue and passion. I flew through the pages!
What a start to a new crime series and I'm very much looking forward to reading the next book. Frank Black better start taking more care of himself, he's not getting any younger! Can't wait to find out!
August 3, 2025
FOUR AND A HALF STARS
Such a beautifully written novel. I’ll be certain to find more by this author, Wes Markin. This is the first in a new series from crime author, Wes Markin.
I enjoyed so much that women were portrayed well. There were also many interesting characters, including the lead Detective Chief Inspector, Frank Black, who in his mid 60's sh0uld be retiring. He is not however because of the murder of a young woman. I also loved that “normal”, to Wes Markin, defies the typical stereotypes that we've all grown tired of.
My only con is that I found it hard to keep track of all the characters in the audiobook and there were plenty of them. I rated it 4-1/2 stars and rounded it to 4 since the confusion in the audiobook may have been partially my stopping at times, but it didn’t achieve my full 5 star 🌟 rating. I'm ready for #2 in this series and glad to have found Wes Markin.
Such a beautifully written novel. I’ll be certain to find more by this author, Wes Markin. This is the first in a new series from crime author, Wes Markin.
I enjoyed so much that women were portrayed well. There were also many interesting characters, including the lead Detective Chief Inspector, Frank Black, who in his mid 60's sh0uld be retiring. He is not however because of the murder of a young woman. I also loved that “normal”, to Wes Markin, defies the typical stereotypes that we've all grown tired of.
My only con is that I found it hard to keep track of all the characters in the audiobook and there were plenty of them. I rated it 4-1/2 stars and rounded it to 4 since the confusion in the audiobook may have been partially my stopping at times, but it didn’t achieve my full 5 star 🌟 rating. I'm ready for #2 in this series and glad to have found Wes Markin.
August 16, 2024
I thoroughly enjoyed this book Wes markin is fast becoming one of my new favourite authors. The characters in this book were amazing and I loved how the author portrayed Gerry and her neuro divergent condition and how it proved that regardless of her problems there is nothing too difficult that can’t be overcome. I felt that Gerry and Frank black made an excellent partnership and the way frank perceived Gerry without reading the e mail
About her profile was brilliant especially when he saw the way she looked at and handled things in her own way. The story itself kept me guessing and on edge till almost the end and I had almost all characters guilty before finding out who the killer was. This was most definitely a five + stars and I look forward to reading more about frank and Gerry and there crime busting cold cases in the future
About her profile was brilliant especially when he saw the way she looked at and handled things in her own way. The story itself kept me guessing and on edge till almost the end and I had almost all characters guilty before finding out who the killer was. This was most definitely a five + stars and I look forward to reading more about frank and Gerry and there crime busting cold cases in the future
February 21, 2025
I was looking forward to reading this as I had been looking for a really good crime series to get involved with. Stuck with this story until page 52. Sorry for me the narrative didn’t flow. I found the story to that point irritating and boring. Conversation between the characters was stilted and annoying. I didn’t care about the victim and even less about the characters. The DI is an autistic female officer who depends upon a therapy dog sorry but she just would no way be accepted into that kind of stressful environment. Did she come thru the ranks? With a therapy dog? No chance. As an ex British police officer I went with the concept of an unfit serving DCI who is 64 yrs old for a while but he keeps his 32yr old daughter locked in her room. A recovering addict? I don’t know I didn’t read enough to find out because I didn’t care. Won’t bother with this author anymore.
May 19, 2025
Frank is a copper investigating a murder case from 40 years ago. He's got a new team including Gerry who is autistic and has a therapy dog.
Set in Whitby.
There was a lot to like about this. The main characters, the mystery and the plot were great.
Sadly, I can't give it more than 2 stars for two main reasons.
Firstly the chapters are mostly very short. This isn't a problem of itself, but when new characters are introduced you don't get a chance to remember them when you've got a minute with them. I was befuddled with the amount of people to keep track of.
Secondly it needs a firm edit. Numerous typos and grammar errors but also he got a character's name wrong twice and the date of the murder.
If he'd spent longer with the characters and tidied up the text, I'd be happy to read the rest of the series. I may try the next one to see if it improves but I might not bother.
Set in Whitby.
There was a lot to like about this. The main characters, the mystery and the plot were great.
Sadly, I can't give it more than 2 stars for two main reasons.
Firstly the chapters are mostly very short. This isn't a problem of itself, but when new characters are introduced you don't get a chance to remember them when you've got a minute with them. I was befuddled with the amount of people to keep track of.
Secondly it needs a firm edit. Numerous typos and grammar errors but also he got a character's name wrong twice and the date of the murder.
If he'd spent longer with the characters and tidied up the text, I'd be happy to read the rest of the series. I may try the next one to see if it improves but I might not bother.
June 10, 2024
One of my favourite writers around at the moment. Everything he writes is a nailed on 5 star.
This is the start of a new series. Starting with DCI Frank, you think oh my god what an opening.
