The Pollyanna Drinking Game: Drink one shot whenever Pollyanna says "glad." Drink two whenever another character says it. You are dead by alcohol poisoning after Chapter 2.
I feel like I should like this book more than I do. And I quite did in the beginning, but then annoyance kept creeping up on me and then it only got worse.
Comparisons to the four years earlier book, "Anne of Green Gables" by Lucy Maud Montgomery, seem inevitable. Both star a quirky little, red-haired orphan girl who comes to live with reluctant guardians, is quirky and extraordinary and slowly changes the lives of people around her.
The question is where did "Pollyanna" fail for me while "Anne" is one of my favorite books.
First of there is the world-building and characters. Pollyanna offers an illustrious cast of people alongside its heroine, yet they never quite capture or interest me much, minus one or two exception. Anne‘s Avonlea meanwhile springs right from the page and comes to life, with all its characters in it. The second, more poignant, problem however comes from Pollyanna herself. She is so precious and perfect that is quickly becomes dull and annoying. Anne Shirley might be a special snowflake as well, but she is flawed and her flawed are acknowledged within the story. What sets Anne and Pollyanna apart is that one grows as a character and goes through an arc, while the other one is just so sweet and endearing she might as well let the sun shine and puke rainbows.
The characters around Pollyanna all suffer from deep conflicts and she helps them, until it’s their time to help her right back. This could be working beautifully but it doesn’t.
The book has a very profound message about appreciating the little things in life and looking for a silver lining no matter how bleak the situation, which on paper is something important to teach children. The execution is what kind of ruins it for me.
Pollyanna plays and teaches the people around her a game her dead father invented, called The Glad Game. People who play it should list things they are glad about that are better than whatever troubles they have. Find the good within the bad or think about how the situation could be even worse. Again, not a bad thing per se, but the book overuses it to a nauseating point. Every second word to come out of Pollyanna‘s precious little mouth is "glad" soon followed by every other character doing the same. It’s just too much. I wanted to yell at these characters to just shut up about it for a second. There is using something to send a message and then there is overdoing it. The message gets lost in the effort.
The story goes on slowly, with more or less short episodes about Pollyanna getting to know people, being noisy and changing their lives, until it hits a twist where Pollyanna is hit by a car and temporarily disabled.
The situation happens too late into the story. While it is great to experience how people Pollyanna helped are now there to help her and try to get her out of a fairly depressive state, it falls a little bit flat. I appreciate the message to teach children that they can still live a happy life even with a disability, but the conclusion kind of ruins it. Now, I do like a happy end, but this is just too cookie cutter clean (again Anne does a better job here). In only three short chapters a solution is found and loose ends are neatly tied up. It takes away from the momentum.
Maybe life has turned me into a bit of a cynic, but wouldn’t the message have been more powerful with Pollyanna learning to live and enjoy life with her new reality instead of being last minute cured? Or even, does the Glad game actually work? There might be situations in life where we should consider what he have instead of what we have lost, but that doesn’t work all the time and sometimes (a lot of times) it takes more to heal than a positive attitude.
Overall it is a nice book for children and will engage and entertain them. For me however it is not. The overuse of the word "glad", the lead characters lack of depth and development and the rushed ending were just not my cup of coffee.