Peter David's writing in this series set a precedent for modern comic storytelling and I don't think he gets enough credit.
Obviously Alan Moore set the standard for modern comics around this same time, but we need to recognize the contribution David made for the modern age of comics. His writing felt so close to being something from the late 90s and early 00s, and if you read some of the other comics around that time like Englehart's Fantastic Four you'll understand what I mean when I say there's a huge difference in quality.
There's still some of the old comic book stylings mixed in here. Thought bubbles are used occasionally but they never take up too much room or feel invasive. I also appreciate not overusing inner monologues, which a lot of comics of the modern age could take some inspo from. I also don't love the "meanwhile, in the lowly streets of Manhattan" type of setting up the scene, but it didn't bother me too much since its used pretty sparingly.
Its because of this writing that I like the story. I'm not familiar with what was going on prior to David's run other than what was presented to me at the beginning of the story; a corrupt S.H.I.E.L.D that's using gamma bombs in favor of the U.S Government, Rick Jones being a Hulk, and these people calling themselves the Hulkbusters constantly on the search for the Hulk, without care as to who's currently the Hulk at the time, Jones or Banner.
Needless to say it looks like it was going off the rails a little. David brings these ideas together and makes it work really well in my opinion. I like the story of where the Hulkbusters are headed as a team, and I also was glad he made Rick back to normal. I love Rick Jones, but I never liked him being a powered up superhero. I preferred when he was trying to be Cap's new sidekick or just hangout with the Avengers.
David also brings back The Leader as soon as possible, setting him up in the first couple of issues. Throughout the rest of the book, The Leader is our main antagonist, and he's concocting a way to finally destroy the Hulk once and for all. I don't love the redesign here for the leader, and I can't tell if its just because its McFarlane or if I just think its a bad design in general.
Speaking of art here, I'll take a minute to complain about McFarlane. While the man did have some incredible ideas for certain characters like introducing spaghetti webbing to Spider-Man, the art here is hit or miss for me. I like aspects of it, and when Jim Saunders III is inking for him, the art is noticeably better in quality. Its actually when Todd gets to draw and ink his art that you see a dip in quality. There's like 2 issues or something in here that just look really crude and rough, because the line work gets to thin and scratchy, where Saunders III used thick line work and cleaned up some of the messiness of McFarlane's typical work. I know that's the aesthetic he's going for but its just not my taste. I hate Bruce's hair and his glasses being the thick circular Harry Potter type glasses. It just doesn't look great to me personally.
The other artist who contributes here is Erik Larsen and I'd be happy to see him return to the book. His art here was far more welcome for me than anything McFarlane did on this book, and I'm hoping that McFarlane left the book around this time so the next couple of Epic Collections don't have this bad a look to them.
There's new ideas inserted such as the Hulk being Bruce's coping with abuse and mental health issues that he keeps buried, which I think was kind of always around in the Hulk's mythos, but never this implied. David knows how to take that idea and not make it the entire point of the book but making it something that's covered on every once in a while to remind us that for as good as a guy that Bruce is he's got a dark past.
I love the gray Hulk idea, or the idea that he's Joe Fixit later on in the run. That's a cool premise to me. He's pretty fucked up and I think that's an interesting conflict to the og Hulk and Bruce himself. David knows how to create interesting characters in general that kept me engaged with the book.
Especially his use of random civilians throughout the series just having little subplots or sometimes being the main plot of an issue. Some highlights are the people of Gammatown before it's hit with the Leader's gamma bomb. You get to see these people's lives before they get hit and it brings weight to their deaths/mutations. Same with the woman that kills her abusive husband, and how David keeps it vague as to whether she really meant to do that or not. Lastly, the issue where a man finds Bruce and assumes he's a mutant and wants to give him up to X-Terminators (which was a fake organization the X-Men were using to save mutants at the time) for money is a really interesting dynamic. Not every character is perfect or even good, but you can tell deep down some of these people are actually good hearted, the man who found Bruce being the case. He rethinks his opinions of mutants after meeting Bruce, questioning if they're all that bad since Bruce is so nice and seems just like any ordinary human. Other than, y'know, turning into a big monster at night or whatnot.
Finally, I want to talk about the graphic novel archived here as well by Jim Starlin and Berni Wrightson was one of my favorite stories collected here. I think part of it was how refreshing it was to pour through Wrightson's incredible artwork after suffocating from McFarlane's artwork for so long. I love Ben Grimm and I thought Wrightson's artwork for him was awesome looking. He makes the rocks on his body feel real, and while I usually like a lighter orange for the Thing's rocks, the dark orange actually worked here a lot.
Shoutout to the reference to Utah, I got excited when I read that part. I appreciated that here and in David's issues on the book of the Hulk being a traveling monster who's going across the country, but especially in the Rocky Mountain areas pretty consistently.
Starlin writes a good Hulk and Thing here, and while it really has no connection to what David's story is turning into on the main book, its a really fun read. I haven't read a ton of Jim Starlin other than a few things like Death in the Family, but I enjoyed this a hell of a lot more than that book. He wrote a story that was really fun, and gives me the vibes of a modernized Stan Lee story. Its fun and short and the ending did have me actually chuckle a little bit because its just so stupid it works for me. It keeps the status quo in a way that's poking fun at itself and so I thought it worked.