When some bones are found up by the whale bones in Whitby, Frank and his new colleague Gerry have to try and give the poor victim a name before they are allowed a proper office and team to investigate.
Gerry is a bit different, as she's autistic and has her therapy dog. She is a brilliant character, super smart and brilliant at uncovering clues from places no-one else could.
Frank is 64, very overweight and drinks to excess. He vows many times to change throughout the book and never succeeds. I genuinely fear for his health!
There's some great characters in this. One of them so bloody arrogant I wanted to do horrible things! It was quite scary how easily he could manipulate people to his will. Usually within 5 minutes.
As the book progresses and the truth is revealed it peels back layers and layers of long held secrets. I thought I knew who it was then I didn't!
Wes uses the setting brilliantly, even the description of a professional kitchen.
I hope this is the first of a very long series. I already can't wait to catch up with these characters.
This is the start of a new series. Starting with DCI Frank, you think oh my god what an opening.
When some bones are found up by the whale bones in Whitby, Frank and his new colleague Gerry have to try and give the poor victim a name before they are allowed a proper office and team to investigate.
Gerry is a bit different, as she's autistic and has her therapy dog. She is a brilliant character, super smart and brilliant at uncovering clues from places no-one else could.
Frank is 64, very overweight and drinks to excess. He vows many times to change throughout the book and never succeeds. I genuinely fear for his health!
There's some great characters in this. One of them so bloody arrogant I wanted to do horrible things! It was quite scary how easily he could manipulate people to his will. Usually within 5 minutes.
As the book progresses and the truth is revealed it peels back layers and layers of long held secrets. I thought I knew who it was then I didn't!
Wes uses the setting brilliantly, even the description of a professional kitchen.
I hope this is the first of a very long series. I already can't wait to catch up with these characters.
July 26, 2024
Once you have read a book by Wes Markin, you need another. That's what this series gives me, yet again! Time after time, I finish one of his books and think he can't top that book. Then I read the next one and find he can, very easily.
This series brings a new town and new characters. Whitby is perfectly described, I want to go back now and see the places, like the whale bones. It's so very atmospheric!
Frank Black is a copper who finds himself with a new partner, Gerry. She arrives with her support dog, Rylan. Gerry is a character who will stay in my mind forever from this book alone. Autistic and so smart, a woman who brooks no argument. The one liners between Frank and Gerry had me in stitches. We also learn of Frank's home life and the tensions he has to deal with there.
Aside from the humour, there is a case to solve, one which has Frank, Gerry, and the rest of the team, thinking on their feet. I was glued to the Kindle until the very end.
There are twists and turns in this investigation that had the pages whizzing by at a speed I haven't read at for a while. I absolutely love this series already!
Thanks to Wes Markin for the gifted ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This series brings a new town and new characters. Whitby is perfectly described, I want to go back now and see the places, like the whale bones. It's so very atmospheric!
Frank Black is a copper who finds himself with a new partner, Gerry. She arrives with her support dog, Rylan. Gerry is a character who will stay in my mind forever from this book alone. Autistic and so smart, a woman who brooks no argument. The one liners between Frank and Gerry had me in stitches. We also learn of Frank's home life and the tensions he has to deal with there.
Aside from the humour, there is a case to solve, one which has Frank, Gerry, and the rest of the team, thinking on their feet. I was glued to the Kindle until the very end.
There are twists and turns in this investigation that had the pages whizzing by at a speed I haven't read at for a while. I absolutely love this series already!
Thanks to Wes Markin for the gifted ARC in exchange for an honest review.
July 22, 2026
To Detective Chief Inspector Frank Black they’re not just forgotten bones.
They’re forgotten hopes.
Forgotten dreams.
The forgotten voice of an angel.
When a storm hits Whitby, a suitcase that has been buried for decades is exposed along with the bones inside DCI Frank Black is on the case, he maybe old, he may not look the part, he may be tough and rough but he is nothing if he isn't determined to speak for the victim.
He slowly gathers an ad-hoc team of misfits to help him, including DI Gerry Carver and her therapy Labrador Ryland.
Despite initial misgivings the autistic Gerry wins Frank over and the mismatched pair are soon unearthing clue after clue.
The case is not the only thing haunting Frank at home his wife has passed and he has a shattered daughter.
This is my first Wes Markin book and it won't be my last. Being honest I picked the book up because of the location, having been on holiday at Whitby.
The plot is clever without being self satisfied, and unfolds organically.
There is a kind of bleak beauty to the prose and Markin captures the ruggedness and old world feeling of Whitby perfectly.
But the characters are where this book shines.
Frank is an old school copper, more than happy to pound the streets, working the leads, he doesn't suffer fools lightly and is forever butting heads due to his brutal honesty. But he has soul and an absolute dedication to finding the truth and bringing what peace he can to the victims and their loved ones.
Gerry Carver is an almost exact opposite, the new breed of police, one who has had her own struggles with her autism and anxiety, but she is in her own way more than a match for Frank's stubbornness and it isn't long before Frank realises that he has struck investigative gold with this young singular detective
Over the end was satisfying and suitably obscure. Definitely worth a read.
