I was not prepared for this to be the best written book of the 33 and 1/3 series that I've read to date, but it is. Of the albums in this series, Led Zeppelin's Four Symbols (or @,#,$,% to spite the band) is not my favorite (Steely Dan's Aja is), nor is it my favorite album from Led Zeppelin (God help me, but I think Physical Graffiti just might be my favorite, even though there are several tracks on it that I despise). But this book adds to one's understanding of the album and critically engages the music, lyrics, production, and myth of the album. The author explores the black magic aspect of the album and Jimmy Page, playfully mocking such seriousness at times, while juxtaposing this "darkness" with the lightness provided by Robert Plant's sunny hippiedom and silly appropriation of dorky Lord of the Rings tropes. Furthermore, the author does something that I love: highlights the importance and contributions of often neglected band members such as John Paul Jones. (Think of the treatment of George Harrison of the Beatles or Ron Wood/Mick Taylor/Brian Jones of the Rolling Stones, etc.) All the while, the author establishes a theory regarding the album that is both ludicrous and seemingly accurate: namely, that the album is the journey of Robert Plant's alter ego, which the author hilariously dubs "Percy," through the mythical, mystical side one, reaching an epiphany at the end of the band's opus "Stairway to Heaven," only to then have to lift the needle, flip the record, and continue Percy's journey through the contemporary, smoggy, urban world of side two that returns Percy to the earth when the levees break. And pray tell what is it that Percy is pursuing? Why, "the Lady," of course! The author cleverly uses many of Led Zeppelin's lyrics to not only reinforce this interpretation (and deftly so), but also to mock the mighty Zeppelin, poking a few holes and letting out some of the hot air. My favorite was the author's discussion of "Stairway to Heaven," which ends with a discussion of the alleged backmasking of "My sweet Satan" that evangelists claimed could be heard by playing the album backwards:
"The fact is that, within only two minutes of singing, 'Stairway to Heaven' contains at least seven reversed phrases of a suggestively devilish nature, including four mentions of Satan, or Seitan, or Sadie, or something like that. Moreover, these sonic simulacra are buried in a tune about pipers and whispers and listening really hard, a tune that, for a spell, ruled the world. I'm not saying that supernatural forces are afoot, I'm just saying it makes you wonder."
There are also all sorts of unique thoughts throughout the book, one of the best being the author's juxtaposition of white Evangelists of the early 80s using turntables to find latent meanings in recordings at the same time that black DJs were doing the same in early rap music, the main difference between the two being that black DJs found a multiplicity of meanings, whereas the white evangelists (not surprisingly) were literalists in their "mixing" and found only one meaning (typically a bad/devilish one). The author also suggests that this album was a showcase of Page's skill and acumen in producing a record; upon finishing this book, I couldn't help but think that Page was a more sophisticated and thoughtful producer than Brian Eno, though maybe this has more to do with this book being better than the 33 and 1/3 book for Eno's work. If you're not a fan of Led Zeppelin or of this album or of "Stairway to Heaven," then this book is worth reading. And even if it doesn't change your mind or enrich the experience of listening to the album, then at least you can come away with the idea that when listening to Led Zeppelin, you're really just listening to a guy named "Percy."