They’re forgotten hopes.
Forgotten dreams.
The forgotten voice of an angel.
When a storm hits Whitby, a suitcase that has been buried for decades is exposed along with the bones inside DCI Frank Black is on the case, he maybe old, he may not look the part, he may be tough and rough but he is nothing if he isn't determined to speak for the victim.
He slowly gathers an ad-hoc team of misfits to help him, including DI Gerry Carver and her therapy Labrador Ryland.
Despite initial misgivings the autistic Gerry wins Frank over and the mismatched pair are soon unearthing clue after clue.
The case is not the only thing haunting Frank at home his wife has passed and he has a shattered daughter.
This is my first Wes Markin book and it won't be my last. Being honest I picked the book up because of the location, having been on holiday at Whitby.
The plot is clever without being self satisfied, and unfolds organically.
There is a kind of bleak beauty to the prose and Markin captures the ruggedness and old world feeling of Whitby perfectly.
But the characters are where this book shines.
Frank is an old school copper, more than happy to pound the streets, working the leads, he doesn't suffer fools lightly and is forever butting heads due to his brutal honesty. But he has soul and an absolute dedication to finding the truth and bringing what peace he can to the victims and their loved ones.
Gerry Carver is an almost exact opposite, the new breed of police, one who has had her own struggles with her autism and anxiety, but she is in her own way more than a match for Frank's stubbornness and it isn't long before Frank realises that he has struck investigative gold with this young singular detective
Over the end was satisfying and suitably obscure. Definitely worth a read.
May 17, 2025
Very nice storyline. Intertwined several storylines that all interconnected and made for an interesting listen. Fun, well developed characters that kept you interested in their stories and enough twists and turns to make everything entertaining and well thought out. I can’t wait to read more of this series.
July 11, 2025
great read
February 2, 2026
New to me.
Washington po and tilly Bradshaw on the east coast. A good yarn for all that. Several threads to keep track of.
Washington po and tilly Bradshaw on the east coast. A good yarn for all that. Several threads to keep track of.
June 13, 2026
It seems Wes Markin is not for me. It's a shame, because in all of his books that I've read, I really liked the premise, but then it all falls apart.
(Please forgive my poor English, my excuse is I’m Swedish).
(Please forgive my poor English, my excuse is I’m Swedish).
January 11, 2025
A brilliant read I couldn’t stop listening. The narrator, (I listen to it on Audible) was absolutely fantastic did the voices really well and each character was different. A brilliant cast of characters great plot, and definitely if you like detective stories worth reading, my favourite character well, being a dog lover, had to be Rylan! Gerri’s therapy dog. One negative though and I don’t know if this is the book, or the narrator, but some of the names got mixed up, and some of the months got mixed up, so, if this is the book, editors do a better job please and if it’s the narrator please be careful how you read things because people do listen and it does come across. An example, is that sometimes Julie Fletcher was referred to as Julia, when talking to Paul , David’s surname was used instead of Paul’s, who’s was Harrison! There were other examples too. It wasn’t offputting enough for me not to read the next one, but should’ve been picked up and corrected.
August 9, 2024
This is a new to me author and I have thoroughly enjoyed this book. It took me just a couple of days to read it as I couldn't put it down. The main protagonist is DCI Frank Black, he is an overweight mature detective. His boss gives him a job that he thinks is too old to be solved but it gets Frank from under his feet. Frank is assigned an assistant DI Gerry Carver. He has never meet her before and knows there is something very different about her. He soon comes to admire her and thinks she is a genius. The pair work really well together he has the experience and she has the brains. The writing is just how I like it and the story flows really well, a few twists and I never guessed the ending, which is unusual so well done for that. I will be watching out for more books by this author.
January 1, 2025
A bit slow and convoluted in the first half, a saga rather than a crime fiction, but it settled into a rhythm and unraveling plot in the second half. The major characters are plausible and engaging, their flaws consistent with behaviour and motivation. I find the multiple narratives across time frustrating. It is possible to convey understanding of another era ( in this case the 80s) without slipping back to the time. It also creates rather too many players for this reader to keep distinct.
Nonetheless, there’s a good plot and several interesting players. Worth finding out what happens next.
Nonetheless, there’s a good plot and several interesting players. Worth finding out what happens next.
August 5, 2024
I couldn't wait to start a new series by Wes Markin one of my favourite authors. Set in Whitby and introducing DCI Frank Black alongside his new Di Gerry Carver. The bones are found of missing 18 year Charlotte he and his team have to investigate. Frank already has a fractured relationship with his daughter and this case takes him back to the 80s...A really good read and I'm looking forward to book 2 !
May 21, 2025
DNF Just could not get in to this book at all. Nothing to keep me interested. Ch 51 and I’m done.
July 21, 2025
Nach einem Sturm werden an der Küste von Whitby Knochen gefunden. Die sterblichen Überreste gehören zu einer jungen Frau, sie schon 1987 verschwunden ist. Für DCI Frank Black ist es der erste Fall, den er gemeinsam mit seiner neuen Kollegin DI Gerry Carver, einer jungen Frau mit brillantem Verstand, aber auch mit Eigenheiten, die Frank die Zusammenarbeit zuerst schwer machen.
In seinem ersten Fall lerne ich Frank als einen Mann kennen, der vieles auf seinem Teller hat. In seinen Jahren bei der Polizei hat er zu viel gesehen und könnte such auf seinen Ruhestand freuen, aber sein Leben hat sich nach dem Tod seiner Frau nur um die Arbeit gedreht und er fürchtet sich vor der Leere nach der Pensionierung. Der Kontakt zu seiner Tochter war lange abgebrochen, weil sie auf die schiefe Bahn geraten war, jetzt versucht er, sie von den Drogen wegzubringen. Da kann er sich nicht noch um seine neue Kollegin kümmern, die nicht alleine, sondern mit ihrem Therapiehund kommt und mit deren brüsken Art er anfangs nicht zurecht kommt.
Aber die beiden ergänzen sich, vielleicht gerade weil sie so unterschiedlich sind. Während Gerry bei der Spurensuche eher im Netz zuhause ist, fühlt sich Frank im Umgang mit Menschen wohler. Auch wenn sie noch nicht richtig wissen, was sie mit dem jeweils anderen anfangen sollen und langsam wachsen die beiden Einzelgänger zu einem Team zusammen.
Es ist schwierig, nach so langer Zeit noch Spuren zu finden und die Erinnerungen der Beteiligten sind nicht mehr frisch. So ist es eine mühsame Arbeit für Frank und Gerry. Wes Markin schafft es, dass die beiden in ihren Ermittlungen vorankommen, ohne dass die Handlung konstruiert oder langweilig wirkt. Allerdings kommen die Ermittlungen erst spät wirklich in Fahrt, das hat den Anfang trotz der interessanten Charaktere etwas lang gemacht.
In seinem ersten Fall lerne ich Frank als einen Mann kennen, der vieles auf seinem Teller hat. In seinen Jahren bei der Polizei hat er zu viel gesehen und könnte such auf seinen Ruhestand freuen, aber sein Leben hat sich nach dem Tod seiner Frau nur um die Arbeit gedreht und er fürchtet sich vor der Leere nach der Pensionierung. Der Kontakt zu seiner Tochter war lange abgebrochen, weil sie auf die schiefe Bahn geraten war, jetzt versucht er, sie von den Drogen wegzubringen. Da kann er sich nicht noch um seine neue Kollegin kümmern, die nicht alleine, sondern mit ihrem Therapiehund kommt und mit deren brüsken Art er anfangs nicht zurecht kommt.
Aber die beiden ergänzen sich, vielleicht gerade weil sie so unterschiedlich sind. Während Gerry bei der Spurensuche eher im Netz zuhause ist, fühlt sich Frank im Umgang mit Menschen wohler. Auch wenn sie noch nicht richtig wissen, was sie mit dem jeweils anderen anfangen sollen und langsam wachsen die beiden Einzelgänger zu einem Team zusammen.
Es ist schwierig, nach so langer Zeit noch Spuren zu finden und die Erinnerungen der Beteiligten sind nicht mehr frisch. So ist es eine mühsame Arbeit für Frank und Gerry. Wes Markin schafft es, dass die beiden in ihren Ermittlungen vorankommen, ohne dass die Handlung konstruiert oder langweilig wirkt. Allerdings kommen die Ermittlungen erst spät wirklich in Fahrt, das hat den Anfang trotz der interessanten Charaktere etwas lang gemacht.
November 15, 2024
Forgotten Bones by Wes Markin
Talk about red herrings serving to ensure the reader (this one anyway) had no hope of resolving the murder of a young adult 37 years previously ahead of DCI Frank Black, investigating the crime.
Mind, with such a writer as maestro, it was always destined to be a very rewarding read. Wes Markin has already established himself as one of the top crime writers around with his Yorkshire Murder series. And with this first book in a new series, Whitby’s Forgotten Victims, he’s just doing what we (I) know him to do best – meaty, credible story lines, wonderfully portrayed characters and addictively fast paced page turners.
It's those characters which truly distinguishes Markin in his writing. DCI Bank has a reputation for being hard-hitting, fearsome non-conformist. He investigates by his rules, often at the cost of his own safety. He’s a wonderful old cynic subtly warring with his superior who would like for nothing more than to see him head to retirement. If there is any incentive to keep working, that his biggest one.
An example of the lack of respect his superior has for Black is when he tasks him to uncover the mystery of human bones, sets him up on a windowless tiny office and assigns him a DI, Gerry Carver, who herself has her particular ways. And this is when we get to know the real DCI Black. The man who will fight every corner to bring the victim’s killer to justice and bring peace to her Mum. His real self is a caring, emotionally invested and whole person. He knows the reality of the hardships of life close hand as he works to pull through from the sudden death of his wife and tries desperately to help his daughter fight her own demons.
The very good news if you become as addictive to DCI Black, Gerry and Rylan (Gerry’s support dog) is that there are already 2 further books in the series published. Thank you Wes Markin for bringing a whole new meaning to crime writing master class.
Talk about red herrings serving to ensure the reader (this one anyway) had no hope of resolving the murder of a young adult 37 years previously ahead of DCI Frank Black, investigating the crime.
Mind, with such a writer as maestro, it was always destined to be a very rewarding read. Wes Markin has already established himself as one of the top crime writers around with his Yorkshire Murder series. And with this first book in a new series, Whitby’s Forgotten Victims, he’s just doing what we (I) know him to do best – meaty, credible story lines, wonderfully portrayed characters and addictively fast paced page turners.
It's those characters which truly distinguishes Markin in his writing. DCI Bank has a reputation for being hard-hitting, fearsome non-conformist. He investigates by his rules, often at the cost of his own safety. He’s a wonderful old cynic subtly warring with his superior who would like for nothing more than to see him head to retirement. If there is any incentive to keep working, that his biggest one.
An example of the lack of respect his superior has for Black is when he tasks him to uncover the mystery of human bones, sets him up on a windowless tiny office and assigns him a DI, Gerry Carver, who herself has her particular ways. And this is when we get to know the real DCI Black. The man who will fight every corner to bring the victim’s killer to justice and bring peace to her Mum. His real self is a caring, emotionally invested and whole person. He knows the reality of the hardships of life close hand as he works to pull through from the sudden death of his wife and tries desperately to help his daughter fight her own demons.
The very good news if you become as addictive to DCI Black, Gerry and Rylan (Gerry’s support dog) is that there are already 2 further books in the series published. Thank you Wes Markin for bringing a whole new meaning to crime writing master class.
August 28, 2024
I make no secret that I am a bit of a fan of this author - I have read and loved all his previous series! So it was very exciting to hear that he was embarking on another one, starring near-to-retirement DCI Frank Black and his new sidekick DI Gerry Carver, along with her therapy dog, who yes, does steal the show on occasion!
I read so many books of this genre that they can get a little samey after a while, especially considering that there are only so many ways you can spice up a new cop! But I have to say that having one that is neurodiverse and functions with the assistance of a therapy dog has to be a new one on me, refreshingly so!
But, that alone would not make for a good book, you have to have all the rest of the things that make for a good read. Story, characters, pacing, keeping the reader engaged, all that is also front and centre herein. We start with some bones that were discovered near to a whalebone display in Whitby, Frank not only has to meet and get to know his new associate, but also to find out who the bones belong to, and work out how we got to this point. All alongside the troubles he is having with his daughter.
I really took to both Frank and Gerry, both separately and the wonderful scenes they have together. It was lovely watching them get to know each other and work out how best to rub along - as with every new relationship! So much so that I was quite sad when we were nearing the end where I would have to say goodbye to them. It's a good job that it is the start of a new series and I will be able to reconnect with them both soon. Well, as long as Frank gets his act and health together!
I read so many books of this genre that they can get a little samey after a while, especially considering that there are only so many ways you can spice up a new cop! But I have to say that having one that is neurodiverse and functions with the assistance of a therapy dog has to be a new one on me, refreshingly so!
But, that alone would not make for a good book, you have to have all the rest of the things that make for a good read. Story, characters, pacing, keeping the reader engaged, all that is also front and centre herein. We start with some bones that were discovered near to a whalebone display in Whitby, Frank not only has to meet and get to know his new associate, but also to find out who the bones belong to, and work out how we got to this point. All alongside the troubles he is having with his daughter.
I really took to both Frank and Gerry, both separately and the wonderful scenes they have together. It was lovely watching them get to know each other and work out how best to rub along - as with every new relationship! So much so that I was quite sad when we were nearing the end where I would have to say goodbye to them. It's a good job that it is the start of a new series and I will be able to reconnect with them both soon. Well, as long as Frank gets his act and health together!
August 3, 2024
Excellent, thank you. Whitby is a place very close to my heart so the added bonus of it being the backdrop to this story was much welcomed and it was nice to take a walk down such familiar surroundings.
I was a little sceptical about the characterisations at the start, it was a little too reminiscent of Tilly and Poe but this preconception faded and i became immersed in these as very separate entities soon enough. The fragilities and vulnerabilities of the main investigators is always an interesting edge and gets me on side and rooting for them with each success.
The added complexities of this being a cold case gave an extra layer of interest and the fact that it was the late 80s and within the grasp of my own memories did also, I do feel slightly old now, however. An interesting reminder that quite a lot has changed in the elapsed time.
The pace of the storyline was good and there were plenty of dead ends, misdirected interest and twists to keep me on my toes. The number of characters was good, not too many to keep track of but definitely sufficient for a nice juicy complexity to the storytelling.
Procedurally lots of ticks in the box from me but please don’t have police referring to colleagues as ‘superiors’ this isn’t the done or politically correct thing any longer, higher ranked will do fine.
Overall a very enjoyable read and I honestly can’t wait for the next one, thank you.
I was a little sceptical about the characterisations at the start, it was a little too reminiscent of Tilly and Poe but this preconception faded and i became immersed in these as very separate entities soon enough. The fragilities and vulnerabilities of the main investigators is always an interesting edge and gets me on side and rooting for them with each success.
The added complexities of this being a cold case gave an extra layer of interest and the fact that it was the late 80s and within the grasp of my own memories did also, I do feel slightly old now, however. An interesting reminder that quite a lot has changed in the elapsed time.
The pace of the storyline was good and there were plenty of dead ends, misdirected interest and twists to keep me on my toes. The number of characters was good, not too many to keep track of but definitely sufficient for a nice juicy complexity to the storytelling.
Procedurally lots of ticks in the box from me but please don’t have police referring to colleagues as ‘superiors’ this isn’t the done or politically correct thing any longer, higher ranked will do fine.
Overall a very enjoyable read and I honestly can’t wait for the next one, thank you.
August 16, 2024
This is the first book in a new series set in North Yorkshire, this book is set in Whitby where Frank Black is the police officer in charge and his new assistant Detective Inspector Geraldine Carver (who prefers to be known as Gerry), together with her assistance dog Rylan, they have been called to the cliff edge near to the whale bones where a body has been found in a suitcase. It was found initially by a family on holiday in the town, and the children were playing and running around and then slipped and landed nearby to the scene of the crime. Frank is starting to feel his age with aches and pains as he walks around the area, talking to residents about the discovery of the body.
It's not long before, secrets and admissions come out. Will all these secrets actually prove to be crucial in solving this case? With Frank's own personal problems, you wonder if he will solve this case at all! He has problems with his own daughter, and after losing his wife, he now has to deal with everything as well as the police work.
I liked that actual places and coffee shops were mentioned. Having been to Whitby many times, I, too, have visited these places, and I think it gives the area a mysterious and sometimes spooky background.
It is a very atmospheric story, with a few twists and turns, set in a great location, and I hope that Frank continues to work in Whitby in future books, and his health allows him to. Really enjoyed reading this book, a five-star read from me.
It's not long before, secrets and admissions come out. Will all these secrets actually prove to be crucial in solving this case? With Frank's own personal problems, you wonder if he will solve this case at all! He has problems with his own daughter, and after losing his wife, he now has to deal with everything as well as the police work.
I liked that actual places and coffee shops were mentioned. Having been to Whitby many times, I, too, have visited these places, and I think it gives the area a mysterious and sometimes spooky background.
It is a very atmospheric story, with a few twists and turns, set in a great location, and I hope that Frank continues to work in Whitby in future books, and his health allows him to. Really enjoyed reading this book, a five-star read from me.
August 20, 2024
I thoroughly enjoyed this book!!
When buried bones are unearthed by a storm in North Yorkshire’s picturesque coastal town of Whitby, Frank Black is drawn into an investigation that takes him back to the late eighties and the fiery demise of a popular pub. Frank is investigating the murder of Charlotte, who went missing in 1987 and is found, encased in a suitcase buried near the famous Whitby Whalebones landmark. Aided by his new partner DI Carver, a super intelligent autistic woman, he starts to piece together what happened to Charlotte. There is a side story to this book involving Frank and his daughter. It has nothing to do with the plot of the book but it give a sad human side to Frank.
I have to admit, when I first read about DI Carver and her autism and along with Frank, I did think of another author who has this very dynamic in his books, that put me off for about 12 pages until I really got into the story. The book is so atmospheric ( I swear I could feel the weather) each character was likable and deep, each with their own stories and demons. Fortunately I didn't "guess" who was the culprit and responsible for Charlotte's death and when I did find out, it floored me a little.
I'll look forward to reading more in this series!!
Thank you to TBC reviewers group on Facebook for the ARC in return for my honest review.
When buried bones are unearthed by a storm in North Yorkshire’s picturesque coastal town of Whitby, Frank Black is drawn into an investigation that takes him back to the late eighties and the fiery demise of a popular pub. Frank is investigating the murder of Charlotte, who went missing in 1987 and is found, encased in a suitcase buried near the famous Whitby Whalebones landmark. Aided by his new partner DI Carver, a super intelligent autistic woman, he starts to piece together what happened to Charlotte. There is a side story to this book involving Frank and his daughter. It has nothing to do with the plot of the book but it give a sad human side to Frank.
I have to admit, when I first read about DI Carver and her autism and along with Frank, I did think of another author who has this very dynamic in his books, that put me off for about 12 pages until I really got into the story. The book is so atmospheric ( I swear I could feel the weather) each character was likable and deep, each with their own stories and demons. Fortunately I didn't "guess" who was the culprit and responsible for Charlotte's death and when I did find out, it floored me a little.
I'll look forward to reading more in this series!!
Thank you to TBC reviewers group on Facebook for the ARC in return for my honest review.
July 31, 2024
I really enjoyed this start to a new crime/detective series from Wes Markin.
When old remains are discovered in a suitcase in Whitby, Detective Chief Inspector Frank Black is put on the case. He sees beyond the bones to the person they once were, with hopes and dreams that were snatched from them too soon. But Frank's also a bit of a mess. He's getting on in age, his home life is (secretly) chaotic and he's working with a new team.
I wasn't sure what to make of Frank and co in the first few pages, but it's worth persevering as the author slowly builds the characters up - particularly Frank and his new partner, Gerry. She's autistic and highly competent, but it takes Frank a minute to understand how to work around her. What I like is that they're both shrewd, intelligent hard workers - just with different challenges.
The murder mystery is compelling, though it takes a while to understand how all the 'suspect' POVs will work/come together.
Sometimes police detective mysteries can feel a bit cookie-cutter. But Forgotten Bones has its own distinct flavour that makes it more memorable than other titles in the genre, for me. Looking forward to the next one in the series.
When old remains are discovered in a suitcase in Whitby, Detective Chief Inspector Frank Black is put on the case. He sees beyond the bones to the person they once were, with hopes and dreams that were snatched from them too soon. But Frank's also a bit of a mess. He's getting on in age, his home life is (secretly) chaotic and he's working with a new team.
I wasn't sure what to make of Frank and co in the first few pages, but it's worth persevering as the author slowly builds the characters up - particularly Frank and his new partner, Gerry. She's autistic and highly competent, but it takes Frank a minute to understand how to work around her. What I like is that they're both shrewd, intelligent hard workers - just with different challenges.
The murder mystery is compelling, though it takes a while to understand how all the 'suspect' POVs will work/come together.
Sometimes police detective mysteries can feel a bit cookie-cutter. But Forgotten Bones has its own distinct flavour that makes it more memorable than other titles in the genre, for me. Looking forward to the next one in the series.
July 27, 2024
This is the start of a new series and as usual from this author, it's terrific. After a skeleton is discovered in Whitby, Frank Black and his new colleage Gerry are assigned to investigate. These are both great characters in their own way. Frank is in his sixties, very overweight and struggling to deal with his daughter. Gerry is autistic and has a wonderful support dog in tow.
I loved how both characters interacted throughout the book and how the relationship is already developing. There are a lot of characters here, all with connections to the victim who had disappeared 18 years ago and as the story continues, we see each one has secrets which gradually begin to be revealed. I thought I had it sussed as to who the killer was but I was quite surprised.I had mixed emotions at the end, happiness obviously that everything was resolved but sadness at other events. Everything is set up nicely now for the next in the series.
This author has several series now and no matter how different they may be, the quality still shines through. I hope there's many more books to follow.
I loved how both characters interacted throughout the book and how the relationship is already developing. There are a lot of characters here, all with connections to the victim who had disappeared 18 years ago and as the story continues, we see each one has secrets which gradually begin to be revealed. I thought I had it sussed as to who the killer was but I was quite surprised.I had mixed emotions at the end, happiness obviously that everything was resolved but sadness at other events. Everything is set up nicely now for the next in the series.
This author has several series now and no matter how different they may be, the quality still shines through. I hope there's many more books to follow.
August 9, 2024
Forgotten Bones is the first book in an intriguing new series by Wes Markin and the first book from the author that I have read.
When a suitcase fully of body remains are found on the beach at Whitby. DCI Frank Black is assigned to the case with his new colleague Gerry. The pair are complete opposites of each other. Gerry is 64 years old and nearing retirement age. Drinks too much as he has his own demons trying to keep his daughter from disappearing again. There is Gerry who is Autistic and has a Therapy dog.
But the pair are a good team and want to seek justice for the body on the beach. And when forensics discover who’s, the body is. The investigation takes them back to 1987. What happen to Charlotte all of them years ago and is the killer responsible still at large?
This is a great start of a new series and the first book from this author I have read. It has an intriguing storyline and great characterisation. At first thought you don’t know what to think if Frank but as you read on you find out that he has a big heart due to finding out who killed this young girl and suffering with his own demons with the problems with his daughter.
I really enjoyed this one and can’t wait for the next one. 5 stars from me
When a suitcase fully of body remains are found on the beach at Whitby. DCI Frank Black is assigned to the case with his new colleague Gerry. The pair are complete opposites of each other. Gerry is 64 years old and nearing retirement age. Drinks too much as he has his own demons trying to keep his daughter from disappearing again. There is Gerry who is Autistic and has a Therapy dog.
But the pair are a good team and want to seek justice for the body on the beach. And when forensics discover who’s, the body is. The investigation takes them back to 1987. What happen to Charlotte all of them years ago and is the killer responsible still at large?
This is a great start of a new series and the first book from this author I have read. It has an intriguing storyline and great characterisation. At first thought you don’t know what to think if Frank but as you read on you find out that he has a big heart due to finding out who killed this young girl and suffering with his own demons with the problems with his daughter.
I really enjoyed this one and can’t wait for the next one. 5 stars from me
August 15, 2024
This was an outstanding read with the action kicking off straight away. I will be recommending this to everyone I know.
I loved the slightly grumpy but very lovable DCI Frank Black and his DI Carver who has an incredible brain and a super cool therapy dog to support her with her Autism. Together their dynamic made the story even more special. The author has found the perfect mix of characters and personalities to form the team investigating the mysterious discovery of a secret from decades ago.
Franks determination to do his best to make sure noone is forgotten whilst dealing with difficulties in his own life is admirable , he may be a bit of a dinosaur but he approaches the case and victims with care and compassion.
There are so many twists and turns throughout the story I found myself constantly shocked at each turn of events.
The book is very well written and easy to read , I really liked that the author didn't feel the need to use lots of jargon and I could just enjoy the story.
I'm so pleased that this is a series and can't wait to see what Frank and Gerry will face and inevitably solve together next.
I loved the slightly grumpy but very lovable DCI Frank Black and his DI Carver who has an incredible brain and a super cool therapy dog to support her with her Autism. Together their dynamic made the story even more special. The author has found the perfect mix of characters and personalities to form the team investigating the mysterious discovery of a secret from decades ago.
Franks determination to do his best to make sure noone is forgotten whilst dealing with difficulties in his own life is admirable , he may be a bit of a dinosaur but he approaches the case and victims with care and compassion.
There are so many twists and turns throughout the story I found myself constantly shocked at each turn of events.
The book is very well written and easy to read , I really liked that the author didn't feel the need to use lots of jargon and I could just enjoy the story.
I'm so pleased that this is a series and can't wait to see what Frank and Gerry will face and inevitably solve together next.
August 31, 2024
I love the style of Writing Wes Markin brings to his books, Forgotten Bones is the first in a new series set in Whitby, Yorkshire, as usual the descriptive language of characters gives one a sense of realism, you feel the pain and compassion of DCI Frank Black, an opening scene that absolutely is quite shocking and as with all the authors books has you immersed in the storyline from page one.
A body has been found stuffed into a suitcase, it turns out to be a cold case from decades ago, Franks new partner on the case. DI Gerry Carver is a character who I warmed to pretty quickly, her no nonsense method of working and ability to see what others may not pick up on brings a great dimension to their partnership and so refreshing to read. This is a great start for the series, characters you will misjudge, as layers are pulled away and secrets are exposed, you are taken on a journey into the past and a life taken away, maybe now justice will prevail. Excellent read, really looking forward to the next book in the series.
A body has been found stuffed into a suitcase, it turns out to be a cold case from decades ago, Franks new partner on the case. DI Gerry Carver is a character who I warmed to pretty quickly, her no nonsense method of working and ability to see what others may not pick up on brings a great dimension to their partnership and so refreshing to read. This is a great start for the series, characters you will misjudge, as layers are pulled away and secrets are exposed, you are taken on a journey into the past and a life taken away, maybe now justice will prevail. Excellent read, really looking forward to the next book in the series.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 16, 2024
The beginning of another unputdownable series. We meet DCI Frank Black, an overweight, unhealthy sixty something detective with his fair share of emotional baggage. He is joined by new partner autistic DI Gerry Carver and her therapy dog Rylan. It's not the easiest of starts, but gradually Frank begins to understand Gerry and the way she works things out.
Their first case involves the remains of a young woman discovered in a suitcase near the famous Whitby Whalebones. It's clear the crime was committed years ago and there's not a lot of evidence. But piece by piece the duo begin to discover clues to what clearly has been a gruesome murder.
It's a great introduction to this new crime fighting team and as always the author produces a fast paced, twisty crime novel which grips the reader from the first page. By the time I had finished, I was thoroughly invested in both Frank and Gerry's characters and am now looking forward to the second book in the series which will be published in early October.
Their first case involves the remains of a young woman discovered in a suitcase near the famous Whitby Whalebones. It's clear the crime was committed years ago and there's not a lot of evidence. But piece by piece the duo begin to discover clues to what clearly has been a gruesome murder.
It's a great introduction to this new crime fighting team and as always the author produces a fast paced, twisty crime novel which grips the reader from the first page. By the time I had finished, I was thoroughly invested in both Frank and Gerry's characters and am now looking forward to the second book in the series which will be published in early October.
November 13, 2024
Firstly this isn’t my genre. In fact it’s the first British crime drama I’ve read. Which probably explains why I struggled with it a bit but more on that later.
The draw for me was Whitby.
The story was good and very well written. And I will be reading the next one when it’s out. Mainly due to the two main characters.
So my issue and I accept it’s totally on me. Which is why I’ve put this at the end. But at times it was just so depressing and I didn’t expect that. Naive I know.
I felt so sorry for the main character Frank. I loved Gerry, she was absolutely brilliant. So I kept on reading and I’m glad I did. And now next time I’ll know what to expect
Displaying 1 - 30 of 175 reviews